Art. 21 Bundesgesetz vom 22. Juni 1979 über die Raumplanung (RPG) - Verbindlichkeit und Anpassung

BGE 152 II 289 (Art. 21 al. 2 LAT)

Special land-use plan subordinated to annulled general zoning plan: incidental review of building permit for oversized building zone and voter-approved green zoning initiative

Main ground for the decision: the court found that the special land-use plan was invalid in incidental review because circumstances had materially changed since its adoption, allowing the court to revoke the building permit.

VVGE.1991.92.Anhang · ow (Art. 21 Abs. 1 AB zum RPG)

Right of Initiative in Cantonal Constitutional Law

This article is mentioned in relation to municipal initiatives regarding planning zones.

VVGE.1993.94.Nr.19 · ow (Art. 21 Abs. 2 RPG)

Municipality's Right to Reconsider Zoning Plan Before Final Cantonal Approval

Impliedly referenced through the general discussion of zoning plans and their approval process, though not explicitly cited in the dispositive part of the provided text.

VVGE.1993.94.Nr.20 · ow (Art. 21 Abs. 2 RPG)

Landowner Denied Rezoning Due to Untimely Application and Improper Conditions

The court addressed whether a zoning plan change could be requested after the public display period, considering significant changes in circumstances.

VVGE.1999.00.Nr.22 · ow (Art. 21 Abs. 2 RPG)

Property owner denied rezoning based on obsolete ski lift zone

This provision was used to determine that the conditions for a change in the zoning plan were not met, as the circumstances had not changed significantly.

TVR.2002.Nr.23 · tg (Art. 21 Abs. 2 RPG)

Rezoning Challenge Involving School Expansion Space

This provision is cited in the introductory note summarizing the key legal points addressed in the decision regarding plan review after significant changes.

AC.2024.0066 · vd (art. 21 al. 2 LAT)

Equestrian Center Demolition Permit Denial Upheld Due to Proposed Rezoning

Cited in the analysis regarding the incidental review of planning regulations.

602 2024 106 · fr (Art. 21 LAT)

Property Owner v. Regional Planning Authority Regarding Development Plan Abrogation

Cited in the reasoning section analyzing the application of the principle of stability of plans, which was central to the decision to uphold the abrogation.

602 2024 107 · fr (Art. 21 LAT)

Municipality v. Planning Authority: Local Development Plan Adaptation Appeal

Cited in the reasoning to dismiss the argument that the abrogation of the PAD would violate the principle of planning stability.

VR3 2023 117 · gr (Art. 21 Abs. 2 RPG)

Landowners v. Municipality: Annulment of Partial Neighborhood Plan Revision Initiation

The appeal was granted and the decision to initiate the change of the development plan was overturned because the prerequisites of this article (and Art. 21 Abs. 1 KRVO) were not met for reviewing and adapting the plan.

VR1 2024 1006 · gr (Art. 21 Abs. 2 RPG)

Municipal Council Zoning Initiative Validity Appeal

Substantive law regarding the required grounds (considerable change of circumstances) for the revision of a land-use plan, which determined the initiative's invalidity.

AC.2024.0143 · vd (Art. 21 al. 2 LAT)

Municipal Building Permit Confirmed Against Zoning and Heritage Challenge

Cited as the legal basis for the exceptional review of the land use plan, which the court ultimately determined was not applicable in this case since the ISOS inscription did not constitute a substantial change justifying such a review.

60/2022/17 · sh (Art. 21 Abs. 2 RPG)

Building Permit Denial Upheld Due to Protection of Dry Meadow

The court confirmed that the lower authorities were correct in affirming the admissibility of the accessory review of the land-use plan based on significantly changed circumstances.

AC.2023.0343 · vd (art. 21 al. 2 LAT)

Property Owners Appeal Multi-Unit Building Permit in Protected Zone

Cited in the reasoning concerning the incidental review of communal planning, but since this article does not appear in the dispositive orders I-IV, it is excluded.

AC.2023.0429 · vd (art. 21 al. 2 LAT)

Landowners Appeal Denial of Building Permit for ISOS Site Due to Impending Zoning Revision

Cited to establish the need for substantial change in circumstances to justify a planning adaptation, relevant to the application of art. 47 LATC.