312.0
STPOCPP
CH
CH
Art. 189 Schweizerische Strafprozessordnung (StPO) - Ergänzung und Verbesserung des Gutachtens
StPO; 4. Titel: Beweismittel; 5. Kapitel: Sachverständige
Art. 189 StPO · Ergänzung und Verbesserung des Gutachtens
Die Verfahrensleitung lässt das Gutachten von Amtes wegen oder auf Antrag einer Partei durch die gleiche sachverständige Person ergänzen oder verbessern oder bestimmt weitere Sachverständige, wenn: a. das Gutachten unvollständig oder unklar ist; b. mehrere Sachverständige in ihren Ergebnissen erheblich voneinander abweichen; oder c. Zweifel an der Richtigkeit des Gutachtens bestehen.
Gerichtsentscheide zu dieser Bestimmung (177)
92/2005/23 · sh (Art. 189 StPO)
Physician-Patient Privilege Bars Unsealing of Seized Medical Records
The court used this provision to deny the request for unsealing the medical records.
OG 1992 69 · lu (§ 189 StPO)
Suspended Sentence Revocation and Article 6(1) ECHR Public Hearing Requirement
The court confirmed that the procedure under this article for the revocation of a suspended sentence does not contradict Art. 6 ECHR.
60.2024.100 · ti (art. 189 CPP)
Construction Accident Expert Witness Conflict of Interest Appeal
Cited regarding the weight given to expert reports and their assessment.
BB.2024.9 (Art. 189 CPP)
Federal Prosecutor's Expert Mandate in Fatal Hang Glider Collision Upheld
Allows parties to request clarifications or additional questions after an expert report has been submitted.
P/18417/2019 · ge (Art. 189 CPP)
Appeal Against Prosecutor's Order Supplementing Handwriting Expertise Without Party Consultation
Mentioned as the legal basis allowing parties to request clarification or a new expert opinion if the existing one is incomplete or unclear, but not the main basis for the decision.
BK 2024 61 · be (art. 189 CPP)
Challenging Supplementary Psychiatric Expert Opinion in Homicide Case
The appeal was admitted because the conditions allowing the ordering of a new expert under Art. 189 CPP were not met.
P/8962/2018 · ge (Art. 189 CPP)
Defendant's Fitness to Stand Trial and Procedural Accommodations Challenge
The court implicitly used the grounds of this article (incomplete expertise) to justify the annulment of the summons and the requirement for a supplementary expert opinion.
ARMP.2024.38 · ne (art. 189 CPP)
Appeal Regarding Exclusion of Expert Report in Bodily Harm Case
Cited in the reasoning to indicate the appellant's options to submit observations or request a counter-expertise regarding the expert report.
P/1715/2018 · ge (art. 189 CPP)
Appeal Regarding Mandated Supplementary Medical Expert Report Due to Insufficient Expertise
Cited as the basis for the authority to supplement or clarify an expert report or appoint a new expert.
P/22813/2018 · ge (art. 189 let. a et c CPP)
Prosecutor's Dismissal of Negligent Bodily Harm Complaint Against Physician Upheld on Causation Grounds
Cited regarding the assessment of the supplementary expert opinion, which the court found sufficient.
D.cision.2023.54 · vd (Art. 189 CPP)
Prosecutor's Decision to Dismiss Sexual Abuse Case Upheld Despite Prior Conviction; Legal Fee Calculation Adjusted.
This article was mentioned in the reasoning concerning the grounds for ordering a supplementary or new expert opinion, though the appeal seeking a new expert was ultimately rejected.
390----------- · vd (Art. 189 CPP)
Appeal Regarding Refusal of New Medical Expert Assessment in Death Investigation
Cited as the legal basis for expertise completion/clarification, which relates to the contested decision (refusal of a new expertise).
2023.03.07.sr.1 · bl (Art. 189 lit. c StPO)
Court Orders Re-investigation into Medical Procedure Death
Used to justify the ordering of a new expert opinion due to doubts about the correctness of the previous official expert opinion.
470.22.225 · bl (Art. 189 lit. c StPO)
Court Orders New Autopsy in Death Investigation Over Concerns of Incompleteness and Bias
Allows for the supplementation or improvement of an expert opinion if doubts exist about its correctness, justifying the need for a new expert opinion.
D.cision.2023.30 · vd (Art. 189 CPP)
Prosecutor's Decision to Re-evaluate Expert Report Upheld Following Recent Reoffense
Although cited in the reasoning regarding the conditions for updating an expert report, it is not explicitly cited in the dispositive orders (I-VIII). Therefore, it is excluded based on the rule for exclusion.