220
ORCO
CH
CH
Art. 417 Bundesgesetz vom 30. März 1911 betreffend die Ergänzung des Schweizerischen Zivilgesetzbuches (OR)
OR; Zweite Abteilung: Die einzelnen Vertragsverhältnisse; Dreizehnter Titel: Der Auftrag; Dritter Abschnitt: Der Mäklervertrag; B. Mäklerlohn; V. Herabsetzung
Art. 417 OR
Ist für den Nachweis der Gelegenheit zum Abschluss oder für die Vermittlung eines Einzelarbeitsvertrages oder eines Grundstückkaufes ein unverhältnismässig hoher Mäklerlohn vereinbart worden, so kann ihn der Richter auf Antrag des Schuldners auf einen angemessenen Betrag herabsetzen.
Gerichtsentscheide zu dieser Bestimmung (18)
C/1685/2020 · ge (Art. 417 CO)
Real Estate Commission Dispute After Contract Termination
The court's decision to confirm the lower court's finding that the commission was not excessive is based on the application of this article, which addresses the reduction of an excessive broker's fee.
HC.2021.152 · vd (Art. 417 CO)
Brokerage Commission Obligation Survives Contract Termination Based on Introduction Clause
Cited in the reasoning section regarding the reduction of excessive salary, but not explicitly in the final orders.
BE.2018.17 · sg (Art. 417 OR)
Real Estate Agent Compensation Guarantee Upheld
Cited in the context of judicial reduction of an excessively high brokerage fee to argue against the penalty character of the agreed provision guarantee.
BE.2018.17 · sg (Art. 417 OR)
Real Estate Agent's Guaranteed Compensation Upon Mandate Termination
Cited in the reasoning regarding the possibility for a judge to reduce a potentially excessive brokerage fee.
C1 14 179 · vs (art. 417 CO)
Brokerage Commission Rate Dispute
The court's decision to partially uphold the appeal and reduce the commission is based on the principle that an excessively high commission can be equitably reduced.
RVJ 2017 p 312 318 · vs (art. 417 CO)
Real Estate Commission Reduction for Excessive Rate
The provision used to justify the reduction of the excessive broker's fee.
TDSIO C1 13 2 · vs (art. 417 CO)
Real Estate Broker Commission Denial Due to Lack of Proximate Cause
Cited extensively in the reasoning section regarding the reduction of excessive commission, though no reduction was ordered.
12.2010.101 · ti (art. 417 CO)
Brokerage Commission Dispute Over Surface Rights Agreement
Provision used to justify the reduction of the commission amount claimed by the appellee.
165.2011.DCA · vd (art. 417 CO)
Real Estate Agency v. Property Owner Regarding Brokerage Commission
This article, concerning the equitable reduction of excessive commission, was considered by the court when determining the final commission amount, although no reduction was ultimately applied.
12.2009.61 · ti (Art. 417 CO)
Real Estate Agent Commission Dispute and Modification of Agreement
The court considered, in addition to the contract modification, that the claim for restitution would also be justified under this provision regarding excessive commission.
12.2002.145 · ti (art. 417 CO)
Real Estate Commission Payment and Rate Reduction Dispute
Cited in the reasoning as the basis for the court's decision to reduce the requested commission rate from 5% to 3%.
12.2001.2 · ti (art. 417 CO)
Intermediary Remuneration Rights and Equitable Compensation for Property Sale Proceeds
Applied by the court to equitably reduce the agreed commission amount.
C/35317/1996 · ge (art. 417 CO)
Broker Commission on Post-Termination Sale Due to Causal Link
This provision was applied to assess whether the stipulated commission was excessive, which the court concluded it was not.
12.2001.2 · ti (art. 417 CO)
Broker Commission Dispute Over Property Sold in Parts
The initial ruling on the final amount due (Fr. 40'000.--), which was based on the reduction of an excessive fee, explicitly cites this provision in the reasoning for the final fixation of the amount.
12.2002.145 · ti (art. 417 CO)
Broker Commission Dispute over Causal Link and Fee Quantum
Applied to reduce the agreed commission rate from 5% to 3% based on local customary rates for professional mediators.