220
ORCO
CH
CH
Art. 205 Bundesgesetz vom 30. März 1911 betreffend die Ergänzung des Schweizerischen Zivilgesetzbuches (OR)
OR; Zweite Abteilung: Die einzelnen Vertragsverhältnisse; Sechster Titel: Kauf und Tausch; Zweiter Abschnitt: Der Fahrniskauf; B. Verpflichtungen des Verkäufers; III. Gewährleistung wegen Mängel der Kaufsache; 7. Inhalt der Klage des Käufers; a. Wandelung oder Minderung
Art. 205 OR
Liegt ein Fall der Gewährleistung wegen Mängel der Sache vor, so hat der Käufer die Wahl, mit der Wandelungsklage den Kauf rückgängig zu machen oder mit der Minderungsklage Ersatz des Minderwertes der Sache zu fordern.
Auch wenn die Wandelungsklage angestellt worden ist, steht es dem Richter frei, bloss Ersatz des Minderwertes zuzusprechen, sofern die Umstände es nicht rechtfertigen, den Kauf rückgängig zu machen.
Erreicht der geforderte Minderwert den Betrag des Kaufpreises, so kann der Käufer nur die Wandelung verlangen.
Gerichtsentscheide zu dieser Bestimmung (88)
ZK 2014 468 · be (Art. 205 Abs. 2 OR)
Provisional Legal Execution and Substantiation of Inadequate Performance in Reciprocal Contracts
Cited in reasoning point 9 concerning the conditions under which rescission (Wandelung) is permissible, relating to the substantiation of objections.
C1 05 132 · vs (Art. 205 Abs. 1 OR)
Rescission of Sale Due to Contradictory Warranty Disclaimer and Assured Roadworthiness
Cited as the basis for the buyer's right to choose between rescission (Wandlungsklage) or reduction of the purchase price (Minderungsklage).
C1 05 132 · vs (Art. 205 Abs. 2 OR)
Rescission of Sale Due to Contradictory Warranty Disclaimer and Assured Roadworthiness
Cited to justify the court's decision to grant rescission (Wandlung) instead of a price reduction, given the circumstances.
CACIV.2023.47 · ne (Art. 205 al. 1 CO)
Buyer v. Professional Seller: Breach of Warranty for Undisclosed Auto Damage
Cited in the reasoning to explain the buyer's choice between rescinding the sale or claiming a reduction in price due to warranty claims.
C/21600/2016 · ge (Art. 205 CO)
Buyer Rescission of Sale Due to Emissions Defeat Device Not Cured by Recall
The court confirmed the lower court's decision which applied the remedy of contract rescission (action rédhibitoire) based on the legal right conferred by this article.
CACIV.2023.34 · ne (Art. 205 al. 2 CO)
Buyer v. Seller: Misrepresentation of Vehicle Repair Quality and Structural Defects
Cited in the reasoning to confirm that the buyer was entitled to a reduction of the sale price, as the rescission of the contract was not justified.
CACIV.2023.31 · ne (Art. 205 CO)
Acquirer's Claim for Price Reduction and Indemnity Reimbursement Rejected Due to Lack of Timely Notice and Insufficient Proof of Fraud/Justification
Cited regarding the buyer's choice between redhibitory action and price reduction action in cases of warranty.
C/5548/2018 · ge (art. 205 al. 1 CO)
Appeal Regarding EBITDA Misrepresentation and Failure to Provide Timely Notice in Acquisition Dispute
Cited as the basis for the buyer's choice between rescinding the sale (action rédhibitoire) or claiming a price reduction (action en réduction de prix).
OGVE.2018.19.Nr.4 · ow (Art. 205 Abs. 1 und Art. 208 OR)
Seller's Breach of Contract During Unloading, Valid Rescission
Cited as the legal basis for the rescission of the sales contract due to defects in the goods.
HOR.2022.30 · ag (Art. 205 Abs. 1 OR)
Seller v. Buyer: Unpaid Invoices for Plants and Substrates
Used to establish the buyer's options in case of warranty for defects (rescission or reduction of price).
HC.2022.336 · vd (Art. 205 al. 1 CO)
Seller Liability for Undisclosed Habitable Area Defects and Price Reduction
Used to determine the buyer's right to claim price reduction (action en réduction de prix).
12.2021.12 · ti (art. 205 cpv. 1 CO)
Seller v. Buyer: Latent Defect in Real Estate and Price Reduction
Applied to grant the buyer a price reduction due to the defect (minor value).
HC.2021.707 · vd (Art. 205 al. 1 CO)
Appeal Regarding Apartment Sale Defects: Surface Area Discrepancy and Fraudulent Concealment
Cited in the reasoning regarding the buyer's choice between contract termination or price reduction due to warranty claims, which underlies the modification of the award.
HC.2021.786 · vd (Art. 205 al. 1 CO)
Buyer v. Seller: Used Vehicle Fraudulent Concealment and Price Reduction
This article concerning the buyer's choice between contract termination (rédhibitoire) or price reduction was the substantive basis for rejecting the main conclusion (termination) and accepting the subsidiary conclusion (price reduction).
HC.2021.312 · vd (Art. 205 CO)
Appellant Denied Reimbursement for Unordered Remediation Costs Due to Failed Condition Precedent and Lack of Diligence
Cited as the basis for the claim of price reduction due to defects, which was rejected.