143.1
VRPG
CH-AR
CH-AR
Art. 24 Gesetz über die Verwaltungsrechtspflege (VRPG) - Parteientschädigung
1. Abschnitt: Allgemeine Bestimmungen
Art. 24 VRPG · Parteientschädigung
1. Im Rekursverfahren (Art. 30 ff.) kann der ganz oder teilweise obsiegenden Partei auf Antrag eine angemessene Entschädigung für ihre Kosten und Auslagen zugesprochen werden, die jedoch in der Regel höchstens Fr. 7 000.- beträgt.
1bis Bei der Bemessung der Parteientschädigung sind insbesondere der Zeitaufwand und die Schwierigkeit der Sache, deren Bedeutung für die Beteiligten sowie die wirtschaftlichen Verhältnisse der Beteiligten zu berücksichtigen.
2. Die Parteientschädigung geht zulasten der unterliegenden Partei. Aus Billigkeitsgründen kann sie auch der Staats- oder Gemeindekasse auferlegt werden.
3. Keine Parteientschädigung wird ausgerichtet
a) * an Behörden, ausser im Klageverfahren nach Art. 57 ff. oder bei mutwilliger Prozessführung;
b) wenn die Voraussetzungen des Obsiegens erst im Rechtsmittelverfahren geschaffen wurden;
c) im Einspracheverfahren.
Gerichtsentscheide zu dieser Bestimmung (166)
Verwaltung ARGVP 2005 1432 · ar (Art. 24 Abs. 1 VRPG)
Admissibility of New Argument in Appeal; Denial of Party Compensation to Entity Representative
The authority's discretion regarding the award and amount of party compensation is based on this provision.
OG O4V 22 7 · ar (Art. 24 Abs. 1 VRPG)
Settlement Permit Revocation Over Social Assistance Dependency Reversed on Proportionality Grounds
Cited as the statutory basis for the limitation of compensation amounts for the cantonal appeal procedure (Rekursverfahren).
OG O4V 22 7 · ar (Art. 24 Abs. 1bis VRPG)
Settlement Permit Revocation Over Social Assistance Dependency Reversed on Proportionality Grounds
Cited as a criterion for assessing the amount of party compensation for the cantonal appeal procedure.
OG O4V 22 23 · ar (Art. 53 Abs. 3 i.V.m. Art. 24 Abs. 3 lit. a VRPG)
Property Owner's Appeal Against Cantonal Road Expropriation Dismissed
Basis for denying the award of a party compensation.
OG O4V 22 13 · ar (Art. 24 Abs. 1 VRPG)
Farm/Forest Track Access Road Registration Dispute
Cited in conjunction with Art. 53 Abs. 3 VRPG regarding the decision not to award party compensation due to lack of a request.
OG O4V 22 3 · ar (Art. 53 Abs. 3 i. V. m. Art. 24 Abs. 3 lit. a VRPG)
Condominium Association Appeal Against Stream Renovation Dismissed
This provision was cited to deny the appellant's claim for party compensation.
OG O4V 22 4 · ar (Art. 24 Abs. 3 lit. a VRPG)
Pathologists' Substitute Fee for Emergency Duty Exemption
Cited in the reasoning (Art. 6) as the basis for the non-award of party compensation, which is confirmed in the dispositive order 3.
OG O4V 21 37 · ar (Art. 24 Abs. 2 VRPG)
Appeal Regarding Building Permit for Cultural Heritage Renovation and New Construction in Protected Zone
Cited in connection with Art. 59 VRPG to allow for imposing costs on the state or municipal treasury, though here used to explain the grounds for party compensation.
OG O4V 21 21 · ar (Art. 53 i.V.m. Art. 24 Abs. 3 lit. a VRPG)
Municipality Appeal on Refusal to Dedicate Private Road to Public Use
Cited to establish the exception that no party compensation is awarded to authorities, as applied in order 3.
OG O4V 21 28 · ar (Art. 59 i.V.m. Art. 24 Abs. 2 VRPG)
Appeal Regarding Unauthorized Retroactive Charging of Shelter Costs
Used to rule that the compensation can be charged to the state or communal treasury out of equity considerations.
OG O4V 21 30 · ar (Art. 59 i.V.m. Art. 24 Abs. 2 VRPG)
Employee Termination Annulled for Inadequate Factual Basis and Procedural Unfairness
Cited as the basis for imposing the party compensation on the losing party (the lower court in this context, given the remand).
OG O4V 21 24 · ar (Art. 59 i.V.m. Art. 24 Abs. 2 VRPG)
Appeal Regarding Annulment of Building Permits Due to Lacking Water Protection Exception
Applied to order the opposing parties (Beschwerdeführer) to pay compensation to the Beschwerdegegner.
OG O4V 21 41 · ar (Art. 59 i.V.m. Art. 24 Abs. 2 VRPG)
Homeschooling Authorization Rejection Voided Due to Lack of Competence in Issuing Body
Cited as a basis for the discretionary awarding of party compensation from public funds in principle, although here compensation is awarded against the losing party.
OG O4V 21 12 · ar (Art. 24 Abs. 1 und 2 VRPG)
Employee Benefits Dispute Over Social Plan Waiver and Early Departure
Cited in point 3 as the basis for determining the amount of party compensation for the cantonal appeal proceedings (Rekursverfahren).
OG O2V 21 19 · ar (Art. 53 Abs. 3 i.V.m. Art. 24 Abs. 3 lit. a VRPG)
Property Gains Tax on Real Estate Transfer: Mixed Gift Qualification
Cited as the basis for not awarding compensation to the tax authority.