Sentenza — n. 35971/2021 — snciv
Generato dall'IA
Italian Court dismisses appeal allowing new evidence in second instance only for force majeure cases.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Court of Cassation dismissed the appeal against a second-instance judgment that rejected new documentary evidence submitted by the buyer. The buyers argued the documents were indispensable to prove the seller's breach of contract, but the court applied the restrictive rule that new evidence is generally inadmissible in appeals unless caused by force majeure. The decision reinforces the principle that parties must present all defenses in the first instance to ensure procedural efficiency.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 345, comma 3° c.p.c.; In the second instance, new evidence is absolutely inadmissible unless the party proves it could not be presented in the first instance due to causes not imputable to them.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IA
second instance evidence
new documents admissibility
force majeure exception
procedural preclusion
Italian civil procedure
adempimento dell'obbligazione
obbligo di pagamento
rimborso del debito
Disposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAArt. 345, comma 3° c.p.c.
d.l. n. 83 del 2012
legge n. 134 del 2012
Art. 1460 c.c.
art. 1453 c.c
art. 1460 c.c
artt. 2671 c.c
art. 345 c.p
art. 1226 c.c
art. 112 c.p
Giurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IACass. n. 6590 del 2017
Cass. n. 26522 del 2017
Cass. n. 3693 del 2021
Decisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAOrdinanza — n. 361/2025 — snciv
Cassation court dismisses appeal regarding legal costs calculation, ruling that single fee covers both phases regardless of actual work.
Ordinanza — n. 24520/2021 — snciv
Italian Court dismisses appeal for specific performance of sales contract due to buyer's prior breach and failure to pay price.
Ordinanza — n. 12842/2024 — snciv
Cassation court dismisses appeal regarding contract resolution, ruling gravity of breach is required for judicial sales.
Ordinanza — n. 39117/2021 — snciv
Cassation appeal dismissed as inadmissible because the appellate court ruled on a restitution claim never requested by the applicant.
Ordinanza — n. 2149/2022 — snciv
Cassation court dismisses appeal due to lack of valid power of attorney for the special prosecutor.