Court dismissed enforcement of foreign judgment due to lack of jurisdiction and procedural defects. Foreign court lacked jurisdiction; Estonian court found no grounds for enforcement. Judgment dismissed due to jurisdictional defects and procedural violations. Foreign court lacked jurisdiction; Estonian court refused enforcement. Judgment dismissed due to jurisdictional defects and procedural violations.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court dismissed the application to enforce a foreign judgment against the applicant. The applicant argued the foreign court had jurisdiction, but the court found no basis for enforcement due to jurisdictional defects and procedural violations. Consequently, the enforcement proceedings were terminated without a merits decision on the underlying debt.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.; Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.: A foreign judgment cannot be enforced in Estonia if the foreign court lacked jurisdiction or if the proceedings violated fundamental principles of justice.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
!"!
#$ !%!%&' #&#!%%$ ((&! )!
$!
((' *$ +!!&,--. /$!&$"! !% !%0! !! %% "0 %0! ! ! 1" $! ((' *$ $$ !%% 22 0 )!&%0!!%0! !!%%"0
""'$)!!& "" *)$ /$'" /$$$$& ! ! " !%%220 )!! $! (('*$((&!3& 4$0'5/'45/"0!%!%0&!!4/-$!&0 3 4 $$ $!!&! $$$ !%% 422 0 )!& ! "%& &/'"&%!%0!0 !/"0!
+. )!!& !%0%%2220(!! !%% 22 $!$ / $! ((' *$$ )!! $)'$! !34$0$$4/-&& 6%0$! /$ /$!&!%%!'!%0! !!%% "0%0! ! ! 7!& /$!& $ $0 !%%!' !0 -22 / ' $)'' - 6%0$ '$ %&!$ +%0$ ! ! 5 $-. $% !%%!'%0!/$ %&%&!$!/"!$!%&&$"&0 % !!& % %% "0$ 6%0! % ! $ $ !/&8 $!$!!&&!!'$!%!! !!!"%& $$!$ !%/'($0!$!%%) !% ! !%$$&%% +%0$ ! ! 5 $ . ! %) ((&! )! %0! !%0! !! %%"0 !05 !0! $ % %0$ % !$ $ !%&$ $5 $"& 5 99 )! $ / $& $$!! !((&! )!!$$!%&"! &$$ 99 $ $5 !%&$ !$ / $"& ! $ %! $%& '!!& 0!&5"!&!0&! '% ! 6%0$ %%"0 % ! $ % ((&! )!$ )! $! & $ !8#*/&&!$5%)! $!&$%!$!$!!& %& ! "0!$ ! ! ((&! )! /$ !& $$! 0 %! 5 99$ %"&$ /$ '$ %0$ % !5 '99& '(!!)$/$"! $$!!%!%0 !$ ! !%$ !&!!0 ((&! )!!5&%0!!%0! !!%%"/$)'' ! $ %$ '%&%!%0)! $&99$ : 799$!% !/$!5((&! )!%)! $!%0$!%0! !!%%"0& *9! $!$((&! )!%%"0% !%')/%&&0 !# 34-$0$)!!"! !/"0 "! !%! '" ((&! )! '$ !&! 3 - )! "& !/ "%& !&((&! )!%0!!%0! !!%%"/$)'' ! 3-$0'$)!! !$!! '% ! ((&! )!& !! !%0! !! %% "0 %0! & /05 ! ((&! )! % 0$!$ " %&%& " $ $ %&! )!& !/
+.
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