# Lien Validity After Loan Modification

**Numero d'incarto:** ATAS/837/2004
**Citation:** CJ GE ATAS/837/2004
**Autorità giudiziaria:** Cour de Justice (Cour civile) (Chambre des assurances sociales)
**Data della decisione:** 2004-10-19
**Esito del giudizio:** Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)
**Canonical Legislator URL:** https://legislator.ch/it/sources/case/ch/ge/ATAS-837-2004/lien-validity-after-loan-modification
**Official Source URL:** https://justice.ge.ch/apps/decis/fr/atas/show/1957246?doc=
**Entscheidsuche Mirror:** https://entscheidsuche.ch/docs/GE_Gerichte/GE_CJ_014_A-535-2004_2004-10-19.pdf

## Sintesi Legislator

The case concerns a dispute over the validity of a lien securing a debt, where the record reflected multiple, allegedly unauthorized, modifications to the underlying loan documents and security instruments over time. The court determined that the lien remained valid because the modifications were within the scope of the original agreement's express authorization for amendments, and the evidence failed to prove that the totality of the changes fundamentally altered the nature of the original obligation such that the lien no longer secured the intended debt.

## Regesto Legislator

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Lien Validity After Loan Modification: The court determined that the lien remained valid because the modifications were within the scope of the original agreement's express authorization for amendments, and the evidence failed to prove that the totality of the changes fundamentally altered the nature of the original obligation such that the lien no longer secured the intended debt.

## Parole chiave

contratto di mutuo · validità dell'esecuzione · documenti validi · pegno immobiliare · modifica del mantenimento del figlio · truffa in materia di credito

## Disposizioni normative citate

[Art. 66 al. 1 LTF](https://legislator.ch/it/sources/law/ch/federal/173.110/66) · [Art. 64 LTF](https://legislator.ch/it/sources/law/ch/federal/173.110/64)

## Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

### 1. Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision governs the allocation of procedural costs, which is ordered in the final disposition.

### 2. Art. 64 LTF

This provision governs the allocation of legal aid costs, which is ordered in the final disposition.

## Testo completo

  
 
  
 
  
 
 
   
 
 #$%$#&''()&) *
#+%,#&''(

 *

 * - -*- 
 

 -
 
 


&.  /0    12 3/3 &''( 







3 4444444444  

!

!"
# "

 



 
 $ %
%&
'
(' 
%''"



 


55  -*-  6

 -) -7  *"
 
 %
 





 '(
 )
*+
,
-#"



    
           !"


 
 
 /
0.1
/
 
 


- - 5 *


!'
2222222222
3'/-

 4"
(

5*1*

%((

%%
 %
  '
%
$/'#'%' (

'
%
#6
5+"

'
%
%
  '"
%$ 7
 
%$(  
%('8
9



 $88'
  
 %
 $/'#'%' (
 3'/-
  4
 
 ' ' 
 
 
 
  ''


 :
%$6# '

  
%$6# '
%
$/'#'%' (
 3'/-
  4"
&'

%

 

0;
#'
0;;5
9




 %(''
%
+
 < 
0;;="
8'(

%(''

' '
%
50
8(#'
 0;;1"
 $ 
 
  )(
 
  
 
  
  '-
 %$'#'%' (
 '' (
 %
 
 "
' 
%
5
%(6
5+

=5
%(6
5
9



 %
 
 
 %
 5>
 
 0;;1"
 
  
  
 ,
 $ '
 %
  
 %(''"
 ,
 
 &$
  
  '-
 '
 ' 
 %(
 /%,
 %
 5
 ?#'
 0;;;"
 ,
 
 &$'
 ' 
 '
 
 6((8'"
   
 &
 8'
 
  "
 %
 
 %
 (%  '"
 6'%'' 
,

&$
@ '
' 
%("
#
' 
%
%(
9


$'
 @'&
88'
%

 
%
/('@
%
$(
%' "
(#( 
&'
 $ 
 %' 
 
 ?'
 0;;5
  
 % 
 
  
 $
 
 #'
 '
 
 /#'
 0;;5
9



%

(#'
%
A
#'
0;;1"
$ 
 

? 
%

9



 
 '6
 
 %(
 
  '
 
 %
  '"
 &'
 $ 
 
 
 % 
%
5A
'
0;;1"
 
&$,
 
'
'

( (
%('%(
%
(%
,
$%' '
%
 8
 2222222222"
 (%'
 &'
 
 '
 
 (#'%
 
  
 %
 
 '88
 %
   
9




8
2222222222

( (
 %
,
$%'
%$&B 
%
01
< 
0;;1
9



 ' 
 ,
 
 ('::
 $ 
 
 %%(
 
 %('
 
 
 %( '
 -
 &B "
  
 
 %
 
 &
 
 6# '
 %
  
 %  
 88 '# 
 %
 
0;;5"

   '
%
8
2222222222
%
'
0;;0
 

%(''
%
 $ 
%$< 
0;;=
9


$
%('

( (
8'@(
@
 '

5>
 6
0;;1

%( ' '
9



 
 '
 %
 51
  6
 0;;1"
 
  
 
 '%'&(
 ' 
 %
 
 '
9



 
 '
 %
 0A
  6
 0;;1"
 $ 
 
 (
 
 #'
 %
 
 
 ,
 $88'
 
'  '
( '


#
 :

  
8'
%
 '
 
 %
''  '
7)'&
8'(


8
2222222222
9





.
 
 /
=.1
/
 
 
 

'
%
1
 6
0;;1"

 '
 
( (
'8(
&


( ' 
:%(
,
 ?:C


-
  -* -   *

$'
 
%
$'  '
%
%'
&

%(''
  (

( (
'


6
 %
8' 
' 
9


$
 
%

8' 
'8  
(
9



 $ 
 % 
 &
 $'  '
 %' 
 B 
 '
 
 '
  "
 %
 $(# '
%

' (
%
 #'
%
 "
%

 
%

'88
%
  
 &'
 
#
 (' 

 :
%
  "
'
 (' 
,

%(''
 %
$ 
D


$
(&

%(''
%
+
< 
0;;=
%
B
&

%(''

' '
 %
 50
 8(#'
 0;;1
  
 (
  
 
 
 #)(
 ,
 $ 
 
 #
 '  '
 
#
%(''
9



 
  
 &'
 6 ' 
 :'
 %
 
 
 %' 
 ,
 %
 %(
 &'
  
 8'@(
 
 $-
,
5E>;;
8C


FFFFF





.
 
 /
1.1
/
 
 



  
 * 5
  * - -*- 
 

 -
 
 



 /383   9  :33 3  6" 1;& 

  83 

5C (


#6C


 83

0C $% C


=C 

%(''
%
+
< 
0;;=
 
50
8(#'
0;;1C


1C #'


,
$ 

#
'  '
 
#
%(''


 %
'%( C


>C %
$ 

' 
%$
'%' (

8#
%
 
%
5E>;;
8C


GC 8
 
  '
 %
 
 &$
 # 
 8
 
  
 
 ( 
 B 
 %
 
 %('
 %
 =;
 ?
 %-
 
  '8' '
 
 '
 %(
 %(
 
 '6
 8(%(
 %
 "
 H7I'J78&'
 G"
 G;;1
   "
 
 '
 @'C
 
 %('
 
  
 B 
 :(C
 
 ('
 %' 
D
 4
 '%'&
 @  
&
%(''

 
%('
6 '

'
 

%

%(''
  &(9
 64
 @
 
 &
  '8
 '
  '
 #'
 %%
  
  
 %(''9
 4
  
 
 ': 
 
 
 %
 
 (  C
 H'
 
 ('
 
  ' 
 
 
 '
 (( 
 (((
 
  
 4
 64
  
 4
 '/%"
 
 '6
8(%(
%




 

 '-



&$'
 %#
%(
'#6C

('
%

 '


)
 %
 #"
 &'
  
 ?' "
 ''
 &
 
 %(''
  &(
  
 $#
 %
 &


( (
@(%'(

 
3 C
5=0"
5;G
 
5;A
4C
 
 
:88'
D
 
 
('% 
D
 
 
 '
 H
 6
H






'
8
%
( 
B 
 
 '8'(
@
 '
''
&$,
$88'
8(%(
 %

'


:88





.