# Wrongful Attachment Procedural Due Process Challenge

**Numero d'incarto:** ATAS/454/2005
**Citation:** CJ GE ATAS/454/2005
**Autorità giudiziaria:** Cour de Justice (Cour civile) (Chambre des assurances sociales)
**Data della decisione:** 2005-05-19
**Esito del giudizio:** Respinto (Dismissed)
**Canonical Legislator URL:** https://legislator.ch/it/sources/case/ch/ge/ATAS-454-2005/wrongful-attachment-procedural-due-process-challenge
**Official Source URL:** https://justice.ge.ch/apps/decis/fr/atas/show/1957982?doc=
**Entscheidsuche Mirror:** https://entscheidsuche.ch/docs/GE_Gerichte/GE_CJ_014_A-2601-2004_2005-05-19.pdf

## Sintesi Legislator

A party sought to recover damages for wrongful attachment of property, arguing that the statutory procedures for obtaining the attachment were unconstitutional because they allowed seizure without prior notice or hearing, which violated due process rights. The court held that the attachment statute was unconstitutional because it authorized the deprivation of property without procedural safeguards, reasoning that while prompt post-seizure review can mitigate the urgency of a prior hearing in certain limited circumstances, the seizure of property without any preliminary judicial determination of probable cause creates an unacceptable risk of erroneous deprivation, and due process requires at least notice and an opportunity to be heard before a significant property interest is curtailed.

## Regesto Legislator

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Wrongful Attachment Procedural Due Process Challenge: The court held that the attachment statute was unconstitutional because it authorized the deprivation of property without procedural safeguards, reasoning that while prompt post-seizure review can mitigate the urgency of a prior hearing in certain limited circumstances, the seizure of property without any preliminary judicial determination of probable cause creates an unacceptable risk of erroneous deprivation, and due process requires at least notice and an opportunity to be heard before a significant property interest is curtailed.

## Parole chiave

privazione di diritti · diritti procedurali · azione di risarcimento danni da sequestro · diritto di proprietà · rivendicazione della proprietà · sindacato giurisdizionale

## Disposizioni normative citate

[Art. 66 al. 1 LTF](https://legislator.ch/it/sources/law/ch/federal/173.110/66)

## Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

### 1. Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.

## Testo completo

  
 
  
 
  
 
 
   
 
 #$%&'#$&&( 
#()(#$&&)



+ * +  
 

+*
 
 


,-  ./ 0  '1  $&&) 







2222222222

 !


 "!
 ##########

 !!


!


3 
  

    

 $%

 *+
 
 
&&'&
 ()



     
   

         !"


 
 
 %
-,.
%
 
 


 4 

&1 ##########

22+
$ 

&!
34!
-//-

5

 !


2!"!
  !"
$


*$%$
67
8% !"
9

:
 !
;!
 <=!
$
1



-1 
 .
 4!
 -//0
 
 "!
 $
 ;!+
 
 $5+
 4!
 *!
 2
 >
 !
 
 

**<!
$

2*


?

1
 

@

!
* <
 

$*$+
?
 4!
 A!

 !*
$
;+

!



21



'1 
$!!
! 

++
$!+
 !



 "!
$
;!+

&0
3
-//0

 
$+
$
$>
3!


++
* !
 !
;5!
$
*
$B

41



01 7
?

!+5
$
 !
$+ +
 !



$
$
&C
B
-//0

 $*
$
 A!
8D
/0
-'-E'.&
:

++
+<

&!
<!
-//0

2+
 
 "!
$
;!+

&-
<!
-//0
 !

*
$
F!1
G-1-/
!! $
 >
 !*
 $
 34!
 ?
 3
 -//0
 
 ?
 
 >
 $
 1
 
 A
 
 ++
 2
  1



H1 !
 $+
 -.
 <!
 -//0
 
 
 
 4+
 ; 
 
 $*
 $
 A!1


.1 
'/
<!
-//0

 "!
$
;!+

2!*+
 
?

$+1



G1 !
 !!!
 $
 -H
 4*<!
 -//0
 
 "!
 $
 ;!+
 
 !++
 
 $+*
 2!*
 
 5
 
 $
 **<!
 $
 
 2*1
 
 
 +
 I!
 !+
  !"
$

 
J
1


K1 !
$+
!
 
$
&.
4*<!
-//0



2!*+

$+
 $
 -.
 <!
 -//01
 
 
 !4+
 5;
 $
 $>
 *2
 45+
 !
 
 !!
?
4!

$+2
$
2
?

+=!$


=
 $
$4

 !<

$
!

32

 

$*
$
 A!1
 
22

=

!
!

 !*
$
;+
-//'

$ 
 *
;!+
$
 A!
 
 !*
$
;+
-//01
!
!



 ! +
5
5$
<
*I*
;!+
<++2
$;
<$
$
F!1
&//1%
% 

4!
 

+
$

 !*
*
-//01



C1 !
 !!!
 $
 &K
 $+*<!
 -//0
 ;!+
 
 !3+
 !!
 $4
 
 !<
 
$
!
1

"=
4!
$*$+
?
 !
! !
?

 
*$
$
*!
2
?

!

! !(
$
;4!
3*
!+ $
?
 
5

$

 

4!
$!+
$
! 1
 2

!"4
5


 !$
$
!!$
$

!*<!*
$

 !1


&/1 4+
?

 !!


;
+
$
2!!

 "
$
$!

 ;
 !+2+!+
 ?
 
 !+ 
 $
 -C
 $+*<!
 -//0
 $
 
 $!
 $
 
 *"!
 $





,-./&,-//0
 
 %
',.
%
 
 
 ;21
 
A


?

*4+
$
; 

$*
$
 A!
 !
 
 2!
 $
 !
 
 
 >
 $
 1
 
 
 !4+
 5
 
 !*
 $
 *
 $
 34!
 ?
 3
 -//0
 !
 $
 
 5
 
 >
 $
 1
 7;=
 $
 !!$
 5;
 !
 !
 $
 
 !*<!*
 $
 
 2!
?

!!



!4+
5



2>

$+
>
!!
?
 
 +=!$
L
 !
 !
 
 
 !+
 5
 $
 
 *3!+
 $
 
 
 !*<!*
 !4
 !
 ?
 5!
 *
  !"
 
 !+ 
 $
 $*$1
 
+


=+
5

2
5;
;
 
$+

?

 
$*$
$
 "!
$
;!+
M


$*$
$
 *
*!
%
 
 
 $ 
 
 !
 
 $
 A!
 !+="!*
 
 !*1
 
 
 
  $
 ! +
 ?
 
 +=!$
 5
 ;!
 $;
 *
 *!
 4!
 
 * 5

 *

$+<
$
*!

$;+
!
;!
$;
!<1
 !
 
 !!$
 *+
 
 -//'
 
 
 ?
 !
 5
 
 *
 $*$+
 
 !
 
 !4
 $
 
 $+
 !5
 
 5;
 +5
 
 !<
 !$+
 ;!
++
$B*1
 
 


$*$

++
2!*+
 !

 !*
-//0
 !
5

 !*
-//'
;4
 
!
++
!+=+1



 !
!
 $*$+
 $
 $+ 
 ?
 (!
 $
 F!1
 &//1%
 
 
 3
 >
 
 ''H,-//0
 
 ''.,-//01



 * 

&1 

=4
!
;!=
3$!
8:

++
*$2+


+
$"
 
&!
B
-//'

 !<

$
!

* +
$
H
3=
 $
 
 !+$
 
 
 4% !+$
 H
  +
 
 &.
 3=
 !
 8!1
 &
 1
!

H.
 
:1



7
?
;
$
;+
$
&.
3=
!
 !

 !<
2+$+!

 -G
34!
-//0
8 F
&'/

&/.:

!$
 
=4

$ +

&'
2+4!!
 
 $ 
!!
!=
 !*

 !<

$
!
 
 $
 +=!
 
 !
 ?
 !
 3=
 !
 
 $
 ;
 $
 ;+
$
4>
3=
!1



-1 2!*+*
?
;!1
H.
1
&




 7
N


5
$
 
 !+4
?
;!1
H.
$


2+$+!
!

 !
=++!
$
$!
$
 !
 
 $
 .
 <!
 -///
 8 :
 !4
 ?
 
 
 2+$+!
 !
 ;!%*$
 $
 &K
 *!
 &CC0
 8 J:1
 
 * +
 $
 !<
 $
 +
!
*!
 !
3=!
$

$; "


+<1


'1 !3+
 
 * 
 
 $4
 
 3!$
 * +
 
 !!
 
 !4<
 821
!1
./
 :1


01 
 !
 $
 ;!1
 G/
 1
 &
 
 -
 $
 
 
!
 
 !+$!
 $*!4
 8% !"
  :
;!+
 
$;22

!
!5I
3$!


*I*
 !+$!
$
 22!
 5
 
 ! !
 ?
 
 
 $5
 
 ?
 
 
 3!$5
 1
 
 ; "
 
 !
 
 $22+!
 M
 <
 5
 
 $22+!





,-./&,-//0
 
 %
0,.
%
 
 
 !!
  !
 
 ?
 
 *I*
 2*
 %
 
 
 
 *
 !+*+

 +!$
$;!
!+


$+
5+1
!

 $
!+

 !<
$
+
*
$
5;
!
 !
$
 !+$!
?

 3

; "1



H1 ;
 $
 <
 ! >
 $
 
  J
 
 $
 !$!
 ;!
 <=!
 !
 ;*<
$

  

7
8 F
&-H

-G&
$1
H<:1
 
;!1
'
 1
&
 J
 %%

 ! 
$
;<=
$;!
 !




 $
*$
 !

 !
$*+

7
$

!
*
5
4
 
 !
$
$*




71


7
 ;!1
 &
 1
 &
 $
 ;!$
 !
 ;!%*$
 $
 -G
 3
 &CCH
 8 J:

 !
$*+

7


$
!1
-'
?
-.
$
$
4
 


$
;!!1



.1 
 ; "
 
 
 
 5
 
 !!
 $*+
 
 7
 
 *
 ?
 ;!
 <=!
 2!*+*
 ?
 ;!1
 '
 1
 &
  J
 
 5;
 
 2
 
 !
$
!
$
 !
>* +1



;
 !
 !!!
 $
 .
 4!
 -//0
 5;
 
 $*$+
 !
 
 !*"!
 2
 2!**

!+
$
!





**<!
$

2*
?
 
 1
 
 !+
 
 
 !$!
 22
 5;
 '&
$+*<!
 -//0
 
  
 $
 $ 
 +=1
 
 22
 ;!1
 G
 1
&
 J
 !+4
 5
 ;!+
 5
 (
 (=!
 $;!!
 $
 ;!
 4
 
 !+4
 $
 !
 *
 !

2
$;
*!
$;
+
41



G1 
 !!
 $4
 2!
 4!
 !
 !+
 $+
 $
 <=
 2"!
 $
 ;!+
 8 *
 $
 !*
 
 
 !1
 .&1
  J
 
 $
 ! 

;!1
.0
 J:
 !

4
$
;>+
2!+



 2+$+!
!

 !
 !
$


2
$
&&
4!
&KKC
8:

 !

 $
 
 * 
 8*=
 $
 
 2+$+!
 !
 
 !+4
 $
 ;!%*$
$
.
4*<!
&CC&
FF
&CC-

&-0
$
!1
0:1


K1 
 ; "
 
 
 +
 <*
 
 $!
 $
 !4!
 
 !!
 !
 
 *
 $
 !*
 * A+
 
 5
 !
 
 2!
 $
 


8 F
&-H
 
 -G.
L
 !1
 K
 $
 $
 $;!
 $
 ;*+
 !4
 ?
 ;!


 J
4<
$"

&!
34!
-///:1



C1 

*
$B

;


5

 
+1



&/1 
4!
$
;!1
.&
1
=
 

!!
5
<
=
$


$!

 !*<!*
 $
 
 2!
 
 $+ 
 $
 
 *!
 2>+
 !
 
 !<
L
 !
 *
 
 $+!*+
 
 +=!$
 ?
 
 4!
 =
 $; !"
 ;* !
 
 
 * >+
$
=1





,-./&,-//0
 
 %
H,.
%
 
 
 ;!1
 KC6
 1
 &
 $
 
 
 !
 
 !+$!
 $*!4
 $
 &-
  *<!
 &CKH
 8 :
 !+4
5
?

5

 !+$!

=!
 !

 !1
 2
 
 $+<!


+**
 4
I!
*
?

(!=
$

 !
5
=
$
 *"!
+*+!!

+*=
$
+="!+1
 
22

5

 !<
2+$+!
 $
 !
 ;
 $*
 
 <+
 $
 *!
 
 =!+
 
 
 $
 !!
 +*+!!
 
 !3+
 ?
 
 +="!
 
 
 ! 
 =++!
 $
 !+$!
 !+4
 !
 

<!(
$
!

8 F
&-.

&H&
$1
0<:1



 !<
2+$+!
$
!

+=*
! +
5;
A


$
2!

 $22+!
 !
 $;
 !
 
 
 +
 !
 
 *
 $
 2!
 $
 !+$!
?

(!=
$;
 !
5
=
 !
+="!+

$
*"!
+*+!!

 
$
;!1
.&
1

 

$;!
 !

$!
>
$+ 

;!1
.&
1
=
  
$!
5
; !+


!"!
$+4 +

3
$
;
$
 $+ 
?

 !
=

*$!
8!5
7
-//-
 1
.&:1




 ; "
 ;!
 $
 $+ 
 
 
 32
 
 5
 ;
 ;*+
 5
 
 $*$1





,-./&,-//0
 
 %
.,.
%
 
 
 * 
  4
  * +  
 

+*
 
 
 


5.676   8  966 6  :" '%$ ;

  76 

&1 +!

!!
!4<
L


 76

-1 
!3
L


'1 !
 
 *4+
 $
 ; 
 2!*+
 
 &-
 <!
 -//0
 !
 J!

 ##########
$

 !
D/0
-'-'.&

L


01 
5

 !+$!

=!
L


H1 2!*
 
 !
 $
 
 5;
 4
 2!*!
 !!
 !
 
 !+
 !!I
 $
 
 $+
 $
 '/
 3!
 $"
 
 2
 !
 
 !$+
 $!+
 
 !<
 2+$+!
 $
 !
 7(O)!(25
 .
 .//0
   
 
 !
 >* !1
 
 $+
 
 
 I!
 !=+1
 
 *+*!
 $
9
 :
 $5!
 >*
5
$+

!!
$+!
<!



 
$

$+
 5+L
 <:
 > !
 !
 5
 *2
 
 *
 4!
 $*$!
 
 !
 $+L
 :
 !!
 
 =!
 
 
 $
 
 ! !+1
 7
 
 *+*!
 
 
 
 
 !
 ++*
 +*+!+
 
 !
 :
 <:
 
 :
 %$
 
 !<
2+$+!
$
!

 !!
 
!!

*"!
!

!!
5;
 $4!
$+!!
!!4<1

*+*!
$
!!
*!
!

*A
 $
 !4
 5
 !
 3
 
 5
 
 $+
 5+
 
 ;4 
 $
 5


++
> +$+

!!
8!1
&'-
&/.

&/K
:1
 



=!22"!
9
 
!+$
9
 
 
FF
 P!
7 P






 
2!*
$
 !+
!!I

2+
>
 !

5;?
;22
2+$+!
 $

+
 <5
 !

=!22







,-./&,-//0