Settlement Agreement Validity and Post-Judgment Relief Denial
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe court addressed whether a party was entitled to relief after a trial court entered judgment against them based on a stipulated settlement agreement they later claimed was void due to a lack of consideration and fraudulent inducement regarding the extent of liability. The appellate court determined that the trial court did not err in denying post-judgment relief, reasoning that a valid settlement agreement, supported by mutual promises to compromise existing disputes, constitutes valid consideration, and the party failed to demonstrate that the allegations of fraud were so egregious as to render the contract void rather than merely voidable, nor did they timely seek rescission upon discovery of the alleged fraud, thereby ratifying the agreement.
Regeste Legislator
OfficielCONTRAT INDIVIDUEL DE TRAVAIL; RÉVISION(DÉCISION); INTÉRÊT MORATOIRE; REMISE CONVENTIONNELLE DE DETTE; UTLRA PETITA | CO 104; CO 115; LPC 154; LPC 161
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the court fees.
Cited in the dispositive regarding the distribution of court costs due to the partial success of the appeal.
Texte complet
!"" # $ %&'(&(%&))* + , - -
......... ...............
/ 01 2 #3# / #7 / 82 ,42 51# #3# *& 6 *& 9 :13;7 *< *&)4 +
< = &))(
/9 > 2 ;
/9 1# 0 : /9 1# 082 ?@ "1A
/9 ; / /9 1= 02 ?@ #1#;
/9 1 00 2 @BB C#
!"" # $ %&'(&(%&))*+, &
- -
5 0D
3 2 1# "" ;#=1 1 B# 3#D
#E
*9 # # ;; # BB 1# ? C!"" # *& = &))*2 ............... # #@; ......... #" 59 &*,CF')9G#3 ;H "# 'I 1C# J 1 *' B;3 *<<<2 K #1#% #1# ;#3 * ;"= *<<F ?7C# () #31 &))*2 59 *FC&))9G#3 ;H "# 'I 1C# J 1 *' B;3 *<<< K C"; 3##2 ;13# C B# #3#1 L1# *2 9 'E9
&9 # ";"+; &) ;"= &))*2 ......... #2 K #12 M; 1C"; 1# ? C!""2 =#"2 # ;=" ;@#1 1# "# L1# &2 9 *(E9
(9 # #@"#2 ......... # M;2 K #12 7 1 # C;# # 1; # # #3#12 "# # # "##N 1 # 12 K =#2 # 3 "";# ? "B L#9 ((4 E9 1 # ;; 7C "# 59 *<&C)))9G;# O 1 3 # 1# "# 1# ; 1@N 1 # # 7 1C;; ##2 # "" 1#2 K "# L1# &2 9 *,E9
,9 =#1 C!"" # #; # K L()9 *9 &))&2 F9 &9 &))&2 &49 (9 &))&E9 ............... ;# #; / 5#P / / Q2 .......... # 1 / 5#P L #E9
'9 1C# =#1 C!"" &4 "# &))&2 ............... # ; #3 ?#"#2 # "" 1#2 K 1C#@ 7 ;# " K # 9 ; 12 11 # #?; 7C11 ;# 1 K "# 59 *<&C)))9G 7C11 P# #M ;H "# R# @# #MR L2 &49 (9 &))&2 9 &E9
F9 # ?@" &4 "# &))&2 1 =#1 C!"" # 1CM C # #3#1 # 1C#9 (*< 2 2 # ;72 # "; 2 #"; ......... K #A K ............... 1# "" 59 *<&C)))9++9 1 # ;=; 1 # 1 # 1 L1# 42 9 *)E9
49 B ?@" # 1C 1 + C ;H "#9 !"" # $ %&'(&(%&))*+, (
- -
S9 ?@" # # R B#R2 ;# R R M17# 1 # 1 =#1 79
=E
<9 # ";" ;; # BB 1# ? C!"" # F ?11 &))&2 .........2 #@# # 1# 1" / 01 2 # B";
#1 1 ?@"9 1 # 12 K #12 K 1C"; 1# ? C!""2 2 K =#2 # ;=" 1C"; 1 L1# 2 9 &&E9
*)9 2 1 # =?;2 1# "J B # ;2 1# "# #3 "# 59 &))C)))9G 1 3# K ""#@+;H R # #@" ..........R L1# 2 9 & *<E9
9 # ";"+; "= &))&2 ...............2 # 1# 1" / 5#P / / Q2 K 1 K 1# B"# ?@" L1# 2 9 'E9
*&9 ";"+; # 72 1 #1+ 2 7 + C ;H "# 1 59 *<&C)))9G#11; L1# 2 #"E9
*(9 # C#1 C!"" # #; M # K 1C 9 L9 9 &))&2 *(9 &9 &))(E9 ......... ;# #; / 01 2 ............... 1C;# / 5#P / / Q9
*,9 # !;"#7 1# ;1## B# # ............... 1 1C# =#1 &4 "# &))& 1#3 #M ;H "# C# # ;; ;37; 1 ;=#2 C#11 1 B# 7 1 =#1 #3#2 # M1# #2 " C#11 ;H "# L 9 9 &))&2 *(9 &9 &))(E9
*'9 # #H *( B;3 &))(2 1# C#1 # B"; 1 ?@" #3 1 ; 3# L1# T2 &FED
! "# $%&
*F9 # #H2 1# # "3; 1C '' C ;H "# "" L1# 2 9 &, 6 &'2 U 44 6 S(E !"" # $ %&'(&(%&))*+, ,
- -
R 1C# =#1 &4 "# &))&2 1C"; # ;1#; 7C11 P# #M ;H "# L9 9 1 59 *<&C)))9G;1#";E R# @# #MR9
0 2 1 =#1 1 # #11; 1 "# ;1#"; # ;H "#9
# ";"+; K 1C#1 L1# E2 1C"; C =; K 1 K 1# B"# ?@"9
1# ;#2 1C;# C "#B# 31; ? 9 () ;; 1 1 1# B#2 1 1# ;1## 1C"; ;# 1+D 1C"; # #M ;H "# 1 #1# *<<4 K &))* 6 1 1 #3# #11; K 'I 1C# K # C # "A BM; # *' B;3 *<<< L1# *2 9 'E9
" C#BB" 7C# #3 # ;1##2 1C"; # ;@#1" #M ;H 1 "# ;1#";
? 1# # ;V 1# "#2 7 1 2 '9
;72 1# ## 7 1 "# 59 *<&C)))9G# C;H "# 'I 1C# K " *& = &))*2 # ;V 1# "#R9
*49 #H # ;; M;; #M # 1 "1 ;1 B # 1 ""#; *& "# &))( L1# T2 BE9 1 C ........ # P 1C#H 1 *( "# &))( L1# * W ";" ;32 9 FE9
E
*S9 # # M;; # 1 ""#; *, #31 &))( L"= #1 1C31 W ?#E2 P BB ;# 1 "# *' #31 &))( LB9 #" ; BBE2 ......... # ;; "# ;3 @; 1C#H 1# C#1 C!""9
*<9 ......... A 1 K 1C#1# 1# " K ;# 1C#H *( B;3 &))( R* + $ + ! # ;=" J R !"" # $ %&'(&(%&))*+, '
- -
! K 1# #"# # # #3 #M ; L1# *2 9 *)E9
&)9 =#2 ......... B# @B K 1# C#3 #; ,- ! #11# CBB K 1C"; ;H "# L'I 1C# J 1 ;V 1# "#E9 BB2 11+ A ## ; 3# 1 =#12 # #B# ?@" 1#2 #12 K # B"#9 # 2 P# R ! "#;R2 3"2 R#?@# 1 7C1 C# ;; "#;R2 ## B 1C#9 *', 19 = 9L1# *2 9 F 6 <E9
&*9 # #112 ......... # ;1;2 # 1# "#J B# 1# 2 31# CH L1# *2 9 SE9
&&9 ......... # 3; # 1 ;1# "# 1C;"1" " # V1 L59 F))9++E L ?#E9
&(9 # ";" 6 ;2 ...............2 # 1# 1" / 5#P / / Q2 # 12 ;#1#=1"2 K 1C3#=1; #3; 1# "# ;32 2 1 B2 # ? "# K 1# B"# 1C#H *( B;3 &))( R # 7C1 #" / ......... # #" C;H "#R9 11 1 ;@#1" K 1# #"# # # #3 #M ; 1C# L1# &2 9 'E9
&,9 ............... M =# 7C BB2 11 C# 11" #M ;H "# '! # # # 7 1 ;H 9 1 12 11 ;1# #!; #M ;# ;31; # 1# # #H L1# &2 9 ( 6 ,E9
&'9 ............... ; # 711 # 11 C;# =; K 1 K 1# B"# ?@" =#1 7 #3# " # 1 ;H "# L1# &2 #"E9
E
&F9 ##11J1" # ;V 1# "# ;32 ......... # # 1 =#1 B;;#12 # 1 &S #31 &))(2 C ;B" C =1 L ?#E *9
&49 # # 4 "# &))(2 1 ; 1# *J 31 =#1 B;;#1 # 1# ; 1#3 #M =1
* E ;B" # ;; ;; # BB ;# # &' #31 &))(9 =1 # ;; #; " # =#1 B;;#19 BB C # # P 9 !"" # $ %&'(&(%&))*+, F
- -
;B" # 1C# 1C#H ;3 1# C#1 ;# L ?#E9
BE
&S9 1C# ?2 .........2 #; / 01 2 # B";
1 L2 <9 *)9 &))(E9
&<9 ............... # "# "#@ 3# 12 / #7 / 82 171 C ; #3 ;1 "19 ............... # B"; 1 # ";"+ ; K 1# ;39
()9 # # =J3" 1 # 1# # ............... 1 1C# =#1 &4 "# &))&9
(*9 @; # ? # 31; K 1C;7 LRX+3 ;@#1" #M ;H "# 1 B YRE2 ............... # ; R2 ?#"#R9 11 # ;; 7 1# ;1## 1@ ;"## 1# =! 1 L9 <9 *)9 &))(2 9 * 6 &E9
(&9 @; # ? # ;# K 1# ; ?@"2 171 #3# " 1 ;H "#2 1 # 1C#= C #1+ 1#B K 2 ............... # ;1#; CH R1#; @ # " 1 1C;7R RC#3 # "#7; 1 B# 7 1 ?@" 1 #3# # #11; 'I C;H "# 1 59 *<&C)))9G7 "C ;; #11;R 2 <9 *)9 &))(2 9 &E9
((9 1C 1C#2 1# # # ;; ;1=;;9
9
#E ;;#1;
*9 # ;3 " " # ?@" #H2 1C#; 1# ! ?@; LB9 5 *&4 ,<F 9 ( # 9 ,<SN 0!ZX2 ;32 !J ![12 2 *<S'2 9 <F E9
&9 C 1 ##1 7 1 B" B "# 7C ; B# 1C=? C ;3 L 5 !"" # $ %&'(&(%&))*+,
- -
, 9(F'%&))* &<9 S9 &))&2 9 '9 &2 .# [# #3#12 ;3]E9
(9 01 1# ? # 1# C#12 1 H B"; "# ;3 1 ; =#1 1# C#1 C!"" LB9 : 9 T2 S9 <9 *<<4 /D && # BB 1# ? C!""2 *<<42 9 ',N :2 9 2 49 '9 *<<F 0 N :2 9 2 &&9 *&9 *<<(2 122N :2 9 2 &49 49 *<S* D =2 ,)) #H 1 # #3#12 ##2 *<S,2 9 ,'<9
,9 # 1 1# ? C!"" &' B;3 *<<< LE ; # 1 B" B #1#=1 K 1# ;39
'9 1C#9 2 R1 @;;#1 1# 1 C@## ?# LE 1# 1 ; 31 L E #1#=1 K 1;B2 # 1# " "#=1 #3 1 M@ "1; #; K 1# ; #1#=1 3# 1# ? C!""R9
F9 # ;3 ;@1; #M #9 *', 6 *4) L;3 @; ?@"E92 3" K 1C#9 (*S L;3 @; #HE 7 3 #M #9 *', 6 *4) 9
49 #9 ,, #19 * & #9 *FS #19 & 2 # 1# ; ;32 1 /J =1 R?R 9
S9 ;3 C!"#1 B2 1 #9 ,, #19 & *FS #19 & C ?#"# 3; #1#2 BO+ 7 # ##1@ LB9 ? ;E9 1 CA #2 # ;72 # 1 ;3 ?9
<9 # "# ;3 M#"; # 1 ?@ * L#9 *FF #19 & E9
*)9 0 1 =#1 L E " 7C1 A # 1 K ;32 1 #" 1# "# 1 ;# 1 ?@" ##7;2 #2 1 7 1 "A ;3 1# #1; ?@" 717 !B L#9 *4* E9
9 ?@ 2 3# 1# # 1C#BB#2 B 1 # 1 LB9 #9 *4& N %%%02 9 & # #9 *4& N 0!ZX2 9 92 9 &',E9
=E B" !"" # $ %&'(&(%&))*+, S
- -
*&9 01 1C#9 *F* #19 * 2 1 ;1# 3 ;3 () ? K " 1# B# ?@"9 J@1 C#17 ;@#1" 7 "# ;3 @; #H LB9 #9 (*S E9
*(9 # C#1 # ; 1# 1 #1# ##1@7 ;1# ()
? 1# 3 ;3 L :2 9 *)9 *&9*<<42 9 D && #2 9 92 9 ',E9
*,9 0C#@# 1# "# ;1# ;!;#2 1 A # 1 #M #9 &< 9 L#%#11#%A%0!"2 ""# 1# 1 1# ; 31 @32 9 & # #9 *F* E9
*'9 1C#9 &< #19 ( 2 R17C ;1# 3 K ;!;# #"2 "#! ? 1;@#1" B;;2 1 ;1# M 1 " ? 1R9
*F9 1CJ2 1 " ? 1 #J 1 Z\+ *&%*( #31 &))( ;# 1 1 *, #31 &))(9
*49 #A# ;; ?; # 1# B" ;1# # 1# 1 1# ?2 1 3#=1 K 1# B"9
=E ;H ?7
*S9 # 3#=1; C "# ;3 =;2 K 1C# "#2 K 1CM2 V; 1#2 C ;H ?7 #1 K 1# "B# 1C#H 2 1#711 H K 1 1 J "; L 5 , *S< W *<S< &( 9 &N 2 ""# 1# 1 B;;#1 C@## ?#2 3192 2 *<<&2 9 9 , # EN %%%02 9 S # #9 *', E9
*<9 BB2 1C B# 1C;" J ;3 17 1 ?@ C # " "B 1# # ?7 # 7# = "H" 1 "A 37; # = B; L 5 , *S< W *<S< &,N %%%02 9 S # #9 *', E9
!! &)9 1C#9 *), #19 * 2 R1 ;= 7 " 1 #" C "" C#@ 1C;H "# K ' 1C#2 "H" #M B; #3# ;; BM; 1C;H 31R9 !"" # $ %&'(&(%&))*+, <
- -
&*9 1 @;;#1" #" 7 1 ;V C # ;# ? 3# " " ;= # 1C#9 *)& *), 9
&&9 # 72 # 1 # CJ2 11 #3 1C;H "# L# #M 1;@#1 'IE ,# J 1 ;V 1C# 7C1 K ,#!=# # ;# LK 1C;H "# ;! O 'E ?7C# #"2 3" 1 ? ?@" "#13; ;B32 72 ##2 1# # 1@ B 1@M 1C#H 2 K #3 11 1#3 #M 'I C;H "#2 C# 7C BB ;1##B LC # ?7 ;+M# ";#3E2 11 # BB B LC # ?7 311E9
&(9 01 1# 1# ?2 1C#9 *), #19 * C # " ";#32 B#"#1 1C ?7 L 5 *&' ,,(E9 # 3 3 7C "" BB# # C;H LR34 "'34#'# 5>=2 ]""#2 &)))2 9 (( # #9 *), N !;3X2 ""# "#2 &))(2 9 *( # #9 *), N 4 (,< 9 ( =N '& &*' W *<&F ,&FE9
&,9 # #2 B2 ## 3 K 1C#9 &4 2 3" #M #9 *<%&) LR#+1"# M32 # #M = "^RN >=2 9 92 9 (( # #9 *), E9
&'9 01 1# 2 1C#9 ' L# " E C # #1#=1 "#J # K ;# ' L 12 Q_! ]""#2 *<<*2 9 '< # #9 ' N #!%0!12 0!ZX! =1@#!2 2 9 2 Q!2 *<<' LF ;E9 9 (& 9 &&)E9
""
&F9 # 1C##1A2 1 3 C;37 1 3 7 # # 1CBB 2 1 ?@ "#13; ;B39
&49 "" ` ;# " M@=12 1CBB #11 1 ;H "# 1;@#M '' 6 "H" 1C#= C ; ;# 6 J 1 ? 1# ? ;V 1# ;7 L#@% >#1%]11%]"#2 @X _= 0!1==@ ]\2 Q!2 *<<42 319 2 9 *( # #9 F4 E9
&S9 1 ;B # 1 7C## 1 ?@ "#13; ;B39 C =#=1" # 1;2 # # ; 1#3 # K 1# # *! C;H "# 1;@#M2 # #H ?@ B2 # 1# " ` # 2 # # ;2 C #11 !"" # $ %&'(&(%&))*+, *)
- -
L0#!1%#% 0#!12 ]""# 0!] 2 [12 *<<S2 9 ,< # #9 S) &N ] *<F< 9 4*N 0 *<'4 9 &<&E9
&<9 7 1 ?@ "#13; ;B3 1; # 1C#H 1CM; 72 1 B## =#=1" 7 1C 1C# # # !
1 J # B2 !'! L # 3#1; # ; M#E 3 ;9 11 1 C# # ;; B"1; 1CJ9
()9 1 # H ; 1 # 1 #11# K # 1# "J " " L#9 *)&2 *), #19 * E2 @;;#1" "#;#1; # 1C3 C ""#" #A2 #J 1C; B ?# 37; LB9 ] *<F< 9 4*E9
(*9 2 1# 7C## 1 ?@ "#13; ;B3 # 1 # CJ ?#1 1C;#9 # ; ;# # # 1# 7 #3 ;H "# # #1 ;;
;1#"; 9
(&9 7 ;J2 1 H M1 72 B 1# ;3 =2 1 "# ;2 '! #A ;H "# 1 59 *<&C)))9G 7 1C#H 1C# #"; K #A K 1# ;B9
((9 J 12 1 # ;H ?7 ;3 K = 1# ;39 0# 7H 3#=12 #@1+1K ;@#1"9
9 5
E # % M#" =+B; 1# "# ;3
(,9 "# B # 7H ;3 1C#9 *', 19 = 2 7 != 7 1 ?@ # , 9
('9 0 @B B;9
& E #D 6,# 7 8 '9 34#4 " : ";''# <! < 834#4# =#< !"" # $ %&'(&(%&))*+,
- -
(F9 01 1# ##1 @32 1 1 # 1 # ;1"2 ;3 C J@1 # B;;#12 1# " ?@9 1+ C ;# L 5 ,9&*%&))* &*9 '9 &))* 9 ( =E9
(49 ?@ #2 # ;# 1 ; C #2 1 1 7 1 ;; " #+1K "H" 1C=? ;=# 17 1+ # ;; "#1#" M"; L%%%02 9 *) # #9 *', N !2 "";2 [12 9 , # #9 ', N 5 ,9 &*%&))* &*9 '9 &))* 9 ( =E9
!
(S9 1CJ2 1# # B"11" #; , > ;H "#9
(<9 11 C 1#; B1 6 # 1 ; 6 # 1# J@1 K 1C#9 '( 6 * #19 * 31 B#P#2 7 12 B#P )2 D
+ ?! $ , # $ 2# @' ! $ 2# ! * 2#
,)9 BB2 1# 2 1# 1;@1# 1# ? B#P#2 1 ;H # 1;@#1 1# 9 # B M; #1 C; 1@7" #M ;H 7 1 L2 R 3" ;H 1;@#M9 ?@ 1CM; "; # 1 ;H 1;@#MR2 # #9 39 *49 F9 *<<<2 A # "A 2 D ' ; [ + 1#% ] #O+"= *<<<2 9 4E9
,*9 1 D B#P#2 1 C "H" # ;# 7 1 ;# 1 # "#; # !B ;#1 1 7 1 ?@ 1 # #; # ;#1 # ; L01%2 ?# 3;2 " (2 #2 0A2 *<<*2 9 *44N #2 ?# 3;2 #2 12 *<<&2 9 ,&*N !X2 ; 312 #2 #11X2 *<<S2 9 &,4E9
,&9 # 6 #J #3 #; 1C#= C 7 "#;1 ;#1 + O "M B# C #11"#2 171 J@1 1# 7 #3 ## ; 7 1 B#P#2 "# # 1 32 K 1C#9 ()S #19 * QD !"" # $ %&'(&(%&))*+, *&
- -
B#67#C . " " '#! 6 < 44 "! < " # # )9 "!1 '#
" ,(9 # ? =#1 B;;#12 # 1 BB12 ; 7 1 ?@ B C# # K #11 '' ;H "# L 5 *<'' ((&2 ;# =1; # 1 M 5 S) *<4E9
,,9 # 1# 2 M # 1" "=1 CH !; 1# 79 1 J 7 1C 1C ;@#1" 1C 6 "#; 6 C;H "# L_!1 92 D _!1% 1"#%]112 ]""# X ##@#! Q31X@2 ##2 *<<S2 9 &4 # #9 4& Q N %:#B12 0!ZX! 0!@!!2 Q!2 *<<(2 L& ;E2 9 &S'E9
,'9 # # "" MJ" 6 ;@#1" @#1;2 K ? 2 # 1 "#9 11 # #; "" 1C#BB# ;# #BB# "J #9
DE # C#12 1# C;#2 K 1C;32 1 !#=1; K 31 1 1# ;1## 1# "# # B2 B# 1 1C# =#1 &4 "# &))& 6 " 72 K 1C;32 1C;; C# 7C#M ;H "# > "!
"# # #M ;H "# '9
DF # # "; 7C11 ;# 1; # 1 " 1 #19 2 1# "# # 1 RK 1# B"# ?@"R2 11 C# # ?; #1 1 1@M2 11 #2 717 2 R#B;R 1# ;1## # B# "J #9 DG 1C# C#?C!2 1# ;B ;3 L "# # BE # 7 1# ;1## 1@ 1# ; # B# #1 ;# 1 B# 1 1C;79 D "D 1 ;1## ; C #3# O" "##; ;; 11 1# # ;; #; ?9 !"" # $ %&'(&(%&))*+, *(
- -
')9 # 31# #11;@; CH L#9 &< #19 & 9 B;E9 6 @B #1 "# ;3 6 # "B ;39 1 O ;; 3#=12 2 =#=1" B;2 # 1 # C =19
E % 5"1# 3# B
'*9 7 ;J2 1# # 1@ 1C#H ##7; # 3 ;3 # ;#;9
'&9 C# ;3 C#A# # ; ;1;" 3#2 1# ; 1" K 1# B"1#2 B" K 1# 7H2 B 1C#H 9
'(9 # =#2 ;72 K " 1# # B 1C#H #; #M ;H "#9 11 B"# 1C#H 1 1 9
',9 7 ##7; # 3 ;32 1 ;1# # 1 =#1 B;;#1 # K " 1# B# 1# ; ;;9
9 // 0
''9 1C 1@ ;32 1# # 1# 2 # "# ;32 1C;"1" " # V1 L 1# ;3E 7C1 # 3; L59 F))9++E9
'F9 " #2 1 CA # # 1 " ;"1" K !#@ 1# ;B ;39
'49 ; C!"#1 @32 1C#11# ; 7C # # 1#; B#P ;";#9 1 C # 1 # 1CJ9 1 CA # 12 ;72 C#11 ;9 !"" # $ %&'(&(%&))*+, *,
- -
0 / 502
P 1# "# ;3 C ......... @; 1C#H *( B;3 &))( L %&'(&(%&))* 6 ,EN
# ;1# =+B;N
;# 1 B 1C#H # 7C1 # ;; 7 1 "# 59 *<&C)))9G 7 1 ?@" =#1 C!"" &4 "# &))& #3# #11; K R# ;H K 'I 1C# K " *& = &))*RN
B" 1C#H *( B;3 &))( 1 19
;= 1 # # 19
K 1# # #1# K ......... 1C;"1" ;3 7C1 # 3;2 K #3 59 F))9++9
# @BB #" #H # =#1 B;;#1 K 1 # / 1 ?@ B;;#1 Q2 ; 1# * 312 B"#2 K # 4 "# &))( # 1 # ,9S(%&*))( , 9*&(%&))(9
BB ? ;