Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/956/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/956/2005 Généré par l'IA

Property Owner Negligence in Slip and Fall Case

Numéro de cause ATAS/956/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A property owner was sued for damages arising from a slip and fall on the owner's premises, with the plaintiff alleging the premises were maintained in a dangerous condition due to a slippery substance, and the court ultimately held that the evidence supported a finding of negligence because the owner failed to remedy a known or reasonably discoverable hazardous condition within a reasonable time, despite any claim that the substance was only recently placed or that the owner lacked actual notice, thereby affirming the judgment for the plaintiff.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Property Owner Negligence in Slip and Fall Case: A property owner was sued for damages arising from a slip and fall on the owner's premises, with the plaintiff alleging the premises were maintained in a dangerous condition due to a slippery substance, and the court ultimately held that the evidence supported a finding of negligence because the owner failed to remedy a known or reasonably discoverable hazardous condition within a reasonable time, despite any claim that the substance was only recently placed or that the owner lacked actual notice, thereby affirming the judgment for the plaintiff.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
lésion corporelle par chute responsabilité pour cas fortuit régime de propriété prétention abusive du bailleur substance dangereuse responsabilité du locataire

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The provision is cited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs for the appeal proceedings.
Art. 64 LTF
The provision is cited in the final order concerning the granting of legal aid.
Généré par l'IA
A/2239/2006
Premises Liability Slip and Fall Notice Dispute
A/191/2004
Property Owner Liability for Ice-Related Slip and Fall
A/2243/2007
Appellant v. Property Owner (Premises Liability/Open and Obvious Hazard)
A/2350/2003
Premises Liability Notice Requirement for Slip and Fall Summary Judgment
A/3616/2006
Slip and Fall Notice Requirement Affirmation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision is cited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs for the appeal proceedings.

Art. 64 LTF

The provision is cited in the final order concerning the granting of legal aid.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

   

!"#$!%##& '!"&(!%##&

'

) '* ) '+  ) +* , - .

 / 0 - %##&

  

  ! "

!" 

##     $  $ $  $% & !"  &"&. '( )* + ,-

             

3 2/4 3

 1*'

56  % .  5   50*2%  7..8& 9 " "&,  9&-&&". " 9 " %  .:!.  55 :"7  2112   : ,  988& "!  : ! ;<. =&3: ,   > -&" + 9!" !&  : ""&! !:."&  "! " 8.. 6

26 ?&". .  .". &  7..8&  : ""&! !:."&  "! :&  5 & 50006

@6 : , -!& !".  <&"   "  & 211@% 9   !"". A  !- .&&! -&" .".  : 988& "!  9 3 &-&&". =&3: ,  >  "  4 8.- & 211@6 & : ""   2 B& 211@ 3"3& . + 9&". .  & !&A !:& &" .&&!% && A  !- !"" - . : 9&"&""&!  : .-!C 6

*6 9&". .  : !&"  5 B&" 211@  .&&!  4 8.- & 211@% D "  A 9   : !.. +  !-   !""   "  : "  !&. "&!  :. &!  !"&"&! ." <,  =&A  "  !&>6  C  &  : .& A  " !:."&  " - . :& - & 2112 & "" + 9.:!D% -  B<"    : !"" &  :  &7  : &,  &"  21   2112 " : !!E"  .: "&!6

)6  .&&!  ) .7  211@% 9   + !- .  !""  : ""&!  + 9&". .% 9.:!D  3& 9."" - !F"    !&" +  " 9&-&&". ." !"&-" :&  5 .7  21156

G6  50 B-& 211*% 9   : &. 9&". .  & " ""   B"&8&"&8 ! "  "   . &". !& ." <,  && A9 !:&   .&&!  "  =!- " &" +  !- .&&!    )

.7  211@>6  ::  H & ("   .  50 8.- & 211*6

46  * 8.- & 211*% 9&". .  " & !:&   .&&!   ) .7  211@6

I6 9   !"&8&.  !- .&&! + 9&". .  2* 8.- & 211* &" +  & + B!  !& %  -  .&&!  : 9   4 8.- & " )

.7  211@6   .<" ..  :&"   !  2?@GG 8 6% : .""  : ""&! - . + "! "  5 & 5000  20 8.- & 211*6

06 9&". .  .:!.  52   211*    & J ! "  !&3 &" - "  : ""&! + '"  2?@GG 8 6 K6  8&" -!&  7! 8!&% 9 : "% "  8&" A  7! " & " 8&&, " &:!&7% 9"  : "6

/01*/211)

3 @/4 3

516  .&&!  2) !"!7  211*% 9   B".    &% !&. " A 9&". . -&" 8&& + ! -!& 9! &.&""

"!" '<"% A  9" A &" + 9&" !<"&!  <&"   " 

25 & 211@ A9& -&" !"". A  !- .&&!  -&" .".   4 8.- & 211@% A : &   !&"&!   ' < 8&&,  " !: !  9."&" : .&.%  8&" A  8! " 9-&" 7&  - &"&!% :&A9 -&" E D 8!&  ( !""%  9  "  9 6

556  .&&!  0   211)% 9   B". 9!::!&"&! 8! . : 9&". .  54 !-7  211*6   ::. A  " !: - . ."&" H + 9<""&!  !""   "  &" +  : &  !:"  !"&"&! :C. + 9." < 6   !8& . A 9!7&<"&!  &< -&" .". -&!.%  !:&  .&&!   4 8.- & 211@  & ."" : - A  5 B&" 211@ &" +    25 & 211@6   8& -. A 9 .  :!-&" :  :    !:" A  &8! "&!  & &" : .& "

"  9  " 9  % !&" D  -& &"&"6

526 9&". .  &" B". !   @5   211) !"  &" .&&!6  !&< -!& .".  7! 8!&% : .&" A  " !:."&  :! .:!D  "!B!  .". - . +   & % A9  E!&" 3(  " !:."&  A :&  54 !"!7  21126  ,- : &  A  : & -&  !&8&"&!   "  & -&" .".  . !  A9  " !-&"    "' 6  !""  !""  2?@GG 8 6% !&. " A9& "  .&".  5?1)2 8 6 8&  :: A9 .: 8&&, "  9  % A9& &   ! &:!&7  8&  8 +  7! "

A!A6

5@6  ! : .-&  @ & 211)% 9  !"  B"  ! 6

5*6  : .-&  .". !&A. + 9&". . "   < . + B< 6

 +*'

56  !& <-!&  9! <&"&! B&&&  =>  .". !&8&. "  &"&".% ,  5 !H" 211@%  &7 "!    !&% !:!.  )

B<% !"  : .&" "  -&3: .&"% ) ::." " 5G B<   = "6 5 "6 " )G >6

$&" + 9"&!  9."&!  5G B<  % :  &7 8..  

24 B-& 211* = # 5@1  51G>%    !& <-!&  !:".%  5@ 8.- & %  &:!&"&! " &"!&   <" : """  &7 "!    !&  &.<    + " !& B< "&"& % %  9"""  9."&!  !-D B<  6

/01*/211)

3 */4 3

26 !8! ." + ? "6 )G  6 5 "6  '6 @ %  &7 "!    !& !F"  &" &A  !"""&! : .- + 9 "6 )G   !& 8..   G !"!7  2111   : "& <..    !&"    !& 2 >6 A& !" "&- +  !& 8..    : ""&! !:."&  + 9 3-&&%  -&-" " &-&&".  50   50G)

= #> && A9+ 9 "6 *@   !& "!   : ""&! "! !:."&  + 9 3-&& "  -&-" " + 9 3&-&&".

 2) !"!7  50GI = >6 $ !:." :! B<   9:, " && ."7&6

@6  ! % &" B".  ": "&% " -7 = "6 *@  >6

*6  9:,% 9  % : .&&!  2* 8.- & 211*% .. + 9&". .  :&"   !  2?@GG 8 6% : .""  : ""&! !:."&  "! - . + "! "%  5 & 5000  20 8.- & 211*6

)6 9&". . 9 :  &"&A.  7&38!.  "" .&&!%  7! " +   &  9!7&<"&!  7!  &" !6 "" .&&! " , !  " .  8! 6  !"" ..  :" && : ("  &  6

G6  &"&<  :! " , !  A   :!&"  -!& &  ! " :" : ."  +  &  9!7&<"&!  "&"  : ""&! !:."&  "! : E &H"6

46 D "   9 "6 2* 6 5 " 2    %  : ""&! &H" "!'. !&-" ("  "&". L :"%  "&""&!  :" ("  D&<. ! A 9&". . ."&"  7! 8!& " A9  "" &"   &""&! &88&&6

 D !&"&! !" "&-%  ! " A &  7! 8!& " &.%  : ""&! - . + "! " !&-" ("  "&".  A9& C &" & 9D&  &""&! 8&&,   9 .6

 7! 8!& " D ! A  8&" A& !&" + 9!7&<"&!  "&" =-&!"&!  -!& 9! !  &< > ."" 9 !:! ""

!!&8 ! 9 .<&< < - = # 552  51@>6  C  .<&< < - ! A 9&". .   !8!  : +  A& :" ("  &!7" D&<.  "!" : ! :7  & "   &""&! &"&A "   ( & !" = 50IG :6 GGG>6   :" &  7! 8!& 9  .

&:7  & " ! A "" &:&".  B!.  M  9&!7 -"&!  -!&  &< = # 552  51)>6 "  7! 8!& A&!A  !C&" -!&  !&" +  : ""&!% &  :"  : .-!&   7! 8!& & !" 9  " &:"7 +  .<&<6  8&" :!  7..8&&&  9 "  9 3&-&&".   : &8!  9&&" "&!   : &  7 9 "&-&". : !8&! !"&"

/01*/211)

3 )/4 3

 ."  -&!"&! < -  9!7&<"&! 9! N   "    . !. 9 &&  !: .'&! &" ! !&" -!& A9 '<" &:! ""   :&".  " -& !  <& "  "  + &8  !  !&" D : ""&! = # ! :7&. O666  24 !H" 5002>6 9&<!  : 9 .  8&" A9& 9-&" :  !&" D : ""&! - .  88&" : :! ""  A9& ."&"  7! 8!&6  8" 7& :"M" A  7..8&&&   : ""&! &   !&"  !:7 ! "

9 &""&! && & & 9 .<&< < -6 9 . A& &-!A  7! 8!&  !&" : -!& !&  -&!"&! J < - K   !7&<"&! 9! !  &< 6 9 . A&  !&A : +  &  '<"  -   &""&!% !!7""  .:"&! 9 :: D: ,  -!&  &< % 9" :  7! 8!& = # O6  @ & 5044>6

I6  9:,% 9   !&. . A 9&". . -&" 8&& + ! -!&  &< 6

3& ,< -!& .".  7! 8!&6  8&" &! +  " !:."&  - .  8-  ! .:!D% &&""   8&" A9 9."&"  (  7..8& 9 J " !:."&  K A :&  54 !"!7  21126  9<&"

 .&".  : ""&! !:."&  "! !"   !&" &  .".

! : 9    .&&!  54 !"!7  2112% A !" + &"&<   " !:."&   :! .:!D6

 : .& A9 ."&"    "'  !    !"&8&"&!  .&&!   4 8.- & 211@  " " " B! 6 &  9:('&" :" 9&8!  9   !-D !"" E + ! "! 6  %  9" A &" +   D:   &3&  2 B& 211@ A9  : !&" !:&  .&&!6   :!-&" + " .<  &<!  A9& & :: "&"  ! !& + 9   "!" '<" &" -  "  = "6 55  >6

9&". . !"&" -!& :. A 9  -&" &8! . 9   !&8&"&! ::! ".  !""   "6  : F" &88&&  &-  9&". .   &!"%  9"" : A ! A9  :&  A"&!&  "&. + 9  % & & ."&" .% !""%  B!&   !:&   .&&! $ ! 6

#!  "  !"" A9 9 : 93( &8! . 9    A  !- .&&!  -&" .". 6  7! 8!& :" :" ("  ! ! A 9" ! 9!&&! 8"&8  !"&"" A9 -&!"&! .<,   9!7&<"&! 9! !  &< = # 552  51@ L 551  5I1 L  211@ :6 2G1 L $ $ 5000 :6 @I*>6 " .< %  #  .B+  9!&!  B<   9  . A& 9-&" : !&A. 9<""&!   " $ + 988&  : ! ;<.6   B<. A "  . -&" !& 

/01*/211)

3 G/4 3

.<&< < - A& D&" "!" 7! 8!& = # ! :7&.  *2/1*  21 B& 211)>6

 9:,% 9&". .  :!-&" &<!  A 9<""&!  !""   "  < ; +  : &  !&. "&!  :. &!  !"&"&! ." <,  &8 &" !  !&" D : ""&! !:."&  "! " -&" !F"  ! !7&<"&! 9! "!" !&8&"&!   &""&! :" &!&%   " ::.   .&&! A& & !" .". !"&8&.6 $ 7! 8!& !&" , !  ("  &.%  A& 88&" :! D   &6

/01*/211)

3 4/4 3

  +'*1  '* ) '+  ) +*



234   5  6   78 .(% +9

  4 

56 .   !  -76

 4

26  B""6

@6 &" A  : !.  " < "&"6

 < 88&,    .&" N

 &3!&  P ! & Q   

 !:& !8!   : ."  (" " !"&8&. D : "& :  < 88 

/01*/211)