Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
ATAS/654/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/654/2004 Généré par l'IA

Breach of Contract Damages in Commercial Lease Termination

Numéro de cause ATAS/654/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party initiated litigation seeking damages for alleged breach of contract concerning commercial property, specifically challenging the application of a provision related to early termination and the associated financial penalties. The court reasoned that the contractual language concerning early termination and the calculation of damages was unambiguous, clearly outlining the obligations and consequences for the terminating party based on the facts presented. Consequently, the court upheld the contractual terms, affirming the award of damages consistent with the contract's explicit termination clause, thereby dismissing the party's claims for relief.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Breach of Contract Damages in Commercial Lease Termination: The court reasoned that the contractual language concerning early termination and the calculation of damages was unambiguous, clearly outlining the obligations and consequences for the terminating party based on the facts presented. Consequently, the court upheld the contractual terms, affirming the award of damages consistent with the contract's explicit termination clause, thereby dismissing the party's claims for relief.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
résiliation de bail commercial dommages-intérêts contractuels manquement du bailleur résiliation anticipée contrat commercial partie au contrat

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Généré par l'IA

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               #$%#&%%' (#)$'#&%%'

(

 (* *( *  *  

$+  ,   &$ -. &%%' 



- ////////// ! "#" $ %  ! &'!(()#'#!(##



! 

00 *( *  1*2*3( ( #!#' *+,!-./0.00123



               !"

   6.4036  

* 0(

07 "#  8888888888  !#!*92':'2 # 0+/0! #2' ;#  0+<,7  *  ! 2#'  !   '=:(97   '!' 2#!# (& #(!  :# 9#!    ! (& #    !> '!#)(!(.?@!0++07#!!(!# '!'##!' !!(! 2#7

.7  .. ('>  0++. #  (''  (( (  !!# ( & 6 #2#(#!'  # (  >1 ( ( ( ) ! ( >  2#! A  !7

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

-7 ;#!A('##(& 6#2#(#!'(..K#0++- :!&! #(& ! & '  #! K!'   ! A &! # (   (& (   :#7

/7  ('##(03('> 0++//3/40++- ##! (  !#1 (& 6#2#(#!' '!!(#   ! 2*'A&::#!(& 6#2#(#!'E#6 1& F  B( ( '(!!#7

?7 & '  '!' # A  !9 (&> 2!#  :# ( .? @!  ./ 2>  0++?7  B ! ! : '  # #2!C D    !! ! 1 ('! !#: !  > ! L7 8888888888  = =' (!># "(!# ! ((B!9A&B!' # A>!# 

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

,7 (!(0-#0+++& '(''(((( !!#( & 6#2#(#!'2#!A&! #(& ! #(( = #) (!M!((!(&'#!7

<7  (! ( - ('>  .555  '(#6! #!!    8888888888  ' #! A &  &#: ! )  !#! 2#! '!' =#!#'  (#2## ( =!9# ( 0,  .? # .555  # (& 99 2!# (  '!! ( !' (  !B! (& *(  ( B = #)7  '(# :# #! 9 #((#(& '(#0++,!B#)#!)  !#! '!#! #2# (#    !!# (  (  '9! A &'!>#!=#!# 7  8888888888*#!(((!#! !(!A&! #(& !(&#2#(#!'7

+7 & ' '!'#A B !#'(# (#!  8888888888 '##!'(##! !(# =!#7 !B !: ' (   ! ( .- !>  .550  # #2!C D  !#C !! =#)7EGF##!!#)#!!#2!)!#!!#2=*#)C !!)!#!>K!7 #(' !("#  8888888888  ># 6(A (   (&' 9 ( =#7  ##!!#   *=#) ! !C  K &# (#! (  (##  B !# *=#! #)  > >! '# 7   2#    # ( ##!!#I7 '(! A ( )!# ! B !  B' )  ! > ! !#2#!  ##!' ( ! 2# !!7  &* 2#!  ( #!' '#((! 2#7 &!#2#!'B 'K)&## &'!#!B#9#>(!!7  * 2#!(##!#!!( (!7&##!''!#!(##'(.5P #(#(!(&#(!.?@!0++07&##!'(! 2#&2#!  :#!  '2' #)& '!#! !' ( 055 P7  #>##!' (&'#    #!'(! 2#  #= 9*=#! #) ' 2(&2#(

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

007 & '  '!' # A  B !# *=#! #)  (! ( 3 # ! 3 K# .55. (#!      L88888888887  ( #   B'   ) #2!CD '!!!A!!#:#!#:: !   &#  !  2  (   (&!!!7  2#! K)&A   ( !!#   !!   M! ##) ( #! !  > ( ( A ( #!  ! #!  #! )  ( &# # (& !!#!(  =*#9#)!# '#!7EGF! '2#:(( ' #!'# !  '#!(#!##9#))! (T27

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

0.7   ('## ( . 2 #.553 &   K!'  (( (  !!#  !#: )  (B B !# '(# !!   )#  #!  ! =*#) )*=#):# #!#!'(! 2#(& '7

037    #  ( < 2 # .553    8888888888 &! ( ' A &  &#: !(&=#!#!# '!(0..0 .55.)#:# #! :#> *9# ('' 2  *(  ( B = #) ( !* :#> *9#7 !:#   ! (&=#!#!# ( &'!>#! =#!#  ( .,   .553 B' A   #  2#! ) !  B ::!' '!#!! #!! B7(#!A&=V#!2#!!#!'!#!    #  = 9 =*#!=' !#) #' A  = !=' # !9#)!!#6#:!# )#>!(&#(&=#!#!#&'!#! ! (#! '# !###)!>7

0-7  (! ( 00 2 # .553 & '  : ' #!#    (& ! !# A &  !! &2#   ( #!' ( ! 2# ! 2#  ( #! A  ! !#1 (&#2#(#!'7!!'&# !##!'(&B !*=#!  8888888888

  4/54.55-  6?4036   !B#)'2#  !# (=O#M! 9'7;'!!( !' 2#! (& :U 9''   9 ( #:    2# )!#(# ! &2#!:#!)(&99 2 (##(!(0++07

0/   ('## ( .< 2>  .553 &   K!' &#!# ( & '  :(! #(&B !#*=#! #)( L8888888888 )& ' '!#!#!'!!(! 2#7

0?7    #  ( 03 K2#  .55- & '    !  !! ('##   #!# ! A &! # (& ! !#1  (&#2#(#!'7  ::! &B ! 8888888888#2#! ##!'!!(! 2#!2#!!#')  !#'!#!!! =#)!)&!#2#!'&'!#!B#9#>( !7  &  &'!#! :('   &B !# (   L8888888888 *=#!   !#  !(( 88888888887 !A&B !#( L8888888888 &'!#! ! !#2' !  :(#!  ##!    :#! )  ( #  2#!::!':#! (&B !#'7

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

0<7  # (0, .55-'(#6! #!!B#)')!#!  '!#!'K !#('!!9'' 2(& != #(#2 (  '#( O #2#(! ! (&!   !  !  (  #:: ( !!  )# #! M!   >>! ' '  =#!7   #   !#! 2#! ('2' '!  (#>1! #9  '#!!  #2#   :(#!2! #!!!#6(#>'!#)7



  4/54.55-  6,4036   *  (

0"   # 92#   & 9#!# K(###  EF  '!' (#:#' !  #!#!' (10 @!.553 #>!( #'(/ K9(! '#(!!2#6 '#(!/'!!0?K9  E !70!7 !/? F7

;#!A&!#(&'!#(0?K9   #>:'('  ., K2#  .55- E L 035  05?F   ( # 92#  (!'  03 :'2 #   (##!# ! #!#   9!  !!!  #> ! (   # ( #'9     A ! # K9 !#!#   ( &!!!(&'!#(2BK9 7

;!!!   (( #!># #>:'(' ( M!(0  K#!.55-:# ')(##!#! #!# !#!#!!# !#!'!#!: (  J!( #!:'(' E M!070<34.55-F7

9!##()!#(&#!#!!##!'( #> !(   # #  (' ' )   '!# (  ! #>  2#! M!  #2: (' 9!# (( #!:'(' #!& & !7 /, 7

.7 #:'('   !#9'' (( #!( #(?!>  .555E F!! ' 2#9 0 K2# .553!!(#> (&1E:7 !7. ! !70(#:'('  & 6#2#(#!' (0+K#0+/+6 F7

37 ! K!'(:  )#!!!#  ! 2>E !7 ?5!?0 F7

-7  &  &   #'   ! !! ( #! A (  !!# ( & 6#2#(#!'7& ')!A#!A&! #(& !!#1  (&#2#(#!'7 &9#!(1 (('! # (9 '(&#2#(#!'(  !! '2!( #!A !7

/7 B! (Y !7<70!3 ! '!'#2#(#!'&##!'(9# !! !#)# ! '' ! (9( '7  ' K  )# &B U#!  (&!#2#!'  !#2 2! (&M!  !!#! (   !'=*#)!!(!#!M! B#9')&#B !! '!' #2#( # &!!#!  M=! (&#    ! 2B =>#!7 ; & !7 -   Y#2#(#!' ! '!  (Y #:# #!' 9'#! (Y (#(Y#(!7&#2#(#!'! '!' 2(1)&!  ! !9 2#!'  A2 # ( #!B !!#! !#(' !#7

  4/54.55-  6<4036    ! '!' ##!' ( ! 2# !!  ! !!   !# ( &!#!( ( & ' A #  (   :#   (# (&!#2#!'  ! 2# )# ! M!  #>! M!  B#9' ( # # !!  ! '! (  !' =*#)!7 (&##!'(! 2#(9( '&!#2#!')# ! M!  B#9' ( # ! # 2  (& !   :#  (& !  (#(&!#2#!'E !7? F7

 &##!' ( 9# ! (':##   !! (##!# ( &>  (&  !# ( #>##!' ( 9# ( & '     =' ( ! 2# ')##> ' )# !   #(' !# # !! (##!# '! (& !!#! A  !' =*#)  ! ! )&  #!  1  ! #!! !    ( '(!!#B#9#>E !7, F7

;  (##!# '9 (   !  #> K)& 30 ('>  .553Y '( #!A !!#1 Y#!#2#(A??.43P#A (#6 !Y#!#2#(A/5P#A) !( !Y#!#2#( A-5P#E !7.<70 F7'#>#2#(#!'(-5P #2 ( #!A(#6 !E !7.<70># F7

6. B !  ( & !7 0, 7 0   #  !B (&#2#(#!' ( >'':###  (  !>#!(#:#!#!> !!(&::# (( '2#'   &2#  A 2#  9!'  '(#!  ')     #'7

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

  4/54.55-  6+4036    )& (( ( '2## ! ('' 6# (#! '!>#  ( :U #>)&#2#(#!'&#!(& '&!(#:#'(#1 A #: ( #!7 ) !&!# #!!'!' :'   )  (9 ' (&#2#(#!' '!#! #::#!    )&# &* 2#!  (&#!  2 ((  ! M!  B#' ) #  (#!#  '2A&73! #E !7<,73!- FC

,7  2#  (9 '(&#2#(#!'&(##! !#EK9&#*   F>#((!)'(#'2!!#(&!  '##! (#2! # : # 7  !H= ( '(# #! A  !   K9!   &'!! ( !' ! A #(#)  ( )   !   ) !#2#!' & ' ! #> ( ! 2# 7  !   (' '(# !#!!  ''! !#   ('! #  ) ! 2B  !   #>!B#9 (& 'E L0./.?0#(7-X00/03-#(7 .X00-30-#(73X05/0/<#(70F7

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

  ##  K9  &' !   !#: #' !#: ( # (& B !# '(#  !H= ( &B ! '!!  '#'! ( !!   # '# A  (##!# (  K!# :# ( &'#      ! '(#B (& '!! ( :#! ('7 ;  K # ( ! !#!   #(&' ! (&B !#K(### :#!)6#!#( ! (#!#  )&  6B !#  ('    ! #>  #:#   # ( #1  2#!7  !   ) (&!  '##! '!!! ( ## ! #  ! A !!  ' #!  (!   !# ( ('(!# ( &B !   ! B     

  4/54.55-  6054036   #!  '!!#(#2 9!(#(( #  K9># #! !#'!# : (&2B !#'(# E L00<.+5#(70>X00.3.!7! ':' F7

)#  # 2  >!(&  !'(#)# ! ('! #! &! )  #! #!#9#B # !! #! :#! &>K! (& '!( :#' )   !  :(   ( B ! )&#   '9!  #(' !#  #! B #' )&# #! '!' '!>#  # #((#  E1F)( #!#(!B!'(##! #  !:#) #(&B !#!>#!#2'E L0.. 0?5#(70! ':' F7 &''!('! #! 2  >! &! ###& #9#(*( 2#('#9!#:  (&  !  (& B !# # > ! >#  ! E L 0..  0?5 #(7 0X " (# 2#(#!Z!>9 # (  >#9! #= :2 #= 97.+,!7X" :(#O##=9!=!9# ( ; #; ;3.40+<<733.!7F7

 ! '9 ( "   #9 ) &B !# (#! M!  :('    (!!# 1! ! ( (#9!#  '# M!  ! 9 H A  (## 2#! (  #!' !  !  ( ' B=!#2 !  ')#2) B )!# ' E"   &B !# '(#  ;#C !#:#!6 B B#9 ( )#!' !R # ; ; 0+++ 7 3, ! 7F7 M $ B)&B !#(#!M! 1!)! B:#! !A#!B 'B)!#'7 (#! M!   '=#> ! !   ! =  ( #! ( ( #! E $  [ !9(#=! ( ;=2 !Z(#9# 0+++7 /?,!7F7

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

  4/54.55-  6004036   !#!7  (#!  :# &' !  ( & '#!#  >K!#2 ( '(# ! #!!7

<7  &    !  (''   #1  (( (  !!# ( & 6#2#(#!'('> 0++.!#:#!&>K!A!!#(& B !#*=#! #)::!'   88888888887 !B !2#! )  !'!#!99'( ##! #)# !!2( ''! ( #!# ! ( #!#7  (#9!# '!#! #  ! #C ! ! !>9X(!>#)  !2H!(&#1  ! 1('! !#2!>#!H!#&2' #!)#2#A#( # =#!  ! ! !#2! 2#!7 ;#! A !! B !# &   K!'  ((( !!#(& '7& '  ! !!('##! ##!(   '!! 2*'(# A&   #\2 ( ( '(!!#7B ! :#!  A  #!' !#1  ( ! 2#   ! ( = 9  ( ! !!# !!#) (>!7  # 0+++   !  (''  ( (( (  !!# 2#! A &! # (& !  # ( (  = #) (  !M!((!(&'#!7:#!&>K!((BB !#'(#& (#!  8888888888'##!(##! !(# =!#&! (#!  L8888888888*=#! 7

   8888888888 B#) ) &  ! 2 ># 6(A (   (&' 9( =#72#!##!!##!B#))  !! ( & ' !  #! 7  &*   >K!#2! # &  !#!  ! (  !! ( & '  >  '!# !   #! &B ##) !  )# ! !  (&>K!#: ##)!7   : '   ) #2!C D    :# K  )  (2  ( ( >1( =#("#  8888888888! #('   )   >1 *=#! #) (! &  (2  M!  ('! #'  (B !*=#! I7 '(# '# )&#B#!-#!( :#> *9#   0< )&# &*    9! ##)  :2  (& :#> *9#  7  #(#) :# )&#    )&# * #! (&99 2!# >K!#2!!>(#0++,!(##.5557

 ! B # (   L8888888888  !  7 ! B ! B#)  ::! )   !  !  ! 1 #!  (  !# # )  !=*# !    2#B ># (' )&#   '!  ( #9 (&>!!!  ( !#! ( ('2 #!# ( >##!'  (&#!##!'7!'2#((&''!(#9'*=!#)!) ('# =#!#!#62##!='#)7 !! :  (  ' !   >1 # &*   ( (' 9#!# !X& '! #!'B(#2 (7(#9!#'    L8888888888 !  #2!C '2  ( !# ! #!# E >>F7 '(#' !(#9!#(! >!: ( B

  4/54.55-  60.4036   & ' =!2:##!'>#! #!9# )&#!> 2'(  :M!   #2# (   A  #7 &B ! ! )  #!' ( ! 2# ( & ' ! 1! ( &# ! ) !#2#!'     *=#)!##'(#!!7

  # ( (B B !# !  (!7 ;   8888888888#&* A& ( >1( =#(&B !#' #( >1*=#! #)!&B !*=#! & ' '!  '2  ( ! :#! A  #!#7 :#   '#!#  !#2' ( '(# ! #!!  !  ( !  A !!     #(B !!#'7

 *  #  !  ( 2  )  (B B !# !  # 2   >!(K # (( L 7

   #   ( (B B !#  :#! '!! (& 99 2!# ( !' (# #1 ('##(& 6#2#(#!' :!&! #(   :#  !7&*(#A '2##& 7

 2()# '1( #>('!!)#!'(! 2# (  ! !!#1  (&# !) !#2#!'!) !!(9 ' (&#2#(#!' ! 7    #! (1    '!(  A (  !!# ( & 6#2#(#!'7

+7   #:!!:('  ')! K!'7





  ;" L;        ; ;;  ;;   ;C



4-5-   6  7-- -  1" 8)&  

  5- 

'  2>    #! K!'   "#  8888888888 !   ('##   #!# ( . 2 # .553 ( &::# ! ( & 6 #2#(#!'X

 5-

07  K!!X

  4/54.55-  6034036   .7 :# ('##(!!  X

37 #!) '( !9 !#!X

-7 :    !# (  )& 2! :     !    '!  M! (  ('# ( 35 K  (1  !#:#!#   # (' ( '  #> :'('  (   ;=[#O =:)# ? ?55-     ! # B# 7  ('#  ! M!   9'7  '#  (#! C F #(#)  B!!)('##  !('# >!# #!(('## !!)'X >F B    ) !#: # !# 2#  ((  !! !  ('##X F  !   #9!    (   '!!7 ;#  '#   !#!   ! # ''! '' '  !!  F >F ! F #6(  #>:'(' (  !  !#1    )&# (2 ('  # 2>7'# (  !#  * (  2 )#  ! K#! ## )  ('## !!)' ! &2 ( )'!'B'(#'  !E !703.05?!05<F7  9 ::#1 C   '#(!C   %] ^ "*  "     '!# 6K #!CL '(' #) ; 

#: ( '! M!!!#:#'B !###)&A&::#:'('  ( # 9 ::



  4/54.55-