Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/580/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/580/2006 Généré par l'IA

Untimely Appeal Following Partial Judgment

Numéro de cause ATAS/580/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party disputed the timeliness of a notice of appeal, which was filed after the statutory period following a judgment that was entered under a rule allowing for finality despite unresolved issues. The court reasoned that when a judgment is entered under the rule permitting finality while other claims or parties remain, the time for appeal runs from the entry of that specific judgment, not from the subsequent entry of a judgment resolving the remaining issues, and therefore the appeal was untimely.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Untimely Appeal Following Partial Judgment: The court reasoned that when a judgment is entered under the rule permitting finality while other claims or parties remain, the time for appeal runs from the entry of that specific judgment, not from the subsequent entry of a judgment resolving the remaining issues, and therefore the appeal was untimely.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
demande partielle délai de résiliation retard injustifié qualité pour recourir délais de recours interprétation de l'arrêt

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Imposed court costs for the appeal.
Généré par l'IA
A/3151/2007
Appeal Timeliness Based on Judgment Entry Date
A/316/2006
Notice of Appeal Timeliness Following Motion to Alter or Amend Judgment
C/24373/2018
Appeal Dismissal for Untimely Filing
A/4332/2005
Appeal Deadline Calculation Following Untimely Motion Ruling
A/1425/2022
Appeal Regarding Inadmissibility Due to Untimely Filing and Lack of Justification for Delay

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed court costs for the appeal.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



               !"#$%!&##' (!')#!&##*

(

+ (, + (-  + -,

. / $  &0 1 &##*         !"#$%&$''" $ (&$'')$  *'    $    + ! ++    +++ ( ++    + $"& (   +!,-"$$$.!/001   

               *126*  

 2,(

.7  !&.4/6!"#8&'""'9"$!&$$ -:";'#<$1001=(&$&%$"'('$'>'$'6 '&"?100@7+&$&#-;# ++    +++  ( ++    +(   +*+ A*#BC7

17  '& ' .@ % 1005!    9"& (& =( $ '  % ' '"$& <B 'B  15 % 1005! '$ D =  %$ %&##$&'$%7 ($9'&##$'.1% 1005 &$? #   ! "&'* '  + 7 *  ##& = (& %$ ?  9$ '  ? ' . "&$# '$ A9$ ' $$C "& ' #" ?'! =   %E %$ <$9& ($%$ '   ! = %$ #$=&  1 #$"? 1003  $&$"! E$$" '  %E! &'$ $ $-'B $#&F* "&$# % ;99 #;7     %& = (&%$ $& %$ &$& $ " 9%? $ =  #$$ &$$ $"$ $9$ ' &$$ ? = #&$$ ' ' &'  % #&$ $  '&9$ 9$ $"$  % ' (##$'#=$"$&7'B='$%$& ""  &$$ #  #$ ' -;  ' $%E % $ &$$'9!(&#%$$%D#$"#7

@7 '&'.@<$1005!<$&(##$9"&#(&7

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



230.421005  *@26*   $ ? '  97  E$ "9$"$ ' &= % $$$ D ($&;$&#%$%'$&H7

(&$"='"#9'=#$$%!($* D*'  $%   %$!  #$  %$ $ ($$! $B; &%$?"$#$'$%#-8='='"-'#&! =(D    7  #! "I" '  -8#$-&$= $%$&D.00K""&$$99$#-8=!$D ? ' '&;&"$ %'$! #=( &#% ' '99$& D & D  "!$=(&$#$"$%7

(&#$&&$?"$'(99$#97

57  I$ '$ ' .@ '&"? 1005!  ? ' &  <$& $$ '"'7

/7   &#  9' ' .5 9&% 100/!   ## =    !(&#&$##$&'$%'$%$& ""&$$#'#$'-;'$%E% '$ &$$ '  97  'B 'B  = '  '" '($%$& #9 = $  ' (&!  #$& ' $%  $ I$ $7 '?"I"E"$=$'#$&'$% (;''#$?B%"$#&%$-:";!'=@0K' $"#'%$I$&D'$%E'9!$$=(#$& ($$'$==L$#'1/K''='$D' '"$&<B($#%$7

67   ' ./ " 100/!  $ $   9$ =     =(  $% <" (; '  " '$ "" %$7'"'D="&'$$'7

M7      &$& $' #  ? ' &  / < 100/7     &#&$& =( %$ # $$ % 'E " #B ('$=?';$(%$#&$&#&!'"G '$ ' # '$ %$ &$& %&7  $$"$ $ &$& '99&$ N  $ &$& & ' #&' D  &'$ '  9$ $ D  9E$ $"##'E?-7+"&'#'$!($##?' ''9OP&=$&$&#""#$$7

#B % E"& (&  1 < 100/!  &$$  " ' ' = (&%$#$*#&$&$$=79"&=(&#%$# "# ' $%E ' 9! $ =  #$ ' ' -;! " = (;$'$J-'"$$%!#&$$#'"$$D##"$ #!''$8;#-'(&$"$7<$&="I"  (& '%$ $%  '$ ;$"#!  (8 $ #  # '



230.421005  *326*   "$$!'"G#$"#7<$&=((8%$# '(;;%$#&%?7

$'  "I" <! (&  ;& =(  &$$ '99 ' $%  "#  "#$ = ' $J- '"$$%7  99" ' $ % ?$  'E ' "# ="$ # =( %$ #$& = ' $%E'9$"#'$$7

+=&$&;'&D<;7

 -,(

.7 ;%L;$<'AC&$&"'9&$$$&!'B .P$100@! ?$'!"#&'5<;! '$  #&'$ $  %*#&'$! 5 ##&$ $ ./ <;  A$7 . $7$5/ C7

+$DL$'L&$'./<;!# ?9&'& 16<%1003A ,.@0.0/C!' ;%'#$&!.@9&%!  '#$$$;$#"$$$ ?$'  ' &;   D $ <; $$! ! ' L$$$ ' L&$'%E<;7

17 9"&"$ D ($7 5/  7 . $7  -7 5 !  ? $ ' )$$='$$$#&%DL$75/ '9&'&#$;&&''$''/$? 1000 $&  %;  . <% 100@ A C! = $ $% D   9&'&L*'$'10".4M.A C7

+"#&$#<;''L#B$&$?7

@7    $$&  %; . <% 100@! $)$  "'9$ ' "? '#$ &; '  '" '  7 +  #"$&!#$'%='$(##='$I$$-&D"B '##=B;##?$%;""$G 9$<'="$'&$"$$#'$A ,.@0@1M'7171$ 17@Q.163/6'7.!.1/.@/'73?$&9&C7 %-!  =   #&'! $ D '&9$ ' B; $$ $!  %'$(##=&%'B<'$&%;A ,..6  4@ '7 /?! ..1@/0 '7 3Q    .44M R @6 #7 @./ '7 @?C7 ($ #=  #&' #'$  . <% 100@  $'$ #B $$ '$ '%$  $? $ "#&$$  "$B '(  $&;#%B;'#&'$' $#



230.421005  *526*   '#$ ' #&' $ '  '99&$  #& "'9& # 7

37 + L$7 /0 7 .  !  '& '  $ ' $$ <7 $9!  '&;$ D   ! L$7 .0/   #&%$  '& '  ' $ "7 $$'&='&##$'$'.@<$1005!$='& $#''.5<$.5P$%"$A$7@M73$7 C!  ' .3 %"? 1005  &$& 9"&  $"# $7 !$<$& '  9"$'&#&%#!$*%?!%$'$75/ $ 7

57  $; #$   '$ ' (&  %"$ '('"$& <B * 'D'15%10057

/7 E $" ' ($7 ./  ! HL& $$"$  #$"$ #? ' $%A$7/ CD$'L'$'$D'"$&<B7

'$DL'"$&<B)$$B"<=$'L'$7 L&$$'B=L&%&##$&'$%!'B=L$ $%&'B=L&'&B'H7

($7 /   #& =($ &#$& #$& ' $% $$ #$! $$  #$!'L#$$''L& D"#'#9'" 'L$%$&$%=#$?"$I$E;&'!$$#$&$ 'L $$$ D  $& #-8=! "$  #8-=7   'L#$& ' $%';'&!L$%$&=#$I$E;&'#$%'L $#9'L$'"'L$%$&7

 #$'&&""#?'$%=!D$'L $$$ D  $& #-8= $2 #8-= ' D  '$!   #$ # E$%$&$%-?$#$LE'"B"$& %='L;;%&$$'$&7';&'L#$&'$% L##&   ;' '  '"$ '  #'$%$& ' L& '  #9 $! $$ = L #$ ?"$ E; '  =L $ '  $ $ 'L$%$&  #$& 9$ &'7  $J- ' "&' $  D '= ' = " $ # = $%$& L&$#?'$%Q$!'&"&'$$$ &&"$"#$$#'&$"=$%E#$!?"$! E; ' L& A , ..5  #7 .@3! '7 1Q , ..3  #7 @.3 '7 @Q ,.05#7.5M!'7.C7

67  (#B!    " 9 D  #$$ % 99$  15 % 1005 '&$=(D$$'$(&%$%&##$&'$%7  ($9'&(%' 7 $'# ?' &!     9"& = (& #%$ $% D # $"#! #



230.421005  */26*   $$ =  $ '  ' '( $%$& ""  &$$ #  #$'-;7

(&8$9"$'("#8&'""$8$E&$%$& ""!$"$'$$"?!%$'(I$-:";! #$&'$%$'B I$$!  (8$  # # 9"& (E$ ' "$$ & # &  $%'('$7

M7 (& B; =(  $ '99 ' $%  "# "#$ E%"$'$J-'"$$%7 %$##%='(' '"#!'P@0K'$"#D'$%E'97

 ? ' & $$ #'$ =  ($%$& = (& $  "'(E!"#$$'9"$'?$'&$$'$&!'$ I$#'&$!$E$$&$$'("-&&=?&' ("#7   $ '  ' ' (E" ' '$ D ' '"$& <B # #$& ' $%! $ "#$ ' '99$& D $%  "# # '  $ = "&' A , ..5  .@@!    .4M6 #7 @43!  1000#741!$7/7.!1B"#- ! ,..3140'7 5?C7

 !!"9'&!'$*I$<$&7



230.421005  *626*  

  -(,2  (, + (-  + -,



345   6  7   89 $*& -:

  5 

.7 &%?7

 5

17 <$$

@7 $=#&'$;$$7

37 9"  #$ '  =L #%$ 9"  $  #&$ I$ '  '& ' @0 < 'B  $9$ # # ""'& '&  ? 9&'& ' ! +-SF-9= /! /003   !  $ E"#7  '&  #$ I$ #;&7  "&" '$N C '= E$"$='&$'&?$$#''& $$=&Q ?C E# # = "$9  $" #% '"' $$ $ '&Q C #$  ;$   '  #&$$7 +  "&"  $$ #  $ &&"$ &"&&  $$ C ?C $ C *'!  ?9&'&'##$"$B=L '%'&%?7"&"'"$"8 ' #%! = $ <$!  =  '& $$=& $ L%## ' =&$&E#&'&$A$7.@1!.0/$.0MC7  ;99B  &'$N     *  T U   

#9"'#&$I$$$9&E#$=LDL999&'& '$&#?=#;99





230.421005