Modification Denial of Permanent Injunction Upheld on Changed Circumstances
Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe appellate court reviewed a case concerning the denial of an application for modification of a permanent injunction that prohibited the use of certain equipment in a specific manner related to land use or environmental concerns. The applicant sought relief based on changed circumstances, primarily technological advancements, arguing the original order imposed an undue burden. The court affirmed the lower court's denial, reasoning that the applicant failed to demonstrate the substantial and continuing change in circumstances necessary to overcome the significant public interest protected by the existing injunction, and that the technological improvements did not negate the fundamental underlying harms the original order was designed to prevent.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Modification Denial of Permanent Injunction Upheld on Changed Circumstances: The applicant sought relief based on changed circumstances, primarily technological advancements, arguing the original order imposed an undue burden. The court affirmed the lower court's denial, reasoning that the applicant failed to demonstrate the substantial and continuing change in circumstances necessary to overcome the significant public interest protected by the existing injunction, and that the technological improvements did not negate the fundamental underlying harms the original order was designed to prevent.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IAApplied to impose court costs on the appellant for the federal proceedings.
Texte complet
!"#$#!%&&' !'$(!%&&$
) *)+ +,+ ) + ,*
- . "
%% %&&$
!" # $% # & ! "#"
"# ' !" # $
(
) * * *! "$1" %*+ !, (-&./!'..& 0
'%3
+ /*
&4 56#( " &- ,(#7 '..3! &28# 9#7 " 7 " , # 8 (, $" : " "# ' !$+ ( &/;'! ( " < ! $ &/=2! # $ "( " /"$#7 '...4
'4 9 11 ;"" , ( 1"56#(, $ ($! 7", # 8 ( " $, (6, # ( $": ", $: <, 1 > , 9"$, ?" (# 64
-4 56#( " " : ( ": "$1 ( 1 &3 ( 7 '..3 ( $($ ( # "@ 11 7"$&. :#7 '..3, ?$( ", (64
A4 7"$ ($", ( #" ( (( ", $: <! , ( ,$ ( (( "$1" , (" ## > # (( " : " , ( > " ( # 6! ( ( /"$#7 '...(&3 ( 7 '..34 " ($ $@5# $, "! #6 $, ,,4
34 @:8 1 #( > "#" ! B6$ " # " : 6(C > # #("" : !@5# ( $D1 "", $: <4
24 ("#" ! (( (@B6": 6(C >-.5 ('..&4 ( " #7#(" #,( " : ">@ @( : $>", ( 7 '..'! , $($ " ( : ($ # +C * 4 ( $ "? 8# , , 8 " ) * * *! 6$ $ , *+ ! > " >$! , " ; # '..2!># (("@: D, (6 @$: (D&@/2;1 4-.4
=4 " #( ( $($ ( # ? , ( ( $($ " >$ >@D "$1( "@ 7 :( ! E( ( " ((74
;4 @7"@ 75( ""$ 1 ?$!$($6 "$D56 4
+ ,*
&4 @ (4'3" 1$"$ 7 ,6", $: <, 1 ! : ! : :(( : " ($"&="$#7 &//-F)G!( $: 6 & 5: '...! 86, $" "" : 4 > 5 ( ( ,"H " , (( " ( D, (6 F (4&''(&'- " : C G! 56" "" : #,$(("@ (4=-4&" 1$"$
%-/2/%'..3 -%3
, $: < , 1 " '3 5 &/;' FG! ( D 8: 7 ( " ", & I('..-!" (!, 8>@11 $($( # F (4&A' G!?$( "@ 11 , (6 7" $" $, ( ( "$( # $, 56"" : 4
'4 * @ (4'')F :( : 6 ", & 5: '...G! " " : ! , (( " ( > " ( # 6 ( , (6$ 1 #$#( ? (4&''!&'-!&A&(&A' J (4-D3 )@,, >( , 6 # ((D( 1$ F4&G4 9> 5 (!, (( " ( D, (6 , "D" 11$ ( , (( " ( !6#($ " : " 7 ,6 ? (( $:(#( # #( " " : ! ( , (( " ( !6#($": " 7 ,6? (($:(#( # #(" "# 6F14 (4'A)G4 ! 5 ( D , (( " ( ( D @: " 7 ,6 ? (( # #( " " # 6 ($ E( " # #( " " : F ) &'; '-.J )&'/AAAG4
H,8! 56 " , # 8 ( " $ , (6 , # ( $ " , (( " ( > " ( # 6 , "#" 4 "( , ( ( (!"H, (!"# 6!/"$#7 '...!"H( , ( &3 ( 7 '..3!"(D>56#("" : (":?$( 4
-4 * " #(, " (!"#" > : ", $: < " ( # 6! > @$8: D &@/2;4-. 1 4 "#" " ( D ?C $, # (("/;A4&31 4
A4 1 #$#( D 5 , "! ", 5 "$( # ( , , (6 5>@# #("( 1 (", (( " ( ""# ! 5 ( " : $7$$1 "((, (( " (D" ($ E( #,( # (("C 4 ($ E( ($(?# ##$6 @ (4&' "@ " , $: <, 1 : ! : :(( : " ($ " &; : &/;A F 'G (? $6#( ! C ( ,$ F ) ,7 $-2%.'"&;5 ('..-G
34 > 1 ""$,"!H (4=-4', $ > ( " :(, $: , $" #,! , "(!, ,!6 ( (4H (4 ;/0 4 & " , $" "# ( ( : " &' ,(#7 &/;3 F G , $: ( >( D > , $" ( 6 ( ( , , ( 4 (1 ! "$7 ( $# #( ,:( E( # D 9 6 " , ( > 6 ( " # 8 ($#$ ($# 6"$68 ($4 11(! > 71$"$ " H "# ! , 7 ($ " # ( 6 ( ($ " ($#$ ( 5($ D $68 ( , , 6$$ " , $" , $: , ( (7 9" F )&'2&3& "4A7G4
%-/2/%'..3 A%3
71$"$ " $6#( ,,$>H < "1 " 11$ ( ! "H , (! ( ( ($ , # " 1 " , $" D9 6"H, ( > 6 (, $68 ($ "# 8 ($#$ "H (4;34'(4" 1$"$ H C: ( : :( F *G F(#( (4 2& (4 " 1$"$ , ( 6$$ " [ !: 6 ", & 5: '..-](!"H( , (! " ( ? "$, H (4 ;3 4 ' (4 1 * [(#( (4 2& (4 6 ]!" (> H,, $ (8 "$: ,,$5("H ( " "$,D, ( 6 (#"( F ( >*'..',42&G4
H,8! 7"$ "8 >! H ( ""$,5( 1 ,!H(( ("""#" 5( 1 :9>H ( "#$, #( "H$# #(4 11(!, : ($( #>" 7 ( ( ( ( 7 D " "$# 9 > ( $($ $: ($ "#" H$( ( 1 #$D 7 6( " 6 !" (: ( ("H , 7 " E( " H#" H (4 =34 H$# #( 1 ?$ H D'3.1 4
KKK
%-/2/%'..3 3%3
,*/ *)+ +,+ ) + ,*
01232 4 522 2 6 7$% ,8
&4 : ( ) * * * D ( 1$ !" #,(" ! ##") 4/;A4&3 #,( " 7 ,6 D : , 8 " ) * * #" "#+ ! > " ($ E( #,( " "$ (! "8 &3 ( 7 '..3 5>@# #("( 1 (4
'4 H< "#((>"7 4
-4 "# D: $# #("'3.1 4
A4 1 # , ( " >@ ,:( 1 # ( , $( E( " "$ " -. 5 "8 ( 1 ( , , ##"$ " $ 7 1$"$ " ! *9L M 9 1> 2! 2..A ! ( ?#, 4 "$ ,( E( , 6$4 #$# " ( N G " > ?(#( > "$ ( "$ 7( ( , " "$ ((>$J7G?, , ># ( 1 ( #, : "#" (( ( "$ JG, ( 6( " , $((4* #$# ( ( , ( $$#( $#$ $ (( G 7G ( G C"! 71$"$ " , ,( #( 8 >@ ": "$ :74#$# " #( # < " , :! > ( 5 (! > "$ ((>$ ( @: ,, " >$($?,$" $ (F (4&-'!&.2(&.;G4 6 11 8 $ "(N )) O * O
, 1 #", $( E(( ( 1 $?, ( >HDH11 1$"$ " , 6 11
%-/2/%'..3