Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/555/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/555/2004 Généré par l'IA

Contract Ratification Despite Alleged Misrepresentation

Numéro de cause ATAS/555/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute involved challenges to the validity of an agreement, with the lower court finding for the agreement's enforcement based on a finding that the challenging party had ratified it through continued performance and acceptance of benefits, despite alleged misrepresentations regarding the underlying transaction's structure and financial implications. The appellate court affirmed, reasoning that the challenging party failed to timely rescind after discovering the alleged fraud or misrepresentation, and that their subsequent, knowing participation in the agreement's operation constituted an election to affirm, thereby waiving any right to void the contract based on the initial inducement.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contract Ratification Despite Alleged Misrepresentation: The appellate court affirmed, reasoning that the challenging party failed to timely rescind after discovering the alleged fraud or misrepresentation, and that their subsequent, knowing participation in the agreement's operation constituted an election to affirm, thereby waiving any right to void the contract based on the initial inducement.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
validité du contrat exécution transaction financière clause compromissoire publicité du marché objet du litige

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Imposed court costs on the appellant for the federal appeal.
Art. 64 LTF
Denied the request for legal aid because the appeal was rejected.
Généré par l'IA
A/1120/2005
Contract Validity and Misrepresentation in Contract Enforcement
A/2714/2006
Contract Validity Affirmation Despite Prior Agreement and Consideration Dispute
A/2978/2006
Contract Validity Dispute and Affirmation
A/247/2004
Contract Enforcement and Validity Dispute
A/311/2005
Appeals on Contract Validity and Inducement by Misrepresentation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed court costs on the appellant for the federal appeal.

Art. 64 LTF

Denied the request for legal aid because the appeal was rejected.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

    #$%%#&%%' (#)))#&%%'

*(

! (! +("  !+ "+

 ,- . &%%'

,/ +0 

  

 12222222222 



+3"+("  +"   4  ! " !  "  #$ % &'

            !"  ( )*+(

 1(

#. / 01111111111  !! 22! 3  !! 41111111111  5! " 67 "82  2 " !' "3  #) 3 9 )$$#.   " ): 7!' )$$;<   7 !   3= 58 " !  33 " ' ' 77  ;$ ' )$$;<  7 33  58 2  "   ' !! 7!< 2   3  "  &  !!.  33 '  3 "  9 6 33! <  3  3!" %  "!" 2 .  36 3  %   3= "   ' '!  27  >&    .

8!!  "!3!  #$ ' )$$;<  " " 3& "   " 8  "   " &' ?(3&  @ ' % 8 "8" ! " 6A 2.  3! 5  7 "  ! "   " '    "  !!  58 2  3" B "86 .

).  "! " : C )$$;<    7 ! 8! 58 ! 3" " 8B "  " % 8" ! " 6A 2 "    C.

;.  )- C )$$;< (< 3!! 3 8  D " ! ?( 3& DD D@<  ! " "!.  &2 5   3  "   3=<  3  "  "  "822 < 8  %   9 " "86 .   3 "  5 9  '  !!! 3& "   3=<    " ' 8 3!C! "   58 E 3 F 5  57! " 992 G.

-.  "!  33 " #H 7!' )$$-<   "& 5 8!  "! ! 33    " 7 "   3= "  "  2 < &' 5  8 583&  "! <   H 3 9 )$$;< 58  "!3!  " " 3& "  C" " "86  '  3  " -,) 7. )$< 3!  " " '  " #-I$-$ 7. 3!  6 33!  77!<  33 7 58  " 8" 5 8  "'  9 " "86   #) C' )$$-<  3  '! %  "<  )I)H, 7.  3  7 " "!3   JIJ$$ 7. 9 3  6 33!    " " C "  3. = ! 5  "! 69" " " ' ! " 5 6< 5   9 "86 33!  3   !   9 " 8"   9 8!' % 5 6<      5 E    (" "  "! B  " '

*,$$*)$$- ( ;*+(

69" " 7  %     ' G. & < 9 5 8!  "! !   " 7 " 8 3= "  2   <   C2! 5  "3  ' %  3 ! 3!.

    " ' 3' E 5  F 57! " 992 G<  58  "! " 833<  8 ! 3  7 !".     7 !  "! " 3 "    C.

J. 8!!  C!   ))   " "!  33.

,. "  )+ C )$$-<   "!! ' E "! ! 3 "'   ! ?6 33! <   '! %  3< . G.   3!!

' 9 "8!  3<  3  5 8 3 !  57   " 992.   %  !2" 7 ! 8' 3  " 39&  " !  3<  E 8F  93 B 3& ' "!  "!  G.   C! 8' 3 66! " ' ' "8!   " "!  3"! 58 '  '  3 & 3"  '  57.

 "(

#5 @   2'  82 C" ?@  !! "7!   !< "&  # K )$$;<  9  "   ?. # .  @.

  F " ;$  )$$-< 3"<  9 " 7 ?(3& @  ! "877  ! " 8. # .  < "! 5  D ' !! !!  ' " 8. #;# "   2' (   (.

9@ 0  "  5       9 " !< B 7 ' L

(   72 3 "  "37 " 8F. <   "37 "8 C2  3 5! 8! "  6 C2!<    7.

8! "  6 C2!  8!" % B( 5 "   M  "37 = ' B3!   M   33 %  5 2 ? 0 +,  )+J N O33< ! " " " 7< -&  !"< #++#< 3. )-H  N P96"< " C" 3'! < #+H#

3. ;#;  .@.

*,$$*)$$- ( -*+(

( 8! "  6 C2!  ' 5 58   5 3  = 5  9 3' B  ?7. O33< 3. . 3. )J#@. <  33Q  83& "B 5  "'<  F  3'< % 8 "8  C! 3 ' " " 35   F! "  "8  7B  " " 8! " C2   D< A  ! "     C".

(      F "!! . D< 8 3  33 " (  9 ?7. (0R 9< "6 " D6S>< '. < #++#< 3. #:H<  -;$@.  '  3 " ' 58 9  "  &2 2!! "82 ' < 3 3&  5  !5 " 8 9'   !2  C"5 ? 0 ##)  ;#;@.   7    < "&  5  "! 35 " 8F " ' %  8B "8 C" 5 7 "3  # K )$$; "!C%<  "  C2 <  5  C2 33!<  !! !2&  !.

@  D B  "877   3! N ' 8F " " ;$  )$$-  C58%  B<   !2  % '!7  7 ! % 8. #;#   "   8.

 D   C" " ' 3!<    58  " "  3 "  .  =   " 33 5  8.

J: "   7!"!   3 2!! " " "   ( (< !  '2  # C' )$$;< 65    9 " < 5    5    "  "  "  .  "3 !2 7!"! 92   % 23   B "     F  < B C5 % !3 % &'  "'    "    . 8  3 !3" % 8B2 3! 3   7!"! 5  !2 2'  !!  D.

D 8. #;# . #   < E   !9 " 9B 3  3 C2    '  3! N   &2   9< 82<  C"    3! G.  "  ! "  #+:#<  "3   !!  3!! 3  ! )< 9!    L E 9 " 7  ! 3     " " " 7 "   M    3!' G.

  83&   F  33 5   ".  &2 "83! 3   C2 " "!22   "8 "3   L  " 3  %  3! !< 65<

*,$$*)$$- ( J*+(

!!25  =! 5 "   .  C2 "' 3 3  " B  "  .  < "  F " ;$  )$$-<  "!! 5  B " 8. #;# . )     3 " 3 3 "8 9B     " " " 7 N   3!! E  9 G   27 E   9 G. < 8. #;# . )   3! 5  9 " 7  ! E "   M    3!' G. 8 " 5 !    " B " 7 &' "8 C".  83! ! 3  %   "  5    E  G " F 57!<2  < "8 "! !.

  =  "  7 ! 3  3! 65  !!25.  ! " 'B 3!3 ?/!  " "  T / ( #+:$< 3. JJ- .@ 5  !2  #+:$ " !< B A! " C" '  3! B 3!' % 8. #;# . #   <  9 " 7 "!3" " 3' B!7.  9 ! "! %  3   ! T  "8 <   " < U 5 ' % Q "    "! " "!3 .  8! 3" 3 5 5   3   2!!<  3 5  9 8! ' "! "  3! "89.  ! !'" 5    3! "' 9<     "   3 3& ? 3 3< B3U@. D  /!  " " < 3. JJ:< E "  =&  '2!<  <   "8      3!! "    !! "!"!<   " C" " ' "  "!3"<  5  !3   3! G.

&  # C' )$$$<   !!   9!!7 "8  2!! "  3!.    "'  C" " ' 3! " "   ?. J, @. '<   "   "  3!  !! B3!  !77 ! ?/ #++:< 3. +-;$@.  ! "  C" 8 " 3 C  !!    <  3  0  3  0 .   ' 3 "  "  5   3F6!  !2< 55 ! 3 "< " 7   3!  & "8 < C5 % "!' %    " < %  C" " ' 3!<  D  8.

&  # C' )$$$<   !!   9!!7 "8  2!! "  3!.    "'  C" " ' 3! " "   ?. J, @. '<   "   "  3!  !! B3!  !77 ! ?/ #++:< 3. +-;$@.  ! "  C" 8 " 3 C  !!    <  3  0  3  0 .   ' 3 "  "  5   3F6!  !2< 55 ! 3 "< " 7   3!  & "8 <

*,$$*)$$- ( ,*+(

C5 % "!' %    " < %  C" " ' 3!<  D  8.

D 8 "' ' 83! " "  F " ;$  )$$-<     D<  !2       "  3!< =  3  6!  ( F   .

 8 7  3 !!  9 '! 3  !2.

 ' "  5 3!&"<  ! " D  33 "    7  %   2'.

8! " C2  = 3  !! ! 3  9 7!"!< "  F " ): C' )$$-<  "  2'  "3!<  #; 7!' )$$-<  "3  3   D " !2   %  C2 < < " 8 " 8! " 'B .

).   2'  82 C" ? N ) $J@  !! "7!   !< "&  # K )$$;<  9  "   <   5<      ' %   7!"!  8(6A 2 92  8" !   "8'9!

?(3&  @  58%     & " 6A 2 ?7.  J, @.   3! " 9 " !   !9 3 C2 "  "83&.

;. C! "  "!  7  !2B<    '9 ?. J,  ,$ "   7!"!   3 2!! " " "   " , 9 )$$$ ? T D H;$.#@  -+ . ) "   2'  & " 6A 2 ?D  ) )$@.

-. 7 !  % 8. ;$ . # .   < 8!  3" " 8B "  " % 8" ! 58  !9 58   ' 3  33 7.    !3!  8! 5  !! ( F    " '<  ' !! 3!9  ! "89    3< 7 8  3' F B2! "  58 'V    3 ?. -- . # . 9 " 8"  8(6A 2 " ;# K #+H;< (3&  @. D 8! 9"   3 !3! '9  F ! "89  '  3<     7 2'   " 8. -J . ;  .

 "! "  3 5 " F 33 %  2'! "  7<  "  % 5> C   " 7 !2&< " > %  C   " 7 " 2'! =<     % B C   " 7 2' ?. ;$ . ;    . -J . ) . *9*  @.

*,$$*)$$- ( :*+(

 =  7   "    5  ' " 6A 2 8 3  39 % " 7 9C7 "8" C<   " %   3  5 8!! 3' !'  " 8(6A 2 8 3 % !3".    " " 8! 58   3 ( F   " 2< 58  3!'. & <  & "  39!  3  C3"   " E  3  9  B29 G " 8!.  7  " " " 65  "83& <  ' "   <  3' 9  B2 " ' 58 'V  3 " ' ? 6 /W N  7 "  "'" " '   " B " ! " 8(6A 2< < 6&< #++)< 3. #,:  3. #:J@.

83&  C3"< 8 39! 3  ! " '   3  3 F "   (6A 2 5  " !!  " !9   5   " 33 " ' ! !9 ? #+,H

3. -:*6. #J@.  77<   3  "8"  5 8 K 3 B2 " 8! 58 'V    3 "' F 33!! " & ' ? #+H+ X : 3. H+@.

 7   " " !2 8(6A 2  "2 "  7   " " 3! 3  7 5 8!  " 3 7!  '   3  !3!69 3    7.  ! 5< 3 "  69 ?3 B 3 9" "8  3 "9 3 37  7 @ 3'5  6A 2< 2  33 7'    "     8B3 "  7 %   ?D <   $#.+)*)#:@.

 9 " 8. -- . # . 9  <  "8!' 5 " !  "  2!  ' !  '  ! 2  9'  % 8( 6A 2.  !' 58  3  "  F  5 " & '.  8 "&  5    " 8 3   3!  ! 36=5  3=65 " 8! 5  " 3 F  ! % "  2!  ' " '  3  '.  3<  33 " ' " 3!  " &2 " '  C7 3 89" "8  3   ' '!   ? #+H, 3. +$*6. ); N  #++H ;## N  #++: )#;@.  '6<   C3" <  7 " "'  7!5   "6 " 6 69 " ' 3 5"  V6  F ! !!   " 6 33!   " "' ' "   " "  < 5 8 3  " 77  " 9  " 6< 3  %  ! "  3 '   3< (  3' F 57! " '9 ?"!. 0. " #J  )$$# "     "   & "8(6A 2@.

*,$$*)$$- ( H*+(

 83&<    "!! 5  7   3   ! 2'<  5 C7  3 "  " % 8" ! "    C.

J.  82  " "!   8 3 5! !   '9   "  C3".

,. 8!  &   B35!    5 8' 3! % "! .

 9 " !  3" 9 5 8  "   7 '5!  3 3'5  "! " !   " '.  2'!

" 7 8 3" 3  58 8K 3 B2 " 8! 58 'V  3 " '  " " '  '  3.  7 !" 8 %  !2" 3" N 8! 8&2 "  3 ' 77 " 39&  " !     " 3 9 "  " "  '.    " "   "83& 5   " 33 " ' ! "' !9.    3  7 ! 8' 3 '!9  66!  '  3 ' " "  "! .

 !2" %  C3" ' " 9 7!"! "    3  "    " < 7  "   7 2'.   C7 "&  " 7   "! "   5  7B!  "! "  3 " " B " !    "    C.

6 6 6

*,$$*)$$- ( +*+(

 + "(1  (! +("  !+ "+

 78   9  :   ;7 ,$& "

  8 

#. R  .

 8

).  C.

;.  5  3!"  2.

-. 7   3 "  5I 3' 7     3! F "  "! " ;$ C "&  7 3 3  "! "!  9 7!"! " < D6S>675 ,< ,$$-   <   B 3.  "!  3 F 32!.  !  " L @ "5 B  5 "!   "! 9    3 "  "! 5!N 9@ B3 3 5 7    3' " "   "!N @ 3  2   "  3!. D  !    3   !!  ! !!   @ 9@  @ ("<  9 7!"! "   3 3   &    5I "' "! '9.  !  "     = " 3'< 5  C<  5  "! 5!  I'33 " 5   !! B3!"!   ?. #;)< #$,  #$H @.

 277& L  3!" L

/(  W  Y   

 3 7  " 3! F  7! B 3   D! "I  % I!  3  277

*,$$*)$$-