Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/539/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/539/2005 Généré par l'IA

Installment Sale Treatment for Contingent Property Transaction

Numéro de cause ATAS/539/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court addressed whether a particular transaction, involving an agreement to sell property with a complex payment structure over time, constituted a sale under tax law provisions concerning installment obligations, despite the contract being contingent on future conditions relating to development and financing. The court reasoned that the arrangement satisfied the definition of an installment sale because there was a clear agreement for the transfer of property in exchange for a promise to pay in the future, evidenced by a promissory note and security agreements, even though the total price and exact payment schedule were subject to future contingencies, thus subjecting the transaction to installment treatment rules.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Installment Sale Treatment for Contingent Property Transaction: The court reasoned that the arrangement satisfied the definition of an installment sale because there was a clear agreement for the transfer of property in exchange for a promise to pay in the future, evidenced by a promissory note and security agreements, even though the total price and exact payment schedule were subject to future contingencies, thus subjecting the transaction to installment treatment rules.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
vente paiements par acomptes droits de mutation dispositions fiscales opérations portant sur des titres droit des obligations

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision is cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of court costs to the appellant.
Généré par l'IA
A/2113/2005
Lease Deemed Installment Sale Contract Based on Substance of Transaction
C/6831/2020
Sale Contingency Breach and Excessive Contractual Penalty Reduction
A/3055/2006
Distribution of Sale Proceeds Based on Contractual Interest
A/760/2005
Property Sale Agreement Supersession and Financing Contingency Waiver
A/686/2022
Real Estate Gains Deferral and Prior Tax Payment Requirement

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision is cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of court costs to the appellant.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

               '()*'*++,  ',-.'*++,

##

 # "   "  #  "

/  - % 0) $% *++, 



  !"!#$#"!%$!& & '!! !

('!& !"!#$#"!%$! ) '

($!

&&   && "($*+,, -../   #0!

&&   &&  & -../  

       

       !"# $%&

  ,  



 1



/3 ! 45$  ,* 46'! ,..+   !'7  "!'8! '$   #"7'9$$(86'("!'6(!!'5($!$# ,/ 4'$ ,... "!    #   $ ('! &3

,3 :'00!*'"('$'045$"!#'$#  !'7"!'8!'$ (!(#  "!$5 "! ('$'# $!  #"(;  ! 6('!  "!#6(< "!(0'(#!$!'53 45$'6(!$$!# 0(!/,!,..+3

-3 !''9#=$!$'$'!>("$'7!"5(6!$"!8  &&   &&?'@"!8A B3

C3 $D! (#=$!$'$'!>0("!#6(< "!8 &&   &&  & 3 "!('$#("$ $#  /E 6!' ,..+  ($ ' !(!$ 9  "!$$'(  (!$' D "!$5!  -/!,..+>#86D*FE-G0!3

+3 &((!!'! ,26!',..+ "!$$'('7! "5 9'"!!>#869$D '$#!=$("!' D//F.,+0!3*+3 #$#"!#'#9"!$$'('7!"5($!'5H'$#!=$ ("!'H#$'$,F--20!32.3

23 ($($#$#$!';"!$'$,.',..+3 ($#$# '0(!#9>D#0$>(7!6$'(!"!$ !'$5!#D45!3

 #



/3 F!$3 ,+   (' 0##! !  '7! "5   "!#6(< "!(0'( 6'' !6'6$$'6''$#/*#7!/GG-?IB  $!#6'5!/!46'!,... !85"!(#!'6(!3(!9 (4('$($">(!!"!$$'((!$'D"!$5!?!$3/,,$ /,- ( '6' @ B   45  '  '6(! ("#$$    F!$3 *- 3/('0##!!"!#6(<"!(0'(,+4'/GE,?B 

    1*2,1,..+ -  



('$D86 !'7$(!('"'/!(J$,..-  ('$  "!8 9 F00'! '  #$# $!' ?!$3 /C, B  ;#$! F(00'  "!$5!7#!#"!$'$'(#$!'#"!45'6(!.

,3 &(F!$3,, I?(6$!6'5!"'/!46'!,...B  '6(! "!$$'((!$'9'!$!'5($"!$5# (0(!#$;!$3/,, /,- /C/$/C, K!$3-D+IF""'9$ "!(5'($$D$!0#!!?3/B3(!:9(4('$ "!$$'( (!$'D"!$5!(!!"(D'00#!$!"!$$'((!$' 5$#  6('!  '7! "5 ;'$$ #6$$  ($  '6(!  $  "!$$'(  (!$'  5$#  6('!  '7! "5 ;'$$ #6$$($('(!'5?03!$3,CIB3(!  (4($D"!$$'((!$'$DF6('!'7!"5;'$$ ($   ('(  !'5  '$#!=$   ($  '6(! ? I/,E,-.K I/,GCCCB3

-3  >"8   45  "!'8! '$  (!(#  "!$5 "! ('$'#  6('!"!#6(<3$"!$'$($ >"!$ !'5  ,/ 4'$ ,...  >$! "!$  /, ! ,..+  $ D 9  45$  '6(!$6;#$('!3

&(  ($ "!('$   "!$$'( 9' "$  !'5 "!  !$EF2EG3/+0!3?//F.,+3*+H,>--232.B$'99'"!  ! $  *FE-G 0!3   '$#!=$ <$ #4D #$# # "!  '$'$$'(  "!#6(< #0!3 ''  ! ('$ D ( ;@ #"(($$C,+3/.0!3?CF-CC32.0!3@-FG/G3+.0!3B3

C3 (0(!#$ D  4!'"!  "'  4(! #$!'$ "(!  "!$5 49F ($  $!0!$   "!$$'(  (!$' (   !   (4('$ '6(!# 7##0'''!  $$ "!$$'(  !('$ D  '$#!=$ ("$('! !  ($$  @'3  '$#!=$ ($ #  $; '' #5 ( F!$3 /,  F(!( !  "!#6(< "!(0'( 6''  !6'6$ $ '6''$#  /E 6!' /GEC ? ,B ( (  $; !#5$'!  ' '@' $ "#!'! ? I ( "7'#  -21.,  /E 4'$ ,..-B

+3 #($!"!L "!(#!#$$5!$'$?!$3*-3,$ EGM3/('!"!(#!''$!$'6/,"$7!/GE+B3

NNN



    1*2,1,..+ C  



#   1 " # "   "  #  "

%

234  5  6     7 & 0)* "89

/3 6'$  &&     &&  D $!0#!!   ("$  ('! &   (  C,+3/.0!3 D  &&     &&     & 06!  #3

,3 6'$  &&     &&  D 6!!   "   ($$   '$#!=$ ("$('!    ('#!$  8  /- ! ,..+ 49F ($$!0!$3

-3 ><($$97('3

C3 '$9"!(#!$5!$'$3

+3 0(!  "!$'   9F "6$ 0(!! !(! ($!  "!#$ !!=$   #'  -. 4(! 8  ($'0'$'( "! "' !(# !#  !'7 0##!  !  &:O'P!:(09' 2  2..C     $!(' ;"'!3  #'  "$ =$! "!((5#3  #('! ('$ A B ''9! ;$$ 9 #''(  !(!$ #'! (7$'!  ' $ "   #''($$9#K7B;"(!"(!9($'0'$'"(6('!!$$ $!#''(KB"(!$!'5$!((!"!#$$3&'#('!  ($'$ "  $!(' ##$ ##!# ( $$! B 7B $ B '@   !'70##!!"(!!"$!!$'8!!!(!9F' 6!#!!'!!673#('!!(!$'(!(!(<  "!6  9' !($ 4('$  '' 9  #''( $$9# $ F6(""  9#$#;"#'#!(!$?!$3/-, /.2$/.EB3  5!00'8!  !#'$A     'II Q!'& Q 

("'(0(!"!#$!!=$$($'0'#;"!$'''9>D>00'0##! !('"!5!00

    1*2,1,..+