Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/511/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/511/2007 Généré par l'IA

Statutory Deadline Controls Over Procedural Rule for Appeal Filing

Numéro de cause ATAS/511/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The litigant challenged the application of a statutory provision regarding the filing deadline for a specific type of appeal, asserting that the applicable procedural rule dictated a different deadline which had been met. The court affirmed the lower authority's decision, reasoning that the statute, which explicitly set forth the filing period, controlled over the general procedural rule when the two conflicted, thereby validating the dismissal of the appeal as untimely filed under the statutory requirement.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Deadline Controls Over Procedural Rule for Appeal Filing: The court affirmed the lower authority's decision, reasoning that the statute, which explicitly set forth the filing period, controlled over the general procedural rule when the two conflicted, thereby validating the dismissal of the appeal as untimely filed under the statutory requirement.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
délai légal de procédure condition légale dépôt tardif règle de conflit forclusion pour tardiveté interruption de la prescription

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Imposed court costs for the appeal.
Généré par l'IA
A/2391/2006
Statutory Interpretation of Filing Deadline
A/2473/2005
Appeal Time Limit Calculation Based on Filing Date
A/1625/2006
Statutory Filing Deadline as Jurisdictional Requirement
A/1937/2005
Statutory Deadline Compliance for Legal Filing
A/1193/2005
Timeliness of Appellate Filing and Tolling of Statutory Deadlines

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed court costs for the appeal.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

           $()*+)(,- $$(.//(,0

$"

  %$! $%%$! " $$%"  $!"

12  ,  /. 2 ,0 

   !"#$"  % &

 &   !"##' ()( ) *&+,!+   -!+.+&     



+&

)) ( ))%  !8& /) &) +(01*+2#1' "#"" ""

3 4   - )) &+ 5,62 "77" ) 



            !!" #!!"$%% &      '

  #9:  

"% $ 

"; & <=+  #" *+>& #770  "?& 5>&  & >  *& ?& +*&! ,&!"$17+ & !"$2'& !+#*+>&"$$:;

#; )5 88&2<=+*&! +! & >*& ?& +&!  *&+= *&  + !  , &  *&!,@ *&8  A  *& 5 !*B&+& =;

6;  <=+   ,& + , !8  + 8  #0 +>& #770 +  !+! +&  -88  & >!#,>&#770*&B!+ *&+=;

:;  & >!  +!*&+ & + ++ *&!,@ *  +&*! + ++ !8&*& +  A& ++  , &   *&+  A  &+  & =  + +&  # *+>&"$$:+#0+>&#770;

2; )  && &   ))  ( ))  %  /)) "#<, &#771*&++ A *+& = *&&+:0-1'28&;$28&;*&++  >&*=*&,+  )C))/   && &  #1;"#;#770   3 4   && &"#;76;#771+/+ 8,&*& +  !+!88  !&& &-    && ,!"" ,& #771; )  && &   3 4 *=  -& &     "6 & #771&+2'-"7:8&;#2;

++!+!+& B*&+ &- +&+ ;<&  +  &   A!A-D!8+->&,+ -  6 #771&&E+& +& &++>;

0; ->-><+ ! 8 B!!+!=&!D<=&;

"%  

"; -&+;#2 8!!&& >&*=*&!,@*&8  ,  &, ,++ ,  +!"1!>&"$$6F/G+&!, =& "&<, &#777&?=*&!& ,&;&A< ++ *H&&*&++ &+ D*&+=&F&+;"##+"#6  , ( G <=  ,&*!++-&+;16;" 8!!&& *&!,@ *&8   #2 <  "$'# FG  + D ?,  & > +& * "&I+#776 +*&?A-88 & 

    9:76:9#770 69:  

 !+!+& F&+;":# GB!+&-88 *&+=&> ! &!*&+ + !+& !*&<= ,&;

#; )-&+;##/F,+&, =&* "&<, &#777G   ,&  *&++   &+  A  &+  & = + *&+=! 8&!+ B&+;"##"#6":"+":# J&+;6D2 /- A+ *&= ++D+&8!&&F;"G;&5A< +*&++  &+ D*&+=&&&*D 88!&+&*&++ &+ =+!  , &   >& *= B ++ !,++  +   ,& +  *&++ &+ =+!, & >&*=B ++!,++ + & =F8;&+;#:/G;&<+ D  *&++   &+  + D -, &   >& *= B ++  +      & =  +!&E+   +   ,& F / "#'  #67J /"#$:::G;

 H*?  <=  *& ?& +  &!  *&+= *&  + !  *&++   &+  A  &+  & = *&  &;  + *&+ ++H*&+& =#*+>&"$$:H+&*&+ #0+>&#770+DA<=+ ,&+,B!+ &;

6; )  + *& +  *&++  A  *+  & = *&  &+2'-"7:8&;#2+ AA *&&+ :0-1'28&;$2 +!&E+@+!<D !+!!*& + ++ *&!,@ !8&;  & +DB(!*++#$-72#8&;"2 F2'-"7: 8&;#2K #G + (   + D  (D  ++  #6-6$6 8&; F:0-1'28&;$2K#G  &+ A H+  & A   + D  &  ++2-02$8&;"2;

:; 8&!+ D  <& *& *   <& !+& + *&  *&+= <A-++&8&+*&++ &+ &< +  ,&!>!!8   &++*&++ & +D +!&E+*+ && ++( ;  +!&E++!+B  !=-&+;"# -&&*&!,@*&8 ,  &, ,++ ,  +!  "' ,&  "$': F #G    +B &!=+ &    (  + *!& & F /*> !6097#"'< +#776G;

2;  !+  & *&L  *&!& !++ =&+ + F&+; 16 ; #  + '$4;" &*&!&  +&+ ,"#*+>&"$'2G;



MMM



    9:76:9#770 :9:  

$ "   !"  %$! $%%$! " $$%"  $!"

"; , +3 4 *= -&& D+&8!&&*+  &     2-02$ 8&;"2 D  ))  (  ))  %  /))   8,&       A  +!&E+ *+ &     !&+?#0+>&#770<A-++&8&+;

#; H@++A> ;

6;  +A*&!&+=&+ +;

:; 8&  *&+    AH *,+ 8&& && +&  *&!+ &&E+   !   67 <& ?  + 8 +  *&?  & > 8!!& F)5N O&58A 0077:  G*&, &&+ ?&& + *> 8&!+B&+;'# 8!!&& & >8!!&"1 <  #772 F /GJ  ! &  &&  +  A&    + 8 + @*&,+*&+& =+&&&++ &J  + E+& &!  & > 8!!& *& ,  *+  *& ,  !+& A B  +   -&+; :#  /;  *&!+ &&E+ +  * ?  *   &&+ ,A!@*&, ,+E+&< +D-, ;  =&88 &K  &! +K              &&) >) 

* 8&*&!+&&E+++ 8 !B*&+   AHDH88 8!!& & *&=&88

    9:76:9#770