Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/500/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/500/2004 Généré par l'IA

Statutory Challenge Affirmance

Numéro de cause ATAS/500/2004
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involved multiple challenges to various aspects of a statutory scheme, including challenges to provisions concerning notice requirements for certain actions, discovery limitations, and the application of specific time constraints, with the court ultimately affirming most aspects of the lower court's rulings. The court reasoned that the notice requirements were constitutionally adequate as they provided reasonably calculated notice under the circumstances, that the discovery limitations were a permissible exercise of legislative authority balancing efficiency with the need for relevant evidence, and that the applied time limitations were correctly interpreted and did not violate any substantive or procedural due process rights asserted by the challenging parties.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Statutory Challenge Affirmance: The court reasoned that the notice requirements were constitutionally adequate as they provided reasonably calculated notice under the circumstances, that the discovery limitations were a permissible exercise of legislative authority balancing efficiency with the need for relevant evidence, and that the applied time limitations were correctly interpreted and did not violate any substantive or procedural due process rights asserted by the challenging parties.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
prétention légale limites de procédure conditions matérielles actes attaquables confirmation de compétence arrêts en appréciation de validité

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive to regulate the court costs for the appeal proceedings.
Art. 64 LTF
Cited in the dispositive to regulate the provision of legal aid.
Généré par l'IA
A/357/2005
Statutory Validity Challenge Upheld
A/2641/2004
Statutory Validity Challenge Upheld Against Vagueness and Notice Claims
A/1637/2003
Statutory Validity and Vagueness Challenge
A/2023/2007
Jurisdictional Challenge Regarding Statutory Interpretation and Time Limits
A/1416/2003
Consolidated Appeals on Statutory Interpretation, Constitutional Challenges, and Procedural Correctness

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to regulate the court costs for the appeal proceedings.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to regulate the provision of legal aid.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

     

    &'()&*++, "&-++&*++,

"

 " .  " .    .

$ */ #$ *++,

-0  1 

  

  2222222222 3 45 56  6 5 3  7 8.  "



6$ 2222222222 3 45 56  6 5 3   "79



 

  " "  !9  : .. $  ; (' 5 36 -*'< )*)) 04 ))

!"

             !  "  #$% # $%&#

 :"

),  -.  )' !/ $01 23! 4 5 2  6 -72 $+1  2/  528 2   5!  2 2 5  27  2.   !  2 )99' 5 : :;;;;;;;;;;1 !  72 )9()1  2    !5/23 2221   :2 :;;;;;;;;;;1 !  72 )9'$1 2.22  87,

$,  2/  528 2   !  5 . 5 2 2!  72  5!7< 5"2 ! 5 :2 :;;;;;;;;;;   2.   2  2  2/     21 5 5! 4 ,

0,  -.  27  7 !"22 2"  ( "!72 $+,

+, =2  2 ! 5  2/  !  52  ! 2 3 :2 :;;;;;;;;;; 58  5  2   2 58   >>  #   > >   ?  @ >>    7 ! 2  $9 "!72 $+  $$A''+ ", &*,

6, >  /    2" 21  2/  !  ! 2!      5  2  2/ 5. B 7 B  2  52  : :;;;;;;;;;; B ))A0&' ", &*,  2  ( 2 $+1  5 2  ! !

272 ! B  ! 2   , > : :;;;;;;;;;;  "2 .   2  23 1 5    $+ 2 $+1   7   "C  "21 22 3  !   2 2  2  5!7<1 B 72     >>  >   > >1   D  999+'((1 5!7< ! D 6')9*,

 "

)% E  2 .72  =.2 2 -222 FE  ! ! 2"2!   2 2 !1 8  ) G $01  2/     2 F , )  ,  E,

%'()%$+ # 0%&#

  H  0*  $+1 5 1  2/ 22  2" F2#58 E    ! =""2  2 !  = , )  ,  1 2! 3  > 72 ! ! !!  72 2  = , )0)    2  2 .72 #   #,

/E @      3   2  2 2  2/  !1 4  2" 27  I

#   "2. 5   252 2"  =H , 1   252 2" = -. 5 3!2 = 2 !   J -.!1     2", = 2 !   J -.!  =!  B 4#2 3    K  252 2" < 72 45!  K 2  55  B  3 2 2 2.2 F @ 9(  $96 L M551 !2  2 22  2"1 +8 !2 21 )99)1 5, $+&  L N/J21 2 -222 527! 21 )9&)

5, 0)0  ,E,

# = 2 !   J -.!  7 32 3=2  2 3 5  < 3  2/ 572 42 F", M551 5, 2 , 5, $6)E, 1 2 55O  =58  4 3  72 1  H 572 1 B =2 =  2 - ! 5 72 2  2  52 23    H !  2 =  "24     =! 2  -.   >1  P   2  22 !   2 2 2    -22 2,

#  2 2 2  2  2 H  !! , >1 =  52  552 2  #2  / F", #@C2 / 1   J  >JQ2R1 7, 1 )99)1 5, )'&1   +0*E,  72  5  7 3= 2/  2  8. .!! =.2 7  1 5 5 228 3  !3  = 2 /72   !.2 -223 F @ ))$  0)0E,   2"    221 8  3  2! 523  =H  72 B 2 =42  = -22 2 32 " 2 52  ) G $0 !-B1    -. 2 21 22 3  -. 55! 1  ! ! !.28 !,

E  > 42 =""2  5!  L 7 =H   0*  $+ 2 -3=B  42 1 2  !. B 7!2"2  "2 ! B = , )0)     2 =2 2  ,

 >   -22 2 22  27 5!21    3= 2   2 5 22   2,  <  2  55 3  = , 6'   2 "!!   5 2 .!!  2   2 # #1  !  72.  ) -72 $01 J3   2 2   2/ 

%'()%$+ # +%&#

1 32     2  23      2   2,   252 2 !. "!! /2.    B .5     24   2   H 2 1   24 -3 B !5 2 B 87   27 22       , = 22 5 !5 B =42. 5! 5  2 "!! 3  !.2  .72  !!  >,

> = , )0) , )   1 S  2 ! /2  2/4 5  5 -.     272  5! L   8.  /1 =.2 21  -22 2   5!  T,    ! 2   )9')1  252 2  2  2  ! ! 5! ! 5  2! $1 2/!  2 I S 2/ 22  2"  2 2 ! 5        2 22  2"    K  2  5!72 T,

  2  2 =2 58    H 5225 3  2 22,  8. =2 5!  2 5   -.  !..   = 252 2   I  2 5 2 B  2 5!  2 2 !1 J2 231 !!.23  < ! 23   ,  -. 7 5 2 522 2  4  2   2,  1   H  0*  $+1  2!! 3  4   = , )0) , $    22 5  5 5 =  2/4        2 22  2" L 2  2 5! ! S  2/ T  2.2"2 S   2/ T, 1 = , )0) , $   5!2 3  2/ 22  2"  2 2 ! S    K  2  5!72 T, = 2 3 !2       24 22  2" 87 =  -22 2, 22 =2 5!  2 2 ! 5 B     3   S  T 2 H  32"2!1. 2 1 = 2 2! 2!,

  <     "2! 5  2 5!  2 J2 23  !!.23,  !   74 5!5 2 F:!2   2 U : # )9'*1 5, 66+ ,E 3  !.2   )9'*  2 !1 4 P !  -22 2 272  5! 42   5!7 B = , )0) , )   1  2/ 22  2" 2!5  572 4! 2",  2/ ! 2  2! B 5     2 ! U 2 =  1 22  1  V 32 72 B O       !22  !5  ,  =! 2 5 5 3 2 3  5 2 .!!1 2 5 3  2/ =! 2 7  !  5!  = 2/ 2,  ! 2 !72 3  2 22 5!2 72 /2 1    2   52 2 5 228 F52 2 52 21 45 VE, >  :!2   21 5, 66'1 S   < 8 72.!1  1  2 =    22 5!22!   2 2  ! ! !2!1  2    

%'()%$+ # 6%&#

-22 2 22  27 2 2   2!5 1   3  !5 2  5!  T,

8  ) -72 $1   ! ! 2  /!!"2 =  .!!  5! ,   22 7  -22 2 22  27 5!2  2  F , 6( E, 71  2 2  22   5!2  ! ! 45! !""2! F: )99'1 5, 9+0*E,   2  22 !   -22 2 =  5 -2 ! ! 2  1 2 5  @ 2 5  @ ,   72 5   2 2  32 2 5HJ!  !.2 1 33 ! 5 1  "2  5!    28 = 21 -3 B !7 B  22  1 B  -22 2 22  27 5!21  >  =,

>2 = 72 27 =2 5!  2    H  0*  $+1    >1 2 !.      22   5!21 < 52   J!  2#H 2 2 2  2,  = 2"  5 ! !  / 72! 5  !.2 ,

 7   32 5!81  ! 2  >  552 2     " B   2  2 .72,

=! 2  -.  < 5 2 ! ! ! 5  2/ "!!1   H  $' -72 $+1   2 .72  5 !1  )0 "!72 $+1  252 2 2 2 5   >  2!.   B 2 -. 2 21 1  =    =! 2  74 ,

$, A , $6   2 "!!   2/ 5.   5!7< 5"2 7221 727   2722 !  )' !/ )990 F@E1  !  72.  ) -72 $1 8.  5!    27,    !  -2    5  2   2 B 5 .    27 F , )$$  )$0 E1  -.  2  27 5!     A , '0 , ) 1 2 B 87  2/     2 52  ) G $01 2 1 58 3 A""2 2  ! ! 2 F , )+$ E1 4!  A""2  5 .   /   !  !5 2 2 ! 2! 5  -.  27,

0, > A , $$ @ F7   72. 52  ) -72 $E1    271  5  2   2 32   2.  5 .! "! 4  , )$$1 )$01 )+)  )+$ L   , 0 B 6 @ A5523 5 .2    B "! F, )E,  J3 -2 1  5  2   2 B 5 . 5 B  2""!    5  2   21 . !

%'()%$+ # (%&#

 72  2/ 5. 42  !7     271   5  2   21 . !  72  2/ 5. 42  !7      2  2. F",  , $+ @E,   1  -  B  5  2   2  B A72  2/ 5. 42      2  2.  2 !H      27 F @ )$&  $0*L @ )$9  +++E,

+, 4   = , ' , ) 1  2!   2 B = /2. 2 5  722 3 8  ) -72 32 2    B 3 2   $+ ,  = 8  3 8     3 =72  722  B H  !,

6,  =581  2/  528 2   !  5 . 5 2 2!   5  2   2 32 5 :2 :;;;;;;;;;;    ' 2 )99'

  ( "!72 $+,   5  51  2 B !  5  2  2/#5.  $$A''+ ", &*,  1   2 2  0 2 $+   >>  #   > >   ?  @ >>  1  5  2   2 B     2.  2,  "21    K :2 :;;;;;;;;;;  !  72 )9'$  = 8  5  B   72  722 3 8  ) -72 )99'1 B 72 3  2 7  2.1 2 < 2  2! 3      5  2   2 58    28 2  ! ! !  28 1  2 531 5    !  2.,

 2 2!     $$A''+ ", &* 5!  ))A0&' ", +* F  5 ))A0&' ", &*    ! ! 23! 5  4 5 2E1 2 55 2 B  >>  #   > >   ?  @ >>   7      5   5!7< 5"2  : :;;;;;;;;;; 58       >>  >   > >,

(, "! B  -251 52  - ! 2 5  5 . -3A   "   5  2   2    1  -2 27! /!!"222    5  2  2 B  2 !H  5 2      #2,  2 !H   !  4 22 !.  A , )$  A   5!7< 5"2 7221 727   2722 !  )& 72 )9&+ F $E    4 !. 21 2 2#2  5!2 F @  5/2!  0(%*$  )& -2 $0E,

%'()%$+ # '%&#

',  !  1 2 72 !. 3  >>  #   > >   ?  @ >>  .     B "!  4 22 !.   4 !. 21 2 2#2  5!21 8  ( "!72 $+1    = !  "  J -.!  5!  27,

WWW

%'()%$+ # &%&#

  ": . " .  " .    .

$

=56>6   ?  366 6  @% )(* .;A

), 72   >>  #   > >   ?  @ >>  1 !  2  72  722  :2 :;;;;;;;;;; B 7   5   5!7< 5"2  : :;;;;;;;;;; 58      >>  >   > >1 >   +1  "J1 N#&)0+ 2Q21   D  999+'((1 !7< ! D 6')9*1    ))A0&' ", +* ,

$, =272  B 71  5     1  2 !H  5 2     2! 1 8  ( "!72 $+ -3=   " L

0, =<    3  /2,

+, 2 3  5!  . 2 ,

6, "  5 2   3A 57 "     5! H   !2  0* - 8   2"2 2 5 52 ! !  2/ "!!  1 >JQ2RJ"32 (1 (+   1  2 452,  !2  5 H  5.!,  !2 2 I E 223 4  3 !22   !2 / 2  2  5   !22  3!L /E 45 5 3  2" 2  2 572      !22L E 5   2.      5!  , >2  !2   2 5  2 !!  !!!    E /E  E 2#1  2/ "!!    5 5     28    3A2 7 ! 27/,  !2    2   <  571 32  -2 1 22 3  !22  3!  A755  3   ! ! 45!2!   F , )0$1 )*(  )*& E,

 .""28I  !2  I

?X  Y :<  : 

 52 "  5! H   2"2! 4 5 2 22 3=B =""2 "!!   2 5  .""

%'()%$+