Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/46/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/46/2007 Généré par l'IA

Patent Validity and Prior Art Challenge

Numéro de cause ATAS/46/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves a dispute over the validity of several purportedly prior art references cited against the patentability of the applicant's claims. The court reasoned that several of the cited references were invalid as prior art because they were published after the critical date for the relevant statutory bar, or because they were insufficiently publicly accessible before that date, thus determining that the applicant met the burden of demonstrating that the claims were not anticipated or rendered obvious by the prior art presented.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 106 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Patent Validity and Prior Art Challenge: The court reasoned that several of the cited references were invalid as prior art because they were published after the critical date for the relevant statutory bar, or because they were insufficiently publicly accessible before that date, thus determining that the applicant met the burden of demonstrating that the claims were not anticipated or rendered obvious by the prior art presented.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
validité du brevet délai de péremption légal opposition à la marque conflit avec un dessin ou modèle antérieur fardeau de la preuve créance contestée

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 106 al. 1 let. a LTF
Basis for declaring the appeal inadmissible as it concerns a final decision where the appellant has not demonstrated a legitimate interest.
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Provision applied for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/2345/2006
Patent Validity and Infringement Suit Involving Prior Art and Claim Construction
A/1701/2007
Patent Infringement and Validity Dispute
A/1112/2006
Patent Claim Validity Review: Novelty, Obviousness, and Definiteness
A/3645/2006
Patent Validity Dispute and Remand
A/4100/2006
Patent Validity and Infringement of Apparatus and Method Claims

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 106 al. 1 let. a LTF

Basis for declaring the appeal inadmissible as it concerns a final decision where the appellant has not demonstrated a legitimate interest.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision applied for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



               "#$%$"&''$  "#$"&''(



) *)  +  ) +*

,-.  %  // 0 &''( 



 !"#$!    "#"

"# !%& !!  '

(

))  *   ) )  +  , )* "$2" )  !")(*-.!%(/0.1!   

 ) ) ) ,  !2( .3!%(/45!6 

              !

  07/  

 1*

9& :;#("9-(<0338!0=#>#<" <"%#=(  %$  "? " "# ! $    9-8-! (  !$9-8.!@A$((#$"("93:? 9--0&

0& >228""%(2":;#(%$($! <"%#=( "$(B%("@A$(("A"?%(;"%(( " ("((("%$?C& >221! >#;$ ?( " "? " 03 D( 0338! @ %$  @ (! A;( " %(;"?"%$?C%2E

9&  &   $($! %"(  %@ ((($ "  "$ " #;!F(?&2"(";;#(" ?F"# #($"#((@A($  (( "  %$?C %2 G"B=# %H "(  #* ;!#"($"$2*%=&

0&  #(( " A? " %$?C %2 " &  "%< %= "   (* (% " $* ?C2!F@(22$!(" I,01A500&//& (2!93"$#<0334!& (($ I,/3A334&4/" "B=#%!"""A"A;#( F%%$($";#(G H!2"A@$A%%(#(2#* & #(("("J(:($F?(!2""$(* ##(($"%(("(& (#((!  %(( " ( " & ! J($  49 "$#< 033/!A$=?F I,.1A50/&-3&

4&& A;;F?F"# #* ($ "  #((! ( I, 4-A090&-/& (2! ##  ## =(#( "%< %= "   (* (% " $* ?C2(22(!#((%@(* ($2!#?$#"($?(E

 %#?#(%(" I,0/A333&*!@("* (#( (2$$ %   (* (% " $* ?C 2 F   " "# K G"$;$>&5*"HL

 #%("%$""?!#($"#((($ >@#%& (("%$?C%* 2G"B=#%H?$#%("%$*

    7584870338 47/  

?C %2 " "# ! :@AF  @  ## (( ?$ %   GC * ?#((" I,0/A333&*H((;4-A090&-/&

5&# GM"A )0/58-/5059-H((#(2* 2$ %= "  ,"( " $?C 2 " *  G?;(2(; !2(.3!539- NH!F@##?$>&4*"(?$&

/& #%(("<=?($"((""#  %"(#;! F2? "("B=#%"$%&

4&  <"#=("$$!F((,"%(O "(O"  :;#(! @ ( "   %(; " ? " %$?C %2* $((2#FA(&900 &

5& :;#(""?("?"$2(205?#<0338($($(# "A22 <"$."$#<0338%B$("%(;&

/& ?(;(%%$#(A$(($#%(("(#" ?(!$($;"$F:;&



 +*

9& A(&0/"2$"$<%;"%$?C%2! ?!??((?"($"9."$#<9--4G,H!($?; 9:?0333!=;%$"""?&@:(( %"P"%(("(F%(;G(&900(904 " ?* H! :;"""?#%$(("A(&.4&9"2$"$ %$?C%2"0/:9-10GH!(F=? <* (""%9D(0334!"(!%=@A22 $($(#G(&950 H!B$("A22%(;<"$"$* %(("$(#$%:;""?&

0& )A(&00,G?(?;"%9:?0333H! " "?!  %(( " ( @ "(  #; ( %(;$ 2#$#( B(&900!904!959(950 L(&4F/ ,A%%@( %;#((F(2$G&9H&>@:(!%((" (F%(;%"F"22$(%(("(!;#($ " ? " < %; B(( $?(#(  ##( " "?! (  %(("(!;#($"?"<%;B(($?(#( ##(""#;G2&(&05,H&!:(

    7584870338 57/  

F  %(( " ( ( F A? " < %; B((  ##( "   " #;  ($J( "  ##( " "? G , 901  043L ,90-555H&

 P%=!  :; " %#= (  >#;$  ?( " "? %"#"(2#$(##(="%(;" %(("(&?(""AC2#("":;#( &

4& 2#$#( F  :%"! "%  : "$(#( %  %(; :* @A##("(2("%(("(""#!:( "?$<$$2"((%(("(F"($J(#%( #(("*& ($J(($(B###$;A(&90 "A"%$?C%2?!??((?"($ " 91 ? 9-15 G 0H    (B $;#(!  * ( %$ G ,%<$48730"91:(0334H

5&  $##(   %Q!  %$" $(( ;(( G(& .4 & 0  ( 1-I&9"%$""#((?"90%(#<9-1/H&



RRR



    7584870338 /7/  

  2+ *1  *)  +  ) +*



345 -- 6  7     8 ! /$& +9

9& ?(  ))   *   ) )   +   , ))*   F(2$!"#%(" !##"0/A333 2& F   ) ) ) ,    G539- NH  2* ?""# $ !@"($J(#%* (" "$(!"=0/?#<0338:@A##(" (2(&

0& PC"#((@"<&

4& ?(  ))   *   ) )   +   , ))*   F?%!F#%("05?#<0338!#($"#* ((($>@#% (("%$?C%* 2   #%( " %$?C %2 " "# !:@AF@##((?$%  *C#%?#(("0/A3332&*((;#(("4-A0902&-/&

5& PC"#((@"<&

/& (@%$"(;((&

8& 2#  %( "  @P %?( 2#  (  %$( J( ""$"43:"=(2(%=" <2$"$G)>S* T>2@ 8! 8335   H! %  ? "   #(= " "( %* <!2#$#(B(&10"2$"$ <2$"$"9. : 033/ G ,HL  #$# "  "( "@  ! #(2 ( #C"%?(%(;("("#"(L"( J( "$  < 2$"$ % ? %(  % ? $(@ B "("A(&50 ,&%$(J((%=%"* (!?@$###C"%?!"?(J(:(FA?&  ;22=  $"(E     ,, K) K %2#"%$(J(((2$B%(@PFP222$"$ "%;22

    7584870338