Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATAS/339/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/339/2006 Généré par l'IA

Contract Disputes and Prior Judgment Interpretation

Numéro de cause ATAS/339/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court reviewed multiple contract disputes arising from transactions across different years, primarily concerning the alleged breach of agreements related to the sale or transfer of property or interests, with several claims revolving around interpretations of pre-existing arrangements and rights established in prior litigation or contracts. The court's reasoning focused on applying established legal principles regarding contract interpretation, the impact of prior judgments on current claims, and whether the specific factual allegations supported the asserted causes of action, ultimately affirming or reversing lower court decisions based on the evidence presented regarding the parties' contractual obligations and adherence thereto.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contract Disputes and Prior Judgment Interpretation: The court's reasoning focused on applying established legal principles regarding contract interpretation, the impact of prior judgments on current claims, and whether the specific factual allegations supported the asserted causes of action, ultimately affirming or reversing lower court decisions based on the evidence presented regarding the parties' contractual obligations and adherence thereto.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
interprétation du contrat créance contestée transmission de preuves transmission de la propriété compétence en matière de contrats conclus par les consommateurs jugement civil

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied for the imposition of court costs on the appellant for the federal procedure.
Art. 64 LTF
Applied for the granting of legal aid to the appellant.
Généré par l'IA
A/790/2003
Contract Interpretation and Enforcement Disputes
A/206/2001
Contract Interpretation and Application Disputes
A/2177/2006
Contractual Breaches and Enforcement of Prior Judgments
A/3560/2006
Contractual Interpretation and Enforcement Disputes
A/1697/2003
Contract, Property, and Remedies Disputes Review

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the imposition of court costs on the appellant for the federal procedure.

Art. 64 LTF

Applied for the granting of legal aid to the appellant.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



               #$%&#'((% #))*#'((+

""

, ", -  ,"- -

-. / $  '*  '((+ 



 !"#$%&'%(""(( $"$% ) %*%$ + , -.. .$(





"%$

//       /     !$ (%(' "%0$(%12!#"%3345!6366   3

          !" 

   -379-  

 0

6:  ;%($(%<;==(%";#"(%'  &$% ;((%'  >?@ A  52 "B% 3221: /$  ="$($   ;((%'! ;(%'$'  ((C' C; &(% '%' =  ="D$ #( E(% 6445 %  $'#" #$  '@%(& <  C%("  &"($ (  (%#$%%("<(%;'#$%(""$#";(&"$:

3: $'(("F"%"0$3221! (%"@&"(>?@G(-#$A  (H  $E%'  !  "%(= C $%  I  #$''% " ($(#%("!52"B%322334"B%3221!E%(=((%;#'$(" "%(%("!("%(=(0'$%(":

5: ;(%'$'="$'"##"(%("5"&0$3221!'@%C;'%(%'#$' "$(#("B%3221:

1: $ "$$($  66 "&0$ 3221!  /$@    "=($' C;( '%(% >$@' ;@@$  #$"'$  (&"$ #"$  "#%  "($  < ;"%$  ;(%'$' % C  '#"I &(&(% '#$': ;(%'$' "#(% ;##$%% "E@ ( 5! $  ('% % " '#"I '%(%"((('63!&$(-"D!< >J%(:

8: 3F"%"0$3221!;$'#$"(%"#(;0(<"D$"" '#"I#"$##$%%(C#(AA6$"%"0$322163!& $(-"D:

F:  63 E&($ 3228! ;'#"I  ;(%'$'  "=($' C;( &(&(% '#$' % C; $CK% "  &  (&"$ '%(%  "$  '@"(%(":   I#(C'C$#((%$%(=!"(('%(%"$II"! #(C;<>$@;%%%#$""'(&"$:

L: $ '(("  L ='&$($ 3228!  (  $E%' ;"##"(%("  ;(%'$'! "('$%C;(;'%(% #'%0(<%(=%(" $"(%C;&(&(%'#$' "'#"I!A"$C0(;##$%%(C#(A'%(%'%0("  I'#"I%C""'(="$%(C;==( %" #"#%("G(-#$A H!I'#"I'%(%%"I"((('63 &:$(-"D:

9:  (%$E%'$"$%39='&$($3228: "%(% C A  "("  0( < "D$  ;##$%%  63! &: $(-"D! "(%6$"%"0$3221!%"'#"I&(&(%'#$'%C;"$&' "(("E@5!$('%: I#(CC""0"$%$(  ; ! (   '%' $@(%$'  63 &: $(-"D! ;% (% <  "(@  ;((%$%(" C( "0(@$(%  $'@( < "$  "%($



718973228  -579-   "%$%% ; 0( < "D$!  #  &'$(=(%(":   %"%="( ' "$$%("<; !C('%'=(%!%$'(('0(63!&:$(-"D! (%""$(:;(%'$'#$"(%"#(;%%%%("  "(( '%0( #$ ;  "=($% " "((  5! $  ('%!  >@% ;$ " <  E"$! (( C "#(  %%%%(" ;'%0(%: A@=(%$"&$(%%("=((A$(==((! &=(E$!'%(%!<>$@:

4:   $'#"  64 &$( 3228!  ( $A& C;<  %  '#?%    ;((%'!  $"$% ;'%(% # "$ '#$'  " '#"I!  "$% C " $= ;((%' A  32 "B% 3221 '%(% ="': /;@(% ; '&% $"(% $#"$%'!  ( ; $% < ;##$'(%("  $(0 #"$ '%$($%I%'#$%("'#"I!$&%#%C $ "M  $"$%  ((C' C " '#"I ;&(% (' =((A$% EC; 38 ='&$($ 3228!  "(%("   "%$(% ;I$$  %(&(%' $%(&;##$*%#$#(:

62:  $(0"&"C'#$%(<("#$%("#$"34 E(3228:$"$%'$'C"'#"I'%(%$%'"(("E@ EC;< =( #%0$ 3228:  ;&(% # (="$'  $'@( C; #$"'$  (&"$ '%(% $  #"(% ;K%$ @@'! $ ( $(@(%   # "0%($ ;##$%%;('%(%!$("#"$C((&(%'(@$(  0(: #$A " '#$%! " $( ( &(% &$'  "%$(0%("   6)222 =$: #% I " %$"( "(! #( 822 =$:! 522 =$: %  '=((%(&! (  &$(%#$(:$"$%I#"'C""D$'%(%#D'#$"$(!C  #$( ;$-( #"$  %  =( '%(% #D' #$  $&( "(  /(%-! C; &(% %(($  $%  $'(% #"$  0"(  % C; =((% ;"0E%  0"#  #"$(%:  (  ((C' C;">(%(%&"($"%'#"I&(%$'@'C%(";%$%( $"$%:

66: %$#' #$  $(0  '!  .$(  +  , -..   "=($' C; #$"'$  (&"$ '%(%  "$  '@"(%("! ( C; ;'%%;&(%"$'%''#"': &(%=($#"(%& %!"%%$C%(";%$%(:

63:  3F "B% 3228!  .$(  +  , -..   (="$'  $(0 C;'%(%"%(%'#"$'=(%'$K%$"$%$  #$"'$  (&"$:   "=($' C  '#"I &(&(% '#$' #( "%"0$ 3221! C    (&"$ &$(% K%$ '#"'   "$%  "(  #%0$ %  "(C'  '"#%  "%$(0%(" &$' #$ ;'#"I$"$%;"%"0$3221<E(%3228:



718973228  -179-   65: &(%'<'%$($!(((C'C$%#'$(";"%"0$3221< E(% 3228!  $"$%  #$N  "%$(0%(" ;%$%( #'$($ I ((%'  >?@ IC  $(%  $"(%O  ==%!  &   ="$%("! ;((%' ="$=(%($  $(% '&' < 63L =$: #$ E"$:  "'C!"%$(%;I$$%(&(%'$%(&;'%(%#$#(&% &$(3228:(#$(%A"$%$'(("$"##"(%(":

61: 38"%"0$3228!$"$%'%'(0''=(;(%E$((C%  .$(  +  , -..   '#"'  "(" "%(&'  8 '0$ 3228:  =(% &"($ C  '#"I "% '#$' #( =( #%0$ 3221!((C;&"%;'#"I;"=($'!%C"($  "%(' < #D$  "D$  )##$%%   (% < >%$  922 =$: #$ "(: "$%=$(;%$%(!;'#"I&$'6;222=$:#$"(EC;<=( 3221!#(822=$:!522=$:%(%'%"%&$%:$"$%"%% ==%&"($$N"%("'$'"#%#$"(%#$""( 3F"B%3228!(%<%:#(6$&$(3228!$"$%% ('#$;"#(''$<$("6)3L8=$:#$"(: "%<;"%$"( ;((%'>?@#(E"$:

68: $(A$"("64'0$3228!($A&C;%" !$"(%<;((%'>?@;%#"&$%A52"B%3221! $"M'#"I"%'#$'C#(=("(#%0$3221: /;@(% ; '&% $"(% $#"$%'!  ( ; $% < ;##$'(%("  $(0#"$'%$($%I%'#$%(":"$$#!( "(@ C   $ "M  $"$%  =(% ## < ;"#( ''$ < #$%($6$&$(3228!(##"$C;#$&%!'%(%%$%#$ "$(:

6F:  '$(%$ "% '%' "(C' <  $"$%  35 '0$ 3228 %  '%'@$'<E@$:





 "

6: "(@&"($;"$@(%("E((($GH'%'"(=('%(%(%'!A 6$"B%3225! $(0%"$"(!"#"'8E@! "%#$'(%%&(-#$'(%!8##'%%6FE@$G$%:6%: $%8F H:

/(%<;%(";'%("6FE@$!#$ $(0=''$ 3LE&($3221G .65262FH!$ "(@&"("#%'!65='&$($!  (#"(%("%$(%"($$@%#$%%% $(0%"$



718973228  -879-   "(  ('@$  $ < %$"( E@ %(%($! !  ;%%%  ;'%(""&IE@$:

3: "="$'% < )$%: 8F : 6 %:  >: 9 !  $(0 %"  $"("*%(%(C"%%%("#$'&<;$%( 8F"(=''$$#$%(@''$$"(%$"(G H  F "%"0$ 3222 C( "% $%(& <  "( =''$ $ ;$->?@ "0(@%"($%;((%';("&0((%'38E(6493G H:

/"#'%#"$E@$;#A%(('%0(:

5:  !%$'&(@$6$E&($3225!%##(0:

%$E%'   ="$ % '( #$$(%!  $"$ % $&0 G$%:8F % F2  H:

1:  (%(@ "(% < '%$($ (  $"$% $#(%  "(%(" #"$ "&$($ $"(%I((%'>?@!##$%((A$%(#%=($&"($ "%(=(0'$%(""(%("$%(&<;"0(@%(""%($:

8: "="$'%<)$%:9:6 !)$'$"(%<)((%'>?@!< "(%(""%%)K%$#"("#$%(%#"(G$%:62H! 0($  #$%  %$&( < #$$  "('$%(" G$%: 66H! )K%$ #%  #%G$%:68H!$#($"(%("$%(&<#'$(""%(%("" )K%$(0'$'G$%:65%61H%%(=($II(@"%$?G$%:6LH:

)"$$!()%#"%%'C$"$%$#(%#)I(@ #'$(""%(%("63"("(((%'(-$!&% " ($(#%(">?@!%C)I(@'#$)$%:65:6  :%A"$< '%$($(#%0''=(($)"%(=(0'$%(""(%("$%(&< #'$(""%(%("!##(%(")$%:61:6 :

/" %% (#"(%("! "% (0'$'  "(%(" $%(& <  #'$("  "%(%("#$"C(!((%'(-$%#%#63 "(  %"%! ;'%(% # #$%( <  $##"$%  %$&( %! #$%%! ;"% # $#($  "(%(" $%(& <  #'$("  "%(%("! "$C #$ (%  '#$%(""$#"(&"$!;(&((%'!"$%$"E"(%"#"$ $(" 00 " #"$   ##$("  $ $% ;(&((%'!  "% "%$(% ;I$$  %(&(%' $(' "  ;'%$: %% (#"(%(" ;%##(0C(;'&'%C%("$"%#<#;' %(#$""$''%(%/("%"M(;%#$"(%:

;$%:61:3 "$#$(A$(@C#$" C("%$(0=((A$%<;%$%(=(&(%<C$""$ $&<(#$*%$: %%(#"(%("#"$0%#$"%'@$#$"C(



718973228  -F79-   "%##$'#$'<#$$"<$#$$!""$<@%$%(&(%' $%(& % C; (%%(" =((A$ #$'($ "0(@ < #$$  (#"(%(" '($   '( $%(&% 0$= G . 638  631 : "(: 3 %  $'='$H:

;$%: 61 : 3   % ##(0 '@%    '#$%("  =(% G  6492P36#:12O  /!Q"%$R $0(%"&$(>$@@%R S T!&":P58$%:61!#:699H:(0'$%(""(%("$%(&< #'$(""%(%(";$%:61:3 ;%#"(0C;(I(% ( (%'%$"%(=(&"C'%'(%'#$$";@%$  %(&(%' $%(&:  #$& %$(%   (%'!   #%(" (%(=(C!  "(% # K%$ I(@': ((! ;I(% ; (  (%' "(% 'E<K%$("$C;(##$*%#(0%$'(0C&""%';$' #$$%(&(%'$%(&'#%%($%%(%'#$"%(= (0'$%("G .636511"(:8700%$'='$O"(:F0" #0('  ;$$K% . 631  122O $$K%  $(0 =''$  $  35 "%"0$3222! 628722H:

 (  (%' "(% '@% I(%$ %$  "%(=  (0'$%(" (&"C' % ;0$'(("%(%("G/3222 P68#:13!"(:F " #0('  ; . 631  122H: ;$%: 61 : 3    &( (( C  (%%(" "M ;(%'$'  '%' #K>' ;"#($  #'$(" ((  "%(%(" #$ C;( ;% "$' I(&% <  %  '@ %  "="$% "%(C   =(: (  $(0 =''$  $ -%-( E@'C#%$&>#;#$'&"($(C(;#I$';%(&(%' $(' #$ C;( I$N(%  %(&(%' ('#%  "#@(  " I- "E"(%G=: .638638&:"(:3:O"(:F"#0('; .631 122H

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



718973228  -L79-   /$  # =(($!  "D$   $"$%! 922 =$: #$ "(! % #D' #$ )'#"I! C( $(% "%$(0' "$ < " %$%( < $("  6)222 =$: #$ "( #%I<%$"("(!#(822=$:!522=$:%'=(%&$$%"% "%$(0%(":#(6$&$(3228!$"$%!C(=(E$"$< >$@!%(%'#$)"#(@''$:

&C(#$'A! $(0'"%%CA6$"%"0$3221! ( % ((%0 C  &""%'   $"$%  $#$$  %(&(%' '#%%($%%(%'#$'#$%(")&"$(:=(%C) (%"0%!#%CC%#!"%$(0%("<"%$%(==(%#< ($  '(%' #"$  $"$% )I$$  %(&(%' < #( %# A  6$ "%"0$3221!A"$C"%$(0%("6)222=$:C"'#"I( &$'#%I<%$"("('%(%C"(C)("(%(==(%#"$"&$($ "%$%(!(=(E$!%#D$$#$(-)$(:

 "&(% #$ "'C% )%%$ C  $"$% % (0'$'  "(%(" $%(& <  #'$("  "%(%(" A  6$ "%"0$ 3221:  /" $"$ $ #$%(%(%$&"D'<)(%('=(C)#$""$ %$"(%("$"(%<)((%'>?@%$"&'((":

$"$%"0%%#$%(%@(!$"(%<((%'< %(%$'#=(I')"$$<922=$:





UUUU







718973228  -979-  

" - 0  ", -  ,"- -

 12   3  4   56 7+' 

  2 

6: '$$"$$&0:

 2

3: )%#$%(%"('$%:

5:    '((" $ "##"(%("  L ='&$($ 3228 (( C  '(("  F "%"0$3221:

1: &"(<)(%('=(C)$"&'((""$% $"(%$"$%<)((%'>?@A6$"%"0$3221:

8: '0"%#$%(%"%""%$($"(":

F: " )(%(' < #D$ <  $"$%  "  922 =$: < %(%$  #$%((#%("<=$(%'#:

L: ="$  #$%(   C; #&% ="$$ $"$ "%$  #$'% $$K%   '(  52 E"$ A  "%(=(%(" #$ #( $"' $'  $(0 =''$  $! />V(R$>"=C( F! F221   !  %$"( I#($:  '(  #% K%$ #$""@':  '"($ "(%W H ((C$ I%%C'(("$"$%'($"0%($(%#'((" %%C'O 0H I#"$ #"$ C "%(= ( %( #"&"($ $ %% %$ '(("O H #"$%$  (@%$ "   " $#$'%%: /(  '"($  "%(% #  %$"( ''% ''$' " %%$ H 0H % H (-!  $(0=''$$#"$$#%$$%(A$$$"$C;( &$'$$($$&0:'"($$"$%("$"$"D  #$&! C( $"% E"(%! (( C  '((" %%C' % ;&"##  C'%'I#'('$"$%G$%:653!62F%629H:  @$==($  $'(%W   X(    (     

 "#("="$ #$'% $$K%%"%(=('I#$%(%/$'%$(%; %%< ;'""(#$@$==



718973228