Contract Notice Provision as Condition Precedent to Breach Claim
Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAA party sued for breach of contract, claiming that the opposing party breached the agreement by failing to provide adequate notice of an alleged breach, which deprived the claimant of the opportunity to cure the defect as stipulated in the contract. The court held that the contract's notice provision, which required specific written communication detailing the breach, was a material condition precedent to the right to terminate or sue for breach; because the claimant failed to provide notice in the exact manner specified by the contract, the court concluded that the claimant could not establish a breach by the opposing party and thus affirmed the judgment in favor of the defendant.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Notice Provision as Condition Precedent to Breach Claim: The court held that the contract's notice provision, which required specific written communication detailing the breach, was a material condition precedent to the right to terminate or sue for breach; because the claimant failed to provide notice in the exact manner specified by the contract, the court concluded that the claimant could not establish a breach by the opposing party and thus affirmed the judgment in favor of the defendant.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in the dispositive for ruling on the costs of the federal procedure.
Texte complet
$%&'$())& $*%+$()),
""
- "- . -". .
%/ .0 1 (' 23 ()),
44444444 ! "#! $ %&% '$(( ! ) !* !&&+'%'!& '',
!
. - . 5.. '!' % $- !!! . /001
! " #
512.65
6
., " ' "77777777 !'! !8' % .9/: ! ')% (' .94:!' %&'! !%!% ;% *! '<77777777=>), !! ! '?'!?''!.99:!* %*! ! )%-@ 8)!&*A! 88% B77777777( 1 '.99C,
1, ' .. ?%) ' .949 * % ??!'! %8 ! & - & !! ;8 '%!%D77777777( ,
6, & & ! )' B77777777 ( ! ' %''% & &*%% !& !5?A! %?E '+% * % %!% !- 8' ' ! ' +' %!% % ! E .99C = 5'&! (( ((( * (( ( * ( F'5 >G H,
3, !!??!' %!% '- 8 !* %E%%?''%&*'& '!% I '> &16 ! E 14 ) E .99C,
:, 13 ) E .99C * % %!% 88% J77777777 ( '%!% %''%& ! !' %!'+, ' & E> ' ! ' * %%!% ! '!&* A! &! )' &>/ '.994,
/, &%'' & .C &% E .994 &% % * % ' ! = ! ! ?' !!K '!' K '> &E ')??!' %&'!,
C, ' &.4?%) ' .999 '&'+%=* %+*&- & !!'! ' ! ' ' &' '! &* ' '!% & ! )' ! +*' )'! %!% '?' %+) !&'& '!%I '> 6.&% E .994, * '! 5 A & >8 ! %)! & *'& '!% I '> -8 !&* !' &>. I)' .999 +* % * '! '!% '!!' ! %!%&% !&* -@ 8= ?'&-+ ', I !'!G L !!' ) ! !!!' ?'!+ ) ! ) ! &* ! '&! ?' & ?'60 I > ) ! & & '> '& '!% -8 ! &* !' F H?') A!E%%?'&'& '!%&* 5-@ 8 ' ) ! )'M &.1- ' >&* ; N,
!! '& '!% %!% ) % & ! ! ' '!% & 3 ' '! I+* 60 ) '.999,
4, 1 ! E .999 * %! !'= , !& A I & !!!+! !'? !' !%!%& %=* % ! %+ &* &%'' &*' !'!& '' + ! *'& '!%
2/3421003 562.65 I '> -8 !&* !' F H!*'& '!% -8 ! &* !' F H, !; !'?%!%'8% * %,
9, &%'' &19 ) E .999 '* %E%%?'&* &>. '.999 ) %? ' % & !3 K' & ! !!%!%?'K%=.0OC/6,5? , '> %,
.0, ' & 1. P! 1000 !'?'% & *'& '!% I '> -8 !&* !' F H %&. I)' 60) ' .999 +''% #! &&1O1:C? ,1:?) &* %,
.., / ! E 1000 )% '?'% !!&.> +' %)%% & & 4/4,5 ? , ?) & * % ! ?'K% !! & 1> = 1.O:C0,? ,
.1, 1. '100. * %%!%!& = && & ! @& 1> !&% % ) ' )& '1) '100.,
.6, .: ) ' 1001 *??' ! & * 5')'&'!% ?'K% !K &*')'&'!% & * % ! 0 0: ! . 9Q +' ' & '! & '! = !!' & !&!! ,
.3, ' & 60 I'! 1001 )% '?'% !! & 1> +' ''! #! &?) &141,5? , !!&6> %!% ?'K%=:CO49.,5? ,
.:, C ) E 1001 * %! !'= )'! ! @& 6> !' ?' %+*'%!'! '' ?''> & ' . ) ' 100., )'! & !!' & * 5-@ 8, !!&'! + ' ! & &%'' ? = '!!' !*)'! !!%&%'' & ?&* 5')'&'!%&.: ) '1001,
./, / 1006 ?'K% !!&3> !& '> =:9O0/1? ,6: !)% '?'% !!&6> +''% #! '+!?) & * %&4:/? ,/0, '%8 ! %+!!'& '!% )'! A! ) % + & ! 3 K' , %+ & '! K !!' '!% '%60) '1006,
.C, &! & 14 ' 1006 ' ! & *! & & '' & * % ! !'& ! @&3> ,* % ?' %= + * 5')'&'!% ' ) '! & !!' & & ;! %!% I!% !+*'*)'! & '!K !!' &* 5-@ 8& ' . ) ' 100., %8 ! '? % *' ! +*' )'! %!% )'!' &* '&! & ' !' : ' 1006, ! '&! ' )'! % & %'
2/3421003 532.65 + ' )'! %!% '8% = %&', & ! ! !' * %%!%'? % + !!' ) % ? &* 8'! ) ! &* 5'&! ! +* %+!'&! )'! A! '- 8 ,'%!% '% & *& = 5 &' ' - 8 & ? ' %&'K ! > & * E''!% ')' & !' E ?' ) ' *%)! !% '+,
.4, ' & .0 I'! 1006 *'!% % % = ) ' %!% )'!' &*'&!&' !' !'! '&') & !; !'?,
.9, &%'' & .3 P! 1006 '? % *'!% % +*' *%!'! ) ! ' &*'&!=*K ' !' &*&%'&60I > & ' & '! -@ 8, %+ !!' '! 'A! %,
10, ' &19 P!1006 '8% !!&3> !) % &&.6:? ,10=* %,
1., 4 ! E 1006 *'!% % *! % = &%'' )8 & & '!, K '+'!*) ' '&'??% ! ! , ' *)'! I ' %!% ) !' & ?'! + ) ! &* %!'! K& !) !& ,
11, ' & .: ! E 1006 K '+% = * % + * '!& &' ??!=*K ' !' &60I +'')'!' R)'! ' ?'& '!& '5' ',* )'! A! '&% % & ' & R ' *8''! &* !!' -;!'+, !!'! & 8 ) ! &* & *' +'!% & ! )' , '& '!% I '> *)'! %!% ) % = * !+I+*60) '.999 & !')'!%!%K % !'? % ' &.4?%) ' .999, * !)'!%8 !%!% % ! '&! > & +*' E%%?'''! & !!' -@ 8 ! !! '&?%) ' .999= P!1000! ) E 1000 =?%) ' 100.,= !! ) ! )'! '?'=*K ' !' &60I R'& '!%)'!%!% S & '> ? ', !! ' ')'! %!%'? %&%'!%&* >&'5 &'?'& * !!' ! '&!,
16, ' &..&% E 1006 *'!% %&% % '!' '!' , *%!'! 'E& !' +* *%!'! '& '!%I '> , )'! ' % '! & ' & .4 ?%) ' .999 +*' '! E%%?'' &>. I)' .999&* +'''! ) ! '&! ?' I+*60I ')!!' &) !&
2/3421003 5:2.65 & '> , '' '' &E ? '' '!&*%!& ) ! '&! ?' I+*=?' '1006,
13, 19&% E 1006 &&%'' '!' + I!% * '!' ! ?' % &%'' ''!', * &'! = ' '& '!% I '> +' *%!'! & * , !! & '> ) %? ' % )'!A! +'?'%&I '> , ' ) ! & I ' & *%!'! !!' &* ' & %)!' & '&! ! & &' ?' FL !!' -;!'+NH, %!'! & ' 'E & *' ' K '& '!% I '> )'% K-!') ! & ' ?' & 8 ) ! &* ,
8 '?&&%?!& '8 !&)'!%8 !A! % !% & R ! ! '? !' %' )'! %!% ? ' = * % & ' & .4 ?%) ' .999, %!'! ' 'E + ' ' ' ' + ) ! &* '! +* > *!' ) ! & * & ! ' *)'! %!% +!' = !! % +, ??! !! '& '!%*)'!%!% % %! +E' ! & '! !') ! &!&3 P!!19 ) E .999,
1:, !&60 1003 * %'! I!% ! !!&%'' > & 'E ! & ' ! = +*' '! &'! +*' E%%?'''!& !& &* ) ! &* ! '&! I+*6. '1006,
( ! * %!'! = & = 8! E & %= +* %*'! ) % ' '!%&! )' +' ! '!& &%?''!' &*'& '!%I '> , % ' &''!% & !!' )'!% ' ! !'! %% ! !'! &%! ' ) ! &* ,%8'! *)'! ' -'!%?' &&'??% ! * ! * & ! + '!' & '! + +!' % !'+ + E! & ' %!'! & !%8 E%%?''' &*'& '!%!!+ '!%&! )'%!'!&' '%,
' '' &E ? '* '+'! ' &> + *)'! 5 A ?'! & &'!'!' ! &K !%8 ' .999 % ')!+ ) ! '!60I >?'&) !& ,
1/, % &.. '1003 %'% !' '! ) ;! =&%'' '!' ,* &'! !=& '& '!% I '> & * E'8! ' +' %!'! ) % ' ! &' ,* *%!'! = ! !!' &* ' %!'! ! ;% ! ) %)!' & '&! ! & &' ?' , !!&'??% !'! ' !&!K! &!
2/3421003 5/2.65 '!'& ', * !* )''!&KE!? & ! ! &'??% ! '! * ) ! !&' ! *! %)!' , ?' ' ' ' '% & .4 ?%) ' .999 %!'! K! A ! ' & ! !! '!'!+&+!' &) !&* , &% ! & * 5-@ 8 !'! ' ) !' ! = & ) ! &* ! & %'!% &* ! ! '! !' & ) !& !!' ='5 &',
1C, !' ! '!% & ' % '+ & .: I' 1003 ! & '+&:I'!1003,
14, 'E & % ) +% &' & !' & !'/&% E 1003, !! ' !&% %+*' )'! ! I ! )' = & *'&! & : ' 1006 ' )'! & E> && , )'!E' S!! & &.4?%) ' .999 ' !' '! + !! !! *%!'! ' , '8 '! A! ) ! '+'&!, 100. ')'!-8%&'5 &' !5'')'!?'! ; & ' ) ! '&!,*)'! &'!%&+!' & ) ! '&!)*) !+')'!& &%'& '!%= ,
&% %+* 5')'&'!%)'!!' %+ '!%&! )' & ! %!'! ! ! & ! & !%, )'! ) % & ! +! * & ! &K % ! & *'& '!% & -@ 8, & !!'!+ ' &.4?%) ' .999 !'! & R ' !' '!*'& '!% -8 !&* !' ,& ' 8 - R ?'8 '!!!'& '!%)'!%!% %!% %&! = !' &*!! 5!; , * )'! %!% ;% ! &! +! ' ! '! ! )'! S & ! ' ? ' % & ! +! !* ,
19, *'&!!&' %!%8 &%=I8 'E&%,
"
., '8) ' * 8'!' I&''' FH%!% &'?'%!'!'!% &> . P!1006 'E! & ' %&:I8 & ! %'&!!)'5 %'&! : %!!./I8 F !,.!, !:/ H,
('!=*!' &*%!' &./I8 'E?%&% 1CI)' 1003F $.60.0/H & '8) '& !% .6?%) ' &' '!' ! '! ' 8! !!! 'E! &
2/3421003 5C2.65 ' & '%8 = ! ' I8 !'!' & *!!! & *%!' & )KI8 ,
1, ' ? % !=O !,:/,.!,-,: 'E! & ' #! '! '+ & !!!' %) = * !' :/ +' ! !') = ' ?%&% * 5'&! & 10 .94.F'5 > H,
( %! I8 &&* >!''%!E',
6, '?%&% !'8%% && '!& '&/ ! E 1000 F'5 >G H ! ! % )'8 . I)' 1006 ! #! &'?'!' & E &' '!' %8 & & ' & ', ? % !=I ' && 'E?%&% &* > %8' &' '!' )'8 & %'!' &*%!!&?'!+'& '!A! %'% I '&'+ ! +' & %+ I '&'+ F $ .1C 3/C '&,.T.1/.//H,*'&!;!': '1006 ! 'E&* > ! ! )! &&' '!' !'> &* 5'&!, !? ' && &K '!' +' ! & % * ! * *' ! & &' '!' ; !') &) A! ' & R'& '!% !8 & !'%!%) %)! . P!1006,
3, ( * !,:/,. '?%&% &/ ! E 1000 !'8%% && '! & 'F'5 >G H &%'' '!' !I!! = & &%' & 60 I F !, /0 ,. H > & ! 'E & & ! & & '' & * % F !, :4 , . H, !'> &* 5'&!! !? ' &% 8!' =* !,/0 &%'& ! & ! ' ' &%'' '!' !! !!' &* F !,.0/ H,
* > '! I!%60 1003 ! &%'' '!' & 19 &% E 1006 %!% &% % & ? ! &%' ' % ' & !+*'! )E,
:, * EI!&'!'8 ! +!' &*K'!&* ) ! &* 5 '&! E%%?'& ! & )&*'&! &) '! &: '1006,
/, ( * !,.,. & '?%&% * 5'&!&10 .94. F'5 >G H ! %=!'! E'8! ' ? % !K&' '!' & %! ' ! )' % (' ; ' ! )' = & '' !' !8'' ) !' '' + ! )'! & & % & %!' & !' !%8%, ' ?%&%
2/3421003 542.65 !%!& * E'8! ' K & !'!!' ! 8= +' %! '!&* ! !&! )'F !,.,1 H,
&%E! ! ?' & ) ! &* ! %8' * !, 6 +' &' +* &'!??!&>I R! )' '!&P ! )') !&*88 ! !& &' ??! = *K ' !' & ! !'> I +' '! ' R ' ?' & '! & '5' ' F !, 6 , . ! 1 H, ' ?%&% >8 % % !' ! !!' & ! +' & ')! A! '&% % ' ? ! ! & )!' 8!' & * F !,6,: H,
(*8'! & ?' & * = *K!'!' & & '! ' * !, C & * & * 5'&!&10&% E .941 F'5 >G H &%! '%+'! % !%' &* !,6,1& ', '' '*8'! ! ! & '& '!% I '> & * 5'&! E'8! ' & * ''!' &* 5')'&'!% & %8' & !' ! & 8' &'5 &'!& 5 &'!'&! ')% +' ! ) % ' ! & ' '' + '& '!% &* 5 ! '!%! F !,C,. !,E H,
* !,1,. &* & O 5'&!& -@ 8 & 13 I)' .99/ %) '! + -@ 8 +' '! &'!' &O !,4& ' * 5-@ 8&1:I'.941F H +' S ')! & '& '!% ? % ! = O !' 19 ! % = !'! E'8! ' ! '&! > & , ( * !, 6 & * & O &'!??!&>I R -@ 8 '! &'!' &O !'4 S '!&'& '!% ? % ! =O !'19 '> ? '!& &' ??!=OK ' !' &! !'> I +''!' R -@ 8 ' &'!' &O !'4 S&'& '!% ? % !=O !'19 & '> ? ', ?' * !,11,3 '&%&'!& !!& *'& '!% ' &* 5'&! ?' E'8! ' ! ) = )! ''> !' =- 8, '' +' S '! & '& '!% & -@ 8 ! % ! '&! ?' ! ?' ,
C, & & %)!' & '&! ! & &' ?' F!'! /& H * !,43,1 %) '!+ 8&*K%!' )! K &*! )'+' !! '!&8 % !''> !K % K '&!! &' ?' , '?%&% >8+!' & '& '!%=) K %+' '!& K' &*!')'!%+*' K S'! %%& ! E'! %I&' '&% E & ) !! )! %!& &*! !!' &* ,
2/3421003 592.65 '' * !, 46 & * & %)!' & '&! ! & &' ?' & .9 &% E .946 F'5 >G H %) '! + ! )' +'!&%?''!') ! ! ' !K&*! )' S '!&* '& '!% I '> & ! '!' ' !! K' ' = ! ! &
8 )&'??'!%% '+ ! ! +*'& '!+'!! ' %&'! ! ' ! * & '! ' , *'& '!% I '> & ! '!' &= ''& '!%I '> %)=* !,.C,.& '!! ) % &! +! ' F !, 43 H, *'& '!% I '> & ! '!' ! ;% ! > F !, 4: H, !! '& '!% I '> & ! '!' & = *'& '!% I '> -8 ! &* !' F H & ! -8%&>. I'100.F100. ,.696H,
' ! )' +' %!% &%?''!') ! ! ' ! K &* ! )' +' %!% &% % ! = * ' = !' &'!' S '! & * '& '!% -8 !&* !' F H ! ! + & ?'! & &%'' ! 8 % & ' ! ) ! &* '& '!%I '> &! '!' ! !! ' &*?? !+* ! ' E ! !!& & ' +*' %I&' +*' E'! -% & ! )' 'E''!% & 8' & ! '&% E ! %&'! F !, 4/ , . !, H, *'& '!% -8 ! &* !' *%>)=40Q& !&' +E'!! )' -%&! )' '! & &%'' &*' !'!& ! ' ! & &%'' &* !'!& &'!' , *'& '!% -8 ! &* !' ! ) % &! +! F !, 4C , . ! 6 H, +* . I' 100. O'& '!% -8 !&O !' %!'! ) %? ' =O), % ' ! ;E&*)-+ 'F !,44 H,
( I ' && 'E?%&% & F $ E'%&14 &% E 100.:.3200H '& '!%I '> -8 ! &O !' ! &!'% = ' = ! ! & 8 ) &'??'!% % '+, O'& '!% -8 ! &O !' + ' ' F !, 41 H ' ?? ! + O ! ' E ! !!& & O % +O' %I&' +O' E'! -% & ! )' ' ) ! &O '& '!% I '> & !, 46 O'! '&O %' 'E''!%&8'F !,4/,.!, & ! )'8 I+O6. '100.H,
$ K % ! %'% +*' ?'! ?' & ?' ! O'& '!' & %+ % '+ &O &' ?' &* '&! ) ! & '! K !!' %) !'! ! ''> & !O'& '!% -8 !&O !' , !!& '> !'! !!' &O ! '!&! ' !!' &% !' ) %)!' & '&! ! &' ?' F $ .1/ 103 '&,1! %?% '!%T " 1000641 ,1:3 '&,6H!
2/3421003 5.02.65 !! OK'!&O )!&& ' '!&%'' &OK' & !,43,1 !C4 F !,4/,. H, !! I ' &%!% % % !& $ E'%&14&% E 100.:.3200,
4, * > ! *%!'! E%%?' & * 5-@ 8 & * !, 4 19 & ) & *'&! & : ' 1006, ? % ! K &' '!' & ! & * & O 5 '&!& -@ 8 ) ! &* ! '&! )'! '?'=OK ' !' &! !'> I +'')'!' R !)'! S& '> '& '!% * !,4 '!&> '& '100., '5' *%!'! & ) ! '+ '&!, ( +!' &) ' ''& '!% -8 !&* !' +*' S ! . '.999!60) '1006 ! 8% ) ! &* ,
&% &I ' &+* !!+*!&!'%= ) ' !&' !&' &'!!' & - -&* ' &= '& '!%I '> I '&'+&! , !&*!! ) '+ ' %' K % ! + * & ??!') ! = ' '& '!%I '> %)=* !,.C& ', !!+*!) % ! +* ! % ' & '5' * 8 ) ! &* A !'! +'& '!%I '> ,
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
* &! ='& '!%I '> & ' 8 '? & ! '!& '!A! I!%,
2/3421003 5..2.65 9, !') +%8 ! '' &E ? ' )!+*'!' % '!& ' ! ! '!%&K!; &*'& '!%F ! H &'!'8 & ' &.4?%) ' .999,
.0, * > * % '! %) ' & '' & E ? ' !' +*'!' %%!'!!& ') ) ! &* ,!) ' +O '8 ! &%'' % '! E'8 *'!' % = !' ! )!8 ! ' = ' ' !' &'!' !') ! %' ? % !K '' &%&'! I ' & & O !,3,. ! )!%8 ! %8' &O !,9 !,F $.1/ 64C '&,6H,
?! + O! '!% '! '! ) & '!!' >! = O%8 & &O &%! '% +O'!8' '!%) ' 8'&' '!& %! + O& ''! % O'! & ! ' %&'! ! & O'K!'!& & '8 ! E! ! +O' '! ? &% '5' & & &' '!' +O' '! &'?' E' %I&'T ' ?! ?'+ 'O'! -8%& ' ! R '8 !%!%& % F $ .1. // '&, 1 ! %?% T $ E'% & .0 &% E 100. C320.T $ E'% & 1: ' 100. U616200H,
* > ' &.4?%) ' .999&*'!' %*! ' &> +*' ! '! & * ! ! K '+! ! + ) ! &* ! '&! ?' & ?'60I >) !& & '> L'& '!% -8 !&* !' N '!* +*'*8'! %'!%&* , &! '!*!E '&*K ' ' ! '! &P & !&*'K!'!&& '8 !& % &> +*! ' & '8 !'K!!&&' '!' +*' '! ' % = & = '! & '5' + ! E%%?'''! &* ) ! I & '&!&: '1006, !! %+&% '+ !&?'!+* 8 ) ! & * % E!! ?'! +*' *8'! &* '& '!% ) % % ,
' ! !& 8E+* '! & ! ! *')'! ' ' %'!%&+ ) ! &* %!'! 8% ) ! & * '! %!% & = ' '+ '&! & ) ! &* 5 &' !! A % ' &, '+ '&! %!% ' & ! ! ) $ "U & ' *% 100. &' !' ,
.., +' %>& O! ! &O & !!' O%)% !&: '1006 +'*%!'! ) !, %!'!& & '!
2/3421003 5.12.65 &%'' '!' & 19 &% E 1006 & ?' ? & ' - 8&'!&*'&! %'!%, & '!& A! I!%,
2/3421003 5.62.65
" . 6 "- . -". .
7 2 8 9 5# *%(
2
., % )E,
2
1, I!!,
6, '!+ %& !8 !'!,
3, ? !' & +* )! ? ! %! A! & &%' & 60 I &> !'?'!' ' &% & % 'E ?%&% & (-V'M - ?+' / /003 ! ' K ' , &%' ! A! 8%, % ' & '!G H '&'+ K! !+&%'' !&%' E!' '! &&%'' !!+%T EH K + !'? ' !' ) ' & & !! ! &%'' T H ! '8! & %!!, (' % ' !'! ! ' %% ! % % % !! H EH ! H '5& 'E?%&% & ! !'> +*' &) &% ' )E, % ' & !' ; & ) +' ! I '! '' + &%'' !!+% ! *) & +%!%K %&'% !F !,.61 .0/!.04H, 8 ??'> G %'&!G ;( % '" %!' 5I '!G " 'U ""
' ? & %! A!! !'?'%K !'''+*=*??'?%&% &!% E'+ 8 ??
2/3421003