Commercial Contract Dispute and Assignment Enforcement
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe court considered multiple appeals stemming from a complex commercial dispute involving various agreements and financial transactions between related entities, primarily concerning the interpretation and enforceability of contract clauses, particularly those related to payment obligations and set-offs, where allegations of breach and misrepresentation were central to the claims. The reasoning concluded that the contract terms, when read in context, clearly supported the finding that the underlying debt was validly assigned and enforceable, that certain affirmative defenses like waiver or estoppel were not established by the evidence presented, and that the damages awarded reflected a proper calculation based on the agreed-upon contractual rates and confirmed breaches, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the plaintiff entity.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 1 LTF; Commercial Contract Dispute and Assignment Enforcement: The reasoning concluded that the contract terms, when read in context, clearly supported the finding that the underlying debt was validly assigned and enforceable, that certain affirmative defenses like waiver or estoppel were not established by the evidence presented, and that the damages awarded reflected a proper calculation based on the agreed-upon contractual rates and confirmed breaches, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the plaintiff entity.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of court costs.
Cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of costs to the losing party.
Texte complet
#$%&$#'&&( )#*+%'#'&&,
)
) !) ! !
!-./ $ '0 1./ '&&,
!"! # " " $ %"
"
& ## ' ( "$! )*+,(
!"
'1-32'
2 )
34 ( ! "$5 3+/,( )&6 "6( $!( 7!8"!&! $56""6 )"8"49&:6) 3/ ( ";! ) &< "" 7$( $$ $=; %"(;")&!$6#3+>14&"!!";!)5:"$" $$$?() $ ")&" @4
14 ) !); ) )'$5( <5! 1003( &"!!!"!$A")";B300C)91+;$51003"& )&";"!) 4
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
-./0.-1002 'D-32' .4 33 K" 1001( &"!! )! ! )$) ) "" 9 ) &77")&';)"!G' 9 I;"B$" ); 78&B"4
/4 ")!B& )")D0K"1001(( $!) """( )8! 8 &"!! 77 ) $5'"6 )"( )& ) "% D'.( .'/( ) ;6( ) !"%" 7" 5"!")&5!"!4 "" ;" B<!"";)$? ) ) ) $5 )" ; ) $$5 7! )"" "$"")N"!6%(6)" 7)5687" ""! )K")&"'7$$"()$*<"")&"68() $A$ 8 ) $" ! ) %*"%! 4 # 677" B') ) ;6;));)! ") !"%" 7"( 8 7" ""! ) $A$ $9( $ ) K" "'"4 "" !"$"")&!!;"")&5)" )! 8);;)<$;$""!(;)" ; ) ;4 "%! ; ) "" /'#3 &<5"B$%"<7<$;$"O ""$"!!4 & "! ) "; " ) 300C )9 1+ ;$5 10034 ; ) "%6() ") """)7$" 7( $%$" 5!!7)&!" 74
24 ""$!))1K;100D( !8 &!"" ) "! " "! "" " 8 "" " "K 5 ) "; B 300C ) 1+ ;$5 10034 !" $"" ) $5"!);"!5")! 8"P" "!"" ""8$?8)"";"!) "!4
,4 )$) ) & ( $$8! )" ) D7!;100D ")&<$$!)<" ""4 $6 ! $6!"8 GI ) 6 )" "8! )" ) 3D"51000& $!;))6 ""7;)&)!% )&)!"$!($5K";!$ $$""" ) "!)$!8" )"B!)6)B 4)6 %)&! "8!)")117!;1003!;!! !"%"7"))<! 4&$5 "8!1+;$5 1003B) "% ";!;9D'.(;"%7""( )"% ";*$!"8;)" .'/( ; /'#3; % ) $!) B '$!) )" " "% 7""( $5 !"" """ "! ! )!6!!"; )'
;"!5 " "" 7"" !"6!( 8 ! ) )< ! 31 " D( B $ " 6( !;8" $ ) %!$6$4K"!6$" ") "" ) *8 ) %6 ) FN "< ;" ) 9; G'
-./0.-1002 '.-32' 9FI)32$1001(<"$)8&<$68$" *)$)!7" "7)&$9)77)K$5( ) )" " ) 7 "! ) )"( $ *"!$"!4 # ( %7 ) 8 )K"( "" ) ) ) "" " $ 8! " !"" !;"$" 7 $"'!"6! 8& " $ 4 )$)! $!) """ )&6 ; " ) 7 ; 7 8& "$"" )! 8"B& ""!)&%64
>4 " )&<$ ) 3, 7!; 100D( #; $!) ' # 9; 8 " )&< " ) ( ; 7 " !!4 " ( $!) """)&!("$8&"";"!&" <65) ""( $;8)89;" )& G$8)7$"I4 # )$" 8 $"" 7" !)" %< ) ";"! ) "!8& "<6)"!4)$)!""7)$"" B ); ) !) "" 7 8 5"! ) $" " !")!( 8 $";" ) &! B " ) ) $ 74 !%!"( " A" "6! !78$" ";"! ) "! ;65 " "! !) <65))"";"!4
+4 33 "5 100.( & )! 5;" 7 " )&"!6" 7G I;)&<$ "")B!) "" 7 " "! ) "; ) &!4 "6 !"! 77"! ) . "5D3"5100.4
304 " ) 3, ;$5 100.( B &$ 5"! ) !! &! ) " !$8 )4 ( !" F $!) "( $!) ) ( ;! 8 &! !")$ ")""%"$5"!"9)$! ) " ( ; ) $ ) 6) "( $5( $"" "$" "") < ";"! 74 "" 8 " "5)&$!""&* )""$" !78B ( &""654"6 )!$"! &$ 5"!)")5$" ")";();) " ) %6( )&77" ) ";< ) 7 !"" " ) 5 '))&%J"()!)";"!" "'B'7<) " 8 ) $" " ""84 ( "6 $ !;)"""9$"!)$$5 !)"%J)"" !" %*877" ";B "$ 4$5 $"" %*8" !B$8)&%5"!$<""" 5"!)&77")";<74 ";"%!8 )&!(
-./0.-1002 '/-32' $")&!)8&B)";<$$ "! !""7($ "5 ;$"" %*84
334 ;$!))1.K100/(##$)"8&&" )!$"! 9 !")8&$ 5"!)!) """ !8 ) 77" $"8 %8 8 77"" &!( "" 8 $; "!6" 6"8 " ) ) 75 "!)&) """)& "6('$A$$"! 5; (7"8" )")& 4 7)&8"" 8 & %6!( # 66!! B & ) $)" (%$"6( < "4
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
3D4 ; ) 3 K 1002( # # $) )9 8 ) " ) , ; " K"7! $!)$"O 77"(8 )!") ")&< ")) %8)"&6&" 68<)<! ( $" )"88"""B"!$"8; 47" )9 )! "" $$ %6! ; $"8 ) &<$ # !$ ) 3, 7!; 100D( 7" ; &!"" ""!
-./0.-1002 '2-32' 66;" ) """ "!$" 4 # #( !!$"5K"7 $")$"")& ");!68 "" $!) ) &<$ # !$ ) 3, 7!; 100D " "" $";5(B;8&! !" "! ) "; ) 300C ) ";"! ) "! "" $"" 7")!"4
3.4 ")3DK"1002(;)!) "" 7) & ;! 8& !) "" 7 &!"" ;65( )9 8 &! &;" ) 7$" 7 "7! " ) ) 5 8$" ) 6 7?4 $ 7");!B&!%()&""8&!)9 " B )88";"! 74 ;)!) "" 7 !)!))6!)&;)"!)&!("" $ " )& "! ) "; ) 300C ) ";"! ) "!4 9 $ )6"""$ ")&!)")1/C(" ;B 8)6!)&;)"!)&!&!9;B1>4.C4
3/4 DQ"1002(& )!B&! K"))!7"&" )&"($"78)6!)&;)"!)1>C!""77" ; )" B " )&;)"!4 ;" ""7 5" !;" )" B ) $"&7")$)4
324 D "$51002(&!7$! "B"")!""!) ;&< 8 $"4
3,4 !"! # ( &!( ) 31 "5 1002( 7$!& 8&""" K"))!8;"!"!$$8!4 7" !"" ) 8 " ) #; $!) 8 " 5)";B300C P"""$" ""$ !%5 6)) 9)49;)&" "8) ")&< "( & "$ "))6")$"! !") )"8&$$6;$)8"8)< ! ";" )&6 68( 8 !"%" '
%$!7"5"!""78$")!$"!46!(&< " " "!)";)";"!!69)/0C""6" 8 7""6)$ ";"")$"" %*8 " 4 "( &! !79 < 5;" 7" ( 7$! ( " " B 8 K" ) )! " !<$!B$9)6$"4
3>4 )! ) 3. ;$5 1002( & K"! )$) ) "" ) &"!!( $"7 8 """ B "! "P "! ) "; )&";"!%5"($8;$!)K6 "!)";
-./0.-1002 ',-32' "9) ") "!B!"")"!4 9$ )6( )6!)&;)"!&!9;B1>C(77" ;)"B"4
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
104 ! )D0K;100,(& &"!7!!< 9))" K")4
134 5 ) ! "6! ( 7 8& ) ) < "K") !"%"7"))<! (77" $5"! ) " " "! ) ";4 &< " !"! ;"! B ) & ;" " $ " ) "" 77" ) & !" ) "! ) ";!))""()!6";()&< 84
114 )1.K"100,( < 8!8 !"%" 7" $"! 6 / ) " )&< " " < $$" ) )64 &6" 7" ) $ !;) ) 7" 6) ) )< ! 8 ;" 7 A" B &6 ) )( $ !6$" 7 A" ) )!;" ) )6 % %J
-./0.-1002 '>-32' ) *$ "$"84"!"! K"( )&$6() B))! N")7" "N"8&B !"%"8""$ 84&<$8)";"!"!5<("$$"; ) )< ! ( ) ) "9 )77 !6" B ;( $ !"$" ; %)4 8 & B)!!$"87;)& !"%""< 8&" 8;""!"9)77))""55B ))%8)""68&" !;)"( "" ;"5!!7!"5100D)&)&! )"8&;" $ !;) ) 6 ) " ) 77 ) ""4 & ) " )6" ) !"%"( $ ) ) %8 ! B ) ! 68!;)"47$!8" !" "!)"; !) )&; /0 C ) ";"! ) "! !"" " ) %6( "" $$5 6!( $;$" ! !""7 ; $$5 !4
1D4 "$ !$"!"!$$8!< "8"!"!;"!B )!"$4
1.4 !" ) 32 Q" 100,( " "! ) 4 $ ) 8 & " )6" ) !"%" '%$!7"5"!(8&$6$!) $"!7"4""8&&"5)& ")77 )"" ")6"" 8&< ";"5;! $"")$5"!))<! 4#&6") "!)"; !) ) /0 C( 9; 8 &< " ;" $"! S 7" "" ) $A$ )$""8 )&";"! 7 )"B 6)$5) $""S4 )9 8 ;" ""$" $$! """8 "!)";"5""$" !;!8 " &< "4
1/4 & ()!")3. "$5100,(< 8& 9;$ "$ !$") #(K"7)"()9 $ ) ;$5 1003( "! ) "; ) /0 C ) ";"! ""$""7"4 9;()6!)&;)"! )"&!9;B2.C()"8&"$!"B&")&"'8" )"7;)"4
124 9!%6)!"(!"!6)!BK64
-./0.-1002 '+-32' )
34 6;T6"K)GI!"!$)7!"""!()9 3 Q" 100D( 5 " ) """ 7$!$" B &"4 /2 4 3 "4 %4 1 " 8( """ !;BT"4/2)7!)! "6!!))") ) 2 "5 1000 G I 8 " "; B T';)"!)3+K3+/+G I4
#$ !" K6))T 9"!"54
14 ""!;63K;100D("P")$)7" !6"; "$$" ) )" ) &';)"!4 " ) ; "$ (" 596))";6$$"M 7" K)8$" )!"$" " )" " K6 ) 7) ( !(&!"")7"!!B )" )!"$" ) )! "6( " & 9( 1/ "$5 1002G 31+.)4341(D/2)43("A""!I4 $$)" &<$ ) 5'7)! ) )! "6 B $9 ) ) " ) !) &!")" K8& D3 )!$5 1001 " 6) ) ; ) " ) !) "!G; 3D0../I4 """7) " ) "" !) $ ) &;)"! G"4 >I " &!;")"<)&;)"!G"432I )"<" !!)" ) &';)"! " 8 )!; ! K8'B K ) G 3D0D.DI4K"8$)7") )13$100D G.9$ !; ) I( "! ;6 3 K; 100.( " 5 !""66))"9 !';"4
$9 6!!( 8 !) " B )!7" ) 96 """(;)"& 8!;)9K) "!;6G 33,+D)425O331D20)4.O 3++> U D, 4 D32 )4 D5I4 " !6)( 7!)! ) 32 )!$5 100/ $)7" 7!)! &';)"! " "! ;6 3K" 1002 G1002 100DI( "" ) $)7" 8 " "$$" !) )" );" 5 " ) G"4/1( /> " 23 "4 I4 !" " )9 $ ; )"( ) $$" 8 ) )" )$""7 !"! 7$! 9 3K"1002G%4"4)) """";B$)7" )32)!$5100/I4
D4 "6 ")6!)&;)"!)"" !8")" B) "")&';)"!4
-./0.-1002 '30-32' .4 # T"4 . ( &;)"! G"4 > I " !" )& 7$"! 6!"()&$) )& )"4 T;)"!"! "!;)9 8T" ""6;"!( B;)"< """" )!"4
< "$ ) &"4 > 4 3 " D ( " ! "! ;)"! T "! ) 6 "" " 8 " !$! $" ) 6 )!4 ! $K8T<?" )T";"!";;")TA"""")"! %*8$"")" "A"<6!8T<""! "! ;)T"""$ A%)T$ ";<%5"44
" ! "! "! ) "; "" "( "" "( ) T "") ) T!B$ ) 7)$)T";"!";8 " A"5$"A"<6!)("" "!")"! %*8 $"4 )T "! ) "; ) 6 )!( T";"! 8 " A" <6! ) " ; )T " 7 )T " )$ )T";"! G"4 2 I4 " ! "! "! ) 6 "" )$" ) T$5 )T " ) 5"! ) 6 ) T! $%! ) ";!85!8")!"("")$"!")T""" B "! %*8 $" " 8T " 9 ""$" " $)!) ""<65G"4, I4
# &"4 1> 4 3 ) " ;6 K8& D3 )!$5 100D( &!)"B""9&";)B221-DC$(B)$'
"&";)B/0C$(B8")"&";)B.0C $O ) !5( &! "( )& 9 &"4 1> 4 35 ( !")B)$'"&";)B.0C$4&"!;6( 3K;100.().9$!;) $)7!")&"41>43 "7 B &!%$" ) " "< )&;)"!4 8& " "9 !"" )! ;" B ! )9 8 )6! )&;)"! ""6"221-DC("") " !;")!$)&"*"'8") " B ! !"" )6! )&;)"! )& $ 20 C " " "9B)""<" !B,0C()"";B&" )& 8" )& )$'" )$" %6!4 ;%( )!; ! K8& K ) $"9 )&!;" ) &;)"! ;";)"!(8"&$ ) ).9$!; ) G 3D0D.>)4D4.O 5!)3,$100/(,-0/( )41()2 "$5100.(1.+-0.()4.I4
/4 ")!;""!!G <$ $)(&)"(& "! ) ";( &;)"!( &""" B &"!6"! %*8 $"I " &"")7")&)$!)4( ;!"5)")&!B ) ""(&)$""K65))$"8$!) )" 74 & !" ) )! $!) ;A" $ "
-./0.-1002 '33-32' )&"" 6))"<"4K )) !!":%) $!)( <$ )&!;")&;)"!)&"""B&"!6"!( )&<$))"!""&!;!$")"" ;))$$6G 3113/>)435"!7!O# ( ;)")(V!6&%)F'5" # FW F':(1000( 412>I4
&';)"!( &"" ) 7" )&) $!) 7) ")$!)""")"!B&77)&';)"!(< " )$!))! )")&""")&(<$ "8! ")&5;"$!))& G 31D3,/I(< " )" "8< "$!))! K6) $9 ) )9 " G# 3++,( 4 D3> )4 D5O ( !) )$""; ';)"!( "%9 56 3+++( 4 3.1I4 ) &!;" ) &;)"!( ":% ) $!) " B " K6$" &!"")"!"B)8)8$" 8";"!&!" 5)";4"()!$!)"""!!$"" )!"$8";< "(5$"(<6)&! G 31/ 123 )4 . " !7!I4 )! $!) $""" 6!!$" !" 5K"; ) 4 &$ "" """ 8 ;" A" 7" B & )& "6 )&5;" 7( 8 " "5 )&A" 7! ) !!$" 5K"7!$ "$")&! )""6G 5!) 2$100D(,21-01(")30;$5100/(/,D-0.I4
8; 5")& "$!)(8")!"$" &" 8 " "6< " 7" &5K" )& !") "!( 8 "7))<$$ "(8& !6$")!" " < $! <$!( 8& " !"! !"5 )&$9(8) ")"<"$!)"& !" )""$!)""78)&< "" )Q$" $";!4 )$"( &!!$" )!"$" ; 5" &"&6)$*) ;)!6"$$ "$$ < "( $ 5 " 5 " G 31/ D/1 )4 D( 311 320 )43"!7!I4
( &6" ) ; 5" ) " !"5 $!) """(K6 "")""$ ")7"8(&< !($!) """"6!!$"())"(B ) " "" ) " ) 7 8 &" B )4 ( K ) ) ) )<"""7" !"8&B& !" )& "!)"; $!))7$G 31/D/D)4D5-" !7!(3++/( 4..O 3+>> 4/0.)41I
-./0.-1002 '31-32'
24 & 9( " !"5 8 " &" B $A$( ) 77" $"8( )&< $!" ) $?4 " "6 ;%8") "!)";!))";"!) "!4
# ( $!) """( " " < )&";"!";(88&"($ "")$5$""8& !"( ) " " ) 7$" 74 ) ;")$A$O&" 5)!!") " !$8 )( )& "9 $ "" ) ) " $;$"( ) &$ 5"! ) " )5$" " ) "; " )& !" %*8 77" "; B "$ 4 $5 $"" &K" $8 )&%5"! $ <" "" 5"!)&77")";<74 ($!)) ( 9;88$"( "" !")$ ")"" % " $5"! "9 )$! ) " 4 " 8 )( " " $8 )&%5"! ) " "! )" "6 " $ "5 ; &< "5 )& 7( )% )& !;" ";"! "!6!4 " ( 8 ;" < "! " 7!; 1001 B )$) ) &'$) " ) 6( "$" 8 " ;" "; ) 5:"$" " 8 );" A" ! &';)"! """; ) $" 7)$)!4
#( ) $ ; ) 1. K 100.( )$" 8 " " 5 ) "; B 300 C ) 7 ) 5:"$"( $ )9 8 9 ) )!$"" 8 &$ 5"! ) !) "" "!8)77"$"8%8( ""8 $; "!6" 6"8 " ) ) 75 "! )&) "" " )& "6( '$A$ $"! 5 ; 4 # ! !8 ) 7 $)" )&< " (%$"6(7)&8""8& %6!4
9;)< ")32Q"100/(8&!"")"! ) "!;!))&)77))($5) 3++,(;)88&;))<! (;);'
5%64 "! ) "; !) " 7" $"!( 5 ) &<$8""$$")$ ""$""))<! (5 8& B;!;85"$"!) ") ""( ) )( 8 K" ) 4 "%!( &< "( " " <( B "$ "( ";"! !69 !"" " ) %6( "" $$5 6!( $;$" ! !""7;$$5 !4"";"!( "!)"; ")&;/0C4
-./0.-1002 '3D-32' ;)5K")"(8"$"8&< "&;" "$ "( B ""( ) !"%" ) ! ( "" 5K";! B &( 5 ) ! "6! 4 # < " ) )( 7" ) )< ! ;" A" 7 B &6 ) )( $ """ 7 ) )!;" )68 7"" %J ) "" *$ "$"84 ! 8 &<$ 8 ) " ;" !"! 5<($";))<! ))($ !6$";%)4&< "< !8) ");(& " B ) !!$" 8 7; )& !"%" ) )< ! ( 8&;" ")6"";""! "9 )77 ) )( ""55 B ) ) %8 )" "68&" !;)"4$"(B;8 " !"( ; ) "" 8 " ) $"" 7" 8& ;" !!( "! ) "; )&; /0 C ) ";"! ) "!4
;");8&"$!(7)"&;)#(&"!B 4
5 ) ! "" 8( "$" B 8 "" "( &< ""$ "))")$"")! )&!;" ) "! ) "; !)( $A$ & & " )6" ) !"%"4 < " )!"! )! &< " ) " $ !$" " " 5 $";!4 7( " )&< " $ " $9 $ 9"( 7) <$ 8 " &!") ) ) $!)( * $ )684 $ " !8 " !8")K ) $""")7! ; 5"4 ()$!) $""" 6!!$" !"5K"; )"&$ """""8 ;"A"7"B&)& "6 )&5;" 7( 8 " "5 )&A" 7! ) !!$" 5K"74 P"( &( ) "6 $ "" ) !!$" )& !" 8 " ) " ) &'
;)"!("8$8)7$"4
;)8 !9)( 5&$"7)&!")) &< "()"8&*)"8" !" "!) "; !) ) /0 C ) ";"! ) "!( "" $"" 7"4
,4 "B)!"$8")6!)&;)"!)"4
%J ! "7( )6! )&;)"! )" A" !;! 5 )& $ ) ;4 ( ; 8 &! " 5" & &!"" ;) " $ ! ; 8& " 5" <?"
-./0.-1002 '3.-32' &";"! 8 " 5$" A" <6! ) 9 ""$" " $ ) !) ""( $%! ) "; !85!4 $ ) ;&77"(96)(%77"<"$"8 5 $""))<;" 7""& ;&"()77! $""" ) "< )&;)"! G$!"%) 6!! ) $ ) ;O 3D0D.>)4D4.(31>D0)43(30.3D2)41" 15OK8&D3)!$51001V "41>41 O)3K; D3 )!$5 100DV"4343 !";&"432 O) 3K;100.V "4 1> 4 1 !" ; &"4 32 I4 !) B $ ) ;( ;" ) $$" ) ) )" B "O ; ; " ;)"! );" A" )!"$! " B $A$ $$" " $)7" ) ; "5 )&7 )" B "( ; K8& $$" M )! " )();"A" $ "G 31+11D)4.43(31>3,.I4
; )&;) )" A" !;! ;" "" 7" ) "" 7 9" ) &"!!4 &5 )& ; 77";$" !!(*)!7!<)!"""8("8&!"") 8A"""))&777!)!)"""8G 312 ,2 )4 D5- " 55I4 $ ) 8 "" ) """8 );" A" !)"( )! ) ) &$5 ) " " 7 ) " G$"" ! %) ( :6( ! ) ;( ""!-"!6 )&"" ) !K " "< )& "I"!")&!;")$") ;)& !"4 )!)"65$<$$)1/C"""8 $")" $ " ) )77!" !!$" 8 ;" 7 ; )& ";"! ";G74 312,>)4/I4
; ) ;) )!"$ !"5" )6! ) ;$5 ! )!"8&"77";$" !$$" )!"$" !"" 5 "! G 31+ 11. )4 .4D43 " !7!I4 )" A" !;! ) $9 9" 8 5 5 8& ;"( 96 6!!( ) !7! ) 8 &! 5" ;"&"""B"!4
& 9(" !"! "!)";)5)300C)9 1+ ;$5 1003( ) " 8 )" B " $" "N" 1+;$51001G74"41+ I4
# )" ) &$ *( " 5" 1000 )20&D1274(3D9$$ (5)&%)1274 //(8;")&K">(DDC ;("2/&D/374 "!B 1001 &!;" ) $< G) 10.,( !$8(
-./0.-1002 '3/-32' 433(100. 4>,I;;)"!)"&!9;("$"B 8&"$!"(B2>&3.,74
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
$ !;;)"!(!")6!)&;)"!)2.(./C( ;")"B)$'")93;$51001"B"'8")" )93K;100.()")&"!;6).9$!; G74"41> 43 ";6K8&D3)!$5100D";")9 3K;100.I4
>4 ;)8 !9)(" "$")$4 6))&) !)(&"$!;")$"!B""))! (7<! & 9B3&00074G74">+F O"423"46 I4
+4 7!)! ) 32 )!$5 100/ $)7" 7!)! &'
;)"! " "! ;6 3 K" 1002 G1002 100DI( " ) $)7"8""$$" !))");" 5 ")G"4/1(/>"23"4 I4 "( !) )$"9)""" ""&"7) "" )& );" 5)!")!$$B)7)K"(8 );" " " 100 74 " 3&000 74 G"4 2+ 4 3 5 I4 & 9( !" " $ ; )" G%4 "4 ) ) " "" "; B $)7" ) 32 )!$5 100/I4 !8"( &"$! " )$!B *!$$"(8 5)!7<B/0074
-./0.-1002 '32-32'
! 3) 2 ) !) ! !
4.
34 !;54
4
14 &)$" "$"")!)& )3.;$510024
D4 " 8 )" B )$'" )&;)"! )9 3;$51001"B"'8")")93K;100.4
.4 ;B& )"4
/4 &*)$""8)54
24 )$ & B ; " $$ ) 3&000 74 B "" ) " "B7")! 8&B<)$)"4
,4 &!$$"(7<!B/0074("$B%6)& 4
>4 7$ " ) 8T ;" 7$ " !" A" ) )! ) D0 K )9 "7" 9 ) 5 7!)! G#%XJ%782(200. I( ;)$"9))" 5(7$!$"<"4>1)7!)! 57!)!)3, K 100/ G IO $!$ ) )" )8 ( $"7 " $*) ;" "6")")$)"O)" A" )! 5 7!)! ; " ; !"8 < )" ) &"4 .1 4 !" A" " 9 ) "(;8!$$$*) ;();"A"K"B&;4 6779 !)" #*; F @
7$) !"A"""7!< "8TBT777!)! ) 677
-./0.-1002