Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/655/2006 • CJ GE ATA/655/2006 Généré par l'IA

Guarantor Liability for Modified Underlying Obligations

Numéro de cause ATA/655/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute centered on the scope of a guaranty agreement concerning various financial obligations under several contracts, where the guarantor claimed their liability was limited or extinguished by subsequent amendments or performance of the underlying obligations, specifically arguing that the amendments materially altered the risk undertaken. The court reasoned that the guaranty agreement, viewed in its entirety and in light of the relevant state law governing such instruments, clearly and unambiguously established the guarantor's liability for the obligations as modified, finding that the modifications were either explicitly permitted by the guaranty terms or did not materially increase the guarantor's risk beyond what was contemplated, thereby rejecting the guarantor's defense and affirming their ongoing obligation.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Guarantor Liability for Modified Underlying Obligations: The court reasoned that the guaranty agreement, viewed in its entirety and in light of the relevant state law governing such instruments, clearly and unambiguously established the guarantor's liability for the obligations as modified, finding that the modifications were either explicitly permitted by the guaranty terms or did not materially increase the guarantor's risk beyond what was contemplated, thereby rejecting the guarantor's defense and affirming their ongoing obligation.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
responsabilité de la caution droit des obligations responsabilité limitée modification de la demande risque financier instruments financiers

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied for the allocation of procedural costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/4407/2006
Guarantor Liability After Modification of Principal Debt
A/889/2005
Guarantor Discharge Due to Material Alteration of Underlying Obligation
C/3494/2023
Guarantor Liability vs. Lease Contract Amendments
A/1944/2003
Guarantor Liability Contingent on Condition Precedent Fulfillment
A/2502/2006
Contractual Liability for Debt Enforcement

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of procedural costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



        

         

  

     

  

 !"#$





%% &&&&&&

! %%'&&&&&&   !" # $ 

()()  (*** ((*  





     %&'(%

* 

),  -" ...... /......0#%12$$ 3 $ 44##15$# #$ $$#!##5"#  # 0#%12#$53!#167 ! #  $#48%"#)(")99:0 -%;(+&,)*3,

&,  <$="> :">&&!#$""#?@ ##$4$"$"$  $=#""$5&+,

  6# 5$# #$#0#%12 3!#167 $6!   $  4#  $$# #$  )*   &* "> && 7   ##$,

+,  )& &A"#&+!5##$$$# #$ B?44#,

   #"  #  6 $ $    4$ #$   #  #,  "$   = $ 5 &+ =#    $=  5$44#4$#0#%125C ;!$ $"  $     #"  #  5$44# 4     >#? $ 5C;3,

    =#  D  $  $#  >@  >#  5C ;!  ? 4#6#   "$     #", 5  1 $ E  5$$# #$  #544 #47= $,

:,  $E$    !   $  $   % F  )* &AE#&+$ ##$$$# #$  1  #> "##  #4,  $  7 5 #$   B   $ # #$  "$ #4 ? %# 5 #   E #4#  5=$ #$$G   $1=5&7&), $ "$  #  #$544 #4,

  &AE# &HE# &+! ?##$! 5  5I  #>4,

  : ))E# &+!54# "I" $E  " #  #$544 #4,

H,  ##$&)E#  )< ">&+! #>"##  #4 E " #  #$544 #4 5#  #$ ,

')'&+ %+'(%

 

A,   #>4F !)4=#&H!I  J:H'*+ 4#@   ## #> @ $   #$  " #1  $ # #$D #  -!># #" $ #$ $44## 0 C )+)  AA3!  #>  $$  &) =# &H  #  5#  #$,

<,  &+"#&H!#$$" #= 2

  %$ 6 #$$&7&&K

  % $"  5@$#  #$  7 5C ; $   & 7 && 04$"# C&3K

  %$ @# #45$6=##$75C ;$& 7&&K

  %   #$5$6=##$)9"#&H,

   $"  " #   #>    ? $$# # ! $  B6   $# !  $" >##  # #  $ 5 "# $#  !   !  $" >##   $ 5 $>#6 $#$#0 ;3!$4$" ##15 5 #A& -! $55#"# E$#1,

  4#!  $"  5@$#  #$    $  @# #4  #  $"#  44#K#5 # $"#?5 #>,

(,   +* $G  &H! 5  $   #$  4D#  5   #$  >#  )9 "# &H  $ $6  =##$!  $#  #L B$ $$ ;, ,  =# 4$ #$#  # 5@# )99<,       4$ #$! # $ M#  "   $" >## !  $"    # #?4#5?5 # 4$""    " #"  $4$" @ @#6 #"$   $#, 5$6  =##$ =#4##  6"  # 5"##  #$ $44#  $   6 # 5 6 #$ $    6#1! $ ""  # $ $6# #$  #  ?    # $>=# #$# #$6 # ,

  5$6  =##$ $=#  $4#" ? 5 #   $" >## # # $5"#$#4$5 #() 5$$8%"#&<E#)99H0 -%;(+&,)*&3K B6    $#   #  $" >## "  $ 5 $>#6 $#$##$#!$B?4$" ##15 5 #A&  -!## ?$55#"# E$#1,  4# 5"##  #$ 44  7 5 "#  #   # $

')'&+ %:'(%

#44   $4$" 7  $#!   5 $>#6 $#  $#! 55#"# E$#1##?$"" #     >B 5, 5$6  =##$  $ $4#" ?  $" >## !  $"        # #?  5  #  4$""  " #" $4$"7$#,

9,      )( E#  &A  7    "#  $# 7  #! #>#4$"$ ?5#=# #E$ #$ @$N ')'&+% ;;,

  #1$5$"$ # $ "" $  6 #$ &! &)   &&! ## ?  4$"# C& "# 7 5C ;! $"6 5 $  @# #4  5$6  $ M,   ?I   #>! $6$ M=# $$  #$=4D#  $    #$  )9 "# &H, $#       #$  #  "# @ $ $"I"#,

  5">  $"  ## 4$#   # $$#  @ @#6E# #>40#%12 C 3, 5  #$$  #  #4# ?5# #$5 #A)  $#4 #6$# $# A$ $>&0 O;(+*,)3!4#$$=# I "#7 B6 #?#6## "#1 "#$ "$#6# 61 ,

)*,  &($G &A! 5 # =#$ #$$# 5I   "$ #4? 44##$=# I $$@, 5#  #$  $=#  I  $# $"" "#!  ? #$  5F  $=$,

)),  ) ">&A! #>"##  #4=#$ ?  # 67E6,

* ) 

),   $# 4    # 6  $#    $#  A$ $>&0 %;(+*,)3  =#6)E=#&+,;$ 8 # (&  !  #$# #$ " #     $#  $   #> @   #$  $   @  4#@ =  $    =#6,#$# #$$$  $ #"##7   5# $# !  $  ?  ? #$  =$# ? $  #>  #? 75## #604,$6# C)+* +)($#,H,),+)9  '<A'&A<4=#&A3,

')'&+ %H'(%

   51!  ##$ $"$    "$     #" " $ 5&+ $ #4#@$ $5&&,

   $=#  ## 5"  ?   # #6#    4#@ =  5 =#6 !"I"###$$$# #$B  "$#"#&+,

&,   E  " #= E## #$ $$$"  ! $$ =># #$ #(A#"# + - 0 E?5+)">&&3##?HA#"#   $#  8$6# #$ E###  && $="> )9:) 0 %  & *H    E?5 +) E#  &+3, ;  =  ##$  $$# #$  5!"I"?$#$$$!# F # $#?   5I E6,

+,   $   #6  5 =#$ #$   $#  5I    "$ #4? #>$75@"#1$" >$ 5# #" 5#  #$$ # $#,

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

 >, ;$  #> 4  !  $ #$  $"  5   #>544 $$#  44#0 C)+)AA $#,H,+,<A3,

  $"$ #4!#%#$#$ "" ?E6$# 5F  #"  "$#66# $$5$6=##$0 

')'&+ %A'(%

 , ;$ 5 # :H # "#   &   $#   $ "##  #=)& ">)9(H0 % H)*3! #> # # $  #$   # #1 ?5# F  #  6 1 ,  $  $$> @  # #  $   #    $  7  $#  %# ?5$#$ $5@#"0 ,:H,+ 3,

    51!  $  $    #4$"!  &) =# &H! ?  #>?# $ #$#1$" >E7# ,

  )(E# "I"!#75$# #$   $ $ 5 #:H ,

  )(E# &A!#$""#?@$ $  # #1 61 , ;##1 =#   # 4 $   #1 $" >!  #  G  4#  $  #""# " $ 4$""# #$"$#E# &H!$"" 5 #:H#: =$# ,? #$=$##= $  # 5 =#$ #$  $#  8I    $?  #>  $""#?  $   #  #1 6 1    " ##, 44 !$ $7 $#$ $ $##5@#", ? #$?5$ $!$ 4# ?5$ #=# #6 $$  7  # # #"! #?5 $=#  5 ? #$# F! $ $ 4$ >#4# 4#@ #>4,PF=# $#5F$# ,

:,  ;$ 5 # A*  -    E#  #>  

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

')'&+ %<'(%

   # ?  4# 5"##  #$ $#=  6"  I   #   5 $>#6 $#  $#! 5 5#"#  E$#1    >B$"" #=$#5 >B50 ,(: -3,

  51!#$5# 6# $" ?##=#   "! $ ? #> 4$# " $=# #$ #1,

  " 4# !##4$" #$$ 4$"# $44## $"# 7 5@"  #>  "    $   5@ #  $" ##$#  # =,5F1$#$ 75  5#  #$,

  -4$!$$ E ,

H,   5 #A)  !4#$= I  "#7B6 #?#6# "#1 "#,

   51!  $ #$ 7 ?   =  #>     4$ $ ""    E#  # 0 '<A'&AK '<H'&A  '<:'&A! $  < 4=# &A3! 6"  $ 5 ! ?#  #    $#    $! ? 5$   $    $# I  =   #> 4  ,  $ #$ ## I    6"  $4$" 7  E#    #>  $$#!$"  $E6 # "# $G  &+ 0 ;'<+(<&A  )A $G  &A! ;')*9)'&H   ;')*9*'&H  )+ "> &H3! $   I  $  6"  $ 5 ,

  1$?5=# "##6"  #4$# #!$  # "$#?56## = "# #  $!5  ? #>=#  #   #$ = # ,

   $=#   "  7  B6  ! # $E$# "    $##" !  "$"  5 "$   $   /C &,%!   $"> , QQQQQ





')'&+ %('(%

+ (*)  *    

,-%.#/

=>$# E E#&+-" ...... -" /...... $   ##$  $$# %  "#   #   )& "# &+K

%.#$/

E K

#  ?5 "$"   /C &,%  "# 7  B6  $ ! # $E$# "  $##" K

#  ?! $4$""  @  # 9<   #=    $# 4 8$6# #$ E###! I  I $ !=$#$$# "##  #4!   E$1$ #4# #$!1 #>4,#    I  $$6,  ""$#  $  !  $# @"#!  #>4!;BL#RB$4?#A!A:K

$""#?    I  7 ! " #  -" ......   -" /......##?57 $$#%"# # ,

;#6 2 -"$=F!# !--,FB1  B#!E6,

$" #>"##  #42

644#1%E# E,2  =#%# 2     -, $$# ,$=F   $#$4$" I  $""#?@ #, 1=!  644#12       

')'&+