Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ACOM/151/2003 • CJ GE ACOM/151/2003 Généré par l'IA

Student v. University: Procedural Fairness in Examination Exclusion

Numéro de cause ACOM/151/2003
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A student challenged the administrative decision to exclude them from further studies following an unsuccessful attempt at a required knowledge examination, arguing procedural irregularities concerning notification and a violation of their rights to proper feedback and appeal. The administrative tribunal found that the challenge regarding the examination results was partially inadmissible due to a failure to file a timely opposition, but it partially admitted the appeal concerning the subsequent administrative decision related to the examination, reasoning that the administrative body had not adequately demonstrated that the procedural requirements for providing detailed feedback and ensuring the student's right to appeal were strictly followed, thus warranting partial annulment and referral for further assessment of the procedural compliance surrounding the contested decision.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

POUVOIR D'APPRECIATION; ELIMINATION; RESULTAT D'EXAMEN | Pour qu'une décision concernant un contrôle de connaissance soit annulée, il faut que les limites de l'arbitraire soient franchies. | RIOR.20 al.2

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
violation de garanties procédurales décision partielle recours contre des décisions administratives règlement d'examen notification de la décision échec définitif aux examens

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of costs to the appellant.
Art. 64 LTF
Cited in the final order regarding the decision on the request for legal aid, which was denied.
Généré par l'IA
A/454/2005
Student Exclusion and Examination Annulment Appeal
A/1743/2008
Student Dismissal Appeal Over Examination Procedure and Mitigating Circumstances
A/4455/2009
Student Exclusion Appeal Following Exam Failures Upheld
A/4497/2008
Student Appeal Regarding Examination Grade Annulled Due to Incomplete Information
A/595/2004
Former Student Appeal Regarding Examination Result Admitted Due to Procedural Violations

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of costs to the appellant.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding the decision on the request for legal aid, which was denied.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



           

 

 

       

 !"##$



%&'(%%'



Madame G______

contre

FACULTE DES LETTRES

et

UNIVERSITE DE GENEVE

A/1080/2003-CRUNI

contrôle des connaissances – élimination –recevabilité partielle pour défaut d’opposition)



p.a Tribunal administratif, rue des Chaudronniers 3, 1204 Genève, tél. : (022) 388 23 30



!  %%))))))*&&+,*-. /0/&(0% *'-'1/%1 /(2(-&/3 '/1 &43 & %1.& ++5! (( '-'1 /&' /1 2 (-.(  (%&0 1  /3/(/'%1/.& 6 %&7%/'' 8/9%: 4';  <=*:&%&1(%6%(1'(11 '8/9%: 4';(%6%(1=!  "!  : 4' %3./  >. 2 (% '''/.& -.1.  +++*  )))))) % .1& (  1/6/%1 -1'6 %&7%/''2(%'''/.&% '"###!    (%%&))))))*(./1/ 1/.&(-  <8/9%: 4';(./1 / 1/.&=(/%%. &''1 -1''::(&1%/ %&'(% /:(?-1'

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

0 /6-/&0%(/11 %/1&1'.(3:% (-1/%&1*(%6%(1%.&'1%1A(%./''/.&' .::.'/1/.&'%3%/1: /'&'./&1.1:% 1/(/ -&:% 12%/1/.&& ))))))1-%1 :% 1 &'.11%&1(%. 1/.&1 %3%/((-1/%&121 ./'&'/0&%&1'(-.(A/%3%/&13%(

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

   .&/A(%: '&1/'/.&2%%))))))*26%(1'(11 '*%' 3/ C //A(-&/3 '/1&43*%/&'/A%:% 1&1(/&'1 1/.&:(/A!!   /0%&1'; .3J*: '/&1*! &/. J*<(/'>%&&* '!    &.(%./''/.& . ';  (%0 66/4 ; (%: '/&1;   !<%(A1 !.3J   .:/.&6. 11/'/.&%1.&/A%B:% 1/'!  &43*(  (%0 66/4 ;     ! %&/