Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
Sklep II Ips 436/98 ECLI:SI:VSRS:1999:II.IPS.436.98 AI generated

Appeal dismissed as withdrawn by the appellant due to an out-of-court settlement agreement reached between the parties.

Case Number Sklep II Ips 436/98
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Slovenia (SI)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Supreme Court of Slovenia dismissed the appeal filed by the appellant against a lower court's decision regarding the dissolution of an agricultural cooperative. The appellant argued that labor and social courts had jurisdiction and that the administrative board incorrectly set the agenda, but the court noted the appellant withdrew the appeal on January 8, 1999, citing an out-of-court settlement. Consequently, the appellate court did not rule on the merits of the jurisdictional or procedural arguments because the appeal was no longer pending.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 243 of the Civil Procedure Act; Upon withdrawal of an appeal by the appellant due to an out-of-court settlement, the appellate court does not rule on the merits of the case.

Keywords

AI generated
withdrawal of appeal out-of-court settlement supreme court jurisdiction agricultural cooperative procedural dismissal

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 243 of the Civil Procedure Act
AI generated
Sodba II Ips 415/2001
Cooperative society rules allow member authorization; improper representation invalidates votes but does not nullify resolutions.
Sodba II Ips 49/98
Slovenian Supreme Court dismisses appeal against shareholder meeting nullity ruling based on statutory publication duties.
Sklep I Up 126/99
Supreme Court allows temporary injunction against appointment of public service holders in holding company board resolutions.
VSL sklep I Cpg 497/99
Court allows appeal, voids first instance judgment, and remands case for new trial regarding corporate registration entry.
Sodba III Ips 112/99
Shareholders' meeting resolutions are void if not all shareholders attend and agenda items were not published.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Ugotovi se umik revizije.

[JEDRO]

Ugotovitev umika revizije.

[OBRAZLOŽITEV]

Sodišče prve stopnje je ugotovilo, da sta nična sklep občnega zbora tožene stranke z dne 18.12.1994 in njegov pisni odpravek z dne 22.12.1994 o razrešitvi upravnega odbora, nadzornega odbora, predsednika in direktorja kmečke zadruge. Istočasno je toženi stranki naložilo povračilo pravdnih stroškov tožeče stranke. Pritožbo tožene stranke je sodišče druge stopnje zavrnilo kot neutemeljeno in sodbo sodišča prve stopnje potrdilo.

Proti sodbi sodišča druge stopnje je zaradi bistvenih kršitev določb pravdnega postopka ter zaradi zmotne uporabe materialnega prava tožena stranka vložila revizijo s predlogom na njeno spremembo z zavrnitvijo tožbenega zahtevka, ali pa na razveljavitev sodb nižjih sodišč in vrnitev zadeve sodišču prve stopnje v novo odločanje. Meni, da je za sojenje v tej zadevi pristojno delovno in socialno sodišče. Poleg tega je zmotno stališče, izraženo v sodbah nižjih sodišč, da je upravni odbor tožene stranke dne 7.12.1994 pravilno določil 4. točko dnevnega reda. Predsednik tožene stranke v vabilu za izredni občni zbor ni povzel zahteve in predlaganega dnevnega reda s strani skupine članov, ki je zahtevala sklic, vendar je bil ta dnevni red v skladu z določbo petega odstavka 21. člena zakona o zadrugah preciziran na samem občnem zboru.

Omenjeno revizijo, vloženo dne 15.7.1998, pa je tožena stranka s posebno vlogo z dne 8.1.1999, zaradi izvensodnega dogovora s tožečo stranko, umaknila.

Zaradi umika revizije je revizijsko sodišče ta umik vzelo na znanje in o stvari ni odločalo.