Legislator Case Law & Legislation
VSL Sklep I Cp 385/2018 ECLI:SI:VSLJ:2018:I.CP.385.2018 AI generated

Appeal dismissed as untimely because first instance court failed to reject the late appeal. The court ruled the appeal was inadmissible due to procedural delay. The court applied the principle that a first instance court must reject untimely appeals. The appeal was filed after the statutory deadline expired. The court held that the first instance court's failure to act does not cure the delay. The appeal was rejected based on strict procedural timelines. The court emphasized the importance of adhering to filing deadlines. The appeal was dismissed without further consideration of merits. The court ruled the appeal was procedurally invalid. The appeal was rejected due to non-compliance with time limits.

Case Number VSL Sklep I Cp 385/2018
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Slovenia (SI)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The appeal was dismissed because the first instance court correctly rejected it as untimely. The defendant received the judgment on October 9, 2017, but failed to claim it within the 15-day deadline, resulting in a deemed service date of October 24, 2017. The appeal was filed on November 9, 2017, exceeding the deadline, and the appellate court ruled that the first instance court's failure to reject the late appeal does not validate it.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Zakon o pravdnem postopku (ZPP); Pritožba je prepozna, če ni bila vložena v zakonskem roku, in prvo stopnjo sodišče mora prepozno pritožbo zavrniti.

Keywords

AI generated
untimely appeal procedural deadline deemed service first instance court statutory limitation appeal inadmissibility service of judgment

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Pritožba se zavrže.

[JEDRO]

Pritožba ni dopustna, saj je prepozna. Ker prepozne pritožbe ni zavrglo že sodišče prve stopnje, je to storilo pritožbeno sodišče.

[OBRAZLOŽITEV]

1. Prvostopenjsko sodišče je v tej zadevi izdalo zamudno sodbo, s katero je tožencu naložilo v plačilo 6000 EUR z obrestmi od 4. 5. 2012, za 4000 EUR z obrestmi pa je zahtevek tožnika zavrnilo in glede na uspeh odločilo še o njegovih stroških.

2. Zoper sodbo je toženec vložil pritožbo; predlaga njeno razveljavitev.

3. Pritožba ni dopustna, ker je prepozna.

4. Zamudno sodbo je sodišče prve stopnje tožencu pravilno vročalo in vročilo. Obvestilo o sodni pošiljki mu je bilo puščeno v poštnem predalčniku 9. 10. 2017. Ker pošiljke ni prevzel v 15 dnevnem roku, kot mu je bilo naročeno, se šteje, da mu je bila zamudna sodba vročena 24. 10. 2017 (139.b čl. Zakona o pravdnem postopku - ZPP). Pritožbeni rok 15 dni je torej pretekel z 8. 11. 2017, pritožba pa je bila vložena 9. 11. 2017, torej prepozno.

5. Ker prepozne pritožbe ni zavrglo že sodišče prve stopnje, je to storilo pritožbeno sodišče (2. odst. 343. čl. in 1. odst. 346. čl. ZPP).