Legislator Case Law & Legislation
VSL sodba in sklep II Cp 3944/2011 ECLI:SI:VSLJ:2012:II.CP.3944.2011 AI generated

Court dismisses appeal for revocation of gift due to lack of severe ingratitude meeting moral unreasonableness threshold.

Case Number VSL sodba in sklep II Cp 3944/2011
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Slovenia (SI)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The High Court in Ljubljana dismissed the appeal against a first-instance judgment confirming a gift contract. The appellant argued that the donee's behavior constituted severe ingratitude warranting revocation, but the court found the conduct insufficiently grave to violate fundamental moral principles. Consequently, the court held that only actions so significant they justify rescission qualify as severe ingratitude, requiring a holistic assessment of all circumstances between the parties.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Zakon o premoženjskih pravicah; Zakon o prenehanju pogodbe: Severe ingratitude requires conduct so grave it violates fundamental moral principles, necessitating a holistic evaluation of all circumstances between donor and donee to justify revocation.

Keywords

AI generated
severe ingratitude gift contract revocation moral unreasonableness donor donee relationship contract rescission threshold

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Zakon o premoženjskih pravicah
Zakon o prenehanju pogodbe

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

I. Pritožbi se zavrneta ter se sodba in sklep sodišča prve stopnje potrdita.

II. Dopolnitev pritožbe z dne 15. 5. 2012 se zavrže.

III. Tožeči stranki sta dolžni toženi stranki povrniti stroške odgovora na pritožbo v višini 1.104,43 EUR v 15 dneh od vročitve te odločbe, v primeru zamude z zakonskimi zamudnimi obrestmi od prvega dne po izteku roka za prostovoljno plačilo.

IV. Vsaka stranka sama krije svoje stroške postopka v zvezi s pritožbo zoper sklep.

[JEDRO]

Za utemeljenost preklica ne zadostuje vsaka nehvaležnost, ampak mora biti ravnanje tako zavržno, da bi bilo po temeljnih moralnih načelih nepravično, da bi potomec izročeno premoženje obdržal. Kot hudo nehvaležnost je mogoče šteti le ravnanja, ki so po pomembnosti taka, da razumno upravičujejo preklic pogodbe. Presoja o obstoju velike nehvaležnosti narekuje celovito presojo vseh okoliščin in dejanj med potomcem in izročevalcem.