Legislator Case Law & Legislation
Sklep II DoR 231/2010 ECLI:SI:VSRS:2010:II.DOR.231.2010 AI generated

Supreme Court dismisses review application as compensation aligns with established judicial practice regarding noise pollution damages.

Case Number Sklep II DoR 231/2010
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Slovenia (SI)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Supreme Court of the Republic of Slovenia rejected the applicant's request to permit a review of the second-instance judgment. The applicant argued that the awarded compensation significantly deviated from established case law regarding noise and vibration damages, citing specific prior decisions. The court determined that the awarded amount was consistent with existing judicial practice based on the duration of the damage and distance from the road, thereby finding the statutory conditions for a review not met.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Zakon o pravdnem postopku (ZPP), prvi odstavek 367. a člena; drugi odstavek 367. c člena ZPP: A review application is inadmissible when the lower court's decision aligns with established Supreme Court practice regarding the assessment of non-material damages for environmental nuisances.

Keywords

AI generated
review application admissibility noise pollution compensation judicial practice consistency non-material damage assessment Supreme Court review procedure

Cited Legislation

AI generated
prvi odstavek 367. a člena Zakona o pravdnem postopku
drugi odstavek 367. c člena Zakona o pravdnem postopku

Cited Case Law

AI generated
II Ips 148/2007
Appeal partially allowed; expert opinion required for mental damage compensation exceeding tolerance threshold in traffic noise case.
II Ips 813/2007
Appeal dismissed; court held expert opinion unnecessary for mental distress damages under Art. 200 ZOR.
II Ips 940/2007
Supreme Court rejects appeal on noise nuisance damages, ruling expert medical opinion unnecessary for mental distress claims under ZOR Art. 200.
II Ips 567/2008
Supreme Court dismisses appeal against mental damage compensation for noise pollution affecting personal right to healthy living environment.
II Ips 409/2009
Supreme Court partially allows appeal on noise damage compensation but rejects procedural violation claims regarding expert witnesses.
II Ips 290/2010
Supreme Court partially allows appeal on damages for nuisance, adjusting amounts based on parties' comparative burden and success rates.
II Ips 300/2010
Supreme Court partially allowed appeal on noise nuisance damages, reducing amounts based on new success assessment.
II Ips 293/2010
Supreme Court partially allows noise nuisance claim, reducing damages based on individualized assessment principles.
II Ips 225/2010
Supreme Court dismisses appeal as individual claim values under 2,000 EUR exceed no review threshold.
II Ips 302/2010
Supreme Court partially allowed appeal reducing noise nuisance damages based on plaintiff employment and absence status.
II Ips 279/2010
Supreme Court partially allowed appeal, reducing damages for noise nuisance based on individual work schedules and household presence.
AI generated

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Predlog se zavrne.

[JEDRO]

Ker je odškodnina odmerjena v skladu z ustaljeno sodno prakso, je bil predlog za dopustitev revizije zavrnjen.

[OBRAZLOŽITEV]

1. Tožnica je zahtevala od sodišča, naj razsodi, da ji je tožena država dolžna plačati odškodnino za nepremoženjsko škodo, ki ji nastaja zaradi prekomernega hrupa, vibracij ter onesnaženosti zraka zaradi vožnje tovornih vozil ob glavni cesti, kjer živi. Sodišče prve stopnje je njenemu tožbenemu zahtevku delno ugodilo in ji je prisodilo odškodnino v znesku 5.000 EUR, v presežku pa je tožbeni zahtevek zavrnilo. Zoper odločitev sodišča druge stopnje se je pritožila tožena stranka, sodišče druge stopnje pa je njeno pritožbo zavrnilo in je odločitev sodišča prve stopnje potrdilo.

2. Zoper odločitev sodišča druge stopnje vlaga tožena stranka predlog za dopustitev revizije, v katerem navaja, da prisojena odškodnina v tem primeru bistveno odstopa od sodne prakse v podobnih primerih. Sklicuje se na zadeve Vrhovnega sodišča Republike Slovenije II Ips 148/2007, II Ips 813/2007, II Ips 940/2007 in II Ips 567/2008 ter II Ips 409/2009. Tako predlaga, naj Vrhovno sodišče revizijo zoper sodbo sodišča druge stopnje dopusti.

3. Predlog ni utemeljen.

4. Primerjava z zadevami, ki jih je obravnavalo Vrhovno sodišče in v katerih so oškodovanci glede na trajanje škode in oddaljenost od ceste utrpeli primerljiv obseg škode (II Ips 290/2010, II Ips 300/2010, II Ips 293/2010, II Ips 225/2010, II Ips 302/2010 in II Ips 279/2010) pokaže, da odločitev sodišča druge stopnje ne odstopa od sodne prakse Vrhovnega sodišča Republike Slovenije.

5. Ker pogoji za dopustitev revizije iz določbe prvega odstavka 367. a člena Zakona o pravdnem postopku (Ur. l. RS, št. 26/99 do 50/2010, v nadaljevanju ZPP) niso podani, je Vrhovno sodišče RS predlog zavrnilo (drugi odstavek 367. c člena ZPP).