Legislator Case Law & Legislation
Sklep II DoR 480/2011 ECLI:SI:VSRS:2011:II.DOR.480.2011 AI generated

Supreme Court dismisses review application regarding excessive non-material damages for noise pollution. The court finds no deviation from established case law. The review request is inadmissible under the Civil Procedure Act. The review application is rejected due to lack of grounds for deviation from precedent. The court confirms the first-instance damages are consistent with established practice. The review request fails because the claimed deviation from Supreme Court practice is unfounded. The review application is dismissed as the conditions for review under the Civil Procedure Act are not met. The court rejects the review request because the claimed deviation from established case law is not substantiated. The review application is dismissed as the conditions for review under the Civil Procedure Act are not met.

Case Number Sklep II DoR 480/2011
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Slovenia (SI)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Supreme Court of Slovenia dismissed the applicant's request for permission to file a review against the first-instance judgment. The applicant argued that the awarded damages for noise pollution were excessively high and constituted a deviation from established Supreme Court practice. The court rejected this claim by comparing the awarded amounts with similar cases and finding no justification for a departure from settled jurisprudence. Consequently, the conditions for review were not met, and the request was inadmissible under the Civil Procedure Act.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

367.a, 367.c(2) ZPP: A review application is inadmissible if the applicant cannot demonstrate that the first-instance judgment deviates from established Supreme Court practice regarding the assessment of non-material damages.

Keywords

AI generated
non-material damages noise pollution review application deviation from precedent Civil Procedure Act supreme court practice inadmissible review

Cited Legislation

AI generated

Cited Case Law

AI generated
II Ips 148/2007
Appeal partially allowed; expert opinion required for mental damage compensation exceeding tolerance threshold in traffic noise case.
II Ips 813/2007
Appeal dismissed; court held expert opinion unnecessary for mental distress damages under Art. 200 ZOR.
II Ips 940/2007
Supreme Court rejects appeal on noise nuisance damages, ruling expert medical opinion unnecessary for mental distress claims under ZOR Art. 200.
567/2008
Zatrjuje odstop od sodne prakse Višjega sodišča in Vrhovnega sodišča ter pri tem navaja zadeve II Ips 148/2007, II Ips 813/2007, II Ips 940/2007, 567/2008 in 409/2009.
409/2009
Zatrjuje odstop od sodne prakse Višjega sodišča in Vrhovnega sodišča ter pri tem navaja zadeve II Ips 148/2007, II Ips 813/2007, II Ips 940/2007, 567/2008 in 409/2009.
AI generated

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Predlog se zavrne.

[JEDRO]

Presoja pogojev za dopustitev revizije glede višine odškodnine za nepremoženjsko škodo.

[OBRAZLOŽITEV]

1. Sodišče prve stopnje je delno ugodilo tožbenemu zahtevku za plačilo odškodnine zaradi kršitve pravice do zdravega življenjskega okolja (hrup zaradi tranzitnega prometa). Prvemu tožniku in drugi tožnici je prisodilo odškodnino za nepremoženjsko škodo vsakemu po 5.700 EUR, tretji tožnici pa 3.500 EUR. V presežku je tožbeni zahtevek zavrnilo.

2. Sodišče druge stopnje je delno ugodilo pritožbi tožene stranke glede zamudnih obresti in pravdnih stroškov, glede višine odškodnine pa je pritožbo zavrnilo in prvostopenjsko sodbo v nespremenjenem delu potrdilo.

3. Tožena stranka je predlagala dopustitev revizije glede višine odškodnine in sicer izpodbija odškodnino za vsakega od tožnikov v znesku po 2.100 EUR. V predlogu navaja, da so prisojene odškodnine previsoke glede na okoliščine drugih primerljivih zadev. Zatrjuje odstop od sodne prakse Višjega sodišča in Vrhovnega sodišča ter pri tem navaja zadeve II Ips 148/2007, II Ips 813/2007, II Ips 940/2007, 567/2008 in 409/2009.

4. Predlog ni utemeljen.

5. Po primerjavi pravnomočno prisojenih odškodnin za vse tri tožnike z odškodninami iz ustaljene sodne prakse Vrhovno sodišče glede na vse relevantne okoliščine ugotavlja, da trditve o odstopu od sodne prakse Vrhovnega sodišča niso utemeljene. Pogoji iz 367.a člena ZPP tako niso podani. Zato je bilo treba na podlagi drugega odstavka 367.c člena ZPP predlog za dopustitev revizije zavrniti.