III SK 27/08 AI generated

Supreme Court dismissed cassation against fine for mobile number porting fee deemed non-deterrent.

Case Number III SK 27/08

Court / Authority Sąd Najwyższy

Jurisdiction

Poland (PL)

Decision Date 2010-11-10

Outcome Dismissed

Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Supreme Court dismissed the cassation appeal filed by Digital Polska against a fine imposed by the Electronic Communications Office. The regulator had penalized the company for charging a number porting fee that allegedly deterred subscribers, relying on subjective consumer surveys rather than objective cost analysis. The court ruled that the regulator must balance operator costs and subscriber interests using an objective methodology to determine if a fee is deterrent, rejecting the reliance on subjective consumer expectations.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 71 ust. 3 Prawa telekomunikacyjnego; Dyrektywa 2002/20/WE art. 30 ust. 2: The regulatory authority must objectively balance operator costs and subscriber interests using a reliable methodology to determine if a fee is deterrent, rather than relying solely on subjective consumer expectations.

Keywords

AI generated

number porting fee deterrent assessment regulatory fine objective methodology subscriber interests Telecommunications Act EU Directive interpretation

Cited Legislation

AI generated

Art. 71 ust. 3 Prawa telekomunikacyjnego

Art. 74 ust. 3 Prawa telekomunikacyjnego

Art. 209 ust. 1 pkt 16 Prawa telekomunikacyjnego

Art. 30 ust. 2 dyrektywy 2002/20/WE

Art. 98 k.p.c.

Art. 108 § 1 k.p.c.

Art. 391 § 1 k.p.c.

art. 47964 k.p.c

art. 233 § 1 k.p.c

art. 328 § 2 k.p.c

Cited Case Law

AI generated

C-208/04, Telefónica de España SA v. Comisión de Mercado de las Telecomunicaciones

I CSK 410/06

Supreme Court dismisses appeal due to appellate court's failure to address all appeal complaints and evidence evaluation errors.

II CSK 14/2010

II CSK 289/08

Supreme Court dismisses appeal where procedural errors did not affect the factual outcome of the civil case.

Supreme Court dismissed cassation against fine for mobile number porting fee deemed non-deterrent.

Legislator summary

Legislator headnote

Keywords

Cited Legislation

Cited Case Law

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Full text