I C 174/24
AI generated
Consumer loan court allows partial claim for unfair contract clauses and procedural costs.
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe court dismissed the plaintiff's request for the remaining balance but allowed the claim for 3,591.71 zł regarding unfair loan terms. The defendant argued the transfer of debt was invalid due to the loan's predatory nature and lack of individual cost calculation. The court ruled that specific clauses setting excessive fees were void as they were not individually negotiated, while the debt transfer remained valid.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedUstawa o kredycie konsumenckim; Kodeks cywilny: Postanowienia umowy pożyczki zawierające rażąco krzywdzące warunki dla konsumenta, nie ustalone indywidualnie, są nieważne, a wierzytelność może być przeniesiona mimo wad w pierwotnej umowie.
Keywords
AI generated
consumer credit law
unfair contract clauses
usury penalties
assignment of debt
procedural costs
individual negotiation
void contract terms
Cited Legislation
AI generatedUstawa z dnia 12 maja 2011 r. o kredycie konsumenckim
art. 36a ustawy o kredycie konsumenckim
art. 98 § 1, 1 kpc
art. 108 kpc
Cited Case Law
AI generatedIII CSK 266/06
Supreme Court voids insurance settlement due to abusive clauses and excessive compensation costs.
I CSK 660/12
Supreme Court allows consumer clause allowing damages exceeding penalty to be invalid due to unfair imbalance.
I CK 297/05
Supreme Court vacated appeal ruling on unfair contract terms, requiring full reasoning for general clauses under Civil Code.
I CK 832/04
Supreme Court quashes appeal ruling on bank fee clauses for cash withdrawals violating consumer protection law.
I CK 472/03
Related Decisions
AI generatedII C 2293/21
Consumer credit lender ordered to pay early repayment fee plus statutory interest to assignee.
VI GC 2276/19
Consumer loan costs partially allowed; court adjusted fees based on early repayment period.
I C 1329/23
Court partially allowed loan claim by reducing usurious fees and capitalizing interest from invalid clauses.
II C 1075/19
Court dismissed loan claim due to invalid usury clauses and overcharged fees violating consumer protection laws.