II Kow 981/21
AI generated
Prison director's refusal to allow a fan in a cell is dismissed due to lack of written justification and failure to address medical needs.
Poland (PL)
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe court ordered the prison director to revoke the decision denying the inmate a cell fan and to retry the case. The inmate argued that extreme heat and hypertension required the device, while the administration claimed it lacked basic equipment and failed to provide written reasons. The court ruled that the decision was invalid because it offered no written justification regarding safety or order and completely ignored the inmate's medical complaints.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedArt. 110a § 2 k.k.w.; The prison director's refusal to grant an inmate a personal device is invalid if the decision lacks written justification regarding security or order and fails to consider the inmate's specific medical needs.
Keywords
AI generated
prison cell ventilation
inmate medical needs
administrative decision
written justification
prison security order
healthcare verification
procedural fairness
Cited Legislation
AI generatedart. 7 § 5 kkw P
art. 110a § 2 k.k.w
rozporządzenie Ministra Sprawiedliwości z 13.08.2003 roku
Related Decisions
AI generatedIII CZ 448/22
Supreme Court dismisses appeal for inadmissibility due to missing prior request for judgment reasoning under Civil Procedure Code.
I ACa 1250/15
Appeal dismissed; prison conditions deemed adequate despite prisoner's fall in isolation cell without orthopedic device.
II AKzw 2964/22
Appeal court dismisses electronic monitoring request due to lack of positive criminological prognosis and prior recidivism.
VI Ca 405/22
Appeal dismissed; prisoner's claim for damages rejected due to lack of proven non-material harm.