VIII GC 131/21
AI generated
Contractual penalty applies only to non-monetary obligations; monetary obligations cannot be subject to contractual penalties.
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe court dismissed the plaintiff's claim for a contractual penalty because the underlying obligation was purely monetary. The defendant argued that the penalty clause was invalid since it attached to a debt rather than a non-monetary duty. The court ruled that contractual penalties are legally restricted to non-monetary obligations, rendering the clause inapplicable to this financial dispute.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedZastrzeżenie kary umownej może odnosić się wyłącznie do niewykonania lub nienależytego wykonania zobowiązania o charakterze niepieniężnym; contractual penalties may apply only to non-monetary obligations.
Keywords
AI generated
contractual penalty
non-monetary obligation
monetary debt
invalid clause
civil liability
performance breach
Sąd powszechny
Cited Legislation
AI generatedArt. 389 k.c.
Full text
Zastrzeżenie kary umownej może odnosić się wyłącznie do niewykonania lub nienależytego wykonania zobowiązania o charakterze niepieniężnym.