II Ca 409/18
AI generated
Court partially allowed appeal on loan interest, reducing claim and reallocating procedural costs between parties.
Poland (PL)
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe Court of Appeal partially modified the first-instance judgment regarding a loan dispute between M. M. and A. N. The plaintiff sought 140 zł with high interest rates, while the defendant appealed the interest calculation period and amount. The court reduced the awarded principal and interest due to procedural gaps in the first instance regarding the exact claim scope, ultimately dismissing the remaining appeal claims and reallocating costs.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedKodeks postępowania cywilnego; Kodeks cywilny: When a first-instance judgment lacks a ruling on a specific claim component, the appellate court cannot determine a winner for that component, leading to a partial dismissal of the appeal and a proportional allocation of procedural costs.
Keywords
AI generated
civil appeal procedure
loan interest calculation
procedural gap
costs allocation
partial judgment modification
default interest rates
appellate review scope
Cited Legislation
AI generatedKodeks postępowania cywilnego
Kodeks cywilny
art. 118 k.c
art. 378 § 1 k.p.c
art. 482 § 1 k.c
art. 482 § 2 k.c
art. 123 § 1 pkt 1 k.c
art. 386 § 1 k.p.c
art. 100 k.p.c
art. 99 k.p.c
Cited Case Law
AI generatedwyrok SN z dnia 15 maja 2001 roku, I CKN 350/00
postanowienie SN z dnia 4 października 2002 roku, III CZP 62/02
wyrok z dnia 11 marca 2004 roku, V CK 328/03
wyrok SN z dnia 14 lipca 2004 roku, IV CK 544/03
wyrok SN z dnia 24 czerwca 2005 roku, V CK 70/04
wyrok SN z dnia 25 sierpnia 2004 roku, I PK 22/03
uchwała SN z dnia 31 stycznia 2008 roku, III CZP 49/07
uchwała SN z dnia 26 stycznia 2005 roku, III CZP 42/04
uchwała SN z dnia 4 maja 1991 roku, III CZP 20/91
uchwała SN z dnia 4 maja 1991 roku, III CZP 21/91
wyrok SA w Katowicach z dnia 9 lipca 1991 roku, I ACr 204/91
uzasadnienie wyroku SN z dnia 7 czerwca 2001 roku, III CKN 369/00
uzasadnienie postanowienia SN z dnia 19 stycznia 2012 roku, IV CZ 119/11
Related Decisions
AI generatedIII Ca 450/23
Civil appeal dismissed; court rejects consumer protection statute extension for business debt collection claims.
II Ca 709/18
Court dismissed part of loan claim due to statute of limitations while allowing remaining unpaid installments.
I ACa 557/20
Court allows partial claim for late payment interest on a bill of exchange, rejecting capitalization of prior interest.
VI C 222/24
Civil court dismisses claim for substitute car rental and towing fees due to lack of causation proof.