Consumer wins court case against Apple for replacing non-conforming iPad with refurbished unit instead of new one.
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe court ruled in favor of a consumer who purchased a new iPad that subsequently failed to connect to Wi-Fi. Apple attempted to resolve the defect by offering a refurbished replacement, which the court determined did not satisfy the consumer's contractual right to a new device. Consequently, the court ordered Apple to deliver a brand-new iPad Air 2 within two weeks and to pay associated costs.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedConsumer Protection Act; Unfair Contract Terms Directive: A consumer who pays the purchase price and performs their contractual obligations correctly is entitled to receive a new good in lieu of a non-conforming one; receiving a delayed good that was due from the outset does not constitute unjust enrichment, and therefore a replacement must match the original specification of a new product.