Court declares immediate dismissal void due to disproportionate sanction given the long service and tense relationship.
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe court declared the immediate dismissal of the employee by the employer void and ordered reinstatement with back pay. The employee alleged he was fired for insulting his supervisor, but the employer argued the statement was threatening. The judge found the immediate termination disproportionate given the employee's ten-year tenure and the tense working relationship, ruling that a lighter sanction would have sufficed. Consequently, the dismissal was invalidated, and the employer was ordered to pay wages, vacation pay, and legal interest.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedArbeidsovereenkomst; ontslag op staande voet: De rechter kan het ontslag op staande voet nietig verklaren als de sanctie niet evenredig is aan de verwijte, met name bij een langdurig dienstverband en gespannen verhoudingen.