ECLI:NL:RBALM:2011:BP9488
ECLI:NL:RBALM:2011:BP9488
AI generated
Utility company claim dismissed due to insufficient evidence regarding unpaid bills and third-party debts.
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe court declared Essent Retail Energie B.V. inadmissible for claims against third parties while dismissing the remaining claim for insufficient evidence. Essent alleged non-payment of specific utility bills but failed to substantiate the amounts or explain discrepancies in their records. The judge ruled that the plaintiff must clearly demonstrate the debt's existence and cannot rely on unexplained documents to prove the defendant's liability.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedArticles 6:119 and 6:162 of the Civil Code; A claim is inadmissible if the plaintiff fails to provide sufficient evidence to substantiate the alleged debt, and a claim against third parties is inadmissible without clear legal basis.
Keywords
AI generated
insufficient evidence
utility bills
inadmissible claim
third party debt
Civil Code
burden of proof
utility provider
Cited Legislation
AI generatedArticle 6:119 of the Civil Code
Article 6:162 of the Civil Code
Article 7 of the General Terms and Conditions for Household Gas Supply 2003
Article 7 of the Special Terms and Conditions for Energy Supply to Small Consumers 2004
artikel 6:119 BW
Related Decisions
AI generatedECLI:NL:RBLIM:2017:11295
Court allows debt collection claim for unpaid utility bills despite debtor's insolvency defense.
ECLI:NL:RBNNE:2025:4693
Court dismisses debt takeover claim under Wht as debt was not demandable before June 1, 2021.
ECLI:NL:RBROE:2011:BP4361
Consumer wins gas bill dispute; utility rejected due to missing payment records and procedural errors.
ECLI:NL:RBLIM:2017:7660
Court dismisses creditor's claim for unpaid energy debt and interest due to lack of proof and procedural errors.
ECLI:NL:RBLIM:2014:3492
Court dismisses claim due to insufficient evidence and failure to comply with procedural requirements under Dutch Civil Code.