ECLI:NL:PHR:2013:970
ECLI:NL:PHR:2013:970
AI generated
Dutch Supreme Court allows appeal against confiscation order due to lack of specific attribution reasoning for joint offenders.
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe Supreme Court of the Netherlands allowed the cassation appeal regarding the attribution of illicitly obtained profit to the defendant. The lower court ordered full confiscation of €18,300 without explaining why the defendant bore sole responsibility despite being a joint offender in a cannabis cultivation case. The Court ruled that this lack of specific reasoning violated established case law requiring clear attribution when multiple parties are involved.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedArt. 36e Sr; Art. 36e Sr, 7th paragraph: The court must explicitly determine the degree of individual responsibility for joint offenders when calculating illicitly obtained profit, as a blanket attribution without specific reasoning violates the principle of reasoned judgment.
Keywords
AI generated
illicitly obtained profit
confiscation order
joint offenders
attribution of liability
reasoned judgment
Wetboek van Strafrecht
cassation appeal
Cited Legislation
AI generatedArt. 36e Sr
Art. 36e Sr, 7th paragraph
Art. 6 EVRM
artikel 36e van het Wetboek van Strafrecht
art. 36e Sr
art. 6 EVRM
Cited Case Law
AI generatedHR 30 november 2004, LJN AR3721
HR 14 februari 2006, LJN AU9127
HR 7 december 2004, LJN AQ8491
HR 9 december 2008, LJN BG1667
HR 16 maart 2010, LJN BK6947
HR 11 november 2008, LJN BD4860
HR 3 november 2009, LJN BJ6953
HR 17 juni 2008, LJN BD2578
NJ 2005/133
NJ 2006/163