Legislator Case Law & Legislation
TALCH01_45409 AI generated

Court dismissed defamation claim against journalists for reporting on a prisoner's prison conditions.

Case Number TALCH01_45409
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Luxembourg (LU)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the plaintiff's defamation suit against three defendants, including two journalists, regarding their reporting on a prisoner. The plaintiff alleged the reports were false and damaging to his reputation while incarcerated. The court ruled that the journalists acted with sufficient diligence and the reports were based on verifiable facts, thus protecting freedom of the press.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Articles 10 and 11 of the Law of 15 March 1991 on defamation; The court established that reporting on prison conditions is protected speech if based on facts and published with professional diligence, even if the subject is a prisoner.

Keywords

AI generated
defamation action freedom of press prison conditions journalistic diligence public interest reputation rights media liability

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Articles 10 and 11 of the Law of 15 March 1991 on defamation

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Jugement civil

/ 93

{ 1ère section )

Audience publique du mercredi, dix sept mars mil neuf cent

quatre-vingt-treize.

Numéro 45 409 du rôle.

Composition :

Marion LANNERS, 1ère vice-présidente,

Thierry HOSCHEIT, juge,

Paule MERSCH, juge-déléguée,

Paul SCHMITZ, greffier.

Entre :

le sieur

, sans état, demeurant à (

•

, actuellement emprisonné au Centre Pénitentiaire de

Schrassig,

demandeur aux termes d'un exploit de 1|huissier de justice Pierrot

FRISCH de Luxembourg en date du 30 avril 1991,

comparant par Maître Jean-Jacques SCHONCKERT, avocat, demeurant à

Luxembourg;

1 . la société anonyme

bcC>i-)

'

établie et ayant

g

.

T -

A \

, inscrite au

social a

L

-

r

\

Registre de Commerce sous le numéro ^ .)

>

défendeur aux fins du prédit exploit FRISCH,

comparant par Maître Claude PENNING, avocat, demeurant à Luxembourg;

2. le sieur

3^^

journaliste,

demeurant à L-

^ ^

'

3. le sieur

C

. journaliste-photographe, demeurant à

L-

défendeurs aux fins du prédit exploit FRISCH,

comparant par Maître Charles KAUFHOLD, avocat, demeurant à

Luxembourg.