Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
TT:1976-56 AI generated

Labor court dismisses union claims against employer and union for violating social facility agreement terms.

Case Number TT:1976-56
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Finland (FI)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the claims filed by the employer and the union against the union's branch and a member regarding violations of social facility provisions in a collective agreement. The employer and the union argued that the branch and the individual failed to provide adequate social facilities as mandated by the agreement. The court ruled that the specific facts did not constitute a breach of the social facility requirements under the relevant labor law provisions.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Section 29 of the Collective Agreement; The court held that failure to provide social facilities as stipulated does not automatically constitute a violation if the specific circumstances do not meet the statutory threshold for liability.

Keywords

AI generated
collective agreement violation social facility requirements employer liability union branch responsibility labor court dismissal social protection standards breach of contract
AI generated
labour_1974_71
Labor court allows union and employer to pay fines for violating collective agreement social facility rules.
labour_1988_90
Construction company and unions fined for failing to provide workplace social facilities under collective agreement.
labour_1992_4
Construction company fined for social facility violations; union's monitoring breach claim dismissed due to prompt remediation.
labour_1988_76
Labor court allows union strike for unauthorized outside labor; employer fined for failing to inform union.
labour_1988_104
Labor court orders employer to pay fine for breach of collective agreement but dismisses union's claim regarding union member scope.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Työnantaja tuomittu hyvityssakkoon työehtosopimuksen sosiaalisia tiloja koskevien määräysten tietensä rikkomisesta.

Työnantajaliitto ja sen piiri vastasivat piiriasiamiehen laiminlyönnistä. Ne molemmat tuomittu hyvityssakkoon valvontavelvollisuuden laiminlyömisestä.

Asianosaiset: Rakennustyöläisten Liitto r.y. Suomen Rakennusteollisuusliitto r.y. ja Liikkeenharjoittaja Einari Savolainen

RATKAISU

Asianosaisliittojen kesken 23.4.1974 tehdyssä rakennusalan työehtosopimuksessa on muun muassa seuraavat määräykset:

VII Sosiaaliset määräykset

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

29 §

Rakennuspaikalle tai sen läheisyyteen on rinnan rakennustyön alkamisen kanssa järjestettävä alempana mainitut sosiaalitilat.

1. Ruokailusuoja

Ruokailusuojat on järjestettävä sellaisiksi, että

- ne kunnollisesti suojaavat sateelta, kosteudelta ja kylmyydeltä ja että niissä voidaan kylmänä vuodenaikana pitää noin