Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-07-7801\8 AI generated

4-07-7801\8 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas

Case Number 4-07-7801\8
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

,$,' , $ ,$$,$,'  ,  .$$ 14, 1' ,$$,$  ,' $,+ 

Legislator headnote

AI generated

4-07-7801\8 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Põlvas: ,$,' , $ ,$$,$,'  ,  .$$ 14, 1' ,$$,$  ,' $,+ 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



          

 

  







 

 





 !!"#$%&'"#$%

# 

 



  

()!*)*!

 



$+,-

 

  



 

 

,



 -,  ,+ # "$,.,/, ,

  %,&+$ 0  !!* ,  .,$, 

-,%11, 2! '!*'!3!$$,4,5*()

*$-1-

  

   

 - 647 3!*! 2!89 ,

+-

49,$7:







4,4%$#%

 

   

 * !!





,+$44

;41,$$#"$,.,/,,%,&+$0  !!*

 -,%11, 2! '!*'!3!

,,$ -,%11,$$,4,5*()*$-1-

5 8$-.$,$

$#.,4

 5 3 $,$ %1$ &# ,

+-$   -,  !!! 6, :

,

.,$ *!!6,,4:1,

+-4





 



 



 &,,$, .$ %+ 4 #-' .,+  ,$$, $$ ,&

 $, "#$% & 4 ,&, .1,% $ $, ,

,%,-,&,$,!2 !!

,,$,"#$%&43!.1,%$'$,.1,%'

&$&,,$,.$,$,%&,1,4%$,!2 !!

,&,#-&,,$$,4%4$'%1$,$&,,$,$

%#,&4%4,4$



 6:





  



# "$,.,/, , %,&+$ 0  !!* ,-

%11, 2! '!*'!3! -$$,4,5*()*$-$,$

%-*!%;$,( !!,$$,,,',,&! !!*,$$

308$"#$%%$$")&,,!' &)$4,&#4'$1,,&$,

%,& ,$$, ,1' 4, %.<<, $4 %%<<4,'  ,

%$,-$$#,,,,$ -$$,,5)4,2 '

0('!8#4,4









! 

"!  



-

$,+

#

"$,.,/,

,

%,&+$

0  !!*,;&%11,&,,$,$#.,&

5 8$-.

$,$,%11,,.4&,#,+%,,$,$,44;$$$4,$

#,4& -, #-%, 1&,' & .# %$,  ,&,'

& , $, $,44 #,4& $, , &,,$$,  1&,  -1,

6%$,,&,:%,$



,,$, 1-  #-, $,44 %&' , &,,$$,  4 #4

 "&, $ "#$% & . & ;$ .$ 4% #4,,4' &

 ")& #4,,-  .# ,$  &<<4 ")& #4,,4 #%

#4- 4!!'&4 =-,&&,,$,,',4

&$.4%4$$&1-4'&&#$,&4,,4,-,,-,-,&

&$-$,,,4,-,$,+)$,,%.,&1,,,-,$52!1,+',

,-$,,&&$-$,,,4,&$.,+<<+,#4',,#-&1-4

,1,'4&,,4.,&$$1,,%<<+,#4$,,,-$#4

4 !! $  $   5 2! 1- 4 ,,4 .,&$ $1,,%$,

#4$,  "&,' &4  &,,$$,   -  #4

4 )$,,%.,&1,,,-$,$4$1+.,&$

$,% #4  "&,'    ,,$ 4 $$#,, 

$$#,,-,4%$,,&,;;4

,,$,%#,,-,&,$,+#-,$,#4 ,$,,,$$,

',%#&;$$,,$$,$,+', ;$,

$-,4$4%11,,&4&,$-,4;$$-;4&$%1

',%#,$.,,,$,$-,',,-,&%#4%11,

&-' %1  ' ,   .,&.<<,'  ,&  .# 

.,&$ $4 #4- ",$, -, %%1, ,& &  

1,4,$ & ;$  %1' ,  $ %$& & .,&.$, .<<,' 

.,&$.$$#4'&$$44%%<<4,'#,

$-

,, $-' , #4  "&, $4 ,, .#-, %$,' $,+

-',,&,-,&,%4$$,#4$4&,

%$, 4 1 4%$ ,& -1, #4  "&, ' ,,

&$,$1,,4,'%,,4'%$,,$,$1,,.,&$.$,#4'$$,

%,,44',.,&$,$1,,,#4'%%$,&1',%$$,+

,, #4' &$$, ;+ ,&  ,, $1+ $. #4   .44 

,,$,%$, #4$, # %1$&, ,,&1-$   1$ %$,

&%,$,%#,4+#4,$,,4#4"&, -

%1$4##4$, 4#%#4"&,-&

36:

>$'#4"&,,$,,,.#-,#&+4%$,'$,

#4#4$, 4,,,,$,%#%,'&$$,$,&,

$,-1,4%#4$$4%$1-,&4

,,$$,  $,+' , ,& .$ 4 #4 %#&$ $4&,

%%<<4, $ -4 14,4  ,,# ,& .$ &,.44

&,,$,%$,+,+',#4"&,%$,.$,

$4&,-1,%,$.4+.#$,

,,$$,$,+',#4 4'&1.,&$$,%#4

$,.44$.44&'&,-$&$,->$'#4 4

,$,$4#4$,-',$,.#-,&4#4

"&,,$,#&+4%%<<4,

,,$$,$,+',15!#4,4#$%1$,$,,$.,&.$,

11,$1,4$,&.$4#4%#$44%%<<4,,,$$,

.$&,.44#-&,#',14%#&$,-1- ,-4

,$,' , - , #4 ,, .,&.$, 11, $1,4$' ,  $4 ,,

$$#,,.#,'#44$,4-.#-4

$,$,44%&&,,$$,.$0(&,

4$$#,,4$,$1+%4  4$,*  !!*,

!!!!*!88*,$$$.#&,,,%%!!?$,

#4 4 ,,-&,4%1$+.#$,,$,&$

&,,$$,,-,%,-1,%,$



      

 



#"$,.,/,,4%4$,3!3 !!&4-$,+,$,

% %1$, &,,$, ,4 %, 1+  $$#,, ,,&$' , 

+%,&,,%.<<,$44%%<<4,@4,$,,&$

1' , .#-, & 1,$$ % %<<4  &,,$$,  $,

&<<% #-, ,4'  $,  , #4 %,& 14  $$#, .$,

&4,,4,.44&+4&#4',,, &

.$,.<<%1$,&,,$,$,+ ;$,-#,4',&

.$,.<<&,,$$,$,$4.,&$.$'.$,#,4'

 4$,4.,&$,.<<



"









 "!  



5 3$- 1,+',&)%#$+%11,1,$,'#$&

,4,+,.4,'$$4,%1$,&,,$,,,-,&,$,$4

/$  #-$, $4 ,,- $,+ $ %# , #-

 5) !

&,4;&,



-,$,4%11,.$$$$,4,5*()*$,$,$$,',,&

! !!* ,$$ 308 "#$% & "#$% %$$ ") & ,, !' &)$ 4,

&#4  "&, ,-&1--  *  ' $1,, &$-$, ,,4,

&$,'

,

%,4

,$$,

,1'



4,

%.<<,

$4

%%<<4,'  & .#-, %$,% #4- ,4  %$,

-$$#,"$$,$ -$$,,5)4,2 '0('

!#4,4





(6:

-41-&,4#,447



,,$$,   -, -$ 4 ;$,4 6 $ 32 .<<4,$)3*: ' &$$,

,$! !!*#&<<4",,4'4,#4

"&,",,$&%$$,#4,,$'#4&-$,&$,

;,- &1 ;$,%$ , $4'     4 -  .,& 1, ,,-$  ..

&1 , $4' - , .444' 4 $1,, &$, %1, -  %

.,&$,',4-,$41%%$,$.4'4,$$,&,4-,

14 -.<<,&'$%$,$,$ 4&

.#-, -.;;4.#-,%1$4#%$,%$,&#4

,,%4.444 -',,,,#",&.<<4,

$,,$$4$%$,',,-!)8!&A,.,&.<<,

&  , .#$,4 ,$  .,& $ -,  , ,,

.#-,%#$$3!)30&A -,%,.$,,4$$#,,,,&$

&1-4,&.441$,4.4,4$$;4&$$.$&4

1$-$.,$,.#-, -#4&,,-',;,,&<<4

.11,",$,#,,,-114,%&,%',$.,,,$'#

,



 -$4;$,6$38:,$! !!*$ 

#4 4$".$$$,&$.<<.,&$,&

,,%%<<4#,$$$,% $,$4-&$,

&%#'&,,4$,,.<<,0!&A4

&1-,4$1%1$',-$-#%$,1,.,&$

, ,- $,& ,4     ,,   %# $$ #,,

&&,4$4$%1,&$*!&A&4,.#-, ,-

.,$,



,B&-$;$,6$(!:,$,&+,$

4 ;,- 14  ;,$ ;4&$ ")&)& ,, &$'  $

&4 4.#-,4,4;4&%$,'/-/,,4'

&##4'  /,,4  ,,&$ #44  #4, 1$,4  %#4 #44, 

,4&,4,,&B&,,&$,44&,44$,4

;4&$ =,, $,4 4,  1$- $ $, %4 C  1$,4 $4

,$-,1',.$,-$.444 41$-$%1,'$.1$-,'&$4

,4;$-$+,&,4-$,$.$,1$-'4.441$-,

$4&$$,-&-,-%#&$4,,$$4,&,

1% &$ $ B& %,   1% .,&$,  $+' ,

.,&$,%#&$,%1$#'1%%1-,

$,$1%

.,&)0) !&.,$1 4$$.,&$,&1%$%$,



4;,-$4;$,,$6$(.<<4,$)( :.$,

%1$, ,, ;,  $$#,,-  ;4&$, # ;   ,

B&-;4&$$1',&.$$$4#4,,

#4 4  $ $4  " .$   & .$ $4  $ $44

.44&,$  %%<<4, $ $ .,4 ,  4$ $ .,4

.,&.$,;$-1$,4;4&$$4,$-,4,,.441$-;

,141%&$.&#$,&$.$%%#&;$.$$,%,,

$1,+%$".$,,,$,.$,.<<,1,&



06:

1$#+-$4;$,,$6$(: !!*-%+

-,4#4"&,'4,#%$4#4""#$%

.$,  $ ;  &,  %1, $$- &1-' $  -,&$  1 &

- %#   & , & $  3!)(! &A >#44 &$,'

%4#+ -.,&$,

$,,14'1,,D$

,, 4&.#-,

&$,$,,%$.$#+,14'

, ,$ $ $, .,&.$, $ .#$,4 4  %# $$ *!)! &A 4

$,4"&,.,&$&<<44'$,4



 , 1- -$ 4 ;$, ,$ 6 $ ( : $4 4 #+ ,

 "&,-' &4    - 4 #4 & .$, 1-  %

.,&$,  ,$ , $4  ", 4 $ %$ .1 , ,-  4

.#4    "&,$  $ ,$,$ %1, '  ,  ,-$ ,,

&

$$4 41-1-%,$,,.#-,"&,

$,,&$,#4&.,$,.#-,&,



14&,-$4;$,,$6$( :# -

- ;, & .$,

$ .$ $ 4  & .#-,  -

# & .$,$ &, %1- , ,-

&$ $ ,$,$ .&,    4

$1,,& &1 14&,  , &#, ,4 $  ",$, #, ; 

-,,1,'#,,;$,',,



;4& %$.$$   /+,$,- 6 %11, 2! '!*'!3! $ ()*:'

&$$, 1%$ ! !!* %4,$44 ;4& ")& ,, !'  & %

&'  $4 .#-4  #4 )"&, ,-&1--  * 

, 4!! %,-&1--((8 EF.,&;$-;4&$4$

,4  ,, $' #4, .,&, .,$, .#-,'  4 $+,&1$,4' 

"&,.441$,4,4,.;4&#4,4/-/,,4



$#,,   ,,&- 6%11, 2! '!*'!3! $ )3:' &$$, ,$

! !!*,$$308$")&,,!' &$&4$$#,'$4

.#-4  #4 )"&, ,-&1--  *     4 !! %

,-&1--  ((8 EF  ,,&$,  4  ,,  $' #4,  .,$,

.#-,' 4 $+,&1$,4'  "&, .441$,4  ,4, .  

,$  ,-,& G $,  &$-$, ,,4, 6 &   ,,4: &-

$#,,/,,4#4,$.#,1-,$,,44



# "$,.,/, , %,&+$ !8! !!  

%11, 2! '!*'!3!6$3 :'&$$,- $$,4,5*()*

$-$,$%-30%;$, !!,$$,,,',! !!*

,$$ 308  $ "#$% %$$ ") & ,, !' &)$ 4, &#4' $1,,

&$,%,&,$$,,1'#,-$,,&&$-$,,,4,&$,

,44,,4.,&$$1,,%$$,,,$ $$,,5)4,

0('2!#4,4



$,., 6$$,$,: ,.,  ))!A !3( 6 $ 02)08:  44

,.,4%&,,$#4"&,',-&1 *'$&

,, .441$-,4, ,& $ %$$ H 0! &A  #4 4 !!'

,-&1 ((8 EF' $& .#, ,,$ $ %$$ H 0 &A

., ,4 &,$4, $,$ , $, %#&$ %4 ,-' & $ #4

26:

4!!1,$,#4"&,$&&,,&1%$,

 .#,  #4  "&, $ ,,$'   ,-,, $,'

#4,, ,,$   .441$-,4, $-, H 0 & -,$  #44 4

.#,,,$,,,,,,&8!I-$$'4-%%11,$,

#4,$,,%,%-,$,$%#&$%4&,$$#,,,,&

$,$%4 #4"&,.441$-,4,")&#4,,%,$

' & 1  #4, .,& ,,,, , .,   $,44 ' ,

$$#,,%1$&,%#&$,$,%$$%#&$%$$$;;4



4 #,44 -& 6 &,,$$,   , ;$,4' ;4&

%$.$$$$#,,4:#,4%4',! !!*,$$308$

&"#$%&"#$%")&,,!' &")&)&,,4,&$

$$#,'    .#4  &<<4 &  ,,4 &$,  $4  #4

"&,,-&1-- *6&4 -:&<<4")&

,,4&$,$4#4 4!! %,-&1--((8 EF6&4

:    , $, %4$  ,$$, ;$,' ,  .#, -1,$ 4 &#$,&4

$$#,, $,4 #44 ,$ %- ;4& %$, 1- ,4

/4,$ 1+' , %-4   "&, ,  4 % .,&.$, ;$-

 528 $-  . 0 ,$ .,+ %11,.$$ $4& ,%, .#4 

 -,$, 4 %11,.$$ .$, ;$4, 1 144' ,$$,$, %$,

,&$$,,,,,+.$,,4%4,%%,

&#$,&4#444&1&%11,4,$%-',%,%-,

%,4,$&,$-,$%$,#4&,$,',$$,$$#,,

1%$>+,$6 4!! %,-&1--((8 EF: ,

,6"&,,-&1-- *:

- &$$$,,-& !  !!( ,   3)))*)!(  4

,$,' , $ ,$$,$,'  ,  .$$ 14, 1' ,$$,$  ,' $,+ 

14' &$$, #,$,  ,, ,, , 1,4 -&  $, ,

&11&' 4 %$, - $$#,, $ $,+  %1$ 4,$ ,4

,4 & , $, .4 .$$   11&,$ .,,4 &,,$#-,

$$,&,

50!$- 1,4,1,$,%4,$$,%4

,4  /,,4 $$#,,  - #,44 4, ,4 /4,-' ,

%1$  %$,  ,,,& 1&, -,$, 4 %11,.$$

,,,,,$$,$,&$%&.$



-%4$,$$,;$,',#44,.#! !!*,$$308$

"#$% & "#$% ")& ,, !'  &  ")&)& ,,4, &$

&4$$#,,'&$$,-1,$,%$,

$,4, 5  $- ,$ .,%4 # $$,4  &4 4 1-& $$$,

#-4,#4,4'$,&$$,$4,,%$4--&$$,%,'

,%1$4,&$,,5(,$.,%4$$,41&,$$,

,,#4,4,4,1,,1,$4+',-$$$,$',$$,$;$$&1-4,4'

.,+ $,& #- ,,$44' ,  ,,4 $$,4  &4 4 14%4 $$,,

#4,4

- &$$$,,-&  4%$ ,$-4' , &&, .$,-

$$#,, .$ $,+  #- #,, .$, 1& 6

-

&$$$,,-&!!8 !!2%11,3)))23)!3'!2! !!2

%11,  3)))*8)!2'  !!  !!0  %11,  3))) )!0:  ,, 

%$'5*(C*-1,4,$6,.1,-1,%$,

%#&,,,%,:&,.,&,,,%+;,',$$,,-$-1,

, .#$ 6 5  $- :  %#&$' , $$#4,4 4 ,,%4

*6:

$$#,,.$,4-,$$,$$$,+%1$,$-4'&$$,,&,

.#%$,%#&,,,%,,

#&$,,-',-1,,

 $, &, ;,' %4 &&,  1&, ,$$, $,,%$ , $, %#&$

$,44 ;, $$#,, .$, %, ;& $& ,, .$, 1&

4&

%    %1$,$ &,,$,$' , .,+ ,$-& %1$' 

%11,-,$,44,$$,&,.4&,,$$,6%

5* $- 

5!:'&$$,,%$

5) 3$- ,,-$,+$1,$,%

   .,$, -,  1&,   ,, $$#,, $,4  

1&,$-4%1$'&&1&,,,$$,,#,,&'&

%#4$$.#$,,%$,,&,-



-,$, 4 %11,.$$ ,%% , ,$  -,$, ,,

,4,45)4,8'!'0(2 #,,&581,+',.<<4,$$,+

&$#',#4,,4,&$$%1$#,,%%<<4,5

! 1,+' , $%1$,$ ,,$ $,+ # #4,, .,&.$, 11, $1,4$   5 0(

1,+',&$,$1,,4,.,+$,&,,%$%,&,$$,,1

5 2  1,+' ,  ,-$,,& &$  , ,' & $ ,,$  ' .,+ 

%,&' , + #%$,,$ - %11,.$$ ,4  %4,  5)$, 8 .4+'

$4+.$$&,41,$,%%&,,$4

%1$, &,,$, !8! !! , ,$' &$$,-  4 ' 

%&,$5)$,0(52!'&1,+',,-$,,&&$-$,,,4,

&$ .,+ <<+, #4 '  ,,#-&1-4 , 1 ,' 4& ,,4

.,&$$1,,%<<+,#4$,



,$,%4$,$$,',")&,,!' &%")&)&,,4,&

 ,-$,,& &$-$, ,,4, &  ;4& %$.$$ 

$$#,, .$$ 1%$   &$, 4%, ,,4, .$ ,-,&

,,4,-  $$4 &$    ,-$,,& - &$, ;4&

%$.$$$$#,,1%$&.$"$1,,4,

.-4$$&1 6 ,,4:'1+,$$,$$$,%$%$ !!&',,,

+ ,%, ,, 4&, , !! & -,$ %$ ,,$  ,,$$, 

;$,,$'&4%4,;$,4'$1,, -,4#4

"&,")&)&,,4,&$,&.$ -,%1,$%

 &$ .<<  %$,  ")& ,,$,  $1 ,$, .,& 1, ,,-$

%,4, $' , ,-,&   &$-$, ,,4, ,-$,,& &-'  

-%,#-,$14$',&$,+5)2!1,

 -,%1,$,&$,$$,',&$,+.,&1,,,-,$'&,

$4' ,   %, 1,$,%$ $ -,$, ,, ,  5)  2  1,

&



$'4., -,4#4&$,$1,,4,6&,,

.$,$%#%%<<4:#,44%$$,4 -,&-

%+441-14&,4', -,4#4

$.,&$,,.$,$ ;$,,$#"&,,&$,

%

%%<<4



$#,,

,,&$,

4



"&,

.441$-,4,1+',.441$-,4,$-,#4$4,,,$-,,

,& %$ .$  $$#,,   ;4& %$.$$ ,$

#4  "&, .441$-,4, $-  &##4,4 .,& ,,,% '! &

-,$' ,$ ,4 %$,  #4,, , '( & -,$   &##4,4

%.$,,,.441$,$-,,$$40'&,,-&#,$,

6:

,, ,$-  '00 & $   -, .$ 4 #4  "&,

%.$,,,.441$,$--.,&,,,%&##,3'(&-,$

 $-,&$, &,,, ;$, ,, ,$-,  ,,- $  -, .$ 4 #4

.44&, $-, + $44 $,$ %%<<4, .,4%&,

,$#4"&,$,,$',-,,$,'#4,,,,$

 .441$-,4, $-, H 0 & -,$   %,  ;4&

%$.$$$$#,,444&,,-"&,.441$-,4,

,.,4%&,-;&+,$;4&,,$$,,1-

 14&, ;$,4' &$$, ,$ -  # ,,  &$, #4& & ,,

.$,$    , ., % -, -$ %$44 %&' , ,&

#4 1$,4 , $, ;4& ,,&$, 4 #-,  4 B& 

;',,-,$,4;4&$&##&,1$-,4,/,,&,-'4',

-;4&$$,1$-'"&,.441$-,4,,&,$,

,,4,,&$,4,-,$$;4&$1$41$-,4,$,$%,,

$,B&;,;$,$4%11,$,$4$#,,,,&$

1%$ 4%4 1$,4  ;4&$ ,4   "&, , 4,

;4& %$, 1- ,4 /4,$  3  (    1 ,- ,4, 1$-,4,

$,&$%;$,$$.,&;$,#%$%,,$$,$&-

1% ,  ;4&$ $,%, 1$-,4,  $$#,, $,4 #4 

"&, %,$  , , $ $' ,  ;4& %$, 1- 4$,4

"&,.441$,4&,4#4&4 -,%14,',,&

.,$,.#-,$&#4$-4',;,,#,4&,4%1,

,+#-,$, %+ $' ,   "&, .,&.$, , , &  $4

#4 .,4 4,$4, $$4 ,,-  #,1$,' , .#-, &  &

'"&,.#,1-,$,&114



-, %1,$' & .$,   &$$,-- ;&+, $;4' % ,& ")&)

&,,4,&$,.<<,%$,58*,$.,+,,.<<,,-

4& #4,, .1%<<4 %% 11, $1,4$,  %, $' 

#4$1,,+&$,,,&1--,%.<<,',,&$,,&,,,

5)!1,4#,#,,.,&.$,11,$1,4$,$$,,,,4,$,%$

5)8*1,-,,#,$,%,, -,.$$$,%

%4,  5 ! &,$,   #,44' , - &$, $1,,4, $

$44  $,$ %%<<4,'  ,&  %4, .  5)$,  3' &$$,

,$ #4, $$ ,  .,&.$,  .$$ 4 ,,$4,

,$ ;;4, - %.<<4,$ %%<<4, &,' $,+

',4,,$4,$,$%#&$,$,.$$4,,%#-$

-4&,$,+', -4,! !!*")&)&

,,4, &$, $1,,4, #4  "&, ,-&1--  *    $44,

%%<<4,'53



-, .$  +  $$$, ,-,,&, ,,$ $&, ,, ,,$ 6 ,,-

$4&,  %.$, ;$,-  + %%<<4,: %+ $$,' ,

-  %.<<4, ,-,&,$  < % $#-  $4&,    %

%%<<4,  ,$&$  % $#&,$,   %,  ,$$, #4$

+,$$,', -,%,44&,1$#,,

1%$,-,&G$,&-'&.$$$,,$,%")

&,,8!4,-$$'%4.-,&$,+%$,.<<,#%

1+ ;4& %$, 1- ,4 /4,$ 6  0'2:' , 1% &$

+$$,$&11$,,11,&,%$,,$41%,'4

86:

-,- -4&#4,&$,$1,,4,3!)30

&A'+,.,4%&',"&,$,,.44&H0!&A

%,%#+,$$,$'1%&$$.4' -,$,,,

, $,' ,  , %1,44  &$, $1,,4, ;$$$4,$  %# ,- ,

.,4>.,+-4,#4&<<%&,$%,,4&&<<%,'

%1$& %#&$ $$$ $ %# $$#,, ,& & .$,

-,%11,.$$,4', -&$,$1,,4,,%$$$,

,4',,$,,,4,4"$$.$,;$4,,,,4'&$$,,,+5

0( 1, &,  "$$ ,$  .,&, ,,,4, ,$$,' , -,

4#4$4%%<<4,%,+,4,,,4,,4

 5) 0( 1,4#4,- %,4&,1,$$,-', -+

,, &$, #4& $4 %%<<4,'   -   5)0(

1,4#,',&$,$1,,4,.,+%,&,$$,,1+#-,,

%$   &,.,& &$ ,  -,$,  %, %11,.$$

44%11,,$4,.4$,#;;%



$#,, ,,&$, 4  #4  "&, .441$-,4, 1%$

$4#4.44&,1-%,,$,&,,%$,.$,$,#+

&,,$,1-%$44,-',.,$,$$& -

#,14,4,,&,4,$4&,%,,$-,&%$,$-4

$$$,,-,,&, -,,&-$4,%1,$$&

,, #4 ,4, %,%1$ &$  -, %1,$  .44  ,, $

%$,.,+%', -,$$,$,-,%-.#-,,,

-%1$44 -,,-,%,4&,$$$,,,', -,4

#4  $ %%<<4, $44 + ,,  .44&  + ,,$'  

,-,, $$$,

,&  %%<<4, $4&, $ -4 -,

,4&%#,,'&, 4.$,4$$



$#,,,,&$,4#4"&,,&.441$-,4,

$,$ %#+ , 1,$4,' ,   #4  "&, &$ $$, #4,,4,

&$$%1$#,%%<<4,%,.,$, -,

.$$$$,,-,,&,&4#4"&,$4&,%,,$-,&

%%<<4,





,,-



&$

,,4,

&$$

%1$

#,

%%<<4, &, $ -4 ,& &, 14,4,'   , $,

 -$ - &, .4  5)  8 1,4  & 14,4

$,,%$5) 8%1$+,#-%,



#,44 ,$$, '    % ,-,$$ # 4 !!  '  %$$,4

   ;$, ,$  .#,  ,,$ $ ,& 4 #4 4

")&,,$,-&.$,'4,,,4%,-,$$&$,

.,&.<<,&.$,'&4,$%%<<4$1,,4#4

"&, -,%1,$,&',%$$1,,% 4%+#,'

&, .<< .,&$,  ,4  4   ;4&$  

14&,%1,$,,;4&$',%#.,&$,-

 ,,.$ %' $  -, 4 #4  "&, &$,

$1,,4,#,,,,,$'$$,,,-$44$,$%%<<4,4

%,$4',,$$,$,,$ ,$$,&$,$1,,'%,%1$.,&$,

;4&%$,1-,4/4,$021%$4$$,$&11$

,, 11, %%4 .4  .##4' , $, %  %14,' ,   -,$ $$, 

4$&11'4#4"&,,,$.,+.,4%&,,$

!6:

"&,$,,-,,&,,,$.441$-,4,$-,H0&-,$

"441$-,4, .  ;4& %$.$$  $$#,,   ,,&

,$ &+,  * &  ,,-  %#  %, "&,   ,,$' &$  #44

$&4 &&-  %,%1$'$,& .#, $$ &+, 3  & -,$

.,+%',&+#4&1$1,,%,#4,&)%1,&

&$$',,,11,&,%&&-%,%1$;,&4#4,

 $4  ;,-,  %1,$ #  ,-  0! &A  ,.,4 %&,

,$$#4 4.#,,,$H0!&A-,,.$

%4',$"&,,,.44&0!&A %,4,#4,

-;,,$',1%,,11,&,',4 1,4'

, $1,,%  "&,  6 &  # ,, ,  $ ;, ;, ;$,-

%%<<4, $44:  %%<<4 #4- +  .,&$,

.<<&.,+%$#4',"&,$4&,%,,$-,&

%$,6&4 %,$,,.#-,%#1:$,4,.,$,,4'

"&, -$$$$,+,-,,4$,+', ;$,4,$$,

',,&$&,&$,$-4"&,$1,,&,&$,

%%<<4',$,#$;4&$-$,+,,#1%,,

%#&+,$,', %#,&'-.#,

,,$ #4  ,-,$$ $    %,  %1$, &,,$,  -,

%11,&,,$,&,$,+#-,$14,,$4,', #4 4

&$,.<<,.,&$,& $1,,&$,,-0!&A

,&,4%1,$,#4&1-,;$4,,.444'%4.,4

,$$,#4$,$&$'+$1,,%#4,,<$1+$.>

4&$,$1,,4,.4$,&11&,$,,%$%,&%#&$,-'

, .,&$ %#+ $1,,4 $$,' ,$$,$,  .,+ ,,4 4&' 4  ,4 , ,4

   &$, $1,,4, , %,4 ,$$, ,1  & ;$,4, ,

44,,4.,&$$1,,4#4"&,$, -,$,' 

5)4,0(2!#4,4



, ,4' && $$#,, $,4  1&,   .#$ ,,

+4-1,-$,+',- -&&$$#,4'

.# $$#,, ,,$      %, $' , -

%4$$,$,&$,$1,,4,$$,$+$44%%<<4,65)

4,30(&,4:,$,,,.#$,,+4-1,-,$$,,

$,$,&'#4 4 $,#,.$,4.<<.,&$,

-, 4 #4 $, ,4 4 -  ,,.$ %' , $,

#,44 $' ,   .,&$, .<<' %4  ;4& $ %+

$$,', #,,,-$'4 -,#4.,&

,,$'   , 4  4-  $& ")& ,,$ ,- .#4 ,,,,

$$"&,$,#4,&,,.,&$.$,$',$,,,

 -$ $$#,, && 1 44 %1$, &,,$, %14,' ,

,&  ,, .,&$ .$,$ $$,    "&,  $1,,% #4 %,&

&1-'$,$%,,,$$,%1,$;4&%$,

1-4$,@4,02$,$%#+,1,$4,',"&,

$, $4 %,4  ,&  ,, .,&$ .$,$' .$, ,$$,- ,4 %,%1$

$,,&"&,$,.,4,&.,&$.$,,4'&$,

%1$#4$$,#44"&, 4-.#-4';$$$&,$

,    ,,   ;4& %$, 1- ,4 /4,$ $$#,,

$,4#4,1+',.#-4#4"&,, 4

.,& ;$- ., ,$4%    1.4' , ,&$ ,,4

6:

.4"&,.,&.$,, 4.,&.$,,

"&,$,&$,%1$#,.,4,&.,&$'%,#,1$,'

,#44$,4-&-$%$,,4,4&;$.$,&

-,,.$%'&4& -&,.4,$,



#4,.#,%$,,,,$5)4,0(2!&, 

.$',,%,4&$,$1,,4,,$$,,16,,-,&&$-$,

,,4,&-',+.,&1,,,-,$:,44,,4.,&$$1,,4$,

-,$,%1$,&,,$,&!8! !!,- 4

5)4,0('2!&,,,$$,4,5*()*$-1-4&,4,

%,.#,4&$1,4%&$$,,$,$, 

.$$$#,,&,-1,$,%$,&,4.4,

$-1,$,%&,$,',%$,,&,-.#$

,,$4 '&, -,.$,4$$#,,&,4

  -$ -,  .$,4 $$#,, &,4  , $, .#$

,, +4 -1,-  %$,  ,&,-'  -, %

$$,4,5)*()*$-1-%1$4,,#$,+,%%

53 .3

$,$  1,$$ ;4  &,,$ -, %11, $$,4, 5 *()* $- 

1-$#.,4

5 8$-.$,$%11,,.4&,#



#



 "!     



5 3,$%11,&,,$,$#.,&,$5 8$#,.)30)21,4

$,$;%,&,,$$,$,$,,&$,$%$4$,&4&#$

,-&11,$,$-)%#$,,$%,%,4,

1,$,%  &,,$$,,4$,;%4,&$,%$4$,

&4   (2!  - ,4 &,,$, %4,4%

$#%,,$$,.$,4$$,(2!

&&,  #,4%4 J 4%4+; $ #% *!2 !! %,  22'

  !!*%, !'3!3 !!%,336$)423'33)3(:

-4%$4,$,6

-&$$$,,-&!*!( !!3

3)))3*)!3' 8!0 !!33)))*0)!3' !( !!2

3))) 0)!2'!2!3 !!3))) )!:',&%11,&,,$,

 5) 3 &1-4 $, $,&$$ $, &4  , &#$, ;$,'

$,+ $ $,44 ;& ,$$,  &&, %$,  .#,4,

,,, %11,  %,4, ,$$,  ,, ,,, - %#4

%,,-,&-&114%#&#,4,=-+$4'

& ;$,%4 $$,$ %&&' ,  $-,4 &#$, ,- ,4 &,,$$,$,

$,1,$$;%4

1,$,%  ;$,+   &114 % ,&  $& 4 & 

,-,& ,$,$ ,, -' &$$,  &4  -' ;$, $4

&&,44,4$$,.,$,+&,,$$,.$

& &,,$,  ,$$,- ,, ,4 $  %$ %,4,  &'

,,%4$4%'$,+.#,4,!!!

'&$,+&,,$$,$,$,-.$;%4



1,$,%&,,$$$-,$&114$$,.,$ *!!

6$2!:%1$,&,,$,,;+&,,$, -,

%11,$#.,+'$,+,.,$1-4