Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-07-13256\22 AI generated

1-07-13256\22 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 1-07-13256\22
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

62'

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-07-13256\22 · Viru Ringkonnakohus: 62'

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text









 !" !#$





%&'"""(&")*+#,)--.$/





&'"""(&")*+#,



0%%12



--$$/'"##".!3/4"/ !,). 3-5-,"-,"'".-,

# -.$!



*"-6.



775$/"/","

.-

.89

$775/$/"3$-$

"$/$$-"5$/ 0-5"$85"2:'6



"" !#/!#/."*6,- !#/3"'"&!,-3;&"

!#/!/$$



775$/"/",.-.8





 !"8! "/

!#/."*6,-

!$" !"

 !"8! <"="..-8-"



.-.80$7"-&$-8/-3;-1%&"2

$  !!5



%1)-$/";" !5" )/<</)-. !#/

>>>>>>>>>???)*&3"". !"$

"$/"/57#-. !".)"."/-$&'$/&",;;

85"3$ !#"$

 !"#$%

&'()*+,-',../'

(0&&120-3,

2'

&'&'

'

,'(4'

5"$ "-;"3$- !5















&3',..5''

')

6

62'

'

*@'"



0%2

&'"" !#/!#/."*6,- !#/3"'"&!,-3;&" !#/!/$$-"0. &) &2

/$/"/.-.8$775":'6'" "$/$- $3+$/-/(0 "#- $"2""$/"/

,"$/$/&

&'&'":.".$-.$-5"/"$ -3" "$/$-$-5"3$-/--..-.8.-

3+$/-/5 "$/$/"'"" !#/,"."" !#/3"'"&!,-3;&" !#/!/$$-"

3+$/-/5 "$/$- "53"/"!$")$&!0$-/$3-2 .$-,"$/$-,+"'"./ "$/$- $

3+$/-/(0 "#- $"2""$/"/'"0$-/$-2 5,"$/$/&

&'&'&'":(.".$-.",-$/"/ "$/$-/6#/"'"#. "--.,"$/$-$,;3$-"-)$&!

&'$/ &!,-3;) ! 0,$2 507 $286-,","$/$/'" "$/$-

"53$-/6#/"-"",-$/"/.-.89,"#$/"3$-$/)$&!"."/-$&'$/&"&

,'.-.8!"/5 !#/".."":'6$-..-$)-/&'.&""$/". -.."&

8" ".%#/3-"$3$!#/."*6,-..+/"86"$/7#$/". !#!./",/"3$/,#"$/'"

"3 "5-5$-$///"7#- !" <<!""$75"3-8 !5"!3"//!!.$$/,"/

///","/*&/),3"$-/-.-A! +-86"$/!3-.$-3-#-"&-..-"8+#'$/"$.-

.8*&.-7#-"++5-/,"/! -.+ -#"",","$" .8!!.5 --.$75"3-

,"$/$-"'"'6-,"$75"3-/"38!""5")3..-/""'6'-.*&&$$753$ !#".&



1'"" !#$)#"5 !/5/+-5-5-5- !3$).-5$)-/&'.&""$/".

"'"8-!!5. -.."& & !/-$""5-$$"".%!#/."*6,-).+$775$/"/",

.-.8$+".$-/7. 6$!3"-5$/-. ""$."$/*&./7#- !"!""5&*&&$

$""55 -#","$/$-/""'6'-.&

1'&'775$/"/",.-.8$-./"$3"" !#/$)-/*&//"-"3"$/"5'"/-3"" !!$-

-."5&"..--3--.55)-/*&&-#!!./$-5!3"."8$---$/)/",/"$". !#!.)-

/<</"5)#-.$/"$ +,".$/-.-3--$/-.-'" !#/$-5-"&

-"5-$)-/*&!. ".5,$". !#!./",/"5")/+/"..-85-.,"&",/"$ !!$*&"

". !#!.&775$/"/",.-.8,+$*&& !/-$/6"3"'"/-3""3//- !#/5")

3-5 !#$/$-./--/-$---$-!.5&.-.8.-!.5+$/+5"*&./)-//"

-." $/-$/$$/-.&B5$"$-,"'"5$/-3"$#/-$,6,".5" "$/"5"&*&&,;$

/"83$-3!3-5."$ -$". !#!!.$-'!!;-$-$5$&"$-8!!./-!.5.-.8$#/-$

3/"-$$!!&B+#'$/)3 $/"*&.-!"#"","/- /"$)$-./"5"-!$"5&"..#/$"./

$" +"$-"3!!5-."3$-$/&77-$!""$75"3-8 !5")-$""5/"3//-

3+$/")-/$--,+;8+#'$/"5"*&&$3"&

1','B-".- /-!/!3-8"-3$/ --"$/"8"$/"!" 6/-6/ $$$-)8" !//'",$ "$

87 !/--$$-&+/.-$,6.'",-$!!)3$!.- $85"5/"..-/""3"".;&..-$$--'6-.

/$$,6.'"8!./$-) ";'"8775$!$/"5"$3","./#"","/5*&.-

";&

$".$-./-"$/$775-/$/"5&B775$3$/$-"5$$-"'"5"'"'#/5" "#/.$-

/!3-8"55/"83$-$-5"./ +,".-&

+ --5/-!566,"5$-..-$/)-//"8"/-!/!3-/-"5. ./)$""5-$")35"/"!./-5

'"8775-$,"$//$-$/ +,".-#.5"&--"!/+-5"/5.-.8$77":'6

-//-6#/5 /-!/!3-8"-3$-$&.-.88"$77/-!/!3-!/$-$-/"#/.$-"&

7'"$/$-3+$/3$-.36 $3"" !#$)-/.-.8$775 --5"," $"$'"!. $.-$

3"" !#$8#/$75"3.  "#-/$$-&





0%2

3'"" !#/!#/."*6,- !#/3"'"&!,-3;&" !#/!/$$-8-".-

"8-.."/$!!-$/"5$775$/"/",.-.80. &%%) &28".;3+$/"/"..-.--;-3

"$/$&

3'&'8-.."/.-";)-/3+$/-/5,"." "$/$ "#- $"""$/"/'"$-/$- 5!"- "$/$&

8-.."/,/";"$'"!..-)-/3"" !#$-",-$/"5/6-.366"./-3"8#/$75"3. 

"#-/$$/'"/-3" !!$/<<53--/.-'""--.3$- 6$&

3','8-.."/.-";)-/8+#.-8!;.--3*&&/"83$-.!.*&&-;"+."- 6/3-&*&&-

/"#/5/<</"5")/",/"$/#/". !#!.)'+3"#"/-3"+- /!"$""5-/5"#"&

8-.."//"!/.-;3"" !#/!/$$-/7#$/"3$/ "$/$-3+$/3$-!$"$.--;-3" "$/$-

3+$/3$/&



-'B6"$/--.$/" -5"3$/$-./"$ !#/ -//- "5'"--.$/ !".5"3$-".$/)3$

$-$-$$-..-$)-/3"" !#/0. &8<<5-.) &2!/$$-8+#'-5","$!$"$85;$775$/"/","

.-.8$77$$-$/.6#/, "$/$-. '"366"$$".5",8+#'-5$&

6/- $)3"" !#/!/$$-8+#'-5","$!$"$ "$/$-3+$/3$-.! '/"/57 $."$-C

D-3"$775 --5"," $"$'"!. $.!-; !#$8#/$75"3.  "#-/$$-D&

-'&'-.$/ 6$/..6#-5"5" " $ 7$3$/C

-'&'&' "$

3"" !#/

!/$$-$

"$/$-

3+$/3$-

8+#'-5$-

853-

!

3"".3--/.$-!..- 3-)3..$-.'#./.-;3"" !#/!/$$/7#$/"5" "$/$-

3+$/3$-!$"$$""/" 3""."$- $"/"3$- $3"" !#/.-),+

-'&','--.3-/"/5"$'"!.-!.- 3"".3--/.$+$-!..- 3-'"'6-. ./

3""."$$775$/"/",".-.8"8-.."/$!!".$-./.-;366"/""/"3$-.-

.6;,""/"3$- $"8-.."/$!! !"$&

/' !"8! <"="..-8-"",".5"$","3$/)-/3"" !#/!/$$/.-;/7#$/"5"

"$/$-3+$/3$-!$"$!/$$-$8+#'-5$-853$-/+//'"$--'6-./.-; 3""."$

$""/"- $"/"3$- $3"" !#/.-&





5' !" !#$)!..-$//,5 3""."$'"3"/-'".5-").-5$)-/"::$/

.6#/5-$8-"; !#$86"$/ /-!/!3-8"-3$-/,"$/"3$/$77$$-$/.6#/,"./"53"

"$/$-. '"366"$$".5","8+#'-5"/5 "$/$+$. #"/!3-8"55

/-!.-0/ !#/ 3"". !..--3."#-5&11))()2&

"$/$-3+$/3$-!$"$0. &8<<5-.) &28+#'-5"$3"" !#$!3"$-$ !#/'63$-./C

D-3"$775 --5"," $"$'"!. $.!-; !#$8#/$75"3.  "#-/$$-D&

"" !#/!/$$-$85;$775$/"/",".-.89$77$$-$/.6#/, "$/$-. '"

366"$$".5",8+#'-5$&"" !#$'6//$ "$/$-3+$/3$-.,"./5 "$/$366"

8+#'-5"3"/"& !" !#$36;)-/ "$/$-3+$/3$/85/","58+#'-5$-5!

!#/!/$$-!..-!$"&!#/!/$$-$ "$/$-8+#$/"3"/"'6/3$-.!/--3$/

3"".3--/.$+$-!..$- 3$-":1.83+//-$&

:(.8 !#"$-./8-"; !" !#$$-..$- 3$-/,"$/"3$-."."/

/7#$/"3"3"" !#/!/$$-'"$""/3" 3""."$'"3"" !#/.-- $"/"3$- $&:

1. 3$- +,".5"3-"8-.."/$!!3--/.$-$-!.-.;"/5&

8' !" !#$.-";)-/3"" !#$",-$/"$ "$/$-3+$/3$-."./ "$/$/

--5","/"$'"!.)$&!8#/$75"3.  "#-/$$/&



0%2

%

":.+ -/-$-$/."$-$/""$-.;)-/ "$/$-3+$/3$-./.-;8-".-".$-",-$/"5"

"/-$"$'"!.$5)$# ",+3".$/3+'/"5"$775."$/-5"$85#!53"$77/-!

/!3-8"-3$-$/'"+$ !" "/$3$-#,$5&--"/.-; !#/. "$/$-3+$/3$-.

$.3"$85"5" " "$/$- !#".5"3$---$36 -&"$-3+'/"3-/!3;.6;

$ $$-)/-3"#!" /-3/3$- "5&

/$$-8+#'-5","$!$"$85;7.5$-$775$/"/",".-.89$ $$-"".77$&$""

'6-.5"5") "$/"! "$/"/5,66/-5-/!3-8"-3$-$) "$/".!.$$$-/.- ) "$/"!.

3"". !"$ "$/"/5&./!/$$--$!./,!$"$/6#/;)-/$ /-0*&&/"83-2

!/!3-8"55 "/$-"'" -$/-.&'665"$""3"/ $) 5"$$"-$3-$-"$/3- !#$

3+$/"./ "$/$- !#/!/$$/- !3")  3""."$'"$85;--.3$-!/$$-6" &

 !" !#$+#/";)-/./ "$/$-3+$/3$-.0 "$#.'-3/,"$/"/5 !3",+

!#/!/$$/- !3"28-" $ 3""."$'"'5-!.-3".$"/5--.3$/-!/$$/-6" '"5)

3..-".$-.3!!5$/"/" $-./ "$/$&

3"".3--/.$+$-!..$- 3$-/,"$/"3$-"--.3--/.$- 6$$775$/"/","

.-.89"8-.."/$!!$$.$-./-"/"/5& !" !#$.-";)-/--./!!5585$

+,".5"3"/"-!.-,+3". /-#"!;'- /,$-/'6-.5$/.-.8.- "$/$-3+$/3$-

!$"$&

!!$ +."$--./!!5"'"'#55-$::5-$/(.8)1.8)(.)(%.

)(.)/7#$/"; !" !#$"" !#/!#/."*6,- !#/3"'"&!,-3;

&"!/$$-.-.8.-":'63+$/-/5 "$/$-'"":.'6

3+$/-/5./ "$/$-!$"$'"$""5"; 3""."$'"- $"/"3$- $$"3".-3"" !#/.-&

##".!3/E"/ !,

-,"-,"

.-,# -.$!

!#/ 

!#/ 

!#/ 