Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-07-10423\10 AI generated

1-07-10423\10 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 1-07-10423\10
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

.(# '' .4".!'! !-. #'--'- .(#'-* '. .! .40!)  . --,0'0 2! .!--' 5!00

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-07-10423\10 · Viru Ringkonnakohus: .(# '' .4".!'! !-. #'--'- .(#'-* '. .! .40!)  . --,0'0 2! .!--' 5!00

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text







   

 

 







 ! "#

 







 

$% &'()'%!*+,"&

 









 



""!- (./!. &*'&!'&!*-!0( 1!-!

 







$% &'()'%!*2!-(''.-#

   



 !! ". !&''  ".(!2! 3% . ) %!

 ".(44#!#.#'.4.(#'-'566!(#' ".!

 





 

770(,#.'. 8(!!-" -0#!-'9  -0'(! 0#

8#7!' 3% . )' 3$%!9  # 0 $3:3*

'#.

!)!

 0!*

'#"!0#*

'- ".

;;;;;;;; <<* ;;;;;;;* .66.!# (..'!('.--.

 #!-'".#'-*4'# -'&!-!2!-&))50!(# "!#*

(!!- !#!#.!.0

 !"#

$%&   

 

'(%  '))*% 

 



 



 !

  



 

 

 %

0!#!')!(#' 0





 

 +,  











%



+



=2! 

  



$%!! ".!&'' ".(!2!3% . )%!(44#'!566!..4.(#'-' -0'(!

0#'-'44'!! ".% &'():%! .##'! !#.##'!0#.8'0!#50 !9

>33-50'*2!*?24(,#.'.04!!0(!.!!#.#87#9!!#.!87(('9

08!#7(('0954'&!&!#.#.8-%9%



'%44'!! ".% &'():%! .##'!.#.!. -0'(!0##770 !

>33-50'*2!*?24!#.#'#(,#.'.8 -(9!!#.!.387"'#!90

&!#.#.% !>$?-!-#'-- '.!#.#!2!"-!''-&!#.#'#&).0!'*?%(!#.

%2*#% :8!#7(('0&#954'&!&!#.#.@% . )#.

%#'5.'():%!*#% 87(('90:8!#7(('0&#954'&!&!#.#.* 

87#.'#.908!#7(('0954'&!&!#.#.% !#.#.24!0!8!#9!!#.!.3

87"'#!9087(('954'&!&!#.#.8-%3?9%

'%$% !>$:-!-#'-#'0!.('.!.0!#.#.44'!! ".:%#'5.'()

:%! ". .##'!8-%$?9(,#.'.0!#.#'87#9!!#.!8!#90&!#.#.&,!

-.!#.#'#(,#.'.8 -(9!!#.!.87#.'#.9087(('954'&!&!#.#.%

!#.#'!0(#'!2!!-#'#- '.:%#'5.'()':%!%

'%'% !2!! ".8-%9(44#'!%#'5.'()#.%!&!)!#.!. -0'(!0# !>

$ !-#'- &!#.#'#. .(# ''.4".!'#'-.% !.#'!2! 5#'# (44!. 4!!0(!.!

!#.#!2!-!.#.''-&!)!#.!(#'#'#!*0(..'&4"'(87#9!!#.!8!#.#'





 



8:9



!2!-,55:%!#.3%!9% !.#'!2!'#.'-  -0'(!0# "#.!.024(! !>:

-#4.'#.!.024(# . --,0'0A

'%'%$%'-!(! ".(44!.0!-!-#'#'- "!#;;;;;;;*;;;;;;;;<<@

'%'%'%-((!(!!-" -0!2!5 -.(44!.0!2!&!"'('24'-(!!-" -0# #! 0!

'#.''(#'-'@

'%'%-%!--(! (!!-" -0!2!  . ---' (! '- "!#  '#.!(! .!--' !0('0 (!

 "#.#.'.4.(#'2!'-!.#&!"'0.' ".!@

'%'%.%#!!(! (!!-" -0#!('.-. ''-'&! - ! '- "!#. -!"(#'# !'(!# 

&'.'#.7('#54'&!#@

'%'%/%#!!(!

(!!-" -0#!('.-.

''-'&!

- !

'-*

.66

&,

,55(# "!

&!"'.!(#'#%

'%-% !>:-!-#'-(44!. -0'(!0#'-'!--24'&!0 "#.#'0A

'%-%$%!#0!.66-'8!"'940!-!2 #-5'!-'&!)!'(#.@

'%-%'%(..'.!&.!0!!- " -2!! .('%

'%.% -0'(! 0# (44!. !.#'!2!#  !! ". (!!-" -0# #! ! 2"!.!2!

5 -. (44!.!&! (!!-" -0#!('. 24'-'&!-&' !--!% 770(,#.'.  -0'(! 0#

&!)!#.!. !--! !-!#. :%#'5.'()- %!!#.!- .'(! !#.#' 4!!0(!.! #!

#'#! :%#'5.'() %!   87#9 !!#.!  87(('9 0  8!#7(('09 54'&!

8-%39



-%% . )- %!!#.!-  #!!)# (!! ".-'  !! ". (!!-" -## #! !

!&''.!-.#'(!!-" -0#!('. #.!B"6)''! !-''..'!'8-%9

(!!-" -0#!-#'-'  -0'(! 0#'-' (,#.'.0 2! 4!!0(!.! !#.#' .4.(#'-'

566!(#'#*#'#.(!!-" -0#!-' -0'(!0##.!--' ".(44#'! !>

:-!-#'-(44!.0 . --,0'08''-!0-!#(44!.0 "!#*''#.!0 ('.'

 "#.#.'.4.(#' ".!92! !>:-!-#'-5!00 "#.#8'!-- "#.#'-'(..'

.!&.!0!!- " -2!! .('*' .#(44!.0!2!#.66 ".!9%

-%$%#.!.0 '! !-#'#. '..'!0'#. 4".)* '. (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# '

'-!0 ".5 -.(44!.0'- "!#;;;;;;;*;;;;;;;;<<*&!0'-!#;;;;;

;;;;;;;; <<<<% !!.!(!.! ?%#'5.'()- %!!#.!- '#(! ".(#'- -)!.-' '

!#0 (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# 7()'  ". 5 -. (44!.0 '- ".!

;;;;;;;*;;;;;;;;<<%

% . )- %!!#.!- #!!)# (!!-" -0#.!-.##'  -0'(! 0#' '0#'-.

!)!!#!-. C * '. (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# '-!) ! ;;;;;;;*

;;;;;;;;<<<<*''-00'##'!-.-!"(!#.%

-%'% (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# ' !--0  ". 5 -. (44!.0  "#.#'-'

(..'.!&.!0!!.#'!2!-!- " -%

(!!-" -0#!-#'- -0'(!0#'-.&!#.!.0!D -.#'5'C'.5 -.% . )-

%!!#.!-!- " -2 &'*(--' ".! $% . )-%!!#.!-(!!-" -0#.!-.#'#

'#.''.05 .  --%

-%-% (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# ' -' !#0 .66-'* (0! .!  ".(44#'

 "!#'-.  8!"'9 40!-! 2 #- 5'!-' &!)!'(#. .''(! 50% #.!.0 '! !-#'#.

'..'!0'#. 4".)* '. .'#'-'  ".(#'-' :% . )- %!!#.!- (!!-" -0#!-'

 -0'(!0#'-(0*! -&!"#.!.0!".-#.!.!'.' . ('5!'(#'#%



.% (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# #'-.!#  ".#.-* '. .! '-!) ;;;;;;;*

;;;;;;;; <<  7#'# :%#'5.'()- %! 2! $%#'5.'()- %!!#.!-  

% . )- %!!#.!- - .! ;;;;;% (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# &4.#* '. .!

.66.!#

(..'!('.--.

 #!-

'".#'-

'..'&,.2!

E

0!0

+! )# 

2'#%

(!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0# !&!-0!#* '. ! .!- ' -' 7".' #. .,'0!&!.





 



8:9



0 ('.* ## ' #!!0 .! '!#. !('.--. .66-' & (#.!0!% (!!-" -0#!-'

 -0'(!0#.#.!#*'.% . )-%!!#.!-*.!--'5 -.#'24'-'.-* -.!''-'&!-.

4!2 08*-90F%

.%$%D 6-'0#*'.(!!-" -0!2!'! !-''..'!' 5,"2'0!.0 -0'(!

0#'-' ". .##'24(,#.'.0!#.#'4!!0(!.! #!87#9!!#.!87(('90

8!#7(('0954'&!&!#.#..-')566!.!.4.(#'-'%

.%'% !.#2!5!-#24..!(!!-" -0#!('.'..'5!'!"-0!(!.!8-%39%



/%!! "#-'0#*'.'#.!.0.! .-#.(#(,#.'.0!#.#'.4.(#'-'566!(#'# 

5,"2'0!.02!-)!"-0!(#'-'%

/%$%!! "#(4#(44#'5,"2'0!&!# #!#8-%9*'. -0'(!0#&!)!#.!.&!-!#.

.(# '' .4".!'! !-. #'--'- .(#'-* '. .! .40!)  . --,0'0 2! .!--' 5!00

 "#.#% !! ". !&!.'# ' -' .,'0!.0 #''* '. (!!-" -0#!-'  -0'(! 0#

-'# (!'- "!#.;;;;;;;*;;;;;;;;<<-!"0;;;;;-''-!(!!'(!#

&'.'#.7('#54'&!#*#'#.#' .!6'-0#'0!*'.4#;;;;;-7#'# -('-54'&!-2!

#'0! -!#.' 54!#.  (!!-" -0#!('.-' -!'# C   -0'(! 0#' '0#'-.

!)!!#!-.% . )- %!!#.!-* '. -0'(!0#'-!) ! ;;;;;;;* ;;;;;;;;

<<<<*''-00'##'!-.-!"(!#.%

/%'% (!!-" -0#!-' -0'(!0# 6'-0*'.!('.--.'#!!0.!'!#..66-'

& (#.!0!'! (!.66-'!#(#.(!!-" -0#!('.-'0 ('.!!-#'-..,'0!0!*#'#.

.!-' -07".'#..,'0!&!.0 ('.%''&40'' -'(..'(--'!7()'-7!.0%

(!!-" -0#!-' -0'(!0# &!"!--!".-#.!.!'.' . ('5!'(#'#*

(#.,.. ".(#'-':% . )-%!'#!!0.!'#.!0!(!!-" -0#!('.5 -.

,.0 0 ('.' (! .66-' !#(#'  ".! '! ! .'!&.!0! (!!-" -0#!('.

#-#'-. (!C!.-#'#..66-'!#(#'#.%

/%-% (!!-" -0#!-#'  -0'(! 0#' '0! 7.-#'!* 0! D -.#'5'C'. !&''

5 -.#' #! !5 .  --!!- " -2 )'.&!#.!(#' ".!0!!. &!"'0&,(,,.'#.!

!#.!(#'-% . )-%!*4".)*'. -0'(!0#'-.&!#.!.!- " -2 &'8*?$(G-9

 2 )'#'#0# # !''(#'-' . ('.!(#' 5 .  --! % . )#. %! 

.4'--..,'0!(#.-'00#''*'.(!!-" -0#!-' -0'(!0##% . )-

%!.'(!-' !2!! ".%#'5.'()%!(44#'! !>:-!-#'-(44!.0

 "#.#.(..'.!&.!0!!- " -2!! .('%!! ".!&!.'#' (!(..4".##.#''*

'..''(#. 7"' 0#'(#'!%



 









0%

!! ".

!&''

 ".(!2!

3% . )

%!

(44#'

5'!-'

'#.!#

(!!-" -0#!-#' -0'(!0#'!.#2!&!0'!0& !!..!#(!!(44#!')#'*

(--'#5!-)(!! ".(44#.7"#.!0!8$?9%

0%$%44#!')#' "!#'-.',#.!.#2!(!! ".#'# ".!0'!2!-'!)*'.(!! "#

!####-#'-.#'# "!-'*'. !>$-: !)# -.'#!.# !&4#'(

 . --,'.' (' 8. !#&,  54'&! &,! '#.''(#'- "-'(' &, .66-'

!#(#' "#.#'.4.('54'&!#'"-'(#'!9. )''#'!!!#!&4-.(!.-.&!2!0#'

4!!0(!.!!#.#.4.(#'-'566!.!%'--'#..-''&!-.'50!0 "#7-0#'&!2!-#

!!-0!(#'#'- (8!- " -2 &' -&4'92!7"' 0##.%

0%'%44#!')#'5,"2'0!&!# #!#(4#!.#2!*'.#'!0#*(#'".'#.!)#!.# 0*

(0!.4.'&&,(5'!),#'2!#".'#!'0!(!*5'!)&,(!-0!(!.4.'&&,(-&,..!

!&'##' ,#'(#' !#2! -#0A &!#.!#'- 2"-  #'!0# ')!5 5 .# !!-'%

4.'&&,(- 5'!) -'(! &,(!-# !&'#.!0! (.('##'0 !#2! -#0* '. &,(

.' #.!('#&!)!0##C44#'(#'! -'#5,"2'0!.02! #,-!#,#'(#'





 



8:9



!#2! -0'!% ' #'# #'--'! &.!) !.#2!  ". -!"'0-'  $ ?%!5--#.

%!%

0%-% !.#2!-'0#*'.(,#.!5'!)#'!0#!0(!&,(!-#'#!.# ''".'#.!0'#8 !>

$-:#4.'#.!.0,' ".-'566!.!!#.#&4-.(!.-..4.(#'-'9! ".&,(-'&,..!

!&'##'(#'#'- (%

".7-'#!''. "'#.!)!D,"#'!0#'8'0!#50D9>$.-''&!-. --!5'-!-.

#''*'..!7#'# #.!.'').&!#.!.0C!.-#.!#2! -2!'0)*'.' (!(..4".##.

!#('.!.0(' -7"' 0'&,(..'*!#'!0#'!-#'- !#.#'.4.(#'-'

566!('&4-.(!.!2)!!7##'--'.,..*'.(' !#'.-'00% ! -' ".

( .&!.#  !.#2!"!-.4'#.-)!(!.%#-#'-.  "# (!( .&!.# !

2,0024'-0#'-'*'..'(!4 - .''(#.#'!0#!02!8'# '".'#.!0 !>$-:

!)# -.#' #!.# 9 2! .4.'&&,( 8(!!-" -0#!('.* '#  .'0 (!

0#'.# -#' .##' 2! '#.!0 '! !-#' '..'!0'9 4'5'0#'!* (..' !!

#'#'#&!&,(!D>##4.'#.!.0&,(0'-!"##'2!.!#!!!-#.!.#'5,"(,..'#.

.-''&!-.%

0%.%44#!')#'  "!#'-. 5'!)  ".- !-!. -'(! &-(# 2!  "#.# !!-0!* !#

!&'#.!0'# (#' #'- ( 2! (!!-" -0#' ''#(4'  4!!0(!.! !#.#'

.4.(#'-' 566!(' 8&!)!0#,#' 4!&,.('9 5 5 .# !!-' 2! (,,0!# (''0'%

!.#2!-'!)*'.(!!-" -0#!('. -.'0.! .-#'!#.#'.4.(#'-'566!(#'#

(.(' . --,0'(#' "#.#'(..'.4.(#'!-#'-% &,0 . --,'.'

&40'.!&!0(#'0'-'00 ".--(#'-.&!#.!(#.*' -'5'-!-.7"' 0#'

 "#.#' (#' .!!242'- !.#2! "!- 5 5 .# !!-' 4!!0(!.! !#.#'

.4.(#'-'566!('% "# 2440##-#'-..4'--.!&'#.!(!.!#'--'!*'. -0'(!

0#4#.66-8 "#-'##'0!#.!&!#92!!.#'!2!-,524&''-5#!&!-.!'!!0(!#

"!..'(!4.(#'-'!.-'&#%













*% ! ".'  -('-('-'  ##'# 8'0!#50  ! "#9* ..&0

(44#!')#' (!.'2!-0'!* (44#!')#' &40'.'!* -'0#* '. (44#!')# 

5,"2'0!(!.  !"-0!(#'-' ' -% !! ". (44#  #'!0#- 2! 5#!&!-.

( .&''.0.7"#.!(#'-''-%



1% ! "#,#.)(!! ".4#.-#'!*'.2"- -0'(!0#!.#'!2!-'

240  . --,0'0 2! ' .4.0 .!--' 5!00  "#.#* 566!) (!! "# !0(!.!

2440 !#.#' #! (!!-" -0#!('. '..'!0' !-#'- .4.(#'-'* #'0! '!(* '.

7-!-('.!.0,'.-'') !>$-:#4..'#.%

!! ".8-%*(44#'-'".9(44#'5,"2'0!&!# #!##'-.!.!#'5,"2!--.*(--#.'-

5,"2'0#.'- 566!. 44' !! ". % &'() :%! .##'! (,#.'.0 2!

4!!0(!.!!#.#.4.(#'-'% ! "#,#.)'0'5,"2'0#'!%



(% 4.(# . --!(44!.0 . --,0'('&,)!#.#'.4.(#'-'566!(#'

!-#'# --!7#'###*(' .!".-2!.!#.!)24'-'&!-'.' #.!(#.#770-!#'7-'

(#.',#.!(,2&5,"2#%

(%$%! !-#'#. '..'!0'#. 4".)* '.  -0'(! 0# -!"#  ". 5 -. (44!.0

'- "!#.2!!##'-!(!;;;;;;;*;;;;;;;;<<% (!!-" -0!2!' -'!00

.!--'-)!'- "!#.-!"(#'#2!'- "!&!"'.!(#'#%'--'! .!0 !>#

: -  5 *  #4.'#.!.0  . --,0'0% )! 5'!) -'(! ''-'&* (#.,.. 5'-!-.

(!!-" -0!2!.'!&.!(''- "!&!"'.!(#'#.*'!!(!!-" -0#!-#'-',#.

 . --,'.'(#'#% -0'(!0# 0#'!0#'#..-''&!-. "#.#'-!0!





 



8:9

:

0-!#(44!.0  "!#* (#.,.. 5'(!. !'! ' -0 &,(!- .'(! #".'# .' #.!0!

4.(# . --%

''5,"2#44'!! ".% &'():%! .##'!(,#.'.02!4!!0(!.!

!#.#.4.(#'-'566!(#'# #''*'. -0'(!0#'!--0 ".5 -.(44!.0

 "#.#'-'(..'.!&.!0!!.#'!2!-!- " -8-%9%

 ! "# ,#.) (!! ". 24'-0#'!* '.  -0'(! 0#'- ' -0 ('0

)2'.&#'0 .!#.#  . --,'.' .4.(#'#% !--' !. &,(!-# 24'-'&!-' .(#.'#

!#.# !0! &!)!0#'#* 5!! ' # &0 .! #'0! !#.!0!% 44#!')#'# ' -'

'#.!.0#'--#'0!!-!0!#2! -#0*(#.#0&!0-#.!.0(44#'.7"#.!(#'%



$)% !.#2!&.'0.7"#.'-' . --,'.'(#.'-'' -'!#2! "!#'0%

$)%$% -''&!-. ! > : - * -.'  2!  #4..'#.* 2"-*  #770(,#.'. ' 24

 . --,0'0*&,'.40!.!--'5!00 "#.# (!! ".- -(&,(!-#.A

$)%$%$%(44!.!#770-!#'-'.4'0!&!0 "#.# #,-!# !>!:-@

$)%$%'%5'0!0!#770-!#'-'(44!.0!.#'!'!*0(..' "'(7"'!!#.!&,!@

$)%$%-%566!.!(,#.'.0!#.#.4.(#'-'%

!>$-:'4''..'&,(!-#.!.#'!2!5'0!(#'#&,#770(,#.'.-'.4'0!&!.'

 "#.#.'5!'(#.%



$$%.!.!&!# !#2!#  -'00 .#.* '. !.#'!2! '#.'- (!!-" -0#!-' #

8 -0'(! 0#9 # .!".--. .!--' 5!00  "#.# 2! ' 240  . --,0'0%

4(#.&44)#''*'..'0!!".-#.!.!#' !>24.' . ('5!'(#'#!.#'!2!

'#.'-8-%39.'(!#".'#  "!-0!.0.,'0!&!"#.!(#.%

 (!!-" -0#!-'* '#  !--.!.0 (!!-" -0#'-'* (--' ''#(4  .!!0!

.'(!'0!#',#-'#*5!')!.#'!2!'#.'-.'!0--.. (''.' *##&.!)#''

.#'#'-.(!!-" -0#!-#'# &(!.#'-'(!!-" -0#',0'0.4.!%



4".0'#''-. 0#.2!2"00'# (!!-(''.-#'#'!0#.>>0'#.32!324.!)

 ! "#(!! ".(44#'(.(!.!(44#!')#'!"-0!(!.!%











""!- (./!. &





'&!'&! 



-!0( 1!-!

 ".









 ".





 ".