Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-07-2311\14 AI generated

1-07-2311\14 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 1-07-2311\14
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

"04/!!/ "  % 6 "D  )% ,"04/! " % 6 - <.$2% ./  !

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-07-2311\14 · Viru Ringkonnakohus: "04/!!/ "  % 6 "D  )% ,"04/! " % 6 - <.$2% ./  !

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text







 

    

 













 !

 





  





"#$"%&' (

   





)"#$"%&' (

 





 

*)+,,-



..!!/#  $ 0/1/(% $0.2 .( .( #

$203$





&.4$

 



!0.2(.2#.(!552!/!.!!/!!.2!/*.2!62



-7#7#4



 

 /(.. /0#"0"/!!

 





!0.2(.2#.(/!#2(//!0

  

!0 .2(.2#.( *.2(.2.(% !5. ,"/8.

,,"-!2,,9,+%.$ /:::::::;;;%

::::::% ::::::::::::% . /<</% 0$!

!/0/%

(44/.!#!

2($/

!//2"

88

620! ! /$!







6/

(..

!

6<.0

 



2.2(//!0*044/2!-

 !"#$

%&' (    

 %%&  )+&   (   (



 



    



 

  

    



     &



2!.80!.2



 

      



 

   *,&

 

)+& &

  

-        

  ' 



 

  

  

      &

  

     

 



  .* / 

0  

     

    1    

       - 

 



 &













*)-







&  =# 

>



%&  / (..  /0# "0 " /!!. 0'!/./ !0 .2(.2#.(

!552#044/!/!.!

7#4?* .!-!//(!/!/%

7#4

?* .!-2(!/!/"

%&%"

7)9$$!.$$./..0!/!./!!.0#0'!/./$/!/!.!?

* .!-!//(!/!/!/!#$!."!.6/.08.)""

%&)& '.2( $$620.#4./0/0/"

%&.&!! 0'!/./ !0 .2(.2#.($/ (4$#  "" !! +), *(! / / !!2

!./!.500.25 .!-"



)&!0.2(.2#.(/!552!//!.!.$$.!%./"!.6/.08$)".$$,""

6 6($$!. /!.!@.0!/!/5 !.$ $60!.#$/.2

!'( ./!.4!#8$$$."$.%$'/.22($/!/.#6'$(.4#

. !!.% /./2.! 6.!0!. ""$. .$ /$2 # !0 6' #!/2 . (!/!.2 

. /5(. # 6. !. /<06/0 0'$.06$!./. ./. 022. # 6.#6'/!.%

0$$./5!!/!./.!4.6!!520.62$!"

)&%&

.$$. 6  !0 .2(.2#.( /0. /.!. 0.!. /60!.% !" 

 7  #4

($A/!../(/."



.&!0.2(.2#.(/!552!//!.!.$$.!%.//"!.6/.08)"' /$#( .0$

.$$ ," " 6 ($$! . /!.!@.0!$'2($/""/!#

#$4%/6552!/.2/!/2""6.!0!/%/./2.!""$.$<<0!.

/.(!. #!/!.6.620!.(!/!."

.&%&

.$$.6!0.2(.2.(/0.

7#4($A/!../(/."



2&!0.2(.2#.(/!/!""#""6.!0!/" $'! 5(/0""/!($ "



3& ! /(!/!% ./ !0 .2(.2#.( $$.! $ $!. #8. !.!2! 52!

",")"!'$!./5$4!//$! $$/!/(/""%$'/.22($/!/.

#6'$(.. 62#64 .#$'6!#4//!$486.!/2#(.!.///$

 $4! !. '($/66 00"

..  ..$'. /'.2/2 !0 .2(.2#.( .2

5/$!/.%""($2/2..$0!.$/25/$!/.%02"" /!/.($/6. 0.2!

/2.!% ./ !(! 644!/ !0 .2(.2#.(/ !/!.!/"

0/ /'.2(2 /.0 !552

 /0.2/!$!. .!6./! # 0$.$.../$!. .!6./!%  !520! 

(/$!6/$$%!/'.2/.(/$!6/$$%5/$!/.$!/!.!/0!.6/$$"

3&%&!0.2(.2#.(/..(!./#4#.$!22(!/!/.!!."" 00$!%

!!!0.2(.2#.(/..(!.!/42./2/60!.!55/.!!.!8#./(.!!.!%

!.!/ /.0 6$/ / 2( !/. # 6'$(. $<<0. 4 # . !!. /' !

.$ /$2. (!/!.2%0$$./#4#.$/!"!0.2(.2#.(/..(!#

!82/#46' #!$!!.!.!%62(220.2%./../..$.!""

6.!2#!0.2(.2.(/2 /!/$%./'""(!/!.2/.0

/.//2" 42./2   !55/.!!.! !8#./(. !!.!% !.!/ !0 .2(.2#.(

/! /!/$%.//6.!!6.0##!$//!/.#6'$(."!0

.2(.2#.(0<<!0/..(!.4!('(/!!/$. (!/!/././0!/%

/ !0 !80!/  !..  /.0 /..(! 4!/$./( / /$ /. 2!.

/ /$!. (0!"

.. /./!.! / / !0 6' #!/0!. ! /.! (4 .0$/ 2!.

/ /$!."

3&)&.$/2 $!.$ . $  $20!.$. /!# //$! 508. ($A/!..2 !0

.2(.2#.(/..(!

7$/

7$.?6%(42./($/.!(2!0









*)-





.2(.2#.( / !0 # 0 #8.!.!2 /'// . ('2 .//. 4 % ./ ('8

6' #!/2/!0"

 ! $.2!% ./  62(2 !552 (4$!/(2 !#$2% !!  !552!//( /..(!



7#4'.!/($A/!../2/4.$$//'.20!/$.22 /!/$"



,&!0 .2(.2#.( !552 "" 6.!0!.! /'.2(2 /.0 .2 # ""5/$!.2% (..$

6/!.226%!0//!/#" "5/$!.2"

,&%& !$.2!%./!552!//(/..(!

7#4'.!/($A/!../2

/4.$$//'.20!/$.22 /!/$"

 $20!.$..$/!#//$!0'!/!0.2(.2#.(

7#4'.!"

.!.!$<<0!.#6.!0!.8#./(.!!.!/42./2"!8#./(.!!.!

/42./2%!0.2(.2#.(0!('/2%.//('!$55" "/%//$

/.2/!/0""6.!0!.$"



+& ! $.2!% ./ !0 .2(.2#.( !/!/ ..2( !#$  !55 !$.

/!/0.%62(2!552(4$!/(2!#$2"!/!/!.2(2!#$262(2"

!/!.0'!/0!.$(.!/!0 !/0.622/.2.!!/#$2% /$!.

!/ !.$0!/(2 20.2% !/!. ..!042. !(/0!/" !0 .2(.2.( 

(.0 /$$/!/0/%(44/.!2($/!//2%/$2.$.$ /%/

./<</%/..0!/*.!0.!.-#*/.!.-!/0./.0 !6.8(#$!

!/2/.2.$!.(!/!.!/!$0044$4 .2$"



 

 





4& /(.. /0#"0"/!!.6.$..!/!!0.2(.2#.(

/!#2(//!06.$$/!%0$$.!6$8/5 !/20 //!!!0

.2(.2#.(!5520'!/0!.!

7#7#4/. /5 !//2!!!/!!%

0$$.0'!//!552!7?#4044/!/!.!9*.$-!//(!/!/%

!552!/!.!

70'!/!0.2(.2#.('.!"



5&/!#$.8%./0 !2

7,$62.%? //!!.!628

6' #.2! #  //!!. .!$/(! #4.$2!.2 . (!/ /'.20!.!.0. /(!//2

!#$2.$."0.//20!.2(20/.$'!.(44$. $20!.$."



%*&/!#$.8%./!0.2(.2#.(/$.8

7#4'.!0'!/"

7

/. 8#./(. !!.! ..$28 /.(!.  #!/0!/ # ($ 6' #!/(/ . $!/

(44 /$.0!/"/""/! /!/$%./$<</#4#.$($./22"

..  

 7  8#./(. !!.! /4/0/"

../'// . $. $!/ / 20

!552!//(/..(!.!8#./(!./5$."!/5!/$!.4!2!!552!//(5/$!%./.

$<<2""/"



%%"/!#$.8%./6' #.2/2.$.!0.2(.2#.(!5520'!/0.

7

#4  /.0 /..(! /$.8 508. ($A/!..2 

 7 ? #4"  !552!//(

62!/ /$!""/66"/!#$.8%./!0.2(.2#.(.622('0$!%./

$<<2./#4#.$/!.8"

%%&%& ! /.! !5520'!/( /!!. /..0!.$ .8!.2!$$/ "" ..$0!.$

/2 5/$!/.$." 

 7!/ ?, $  . /$..  / '!/ (.!/2 !5520'!/(/ /!!/

/. .!..$0!.$/25/$!/." !$.!622(.!/2""5/$!!.$$.!!!%

0! 62/8 !552!//( # "" ( .$ /.2 /5$ 6' #!.  /"  !  (2

 /$ 0!. $48 5 .5$!.$/ # 62$$/% (.!/2.! "" 5/$! # /. .! .2.!/









*)-



#4.$2!.% ./ !0 .2(.2#.( !/! 

 7  !4/.!//2 /."  / #!

6.(2$.0.!0/4 /!2 /!/$/25/$!.2"



%)&/!# $.8% ./  /!/ 6/$$!/ #  //!!. 0/(2.!/  /#/(  /

.88#./(!! !# 0../$.0!.$"  ! .!/! !552!//($. !55!/( !/$!.

5!0!%(.!/!.8!.2!$$/..$0!.$/25/$!%(.!/!(!/$!@' !.2!.

7 9 !'0 !$2!. # /'$.2!0..$2.($2!.$/6<.!//2""#!0

.2(.2#.(( .$!/#( ./!/".$/20!!.8 /$!.$$! /620!.

#40!./2!#!"



%.& / !/$ /!# 2(/ / !0 //$.! 0 / /!!.

/5 !/0!/#!0.2(.2#.(!552/!/0!/

7?6#4!/!.!

.$# !/!. (!/!. 0'!/0!/" 

 7  #4 //$.! /!# !0 .2(.2#.(

'.!0'!/0!/"

552!//(!0.2(.2#.(/./!/!#6.$$/!"

%.&%&6<.0//$.!6.$$/! $20/#0 //!!.

0/0/#4/0!/"



 











%2& !%$$.!2# 20$!#!/2/'.2.2%$24

!552!//(% /!#% 6<% $.8% ./ 6.$$/!  6' #.20/%

 $20!.$. . $#0 / /!!/$.8#4//0/0/!.$$.!/22 6' #.2!/.$%

0$$!.2  ! . 6. (#$! 5$. / (!/($/ 0$0../$!.

!.2!/*.2!62

-7$.9$6"



%3& ! $.8% ./ 0 !  /!/2 !0 .2(.2#.( 6' #.2/$/

!552 

 7  #4 "" / /$! /60!.! # "" 6.!0!.!" .$0.//2

/..6!22.!  0 / 6' #.2!.2 !'$! 0$!#! /(!//2 A/$!/.

!#$2." 6.$$/!! .!//2 6' #.2!.2 .  $!/ 0 / /!!.

/5 !/0!.!"

%3&%&6.$$/!!!!$2((42.%./0 !/'.2/. 20!.$2

7,

$  62. % ? '2.2 #  (44$/  $22 0/.$'!% . $. 6' #.2/2"

!/62!.$/ 6.$$/!$. $.8  !% ./ 0 !  

 7 ) # 7 )

 !.$/ 2'/'.2.2.2.0!0!!.(..20!. !.$/!..

6' .2 ' !#$2. 5$!.$% /4.$$ # 8#./(!.$ $48(/0!.$"

..#.! 

0 //!!.6' !!

76 !.$/42/20/(2%0!/#8/!!.

0.$/ .2.$. /'.2/.$. # . $. !$2!(44!.! /.! 0$!#! $.2(2 /'.2.2"

..  0 / /!!.!/ ('0$ #4$2% 2! # 0$$!/.$. /'.2/.$. /.2.! 

0 ! #'22 !!.(..20!. !.$$.!% ./ !0 .2(.2#.( 6 /0. /$$.

!55!(/2/.2"

%3&)&/!# 6.$$/!! . $. .!//2 0.2 ! 0 /$. 0//./.2$.(2

/'.2.2%(2//$./!.$.0!$.(/./'.2/.(..$2!./ 20!/#!.$$.!//$..($/

!0.2(.2#.('.!0'!/0!/

7#4!0.2(.2#.(/..(!.

508.($A/!..0!/ 

 7 $/ 

 7$. ? 6 " '.2/. (..$2!. 20!.

//$!.$. $4 /2.!  ! $.8% ./ 6.$$/!! . $. .!//2 0.2 !.$$!.2

!#$!2% 0! /!2 0 / #4.$2!/. 508. 20!/"  !  /'.2.2

0! /.! 422 0/(2% 0! 0 ! #8 0 /!!. 0.$/ .2.$.

/'.2/.$. *$"+++?-"

..#.!  /!!.! !!$!.$/ /2  /!# //$!/.$.

*!0.2(.2#.(/..(!/.508.($A/!..0!.#'.!0'!/0!. /-%0!.!//

 /$.!(2$!/.!"

0//$!/!.6.$$/!!*$")9)+01!$./!.%./









*)-



+

0 !



.8'.!/

 $22

0/.$'!/



$$!.$/

2

0$0../$!'!/"  ! . '!/ .2. (42./."  !

'!/80 /6' #.2!/.##4.$2!/."



%,&/!#(428%.//2!#!628/.!8#./(.5$%

74.8.//.

/.5!.!/ /$$//0.622/." !!.2(42./0/!!.6' !!

4!/$.2 *$"++ 5$$/ (0. $' B $ +)-"  ! '!/8 0 /

#4.$2!/.% ./ !0 .2(.2#.( 6 /60!. /0. / /$$/% !.!/ $55.! 2($/

!/. # 6'$(. ""$. 4 # . !!.% .$!..! 

 7  8#./(!. 5$#."

!/0!!/!552

7#4/$.8$!!!$!.!.$./.#/#4#.( .$

/(!/2%.//./0.6#/./!.!!82/#4#.! /.!(4 .0$/2!./ /$!."

 / 0$$$..0  0 "04/! " /!!.!  ? *  

% % ,- 042% ./ /60.   !($!. /.#.$2!. !!.! !0

6' #!/(/$.84!/2/.%0$$.!/0.6#0!!0/#4#.

6' #!$!!.!.!"@' #!$!.!!552!//(!0.2(.2#.(4/0!.#!82

/#4#.%!""""!0( .$%(.$20/$/$.0!%!.!/(2.$2(/.$/#4#.

!80!. ..$2! .  /.!/. !'2. $0 !.$$. /./ 6$.! /#4. !82" 55.!

2($//$$.!/.#6'$(.4#. !!.%!"".$/4 /!/./.62%

/($!. 0'!/$ .$.0!. 6$/ .//. 4 % ./ !.$$. 4/0. ('8 ! / 

'. !.0 /#4#.% !"" !0"  ! $.8% ./ !552!//( !0

.2(.2#.(6/$$.!55!(/(/./0.2!./ /$!.%!.!/2!./ /$!.6 $

!.65/!.!.$//#4#.!(/0!.$.%20<<8!.$$.!80!.('0$!/"



%+& ! 048% ./ / ""  /..$!.! 0../$!.! *$"9% 

04/2 0 / !/ 6/$$! 6! /5- /2 5/$!.2 ($2/ 0 /!

/'.6$.!/(!/($/

7?,$'./."

0!.!#4///4 .$.6/!#$%./

0.//2 //  !/5!/$./ 0 / !/$ # !/5!/$!. 4!  / 22

..$0!.$<.$2!!$!.$///(25/$!"

%+&%&C /$!% 0 / !/$ / "" 6' #.2!1 0! / .  442

 /0../$!.$0 /!!#!/..$0!.$"/""/!0 /!

2($/!.2%./// 8!552!//(/!0.2(.2#.(/644!/#!../!%!!

6. 0.2!!0.2(.2#.(!552(..$%.//.2!44!/"

 !  0 $ .2/.! * / 0$$$..0 $ .22  %

"04/!!/ "  % 6 "D  )% ,"04/! " % 6 - <.$2% ./  !

!28 /$.!/($/#!2($/!.$/2%0!/..($#6.2$22

..(2 5/$!% !8 /.2  622 !$2!(44!.! # /.0 5/$! /'.2 !/2"

/ ""  !/($/ !.$/2% 0! / 0 5/$!/.! 6552!!0 .2(.2#.(

4/0!/42//..$!/6.0#!...6./.05/$!/'.2/'($.#4/0"

.. . /2 / 6$/ 5/$!/. 0/0. ! .8!.2!$ # 6' #.20/

 //!!./..0!/628$!0 //!!./5 !/0!.!"



%4& !.'!//!#/!0(4/.!0.2(.2#.(

7

#4 '.! 0'!/0!.  /" /!# .28% ./ $<< /#4#.$ / "" ($ .

/22" 0!.! /6' !/8 !#40!.$/"

%4&%&

 7  /. 8#./(. !!.! !!$28  /. $/./(!./ /. /.(!.

 #!/0!/($6' #!/(/. $!/(44 /$.0!/"E .(!. #!/0!.!

7

/.%0!('86' #!/2. $!./.(!. #!/!.%!#.!/.(!. #!/!.

/#4#./..$$!80!.$.$.!.$$./.8#./(!.!!.!/4/0!.!6./!/

/4 /!!//.($A/!..0!.!

7#46.8!../.$.00!.$0$/!.$$.%









*)-



)

0!!28. $!./.(!. #!/!././2F*/ /0$$$..0$ .2

?%%"#"-"

4.!$.(!0$!#!!552!//!0.2(.2#.(/!.$$.!%.//$'2($/""$.

! # #$ 4% /./2.! $<<0!. /$. /.(!. #!/!. 6. 620!.

(!/!."

/'.2/2!552!//(5/$!/.6/!.224#*$"9-%./""$$2

(!/!.2#..2/./!/$$.!552!//(!0.2(.2#.("@/!.22!/4 /8%./

""$$!$0!.#$/.//202. (!/!"

..

7/.!!.!

$.0!%/$.(!/!/.//2"



%5&!/!.!/"

%5&%&!/!. 0'!/0!.$ !552!//($.  0 ! (.!/2 '2. 

 7! +)

!4/.!//2 !#$2." .2 ! 0 /$. 0//./.2$.(2 !#$!2 . .!//2

6.$$/!!. /!/$" !!'$!

76!+/22

'2. 0/(..2 !552!//($. 0'!/./2 !/!/" !0 .2(.2#.($. 0'!/./



 7  #4 !/!.!  .! !// (!/!/% !#.! /$$. 

 7  #4

0'!/./2 !/! $./ ./! 

 7  #4 0'!/./2 !/!."

552!//($.

0'!/./2 .!!/.(!/! $$

7#4!/!.!0!.*%+

!//-044"/!/!.0'!/0!.$ $2/25!!/!/!.0!.20!.

6/!6%0!!0/!'$!!.2!."

 !$.8%./0'!/.!!0.2(.2#.($.(..$..0!/!.%!.2

//$./!. /!# / !0 6.$$/!!% $4 .!  ! (!/$ '! /!0!.

(2."

(.!/2.!  !0 .2(.2#.( /.2. /0.6.0!. !#$!2 # !.$$.!/ /$..($/

/.0!552%.6. !/.0!/!...20!/('0$!"



.$<.$2$./.2.!## 22.!

7$6!/%79$!/%79+$2.!/%

#4/8  !   / (..  /0# "0 " /!!. 0/0/%

6.$$/! $20/"













 $0/1/(

.(.(





$203$

 /







 /







 /