Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-07-2754\9 AI generated

1-07-2754\9 · Viru Ringkonnakohus

Case Number 1-07-2754\9
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

0 '=='! 2!  !,#' !+!'!( 0' 2&&.0# +!5!.##0( 2&'!5 '! '0.0 ' %0:!0%#' 

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-07-2754\9 · Viru Ringkonnakohus: 0 '=='! 2!  !,#' !+!'!( 0' 2&&.0# +!5!.##0( 2&'!5 '! '0.0 ' %0:!0%#' 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text







   

 

 







 ! "#

 







 

$%&'#$!()*"+

 









 



""!, %'-!' +(!!! #(,!.% /!,!

   



 

)!0&,

 







1$%&'#$!

   



 !! "' !+!  "'%!2! $%&'# $!$

+!"#'!%#%&&#

 





 

!"',#'!'!+)0+00%2  +3#4.$$+005!67$!8

 # . 9799(  .! .##0'!( :*""!.#(

0, "'

;;;;

<<<<(

;;;;;(

'=='(

+!,.(

%!!, !#!#'!'.$

   

  !: !' "',!)&+0  #! !

: =!5+!0%5'

 !"#$

%&  #  

'(&

 )''(& 



  



 

    *







 

  

 &



.!#!05!%#0 .





 

 +,  











&



)



>) 

  



%& !! "' !+!  "'%!2! $%&'# $!$ +!"#'!%#%&&#0!  "!,.!'

!"',#'!'!+!)0+00%2  +#"'0#'*0.'+!"#'!%0$

%&%&!"#'!%#0!,#0#, 0'$%&'#$!$



)&!"#'!%#'! ',#0  "!#0,'  .! ? ,'#0:0@0' !+! #! ! %!!,'!,'#0

%00',#0# %!!,!#  99( %,,0# !,#'!' %00',#' 9$%&'#, $!

!#'##0!.#'3 !8A,:.0(7'#'0,#0,,0#(0'9$%&'#,$!0,,!

$ !2!, !+!# !,,! %' %!2!  9 '0: 2!# ',. !# '.%!'' %00#' +!

+!,,!#!#2! "*+!%#0 00#%&, !,,!,0 $$,0  +&+!,,! !#'!%#0! 2!  !!

&"+!.!.0#"*+!#.!!'!,'% 5,'0,0@ 2! $

)&%&$%&'#, $! 0,, $ :00' !"',#'!'!+!!  )0+0 0%2  +( 0# 

!"',#'!'!+!!4,0,!'.!..4',#'0 ' %0:!0%#0!#2! ,.0#'$



-&!0%: = ""!, 4'' '! ',0# )0+0 0%2  + +!"#'!%#'( ! '0.!

!"',#'!'!#0!#'%0'0 ' %0:!0%#0#('! +!0% "': ,' .+!,'!#'!'.(





1197 



398



0 '=='! 2!  !,#' !+!'!( 0' 2&&.0# +!5!.##0( 2&'!5 '! '0.0 ' %0:!0%#' 

" .5 "'00,#0#'%#0#'2! "'#'*+!,0$



.& "'#',' 0'!#+!0%: = %!'! ',#'$

.&%& !"',#'!'!+0*#'.+!0%: =+!"#'!%#'! ',#0!$ !'#'!# %!#44.(

.:!,#!+0##0+*''!(0':!0#%0#0!##!#'%0'0 ' %00#%0#' .!('!, !#'%!2!

.!500'$!#!50,!'#!"!#,!!"!#$

.&)& !'#2! :!,# 00,..! +!0%: = '! ',#0 !",.!%#0#'( ! )0+0 0%2  +

,5!#%''0# '!.!''0(,#!#:!,#+*''!!"',#'!'!+!'0+#,#0#.'$



/&!! "#+*''#%&&#0'00%#0,!+0##0(0')0+00%2  +'!"',#'!'!#00#%0#0

!##!#'%0'0 ' %0:!0%#0#(%,,0:", !#'#0#0''0&"'.!,'+!#'#(

'!  +!0%  "' : ,'  3+#8  .! !#'!'.( !#'#' 0 ,0 !#'#0#'#' %!"!

+*0'.('!0'=='!0 %!,0!!,#0'###0',0'$

!! "# ,0.#( 0' )0+0 0%2  + +*5 +!5!.##0 2&&.0# 2&'!'! '0.0

' %0:!0%#'2!" ..! "'00,#0#'%#0#'2! "'#'*+!,0$



 









0& !! "' !+!  "'%!2! $%&'# $! +!"#'!%#%&&#0 :0!,0 0#'!#

!"',#'!'!+)0+00%2  +%&&#!05#0$

0&%& !05#0# :!,5 !"',#'!'!+ )0+0 0%2  +  !! "' #!'#  0#' ,&5

+!!.!'!$ ! 0 !+!'#0  "'00,#0#' %#0#'*+!,0 " ..!( !'!,  ,0%!# .0,

0, "' 2! :!,5 '*0. B +!"#'!%0  !#0.!.! '*0.!  0, "!#' ,!"%#0 00,.$

!"',#'!'!+!#*, '!, ,#0."!#0.!!#'%!(.!500'2!!"!.0%!'' 

7C,!'#0#'==+*%0'$$!:,,,$!:0!5'!%0%!+!,.##:::0.!%!

#0 #0##0,,0!:!,50.+!"!,'+!5!#'!.!$



(& ! "' #', !+!,.!# : = !5 +! 0%5' !+!%#'( 0' %!! "'

+!"#'!%#%&&#0'4"#'!%#0#0 ,0!,#'$

(&%& !'#2!+!.0!.+ !!',!.% #0#'!#'0!'0(0' #!,05!+! "'%!2!#',

!'#2!!  0 ,% !"',#'!'!+! )0+0 0%2  + %&&#!05#0 !'!%#0,0$

&&#!05# !'!' %!!,%00',#0 #0!.#' A 96 ,  !,#0, ,%! !'#2!

+!.0!.+ !!',!.% ,# #!+*''!$













1$ ! "#( ''+. +!"#'!%#' % %!'02!,.0!( %&&#!05#0 +&.0'0!(

,!.&!: =!5(,0.#(0'%&&#!05# :*"20.!%!'!",.!%#0,00

,$

1&%&0#'!5!?*"#0!.#0A:9 "!#0,'+*5+!5!.#0+*''!'0 &!" .%#0#$

%!!,%00',#0 #0!.#' A 9 ,   "!#0,' +*5 !"',#'!'!+! +* #44.#'!'!+!

+!"#'!.!(  '! +*5 %!!,%00',#0#' *+!,0 " ..! +* 2&'+!,' ' %0 :!!

'0#.$

!! "# +00+!,''+!#'!.+!"#'!%#0!,#0.2! ! "#*#'5#0,,0 "!#'0

:*"20.#'0!$  ! "# 0 '+!#'!. !#2! ,#.( %# +&,#'!#. '*0.!

+!"#'!%#0 "!,.!%#0$







1197 



398

2&!! "'+!"#'!%#%&&#0#'&"'+!,' )0+00%2  ++!"#'!%#0!,#0# ,.

 "' !+!%#( 0' +!5!.#0# +5.0# +*5 !"',#'!'!+ ' %0 :!! # '0#. +*

:!%!$

2&%& *0: ,0#' 3,$698( !"',#'!'!+ )0+0 0%2  +  +0,  !, %!!, !#

!#'!'.+!!+!#'!#'0'0.0' %0:!0%#000#'$ !#'!'#: ,0#''!'.$

! ,#' "' #0.!5  ! "' !+!'0# ! !#'#0 !##( %,,#0  "# +*5

)0+0 0%2  +,0 %&&!'!$ &0# ,0+!, !2!, !"',#'!'!#0 )0+0 0%2  +' 0#%0#0

!#'%0'0 ' %0:!0%#0#$ ! "#,0!5(0'%.!!#0% '0 !"',#(#0.!

#0%  "'(0'#+*52&'!'!'0.0' %0:!0%#':!%!$

0+#0: 5,00%.0 ,0%!# ,0 ,0#!%'+!,'.'*0.'4"#'!%#0!,#0#0.0

,!"0.!%#0 #!# #!!5 )0+0 0%2  + :==..! :.!%#!#'#0 !.%#'!'# 

: ,0$

00! 0 '+!#'!.  ! "# !#2! ,#.( %# +&,#'!#. '*0.! +!"#'!%#0

 "!,.!%#0 2! %&&#!05#0 :*"20.#0. 0 ##!,.! #0.!+*. !!,!. !#2! ,#.( %#

!!#. !,#0 &0# ,0+!, !2!, )0+0 0%2  + #"'0# 00%!,,#0 '*0.

 "!,.!%#0#$

0,' .' !+0#'!.0#  '! ',# )0+0 0%2  + #"'0# +!,'. '*0. '4"#'!%#0#

!,#0'$



&"'.0#00,' .#'2!2"..0# %!!,%00',#0#0!.#'AA.0#'962!962&'!5

 ! "#+!"#'!%#%&&#0%'%!'!%&&#!05#0!",.!%!'!$















""!, %'-!' +





!!! #



,!.% /!,!

 "'









 "'





 "'