Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-05-491\3 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:4.05.491.21564 AI generated

4-05-491\3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja

Case Number 4-05-491\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus

Legislator summary

AI generated



Legislator headnote

AI generated

4-05-491\3 · Pärnu Maakohus Kuressaare kohtumaja: 

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text















      







 !"#$

 

 





%&'()%& & *$$ *

 



  

 +



 

 ,*$-

 

  

.* $$

 

 

&&.-*" $(/0) '1(

  

   

&&



     

  





 

   







   

231*$-$4"3(-$*('#-(.!"$- 5*33(! *5 *

%&'()%& &



"#-.3($*6**-3*' *$(, ' 3(! *5 *

 



!"##  



"$"  

 %&'()



 * 



  







+,

 # ),,,!"36-# -

 "



(" -   

   

  



 "$"  

 *     .

   

 

      

     

 





 *



 

  /   $

)'+," 



  

  "



)"

 * 

"$"    

 .   

(),! !$$ , !"36!766*,

 

- $,   # ,$6(($-(6( .*3,$ .*  )) 8 0  *$-( 9#($4 1 $: .((-*

65*)80

&









   



 !+ . 

 0



    *   





     

  



((!,()&&12,2



.





* 

!,((,,)'&42,!!

5 .



0    '!,,,2'1+1"



 



 



"#-"-$$*3*.;(. ,4""3*,*$(- ,  4*33 -$(""! *5$* 33( (1!" !"#-3*"-$$*-*(,





)

!"#- ! ,: -* - ,*$ #(3'*6 3- $*(-$6* 4*.  '""!$3: . -*$ !"#-"-$$*  !3- 6($* 4*. $-

!(' 3(!3-  "6  $"".($- ! $- ,  4*33 -$(""(;(1$- '  *$(- ,*$ 4*33 -$(""! *5$*  4*. 

'""!$3 . -*$4*. $-6(3!"#-"-$$"4""3-*3*--.6($*!$!--*$ , .&



"#-"-$$" !"#- *$$ *!"#-6 ' ! -$*3*($"$$() *$$ *$--.6($*!$

!--*$ , . 3 -*$%&'($-)%& &



6768

&&*3* !""$- -( ))&&)& & .-*"4"-"!"33 $*33* !"#- : *- -  '#-($ ))&&)& & !*33 

%&)4 (! *6 !" $ *$$ *3( $"$$( 1(- . ($-6(!3$ 1 33

- . 4""3*6""-"$;(,!(-:6(33*$"3(-<<- .3((!3$'*3*. 3.*!(($*6;;-*$* ,*- . $- , 

.;(#((, .;(6 3, .$* ,*=#($-3* "&

6 $*33($*-*1*.$*1 (!!$&&3((!3$$!(' /));,*(,' 4 (-"(6*3((!3$$* ,$*

/0) '1(!. 3(>(-$(- . .-*"&



 63

&& *( "3* .-*" $'  - 6($*3* (36,: !(, " !(' 3(!3- !"#-3* -* - , "6 

(366($* .;(6 -$*$- $*"$*$ # (1*$-6($*1 & && 4 35 $'  - ,  -*6  !"# 3"3*!- &

"#-.3($*$6**-3$*$"6**-3$ 3*($(!! #*-$*,"6 $77,'  . 3, ,-"(6

$#-*$! #*-$$-+-&3&%+&



39 763

"#-.3(* 6**-3*'  4* 5 && $77 .-*"$  / 0)   '1( -;*, -!$ 3*(,*$: *- -*6 

! ($-$ .;(!$ "33   # - #.  - #.(7#(!-& "#-.3(* 6**-3*'  4 35 !">($!(, 

$* ,*=#($-3* "' .3' 6;($- 6**-3$ 3$*3-($(!3-*!$4*-(($(!3,&



6633

"#$4* 5.;(6 3(!!$/31 3$*3 $'  - 6($-6**-3$ 3$*($(!- &



((!3$$!(' /))$-*$- 5:*-$;(,!($*(-"#("33 $* ,6*(,:6($.;(6 3, . , . $- , 

3((!3$'*3*. 3.*!(($*6;;-*$* ,*-.;(#((, $*33*-<<,&

((!3$$* ,$*/0) !"# $*3-6""-"$;(,!('#-(6($*$-:6(33*$ $5!(($*6;;-*$* ,*-

. $- ,  .;( $*33* -<<, #((,  .;(6 3, . $* ,*: ? ! ($- - !$*  # - #.(1  !( 

- #.(7#(!-&



"#$ "33*$ 35( .((, !"#-3(! (6($* -*1( !(,3 !$: *- && -*1*.$ " ;(1*$-(

!. 3(>(-$(-, '  $77  / 0)  '1( !. 3(>(-$(- .  .-*" -"(6*4 *6($*$ " 3*(,,

-;*, 6($-@

7,6$!"# . -3$4"-"!"33(1 ' >"-",*1 :6(33*!"# $*3-))&&)& & *6 !" $

*$$ *3( $!*33 %&4 (!"$$('  1(-($-6(!335(.((,,. -3$*1 -. $- -(:

*-&&4""3-'#(-,$;(,!(!*$!!"$""3($6 1*-">"( 33 $$ , ( . $- ' '#-43-:6($

"3(!((- -,- !' !(($*1 & , ( . $- '  -* $$'#(4""3$*4(!*$*. '!73'*$' 

'#*3!$! -$*4"3$-($($$*&;(,!($(3.;*- 1  $$.37!$ -*+-&3&0+A

"#-*!$4*-(($('  (6( 3($-(!  *$!$*)8&&)& &*!$4*-(($( !-(1 :6(33*$-#-5:*-

6**-3$ 3$* ($(! -"$- 3*(-, $* ,* !(' ,*1  =#($-3* "  .;(6 3, 5 . $- , 

3((!3$'*3*. 3.*!(($*6;;-*$* ,*-+-&3&08+A

**-3$ 3$* ($(! *,  !"#-.3($*$ 6**-3$*$ -, 7-3$-*1  +-&3&%+: 6(33* !"# $*3-

'#-($ -  ))&&)& & *$$ *$ $;(, -"-   6(33*$ "3(  , ,*-*!-": !  -  *( "3,

-* ,3(!:*-*$-($*(-"#($*, ! $- , &&! #*-$*5-"(6-A

1  " -;*, -,: *- && 4""3- '#(- . $ -"$ "3( ))&&)& & -<<- . $* ,*: 6($







.;(6 3, $ . $- , 3((!3$'*3*. 3.*!(($*6;;-*$* ,*-.;(#((, $*33*-<<,&&&(!!$

'*3(!3-/));,*(,' 4 (-"(6*/0) '1(!. 3(>(-$(- . .-*"&

/0) *5! ($-$* *--* # - #.(!(- #.(7#(!-& $- . 3- /%313*

-3*5 ! ($-$* 6;($-6($*3 !"#- 4""3- .*$- ,  !*1*, . (, '   $!*, . (, $' "3$(,:

.;(6 3$- 6;'- ,  $77,3 $- *, $4(,( #"(,6  $77-*1,* -"(6*4 *6($*$- '  ;(1$!" 

! (-$6($*#.($(,&

"#$ 3*( 5: *- -, $' $ " $77,3 $* . $--$- !*1*, . !$ $' "3!$ 4#-$7, 63(!

! #*-$$& $--$- $!*, . , $' "3,4,. ,&1  $5!"#$$*($!"# 3*:*-&&-

-3*5! ($- , - #.(7#(!$$* # - #.(1 $" !""(&



"#-.3(* 6**-3*'  - "-3*5 !*$"3*. $ .-*" $' $ 6**-3$ 3$*3- ($(!3-   .;*-,

.-*" -"(6*4 *6($* . #*- "5'*!-( $" 3((!3$'*3*. 3.* !(($*6;;-*$* ,6* . $- 6($-

.;(6 3, . $* ,6*=#($-3*" !">($!(6($-&



/8 31'1(.;(5!"#$!"# 3, , - #-3(!$77-*"-"(6*4 *6($*. #*,(' $77-*"1 

$ ,,.  !">($!(6($-:!(,!3. ,"-$$*-*1*6($* ' 3-"(6*4 (' 3*&-*"

-"(6*4 *6($*. #*,((1.-*". #*-!$"5'*!-(!$"3, (*.;(*$*6*.;(5 /8 

3;(1*-*$?$-*$- -,'#-,*3!">($!(, ! $* ,$*$*--*#-,!"#-.3(*6**-3*' &

"#$3*( 5:*-!"#-.3($*6**-3*' - "-3$"4;#'*, -,' !35 #3, 6($*3*(1

$1 !35&&3- .;*-,3((!3$'*3*. 3.*!(($*6;;-*$* ,6* . $- 6($-.;(6 3, .

$* ,*=#($-3*" !">($!(6($*3*&



 / 8 31 !"# $*3-  #7.(- 5 $77,(6;($-.  !"#-"-$$* !" 3 6**-3$!3,

$77,(6;($-*-&

 5 ((1( 3(-$$* &8&))& &6$*&)% 6,*-,8&%&)& &6$*1 &

))

 3$*3 6;($- 5 !"#$ 6**-3$ 3$*3- ($(!3- 6**-3$!3  .3'  *!$4*-(($(- $

$66 $) &!""(&







&,*$-

!"#-(!