Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-06-4243\8 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:1.06.4243.17470 AI generated

1-06-4243\8 · Pärnu Maakohus Haapsalu kohtumaja Haapsalus

Case Number 1-06-4243\8
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Kohtuotsus
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

1%   '  ,% *,0% , 01 *%%<.,. 9< , *. *%%, $.. *4 9<7

Legislator headnote

AI generated

1-06-4243\8 · Pärnu Maakohus Haapsalu kohtumaja Haapsalus: 1%   '  ,% *,0% , 01 *%%<.,. 9< , *. *%%, $.. *4 9<7

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



























 

















 

 





 !"#  $%

 





  

&'#'("()

 

*+

 

  

%

 



 

*'

,%

--.*

 

/

("(

01

%,$$,!,,*%,



1,%%,!

 





   ! "! 2 ,%* 34 . 34 34

. 34 ,!,,% 3 ,,%4 34 ** ' !% 

.**.5&6") ,$*,!7%&8,'$%*

/&)%1"$&0"%,%*91::4!**.

") &" "";"6: *7%":+<1,9$%* /&%1"

$(0$=%,%#91*,1*1!*,01&=. 

*,!,,*%,**.&:.5&6& & &#

%%%%0,%,9%9,$%* > /(%1"%,%

*91)4!**.&# & &# ;"6"" & &8

%%$%* > /&#%1&%,%*91&:4

!**." & &8;)6: = &=

%%$%* > /

&# %1 & %,% *91 & 4  !  **.

&# ( &;(6&# ( &

%%%%0,%,9%9,

$%* >  / &# %1 & %,% *91 ": 4 ! 

**. &# ( &; :6 # : "

%%  %%0,%,9%9,

$%* > /#%1"%,%*91(#4

!  **. &( ) ""; #6 ") : "

%% 

%%0,%,9%9,  $%* >  / && %1 " %,%

*91 (# 4 !  *!*; 86 8 = "& 0

$%* > /&&%1"%,%*91:)4!

**.&: && "&;=6"& " ""

%%$%* > /&:%1

& %,% *91 #  4 !  **. : ) ""; 6



= = ""

%%  %%0,%,9%9,  $%* >  /

&#%1&%,%*91)4!**.#  "";

&6"8 = ")

%%<0$%* /"&=%1&%,%

*91 # 4 !  **. && " "(; &&6

"8 ) "(<0%%0,%,9%9,$%* /8():%1

&%,%*91("4!**.: ( "(;&"6

  "(<0%%0,%,9%9,$%* /8(""%1

"%,%*914!**.&#  "(;&)6

( : ":<0%%0,%,9%9,$%* /8(&0

/8()%1&%,%*91&=4!*!*;&(6

=  ":<0%%0,%,9%9,$%* /8(&%1

"%,%*91#4!*!*;&:6= " "#

<0$%*.% /##&%1"%,%*918"4

!  **. " " "#4  ") ) "# *<,. %.*.

,%*%!,,,%. 









.,.9* ,%!.,

"!# 



$% --.!<* 



!

 

&'('

0*.*,.





(?6

%

(%   / #= %1 & %,% 9* *0 % *' ,% $1*!, $*

%%<,**

*,!%

,,.

%%07,

*<

,

%*,$,@,*

$%

$%*,0 ,*!00 ,,!,%, %*, ")' "(    ":  " ?6 $,94 !*<

.!*

  $?-6()?-!!,.,6* 





%

+% /#:%1&0/#(%1&%,% , 

 



!

 - 4%1,.,,1,!*,4

!%%,  ,%,9 !%0 !<*,*. 91* &  0 "= $,94 ,* ,!

*,14 !%%,  +<1,9 * $%* : & ": !<*,*. 0 .!* * :

.0"$,991**4 

  .?96(/?-!!,.6* 





 

'%*9%* /8(%1&0)091* ' ,%*,*1!%%*%.!*

1!*4,*!<*,*..!*:"$,9*91**,$AA***!,%, ' 

,%($?,-!,-,6  





0%,$,*!,***%*,10*.7

*%%,*!*%%0$..*%%<.,.0* 

.%* ' ,%*,0 0*!%%.0*0!*.

!%%.!,*0,%,9%9,%%0*.*,.**! /8:%1&$&':*%,,9.

*%%<.,.5

: & ,%!!%%,,%3;

: " 

%!!

!%%.0

!*.

09,!,

0,%

!%%..

,1*,,!,%,;

: ) %%!!%%.0*%%%,!,%1,*!*%%,.!,.!**,

**!,0,%*9,.*,*;

: (  ! !%%.!,*%* ,,%,9 % ,%* %!, ,! 

9,*,*-!,$,9;

: : !!%%.!,*%*,,%,9%,%'4*AA'9<<$$!9,*!, 

0%*,0%1,%1,.+<1,9***,%*!,$,94: & ":  

1%   '  ,% *,0% , 01 *%%<.,. 9< , *. *%%, $.. *4 9<7

!%%.!,*,,.,%,%!**,.9.*9*9%* /

8:%1"*,**%,4$,..*,1-,*9<9<$AA**,**!,%, 



)%

-*. ' ,%*,9%*.*<,.,%*%!,,,%. 

2%   / : %1 & $ & %,% 9<  



 !

 B%*  



  

  !*<.

0*!,<1.?9,63  







 ,  %

$/% 4

 , 

 %% !

 B%* 

     

     5*.

.!*,,! 9,%.9,%,  &"")(=&8



,* C$4 9,%.9, 

""&")88=## $4 9*,!7, "=(##  ,%., ,%1*, 0*. 2

$%*!04*&'#'("()4*%D 





 



$+2.?-

**%!.-,-!!,.96 

<,%,*,<,*,,%**.,*4*7<.,)$,90%%,.0<*!,* 

<.,*7*,,4,%1*,%.!4,%%,,,*<,**, 

$$% %0 !<* %% !

 - !    * 6   



   





        *    

 

 (1( ?. ,*,-!!,. 6

 3 ! *%,7 *. .!*,,! 9,%.9,%,  &"")(=&8



,*

C$19*,!71"=#=#&

$(% ***$,%,0<*!*%%,*,1*,,%, 



"

 



 



**, $,%,  <1 ,. ,9* ,, %,$,!,,*%, !., !,14

*,*.,$,%%*<1,*!,9*0%%** $%*!008

$,90%9*,*,%*!,*0$,%%**%,7,*.* $%

*!00 &: $,9 0%4 %*, $,9*4 !% *!,,*%, $%,%,  9<!% *

**9.**,1 

!%!,,*%, %., -9*!, **, 9<7 9.%*. **,* ,%.4 ,*.,

,%%,  !,7,  * $% *!00 & $,9 0% **,

%*!,* 



 

 



!

 B*--.**,,%%,4,**,!%%,( !%": <0%*,$,@,*

%%0,%,9%9,  $%* **. !*<. 07,,. 0*!, ,,*

%,., / 8(& 0 / 8() %1 & %,% *91 &=  4 !  *!*4 0*

") ,$*,!7%": ,%%&: "(0% $%%%**,,%+!00,%.,-%

-1%,* E*,!7%1,*%9*0*,!,.%9%.,%,9*<.**

%9 =: % ,1*,,!!11 &:  4 ,  *9*. %%4 !%%,1

 %,., / " %1 ) <.,.4 !%%, ,%* 0* , 9< %% !*<.* 0*.,

07,,.4 0, *,! $%* 0*. <.* * +! 0 0, 9 9

0*9,1<**,,%*9%09 

   



 



!

 3   ,      

  

3

 

  

  

 

       3 *

    

 

  & '(' 





 6   



  %



  *   



 !

 B%, , 

 7   / ("( 01

9%@*,,*9*,*!,$,!,,,*<7$A*--.**9%,*,"

.91**  /#=%1&%,%9**0%*',%$1*!,

$* %%<,** *,!% ,,. %%07, *< , %*,$,@,* $%

$%*,0,*!00,,!,%,%*,") ,$*,!7*":"( ,$*,!7":D*%

"8$AA.,%'"=D4"$,94!*<.!**,07&0"=$,991** 

 /#:%1&0/#(%1&%,%!<**',%B%,%**,:.0"$,9

91**4%1,.,,1,!*,4!%%,,%,9!%0!<*,*991*&



 0 "= $,94 ,* ,! *,14 !%%,  +<1,9 * $%* : & ":

!<*,*.0.!**:.0"$,991**  /8(%1&0)1/8:*,*,

%,%97*.--.**9**0%,91*,.!,**1!%%*"&%,*,01 

*,0%1,%1,.+<1,9***,%*!,$,94: & ": *4

,**',%7** 0*!%%.0*0$%*

!*. !%%.!,* 0,%,9%9, %% 0 *7 **!   / 8: %1 & $ &':

*%,,9.*%%<.,.  /:%,%9<!*<.0*!,<19, 



 



 . * -*%4 ,* 7 %,$$,*  0 <*7 ,%%,1  %,$$,

<%!!,%9%0,.!*<,%**,* *,,%!0%,!.9. 







0.*%,$$,0., 

 %,.4 ,* %,$$, <%!!,%  01*. ,.,,.    / ") %1 " ,,9.

%,$$,!,,*%* 9%*9. 0%. , ,,   %,$,  <%!*. --.**9 97%

**,%0*%%,.9 %,$,<%!**00,%,%0!<*7 ' ,%

--.0%.7*,!*,%,$$,%,$*.*, 



  

 ' *,1 *,* *' ,% -1%, * E*,!7%1,* 9%,

0 !*<.%, %%<,*, *100,% *,**. 91**, *<4 . *

E*,!7%1,*C,,%..,%,9!%!,,*%,*',%9%

<.!,*!*D*% )#D

 ,  $.9. 

8  %





%  *9%*   / &8: %1 & $   !,,*%% --.!<*9 *,1 ,9

.   ,%,9 !%0 ,,!, %,9 *,1  *!, $.. ,, +<1,9 

: & ": **4 !%%,1  9%0 !<*,*.  .4  ,%,9 *,1 .

9%0!<*!,%,%4--.**9%<14,**,!0!,,*%,*-,!,,*%, 

8





 



9*9%* /&8:%1&$(!,,*%%0,%,9

!%0,,%%01,9'.9.%, ., ' ,%*!,,,*!*.*

&): 

9  



    9*9%*   / &8: %1 & $ ) !,,*%% 0 ,%,9

!%0,,,*,.%,, ' ,%07,*9*!,1D*%'&)D4

!%%,*.,0,,%%79%0!<*!,%, ' ,%B%* 



*9%* /&=%1&-9*7--.!<*9**,%!,,*%%.--.!<*,* 



D%%D

+ 

*







<1,