Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2-09-42886/8 AI generated

2-09-42886/8 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-09-42886/8
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date

Legislator summary

AI generated

),%,# # $!!,#+ # $!! !7 ), 00 <,'! 0&, .!( !, # $!!

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-09-42886/8 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus: ),%,# # $!!,#+ # $!! !7 ), 00 <,'! 0&, .!( !, # $!!

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text













  



 

 

 !





"!# $!





 %&''

 













    







(%)"*&"!# $!%+#,",#%'!

  



 

  



 





-#" ',



   

&!''!.

/$,((0!#" ','&!.(

 

    





$&!''!.

/+",",# .11111111+!# $

23",4&"!+,'.",#5!'6

#  (  ( + ,,#!# . 1111111111+ ",",)"'

!# $ 1111  1111111 ,'' 111111111111+ ,#

0,,7,%,# $.%

  

"$!..&!''!.

/$,((0!(

)%&,((&!''!.

/#!#"0.!# ' '"*4*-8

9.7'#0&,"0.!# ' '"*--**5'#:3$#!$

3$#.3$##3%%'.3$#;#" ',(

!'',.# $! !,0,,0,%),.0#(

 

 



&!''!.

/%'!#!!.)((#'.(

) %&, (  (  &!''!.

/ #!# %'!#!! * - :3# !$ 0,,.;

#" ',(







  



&!''!.

/ 0&,7 ,. <, '#7! 4 <)0  #!+  !

#) ,%%,+ #!,. %, $,% #!, 0,, #!! %==.!%, "! # $! !

0,#! 0# %,+ "! ,'# ''# $!+ #!!!" #7! 0&,.#

$'..#,",#!%'!+#!,#7!, $'.%,,!',(

((0&,7,. "!# $!&"!# $!% !<#+#!,

%0!!+%, , !%,!#+ ,,',!.%&!0<&$!(

0&,7,.&!%%&!0<&$! % !+#!,>*;$,0%)%,

<!$! , $, #   ,%!. #) %!! 0,,, #!, ,,#,#! #," 0!

:;

3'.%,6;# $!,!',,%!%)%,<!$! ,# $!#! ,%!.# 

0&,%,'.#),,,#!,,,#,#!#,"0!3'.%,0&,# $!,!',6

4;  ! , 0&,'!. .! # $ $(  0&,7 ,.  !

#) ,%%,  * <)0  #! ',' #!,  ! !7 #)  ,%.

0)<  ,  7",,#, 0&, 0,#! 0#%,+ 0&,7 # ,. !

#) ,%%,<)0 #!( !, !$,%'!&!+

# ,0'!.)$# $!0&,,,%!'!.,!',+!7#,.#&,#

 0%,%, &<!0,,%,# 0,#( '!7,  %, <7 %'!7,

 .!)!.)$)",%,#%)$##%'! ,%,'!+

%,%,#%'!7, 7+#&,,%#: ?*@;(





 

!""#

"$" #%

"#

&'#

&$##%#$(##



$! '# $!'!.# # $!#,",#!0%:*4;+$ ,.%+#!,

# # $!%))"!.)$##,",#!,0+ '# $!&,!$, !

"$!..(



,%",.+%, '.!.$< '),.!.# .",&,"!#3& 0.

"!% ' # $! < ,!! <  !. %)"#! A#3 ',%, ,,#! ,

B : -;( &!' 5 ,,<"C#!!", "! < ,, # '' &,'., # $ <!!.!0.

< ,, '.%. (  !.< 0,,7,%,  !# $ # $ : ;(  $0,#!",",

'.%7,)", '# ",",)"'!# $11111111111,''11111110.11111

1111111 : *;+ %,, .", .!. %",. , #!"< , <  # $!

%)"#!B,.",D:@;(.5 ,,<"C#!!",#0"< ,, # ''

&,'.,# $: ;,  ( ('%4.",11111111111,''

< ,,<!!.!70%,#!!# $# $(#! ,%,'.%7,)", '

(  !.<  !. %#!0,. 0)%#,. 0,,%, !!, ((

/ 0"

< :4;(  7# %'!. #!%',.0,##!#) ,%%,:4-;(

 ' # $!%))"!.  $,%",. 0,#! #) ,%!. 0.%,

%,# .''-(' 0%7",:;(0,#!#) ,%%, 7# $!

"0. ?4*@-)!%'!. #!%'.,.# #) ,%!#(

'# .,##0!'.%,# $!!( +## $! '%))"'!.#,",#!

0%,)$+, )$# $!#,",#!0'!.(



 ? @  *+ 4 # $ 0&,7 # $! $  ! $,  ! "$!..

$,0.! %)",!.   !. &,!,#! <&$'.!. !!+ #!, # + #

# $! ' %))"'!. 0%, )$+ ,  )$ 0'!.+ ,, #!, $,  ,%,

# #)0),",,,0&,#!, ,%,#)0,#!(!$! #$,!.

C#,,. 0),. #  <  %#0&!# ','  ! 0&,7  !$! $

# $!,!', <,.%( $! ,7+  , ,' # ,,  ? @  - %)",!.

 !%,0),0,. !,.(



,  !. # $! ,7+  $, ' $,0.! %)",!. !!   !.

&,!,#!<&$'.!.','# $!$'.7 ?@*+4+-+-*)!

"0.   !(  ?    ),. "0. ,7 # $! !

<&$'.0 3#'&,!,#!<&$'.!(





4:;

,0.!# $&%,,.< .*(.%7","7,#".,,.,<,'!+%,# $

'$# -#" ',( #'.,'!!%%# <'# ' (%

$ <  # ".!0 '&!.%, 0&'0! !%,# ,  #  '!<,'!

!##,'!.0&'0!!'!.( 0&'0!$ '#" ',+%,-

#" ', ' <&$,0&'0!    #" ', ' ,'",0&'0!( ,  !. '&!7

&!''!.

/$,((0!E?.@*6*6***<*!0)%&,

# $#!#0&'0!#" ',(  ' %'&!.<&$'.%,## $!

,'!.< 0$&%,!.'!<,'!','# .!.$ ,!.,:@*4;(



E?.6@*6*6*6***<*+# $ '<,'<,'!< 

),%,# # $!!,#+ # $!! !7 ), 00 <,'! 0&, .!( !, # $!!

),%,)$<)0 '#,'.#%))"!.0&,!'70&!$ %!+!7# $!!),

 )$<)0+ #!!!" # $!! ",##!%,' ' 0&!$ !'0 # $!! ),%

)%,'0&,%,# $'),%,'+$!),%,0,,0,%,'( !,0&',# '# $!!

",##!'!.+0&,70&!.'&!.# $!!),%,"$,# $!!),%,0,,0,%,

# ""'&!.0,,0,(



 '$,$,0.!%)",!.!! !.&,!,#!<&$'.!.','$

< ,!.C#,,.0),.!7!.# <  %#0&!#(  7 ?

@*! !%,(, !.#!!!7$, ?@*# $

 !"$!.%,','# !7$#!#0)%&,0&'0!

#" ',(



?*<# $!'',7# $! %!,0,,0,%),.0#

 !(



?**# $#''7$,%'!#!!.< +##$!# !$,( $!+

"$!..$,+)7 ?**!%'!#!!.# #'.(



0 ?*@*4%))"7# $!$ ! !#,'.### 

$30,0.%'!#!!.+#!,$,7# $!%))"!.#%'!#!!.',%#,"+

#!!!"  ? *@   # $ , # $.  ? *@  * 4 )!+ #!,

%'!#!!.%))"##,'.# ?*@*)!.# ""(



 '  '!. #  0) %&, %'!#!!' $,0.! ,%, !!.

",,,&,0 *  #" ',  < ,#!!  #" ',( ),'.0 ' $ !'!. ",,,&,0! *

#" ', %'!. #!%',. #) ,%%,# %,#!. .'.. #!.!(  '

,'!.%'!#!!,.&'.0.. #!%'.,.:-++4;(



?.*4*+# $ '%'!#!!.%'! ,# $!#!!.# $!0),.

#!!.+ #!!!" # $!#!!. ' ",,,&,0+ #! ' ','  )7,0%, #!!.( 0

?*4<*+4!7",,,&,0!!.$,','",,,&,0!!!"!&!7,0,,

$,''+ #!, .! ,   ')$!. ,,, ',' 00  ? *4 < - ' 

)7,0%,#!!.0)'.%,#!. .'..0&,$#!0&,0.%,

#!!.( .!"0.!7# $#!#0)%&,%'!#!!'",,,&,0

$,0.!,%,*#" ',",,,&,0!0.%,0)'.%,#!.

.'..*#" ',





:;

0 ?*< '# $!0),##!!#%'! ,< ,#!!.+%, '#'!.

 %'!(  ' '!.# 0)%&,%'!#!!'< ,#!!.

#" ',(  "0.  ?  *   )!+  7 # $! <&$'.!# $

< ,#!!%&,7# $#!#0)%'!#!!'< ,#!!.!%%#" ',(



, !.# $!,7+#!'# $! !),$%'!#!!# #'.','

"0. ?*@ *4)!0&,7# $!$ ! !#,'.#

%))" # #  $30,0. %'!#!!.+ %&,7 # $! #  $ #!# 0)

"0. ?.*4<*6?*4<-+*<)!%'!#!!# ##!*-

#" ',(







$!',#>