Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
2-08-27327/5 AI generated

2-08-27327/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus

Case Number 2-08-27327/5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

4 1 +&!+$44!* $+ +&1 ) + ,!&+ '  + ,+&  &  &4# 1

Legislator headnote

AI generated

2-08-27327/5 · Tartu Maakohus Võru kohtumaja Võrus: 4 1 +&!+$44!* $+ +&1 ) + ,!&+ '  + ,+&  &  &4# 1

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text















   







 





! "# 





$

%&&

 













    







'&($)!%! "# $*"+!+"$& 

  



 





   





&,&"#+-' '( ../*0"!&+

+&1 ((++(+&% 1'

 

    





#



&,&"*++" "122222222 "#

++(+ +&&*+&11!+%!!3

" -'  ' * ++" "1 22222222222*  "#

222222222222'

  

!# 11



&,&"#+-' '( '

4$%+-' '



&,&"" "../56"1"$+ #"$1

6#""6$$&17"!&+0&+'

4$%+-' '



&,&"" "(++(+,%#+&% 1*.899.56"1&+

 # " 1 " "6$$&1 6"7 "!&+  . &1+*  '  &+  " &+

,%#+&% 1 4+$+&+ :

 ; ..  . 4 1 $44!*   !, ",&

+&!+$44!<='

&&+1"#  +(++(+$4+1("'

 

 







&,&"$& "  14-' '"&1'

4 $%+ -'  '  



&,&" " " $& "   0 0 5(++  # +1

(++"6$$&17"!&+'

4(   %  $+  " &+ 4+$+&+  ) -'  '   1 $& "  

(++(+:

;...&4# 1  '







  







&,&" (%+) +1 ,+&")   ,4( " *   

"4+$$+* " +1 $+ #+$ " + (++ "  $>>1 $+ !  "#   

(+"  (" $+* !  +&"&&"# * "  ! ")  (%+1"

#&11"+!+" $& *" +") +#&1$++ &+'





587

-'  '  (%+)   , +1 " !  "#  %!  "# $

  "4+$$+  .8 ,4( " * +1 " "%+" 

($+$+%, (++$+"(+"'



 

!""#

"$" #%

"#

&'#

&$##%#$(##



#  & "# & 1 " "#  "+!+"  ($ .8 ,4( "   #+

"4+$$+5/.7*#+1$*" +""# $44! 14#""+!+" 

+(*&"# %+ #+ !# 11'



+(1 "+1$44! "+!+" ( &1$+"#  &"

++"+" "4+$ 19',$)+5.7'

&"1+""( &1$+

"#  ' * " "#  & $44!& 1 "+!+"  ($+ 4#* +  4#

"#  "+!+"  (& 1' #  +)*  + +& " ++ 

 ; 8  0 $4!+ 1

 $+(4+(+1 +1'



+  1 #&1) "#  

 ;1 8  .* * 0 4+1 !(1 

 '



# +)*#+&#+(1 $4!+ 1   1%+ +" ,%#&1 1

&+&"  ) !# 1$+'





 ; 8  .*  "# (%+) "#  #   (%+ $   #+

  !# 11 #+(1  $4!+ 1   1 %+ +"  ,%#&1 1

 *" +"*""# &$44!& 1($+4#*+4#(& 1'



 # "#+ 1?"++1(4+1",$"(% "&+& 

(%+) # #"# + &+,+1$'





;888. (%+) (44"+!1(*(4!( 1 # *" +

&   11*    "  )  && $+  4+$+ " (4, + )!++"+'

@%#&1($4!+"6"&%+ +",%#&1 ' && 11* +"  

4+$+(4,+)!++"+*4)"#  (4"+!1($4!+)

,%#&1(6"&%+ +" ,%#&1 '



&#+(1 "+1"4& 1&"("# 1

#+(1 "+!(#&% 1$+&"#" "(%&( ../*0"!&+

 +&1 ( (++(+ &% 1'

+(1  "# %$++1 ,1 .'")!+ 

& ,+& *$+ &1+#"(4+"&  $.899.*."!&++&!+

.8 = ' &  $$ +$"  +&!+ $"  $+ 4#,4(" $44!+

,+& +" '" ,4('

+ ' &+&"& ,+&  &((%&( 

"""  ../* 0 "!&+* $+ ,%#+ (%&(  .899.* . "!&+3 +&!+(%&( 

9 "!&+3  ,,!#( ...* 8 "!&+3 (++(+1 ,%#+ .*  "!&+* (++(+1

,,!#(+*9"!&+'+ 1&% )



&,&"#+-' '( (4$%+

(%&( """ ../*0"!&+(++(+,%#+(%&( ' &+" &+

,%#+&% 14+$+&+:

;...4 1$44!5@+&!<=7'



&#+(1 %+ +" ,%#&1& 1#+$4!+ 1 +1*(++1:

;1

3/83.3...,.*93.3..3..3/9.3/38..$+1"#&

,+& ,+& , 4+$+" "#  +"* "  ! "#   !+"" $+& & (% #

 &("#  4+$4$+&(%+$+"#&4+$+&*# 4+$+(++(+$+&'



587

 + (%&+" & "#   !+"" & 1* (%+) (% 1 &% 1 "#   4+$+  !#+

"#  4+$+(++(+$+"!!&% 1(++(+'#+"#  4+$+(++(+$+

"!! (%+) (% 1 &% 1 (%&+"  (++(+ +&!+ 5(++(+7* !( "#  

+&% (" $  $+ " &+ "# 4+$+&+' ++(+ $44!" " :

 ; /8

4 1 +&!+$44!* $+ +&1 ) + ,!&+ '  + ,+&  &  &4# 1

"%!$ +&!+$44!* " + :

 ;  /8* " (++(+ $44!" ,+&  &4# 1

+&!+$44!*$++&1 )+,!&+'



( :

 ;1 /9  .3 /  "#  ) & ,+&  6" ++" 5& &17 &1$

+++" 5& 7!# $$(%+&1(5&7*& "#  )+

$"$$!# $$(%+$$++"+$" $"(+1+&+&

$&1 (%+" ( & 1&  )$"+&!+':

;8.."#&

"!1++1+,+&,+&*$+6"++"5"!1++1+&17"#  )&1$+++" 5"!1++1+7

"4  !# $$5"!1++7*"!1++1+"#  ) $"!1++1++&!+,+& 

%,,$+"!1++1++$"$'



&#+#+(1 $4!+ 1   1%+ +" ,%#&1 1&+&#

, + 1 ?"++1 (4+1 )  1 " , $"(% "' +  1 "  )

#+ 

;8."# !# 1$+&+&" )#" "

(4 $%+ (%&(  ../* 0 "!&+ &+& !(1 

 ; 9 4  (++(+

,%#+&% 1*.899.*."!&+' &" &+,%#+&% 14+$+&+:

;..

.4 1$44!5 !,",&+&!+$44!<=7'





;89.,"# &&+)"# $ +(++(+$4+1("

 '





;.9."#"&&)#+$& "  1,*""# " #+'# *

!# 11#+*4) 

;.9. $& "  1""&1'



( 

;.8.$44!)"# #  "+&1"""

#6(+(1$& "  1*" +#+)"# $44! 1"$& "  1&+$"+!'

&& 1$44! "+&1""#6(+(1$& "  1'



, "& 1 $& "  1 & #+(1  +$+   1 !+++%+( ,%#+&% 1 00

"!&+*$+(4$%+$+#")50*87'





;1..*"#&$& "  1$& +"# "  1"# (4+1

"  1*"  !"# "  1&!+++%+(*" &&+&4)+($+"  1'

,

"& 1$& "  &#+(1 +$+(( 

;..**

;09.

#+#+&&*.899.*."!&+  1!+++%+(00"!&+'





;."# )$& "  1 1$& "  1 ! "+&1"(

#&1+%  $+" &+4+$+&+(++(+:

;...&4# 1  '# 

$4!+)1"$& "  1"+&1"$44!$+$44! '(:

;...!#+

"#   4+$+ (++(+$+ "!! (%+) (% 1 &% 1 (%&+"  (++(+ +&!+

5(++(+7*!("#  +&% ("$  $+" &+"#4+$+&+'++(+$44!"

":

;/84 1+&!+$44!*$++&1 )+,!&+'



+ 1"# +)*" &"#  4+#$& "  ""&1&+&

!(1 

;.8 .4 (%+)"# #  "+&1"

$44!""#6(+(1$& "  1* )"-' '(4$%+



&,&"



8587

" "$& "  &!+++%+( $$00"!&+' ) %  $+

" &+4+$+&+ 1$& "  (++(+:

;...&4# 1  '









# &+"A