2-05-15891/1 · Viru Maakohus Narva kohtumaja











 

 





 





  !"

 

  





#$%& %'(%
)#*+*

+&',

   



   

 

  
  
 


 !"  

#$%$&%%$  ' ('



  

 



   ' 

)    ' ' 

 ''

"%,-#.#/ $-0001%2&-000/

"%,-# #/ $-0001%2&-000/

"%,-3# #/ $-0001%2&-000

"%,&% % !$, +2, 2 %2- ,$'2 "$!+

/$% -000/

 &,-

 4 



#/%" &$-0001 &-

000/

 &, %$ 2 % !$,- ' '2%+ /$% -

000/

*+   

,2'%!%&2 

  

!

''

#
 '

 



  (  #$%$&%%$,

,

 ' -$

-- 



 

++ 

 + 



   

  



 



   '  

&
+  

  (   



' 



 # %&% .(

 





( '.

 



#%&%.(







( '.

 




#%&%.(







( '.

 






/

  

  

  

 #0#&&%%-   )

 1



  

'



'

   

'



&&  %5%2%!6" % &$5%22& !%( !"!!&2%758%+, 2

+&% &&  %'%!%&2  2 &%2%8&&%&'%&' % &#





  

 

 



&2% ##
# % &&$ "+2$ %  %2& ##
#

 4 



#

92$ 2%2 2 + &+6%&$ &   56,  5!&$% )# , )#) &% & '$& &% &#

36, 5!&$%)#,)#)%%$& ! %2&92$ 2%& ' &!6$,

& ' &+6+$&% &$%+ ,!' ,!2'%$,'&&%+8%'/7&%9 &

2'%&% &#!&$92$ 2%& ' %$!+ &2 %&+'&&%&2!$ 9!"&%

%$ % : 4; <
 8&&%"#  &+2&  4 <
 2"  92$ 2% & (  9 &

,& # &+2& 4<
2"7,& ! &&$& '92$ 2%* %$

!6& %,22& !'!&$56, %$'&&%+8%'/'&&%&2!$ 9 &2'% &

 52% 56,  %&&%!8&$ +8%'+2 & % !$ !'#  &+2&  4 <
 2" = 





,&  % &   92$ 2%* 92$ 2% &&2%+$  $ +6+$  % 92$ 2%

& $* ' %2&!" %$&%%(,& # "%,$2%+$*%&92$ 2%&  

56,  5!&$% )# , )#)   '&'!% &2%( &!! &$ %&%& * ! 92$ 2%

& ' %$% %$& ! 56,5!&$% )#,)#)!+ &2  4<
#



##
#

 4 



# 92$ 2% &  &  %"%%$ "%,&%  ,2%2% ,

 6!2 &%2%+2$ &%2%#!&$ & &2%(&9 &$!&!+ &2  4<>, 4

<
 2"  8&%&%"# 4 < > !!( &%9 & 2'%&%2% &%9 & 92$ 2%&% &

 2%' % , 882%& 6" %#  4 <
 2"  8&% &( 6" % &%9 & 2'%&%2% 9 &

,& %2&+,2!? ' % #%%"!&$&  %"! &&$&%9 &2'%&%6" 

&%9 &,&' % &92$ 2%&% & +6&",6" &,& %2&+,2!? ' % #



"%,$52+$&!! &$%&%&  %$ %2%+ &2 2%+&%9 &&  %&%9 &

56,5!&$% )#,)#)&%&$'$& &%!82,9 &92$ 2%&  % "%,&%2&

+6%& %8882%& 6" !!"%%"%%&!%!$%,2%2%, 2 &%2%+2$ &%2%#



   





&2%##
#% &&$+ & %  &,"%&!! &#



 & %  %2&  4 <
= 2"  2 %2 +6(   '&&%&2!$ 9!" 2'% +6 ,& %

2'%+2$ %2 %2&!! &$%&%&  %$ %+656,"+ &2 2%+92$ 2%

&  %###
#92$ 2%&  %2%+ &2 922&$$ 4<
=2",%2%

56,%!$&$&!! &$ %$&  &%&%& #



 4 <
 2"
 , 7 8&% &(* %& ,&  5%( 92$ 2%  & ' %$ %  +6

56,"%&&%!8&$,&$%2, * '&  *9!"+$ %$!6+$,,& 

5%(92$ 2%& '* %$!6(,22&,56, &8!8$&% +8%'2&

/'&&%&2!$ 9!"2'%&% &,56,"%2%%&&%!8&$+8 %'% !$& %!6%&#

%22% & < & ! %&&% !8&$* %& @,&  5%( 92$ 2%  & '*  %$ !6(

,22& , 56, & 8 !8$&%  +8%'2& / '&&%&2!$ 9!" 2'%&% &A* +$

%$ !$, % %%2* %& 2'%$ +6+$ %!' +" !6$ 92$ 2%  & ' &#

 4<
7,565)# 8&% &+$*%&56,'&' %&  !+ &+6%&$* %22%

52& ! 882%&!$ 92%
/7 92$ 2%   2%!$ 2'%&% &# 36, '&' % %% &

92$ 2%2##
#!882%&!$%!'
/792$ 2%22+(!$2'%&% &#

##
#92$ 2%&  ! 62  %$ %"#



 4<)2"
 8&% &(*%&2'%+6('&&%&2!$ 9!" &56,  8&% && & 62&'&

+82, +& 56, 8&%&% &8&'& ,8&' % +6 9!" 22 %2 '882 , &' % &6&&#

3657# 8&% &(*%&2"%&+6(9 &2'%&%882&%%!' %&  %2 %29 & &+82,

+&56, 8&%&%&8&'&,8&' %+69 &22 %2'882, &' %&6&&# "%,$!

5,, 2 %!$ 4 %22*, %22%58 &92$ 2%+6&& + &&  %*'22%"

"%,$!,8%&$882%& 6" &% &2'!!"!2+&&$&% %$,2% &!!"  6!2 &% &

+2$ &% &#



422&$ 2 %2 52(  &, % !$, ,8&& 2$'& " , +82, '6 & "%,&%2&

2$ %2&&2$ 4  #



    





 &%"
#&(2
)#'88 %*'22%"'88 2%!$$& +2+$2  <=72"

2 %2,2 '%!%&2 % # !52%$%&&2%!$!%2%'88 % !&$&8&,, 2%

& &!"'88' & , %"!%!$%82' && &!"2* '&%+6&!$&" '

!6 2% ,2 '%!%&2 %"* 2%!$(   52&% +$2 % &&  %" ,2 

'%!%&2 % #







&&%&2!$ 9!"&% %$ %: 4;<
=2",2"
 %2&: 6! & !7#
#
#;

+6( '&&%&2!$ 9!"2'%+6,& %2'%+2$ %2 %2&!! &$%&%& 

%$ %+656,"+ &2 2%+92$ 2%&  %*+2$ !% &&$2'%

, 2&  %+ &+6&' % &#



"%,$ 52+$ %&%&  &!! &$ &%9 &

&(% ##
## 92$ 2%

&  %$*'22%"'$%&&%9 &56,5!&$)##,)#)#,&  *'22%""%,&%2&

+6%&8882%& 6" ,&  &&'&&%%"%%$!%!$%,2%2%, 2 &%2%+2$ &%2%#



 4<
7,565)# 8&% &+$*%&56,'&' %&  !+ &+6%&$* %22%

52& ! 882%&!$ 92%
/7 92$ 2%2  2%!$ 2'%&% &# 36, '&' % %% &

92$ 2%2##
#!882%&!$%!'
/792$ 2%22+(!$2'%&% &#

%%" 2%(  * %& ##
# 92$ 2% &   56, 5!&$% '&' %  !

?'2 %2& 62  %$ %"* % & %22%52&!882%&!$92%
/792$ 2%2 2%!$

2'%&% &#' !&2 4<
=2 %26" !!&92$ 2%&  % %$ 58  &

,92$ 2%&  &!! &$%&%& &  !+ &2  %$ %+656,"#



36, 5!& )## &  &  92$ 2% '& ,8"' %  6! & % - 9 & ,&  & (

'&&%2 %92$ 2%'22"& %2+6/79 &2'%&%!6$%2%!8$2 %

&8&, , 2 +6 %+ ,!' ,! !6$%2# 36, 5!& )#)# &  && '& ,8"' %2&-

,2  ,&  52%  & !$ 56,  %&&%!8&$ &8&,  92$ 2%&* 9 &

2'%$'+$6" %5BB$$%+ ,!' ,!52%*% 58%+, 2*2&% +2$ %

' %58%+ &*& (92$ 2%#C2%+ ,!' ,!!&$!6%&%&8$*

 /7 !%9 &2'%&%!& &+"55& (92$ 2%#



 4 <
 2"
 , 7 8&% &(* %& ,&  5%( 92$ 2%  & ' %$ %  +6

56,"%&&%!8&$,&$%2, * '&  *9!"+$ %$!6+$,,& 

5%(92$ 2%& '* %$!6(,22&,56, &8!8$&% +8%'2&

/'&&%&2!$ 9!"2'%&% &,56,"%2%%&&%!8&$+8 %'% !$& %!6%&#



%%" % 2% &%9 & &  %$ 56, 5!&$% )## , )#)# '&' %  %$ %"

 62 * % & 4<
2"7 %2&,& 5%(92$ 2%& '* %$

!6( ,22& , 56, & 8 !8$&%  +8%'2& / '&&%&2!$ 9!" 2'%&% & ,

56,"# %$ %  8&% &&$ / '&&%&2!$ 9!" 2'%&% & '88&2%( +8 %'

&%9 &2'%&%+*% +6+$& $92$ 2%,56,"+6(%&&%!8

+%%2+8 %'2'%&%+*%22%2 %22!%6" 2% #2%6"% &,+8$%*%& %$ %%%2

%!' 2'%&% + '88' & 92$ 2%  & ' %   /# %$ %  !

%2"% 6!2 %2&, *%&92$ 2%5%(,& & ' %$!6(+8%'2&/

'&&%&2!$ 9!"

2'%&% &#

%%"

5%(

%$ % &

&2%!%+2&

+8%'2&

/

'&&%&2!$ 9!"2'%&%2%2%'&"&$6" & $92$ 2%56,"

%2%%&&%!8&$+8 %'% !$& %!6%&#



&%9 & %$ %<,8"+6(92$ 2%2 2%$,882%&$&%9 &2"%+6

&%'% !$,*%22%2%!!&$2&,2+2#



 4 <
 2"  ,8" 5%( ,&  !$' '&&%&2!$ 9!" 2'%&%2% +,2 &%+%&

,&' %&#



%%" % 2% &%9 & 92$ 2% &   &%9 & 2'%&%2 # .#* # # , 3# #

882%6" %8+6&'!%92$ 2%2 2%' %2 %$ 2* % & %22 &6" &&%9 & %$ 

92$ 2%2% % !!# '& % &2%!% %$ % & &%9 & 6"  %%2$$ &%9 &

2'%&% 2 &%2%,,2%2%+2$ &%2%%"%%' &#





=



  2%(* %& "%,&% !6$%$ &2%( 2$$* % & ! 56,%!$&$ &!! &$ %&%& 

&%9 &&  56,5!&$%)##,)#)#'&' % ,&  "%,&%2882%& 6" %

8+6&' %  , '&&%%"%%' %  "%,&% ,2%2% , 2 &%2 +2$ &%2%* % & %22 %$

&  %$! %$ %"+ &2 #



  



 

+2&'%!%&2 % %$ & , &8&%'%!%&2 % %$ & %!$' % %$ % :  ,

 ; < 7  %2& %!!% 8% 2%+ %$ % ,6 &' & 2 &&$ '%!%&2 % 52

2$& % '%!%&2 2$% ,&' %2% , !%!$% !$2 '88' %2% %! %&!$

& +2&'%!%&2 % %$ &  8&% &&&# ! ##
)## %&!$  < ) 2" ,8"

'6 &( 52%&&2 %2*%22%  !&  &%&$*&% %2&52%2& %22%52%  +82,

+,2$,56,%!$&$&2$, <)2"2 %26" (2&'88' %2#

"%,&% &2$ '$ &( ) ! "26+ , " "%, 52& !&$  !

6" (2 $* %"7! ! "2$(*  &2%("%,&%!&$

"26+)!,6" (2$"2%"%,2%!+82,'6 & &,2&#







&!









  !"